- 1 - ! " # $%!! $%! !& ## '( !!! " # $ % & ' ( $ ( $ )***' ! ( '*' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + ( '*' , (( '*' $$ + ( !) " # $ $ ( ' ! ,- % ( +- $ % ( & ( ,( !*!*,.!*'. ! '*!*!, $ ( $ $ % $ /$ /$ % - 3 - !% # /$ & 012 3415 677869 12 :198; <06998=>1=> 6= ?4;84 ;658; ! '*!*!, 76228; @A 508 9864=8; 1=>98 B;>8 1= ?!*!*,.!*'. ! 084827?=;8=5?08481=362677?1=58;626 <18=<8 86<084 ?= **)!**) @A 508 6778996=5 08481= 086778996=53626;C1558;5?>46=51=61;?=')*)!**. 08=6C8?:4827?=;8=5?362C8=51?=8;1=508?4;84 6;C1551=> 508 6778996=5 5? >46=51=61; 08 6778996=5 7B47?458;9A 748D8=58; 4827?=;8=5 ? :4?C ;12<064>1=> 012 ;B5182 301<0 <?C78998; 01C 5? 2B@C15 9855842 @8:?48 508 <?=<84=8; 6B50?415182 301<0 74?C758; 6<51?= @A 508 87B5A 148<5?4 ?: B@91< =254B<51?=2 30? 1=:?4C8; 508 6778996=5 5065 508 6<51?= ?: 508 6778996=5 1= =?5 699?31=> 4827?=;8=5 ? 5? ;12<064>8 012 ;B5182 362 =?5 1= 6<<?4;6=<83150963=508C86=301985086778996=506; 692? 584C1=658; 508 284D1<82 ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 08 87B5A 148<5?4 ?: B@91< =254B<51?=2 =?51<1=> 5065 508 - 4 - 26C8362=?51=6<<?4;6=<83150 B982?'...;148<58; 508 6778996=5 5? :?4503150 4825?48 508 284D1<82 ?: 508 4827?=;8=5 ? ?38D84 =? 6<51?= 362 1=151658; 6=; 50848:?48 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 6;D128; 5? <06998=>8 508 ?4;84 ?: 584C1=651?= @8:?48 508 ;B<651?=69 77899658 41@B=69 #:?4 20?45 E 41@B=69F& 08 677869 @8:?48 508 41@B=69362@89658;6=;6=67791<651?=:?4<?=;?=651?=?: ;896A362:198; 08 41@B=691=584C2?:6=?4;84;658; !!*.!*', 48G8<58; 508 67791<651?= :?4 <?=;?=651?= ?: ;896A 6=; <?=28HB8=59A 48G8<58; 508 677869 81=> 6>>418D8; @A 508 261; ?4;84 4827?=;8=5 ? :198; ?!*!,!*', 08261;3415785151?=362699?38;6=; 508 <628 362 48C1558; @6<I 5? 508 41@B=69 :?4 08641=> 6:4820 6=; 76221=> 6774?741658 ?4;842 08486:584 508 41@B=69 76228; 6= ?4;84 ;658; '!*,!*' 48G8<51=> 508 677869 :198; @A 4827?=;8=5 ? 08 261; ?4;84 362 <06998=>8; @8:?48 5012 ?B45 1= ?!*!*,.!*'. 08 9864=8; 1=>98 B;>8 1= 584C2 ?: 508 ?4;84 ;658; ! '*!*!, =?51<8; 6 <?=;151?= 6556<08; 5? 508 ?4;84 - 5 - 6;C1551=> 4827?=;8=5 ? 5? >46=51=61; 6=; 089; 5065 508 ?4;84 ?: 584C1=651?= ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 =?5 1= 6<<?4;6=<8 3150 508 <?=;151?= C8=51?=8; 1= 508 ?4;84 ?: >46=51=61; 6=; <?=28HB8=59A 699?38; 508 3415 785151?= 6=;285621;8508?4;84?:584C1=651?=?:4827?=;8=5? ;658; +**,!