- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#! !" ' ( ! "###$ %$ & ' % ( ! ' )) * ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + # % ###$ ," # # ! ( - ! + , # #" $ " $'# * ! , - $'# ! , - $'# ! , $'# ) ) . - - 3 - /01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 133>06?45134@10934/3A5==565<93<9@439# #" 2@1139 :; 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 @8@:B<@?0 06 2280A@4056 5 $'# 56 51 $ @69 " @69 @815 133>06? 23<=0110564570835:C3A40561454/3@2280A@405670839:;4/3 D5<>=@6B693<3A4056$$ !574/369B14<0@8012B431 A4"+ 75<1/5<4E4/3A4,! 4 01 4/3 A@13 57 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 4/@4 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 /@9 @22<5@A/39 4/3 @:5B< 5B<475<@<<3@<157D@?31@6945134@10934/343<=06@4056 5<93< /3 234040563<'=285;3< /3<306 D@1 90<3A439 45 <30614@43 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 0645 13<F0A3 D04/06 4/<33 =564/1 7<5= 4/3 9@43 57 2B:80A@4056 57 4/3 @D@<9 @69 7B<4/3< 90<3A439 4/@4 4/3 D5<>=@6 D@1 36404839 45 #G574/3:@A>D@?317<5=4/39@4357A8@0=234040564088 /01 <30614@43=364 /01 @D@<9 A@=3 45 :3 2@1139 56 # # ##% /@8836?06? 4/3 1@09 @D@<9 234040563<' =285;3< 70839 5 %##'## D/0A/ A@=3 45 :3 - 4 - 901=0113956+ #$ #A5670<=06?4/3@D@<92@1139:; 4/3@:5B<5B<49@439# # ##% ??<03F39:;4/31@09 901=011@8 5<93< 234040563<'=285;3< A/@8836?39 4/3 1@=3 :375<3 4/3 0F01056 36A/ 57 4/01 5B<4 06 <04 223@8 5 ##$'# D/0A/ @815 A@=3 45 :3 901=01139 56 $ #+ # 306? @??<03F39 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< A/@8836?394/31@=3:375<34/3 56.:8323H5B<406 ! 5 '#$ 5D3F3< 234040563<'=285;3< D@1 6541BAA3117B8@694/31@0923404056A@=345:3901=01139 56# # #$ $ /01 :306? 4/3 14@43 57 @77@0<1 4/3 D5<>=@6 2<373<<39 @6 @2280A@4056 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4 @69 4/3 1@=3 D@1 6B=:3<39 @1 2280A@4056 5 $'# /3 234040563<'=285;3< 909 654 7083 5:C3A4056 45 4/3 1@09 @2280A@4056 @69 4/3 1@=3 D@1 4@>36 @1 654 70839 @69 =@443<2<5A3393975<<3A5<906?573F0936A3 /3<3@743<56 $ # #$ 4/3 =@443< D@1 251439 75< 3F0936A3 6 $ #+ #$@6@2280A@4056D@17083945<3A@884/3D5<>=@6 D04631175<7B<4/3<3F0936A35<A<5113H@=06@4056A@=345 - 5 - :3 <3C3A439 /3 234040563<'=285;3< 70839 4/<33 @2280A@4056145<3A@88<352364/3A@134583@93F0936A357 4/3234040563<@69@81545708314@43=364575:C3A4056454/3 @2280A@405670839:;4/3D5<>=@6B693<3A4056$$ !57 4/3A4 5D3F3<:;5<93<9@439# #"4/3@:5B< 5B<4901=01139@884/3@2280A@4056106A8B906?4/35:C3A4056 14@43=36445:34@>3656<3A5<9 306?@??<03F39:;4/3 1@095<93<4/3234040563<'=285;3<01:375<34/015B<4 " 3@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< F3/3=3648;A564369394/@44/5B?