*'* 6=; ;148<58; 481=25658C8=5 ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 6=; 8=2B48 <?=51=B15A ?: 284D1<8 6=; 4825?48 699 <?=28HB8=5169 @8=8:152 1=<9B;1=> 26964A 6=; 699?36=<82 62 784 508 67791<6@98 >46=51=61; ?38D84 91@845A 362 48284D8; 5? 508 6778996=5 5? 56I8 =8<82264A ;12<1791=64A6<51?=?=9A1=6<<?4;6=<8315050874?<8;B48 7482<41@8; 81=> 6>>418D8; @A 508 261; ?4;84 508 6778996=512@8:?485012?B45 + 089864=8;<?B=289:?45086778996=52B@C1558; 50654827?=;8=5?362796<8;?=74?@651?=:?467841?; ?: ! A8642 :4?C **)!**) 8 <?=58=;2 5065 508 74?@651?=64A7841?; ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 =?5 ;8<9648; 6=;50848:?485086778996=53628=51598;5?584C1=658508 284D1<82?:4827?=;8=5?3150?B56221>=1=>6=A4862?= - 6 - 850848:?48<?=58=;250655081C7B>=8;?4;8476228;@A 5086778996=512GB256=;74?7846=;50848362=?=88;:?4 6=8=HB14A5?@8<?=;B<58;6>61=254827?=;8=5?6208 362658C7?464A8C79?A88850848:?482B@C1525065508 1C7B>=8;?4;8476228;@A508 41@B=6912GB256=;74?784 6=;5089864=8;1=>98B;>8?B>05=?55?06D81=584:848; 3150508261;?4;84 , 508 9864=8; <?B=289 :?4 4827?=;8=5 ? 2B@C1558; 5065 508 =6C8 ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 692?1=<9B;8;1=5089125?:586<01=>:6<B95A@A5086778996=5 301986779A1=>:?4>46=51=61;6=;508?4;84>46=51=>61; <?=561=8;508=6C8?:4827?=;8=5?82B@C1525065 <?=;151?= ?+* C8=51?=8; 1= 508 ?4;84 ?: >46=5 278<1:1<699A C6=;658; 5065?=<8 508 6778996=5 126;C1558; 5? >46=51=61; 15 <6==?5 B=196584699A 584C1=658 6=A 8C79?A88850848:?482B@C1525065308=5086778996=5 0626<<8758;508584C26=;<?=;151?=2?:508>46=51=61; 15<6==?5B=196584699A584C1=658508284D1<82?:4827?=;8=5 ? 5065 5?? 3150?B5 6221>=1=> 6=A 4862?= 6=; 3150?B5 - 7 - <?=;B<51=> 6=A 8=HB14A 8 50848:?48 2B@C152 5065 508 9864=8; 1=>98 B;>8 062 C851<B9?B29A <?=21;848; 50828 74?D121?=26=;06241>059A;148<58;5086778996=55?4825?48 508 284D1<82 ?: 508 785151?=844827?=;8=5 ? 3150 699 <?=51=B15A?:284D1<86=;@6<I36>82 08 9864=8; ;;151?=69 ?D84=C8=5 ;D?<658 :?44827?=;8=5?2'5?,2B77?458;508<?=58=51?=2?:508 9864=8;<?B=289:?44827?=;8=5? ) 8 06D8 <?=21;848; 508 2B@C1221?=2 ?: 508 9864=8; <?B=289 :?4 508 6778996=5 508 9864=8; ;;151?=69 ?D84=C8=5 ;D?<658:?44827?=;8=5 ?2' 5?, 6=; 508 9864=8;<?B=289:?44827?=;8=5? 08 :6<5 5065 508 6778996=5 06; 677?1=58; 4827?=;8=5??=**)!**)12=?51=;127B58<?7A ?: 508 ?4;84 ?: 677?1=5C8=5 ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? =?3 796<8;?=48<?4;20?3250654827?=;8=5?362796<8; ?= 74?@651?= :?4 6 7841?; ?: ! A8642 08 6778996=5 062 =?5 796<8; ?= 48<?4; 6=A C6584169 5? 20?3 5065 15 06; - 8 - <?=51=B8; 508 74?@651?= ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? @8A?=; 6 7841?; ?: ! A8642 ?38D84 308= 508 6778996=5 362 6;C1558; 5? >46=51=61; 15 06; C8=51?=8; 5065 508 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 ?=8 ?: 508 586<01=> :6<B95182 1= 152 ?4>6=1J651?= 6=; 6<<?4;1=>9A 508 6778996=5 362 6;C1558; 5? >46=51=61; 2 784 508 ?4;84 ;658; ')*)!**. 508 <?=;151?= ?+* 6556<08; 5? 508 ?4;84 ?: >46=5 486;2 62 :?99?32 ! "#$ % &' ()! *"+ ,-./0 .1 *. 0.2& 3 4 * * 56 7 5! 89 5! : & ;< = 3 : ' >5?>- .@- 7 " + &' $A5! BCD C8 E! ,- : E! 0F 1 G H !1 / ) 6 3$+7 % 5! : / $A5! I.6 : I+J<K !!3 L1M 1M 0 N 2O =@+ / % 89 % 5! E! 2% # : 2P 4 * I+Q !O =@+ I+Q! R- R)!! 51R =+7 0887B5A148<5?4?:B@91<=254B<51?=26:584 =?51<1=> 5065 508 584C1=651?= ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? @A 508 - 9 - 6778996=5 362 =?5 1= 6<<?4;6=<8 3150 508 6:?48261; <?=;151?=06;6;;48228;6985584;658;*,*)!*'*5?508 6778996=5301<0486;262:?99?32 7S(BT,.UTHV0FWVBXV8BYBB $TZ7X78B K !#! & & $ #Q.1U[ PW6H 6& !#K 04! TYU.\ +.\]! 0H^ $ # Q:1.1U[PW6H 6&" : G H2M< 6_7 I[+`TY6 .'> 0$TBa7978B7 @04! R6$A< KI[+b. 2cd% 0 @+< =K % : $T7Z78B H2M< L U H%2M<$=%HL U @+I[+b< .e *H!1 "[, .2& e. 2$! efg\ eM< 7 VY I.5 &U &]5"[,K 6& . 5 12 4898D6=5 5? =?58 5065 508 584C2 6=; <?=;151?=2 ?: 677?1=5C8=5 ?: 4827?=;8=5 ? 362 >?D84=8; B=;84 508 64=656I6 ;B<651?=69 =2515B51?=2 # 8<4B15C8=5 6=; 84C2 6=; ?=;151?=2 ?: 84D1<8 ?: C79?A882 1= 41D658 1;8; 41C64A 6=; 8<?=;64A - 10 - ;B<651?= =2515B51?=2& B982 '... 6=; 15 12 ?77?2158 5? 48:845? B98301<0C6=;658262:?99?32 '* B98!*?:508261; B9827482<41@82674?<8;B48 :?41C7?21=>C6G?478=695182301<0486;262:?99?32 !"# $ !#!# "% ! # & & & & ' - 11 - !# ( ) * ( * + , !# - !# & !# ' !# . ' !# /( ' !# ' !# '' 084812=?501=>5?20?350655086778996=5062 :?99?38; 508 6:?48261; 74?<8;B48 @B5 15 06; 584C1=658; 4827?=;8=5?3150?B56221>=1=>6=A4862?=6=;3150?B5 <?=;B<51=> 6=A 8=HB14A 62 C6=;658; 0848:?48 508 9864=8; 1=>98 B;>8 362 GB251:18; 1= 76221=> 508 ?4;84 1C7B>=8; 1= 5012 3415 677869 6=; 362 692? GB251:18; 1= ;148<51=> 508 6778996=5 5? 481=25658 4827?=;8=5 ? 3150 699 <?=28HB8=5169 @8=8:152 6=; <?=51=B15A ?: 284D1<8 8 - 12 - 50848:?48;?=?52886=A844?41=508?4;8476228;@A508 9864=8; 1=>98 B;>8 6=; 6<<?4;1=>9A 5012 3415 677869 12 ;12C1228; )* '!( ! )* ' !& ( ! 125?'9?'*'