/4/3=@443<:375<34/3 56,:83 23H 5B<4 /@1 @44@0639 706@804; 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839:;4/3<312569364'D5<>=@6B693<3A4056$$ !57 4/3 A4 <3IB0<31 45 :3 5:C3A439 45 @69 93736939 :; 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< /3 @2280A@40561 70839 :; 4/3 234040563<'=285;3<D3<3901=01139:;4/383@<639@:5B< 5B<4568;564/3?<5B694/@406 5 +"+57#4/3 55<906@43 :36A/ 57 4/01 5B<4 75< 4/3 <3@156 14@439 4/3<306<3C3A4394/323404056 36A34/3@:5B<5B<4/@1 - 6 - <3C3A4394/3@2280A@40561:;<38;06?B2564/31@095<93<57 4/015B<4 4 01 A56436939 :; 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 4/@4 07 4/3 =285;3< 01 654 23<=04439 45 7083 5:C3A40561 45 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4@69 654 83@9 0413F0936A3 4/3<3D5B89 :3 65 =@43<0@8 56<3A5<9452<5F3/01 A@13@69 314@:801/ 4/31@=3 37B<4/3<A56436914/@404D5B89:363A311@<; 75</0=457083/015:C3A40561@694583@93F0936A3451/5D @145D/364/3<312569364'D5<>=@6/@9C506394/39B4031 @69 D/36 /3 D@1 @:1364 45 93A093 4/3 A5=2361@4056 @=5B644/3@D@<94/3:@A>D@?31@694/3@=5B649B3 45 :3 2@09 36A3 /3 133>1 45 @885D 4/3 23404056 @69 23<=04/0=4583@9/013F0936A3:;70806?5:C3A40561454/3 @2280A@4056 04 01 4/3 F3/3=364 A564364056 57 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 4/@4 4/3 9012B4301574/3;3@<##@D@<9A@=345:32@113906 - 7 - ##% @69 04 D@1 IB31405639 :; 4/3 =285;3< 06 ## :375<3 4/01 5B<4 06 D<04 23404056 D/0A/ A@=3 45 :3 901=01139 /31@=3:306?A/@8836?39:375<34/30F01056 36A/ 57 4/01 5B<4 04 @815 36939 B2 06 901=011@8 /3 234040563<'=285;3< @815 7@0839 06 1BAA33906? D/36 /3 @22<5@A/39 4/3 56.:83 23H 5B<4 A/@8836?06? 4/3 CB9?=364 57 4/01 5B<4 D5 D<04 234040561 D3<3 70839 3@<803< :375<3 4/01 5B<4 45 <3A@88 4/3 D5<>=@6 75< 3F0936A3@694583@93F0936A3574/3=285;3<D/0A/A@=3 45:3<3C3A439 /3<375<3/3A56436914/@44/3F3<;064364 @69A569BA4574/3=285;3<01452<54<@A4@692<5856?4/3 2<5A33906?1 45 133 4/@4 4/3 D5<>=@6 01 7<B14<@439 @69 B6@:83 45 36C5; 4/3 7<B041 57 4/3 @D@<9 9312043 /@F06? :336 1BAA33939 06 @88 4/3 75<B=1 <0?/4 B2 454/3 56.:83 23H5B<4 + 5D@44/314@?3D/364/3D5<>=@6014536C5; 4/3 7<B041 57 4/3 @D@<9 @69 D/36 /3 /@1 70839 @6 @2280A@4056 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4 4/3 2<31364 @2280A@40561 @<3 70839 568; 45 2<5856? @69 2<54<@A4 4/3 - 8 - 2<5A33906?1@69457<B14<@434/3A8@0=574/3D5<>=@6 3 A5643691 4/@4 4/3<3 01 65 =3<04 06 4/3 @2280A@4056 @1 9312043 1B770A0364 5225<4B604; :306? ?<@6439 4/3 234040563<'=285;3</@1654@F@08394/31@=3 36A34/3; @<36543640483975<@6;=5<3836036A; % /@F3 /3@<9 4/3 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< @69 4/3 83@<639 A5B6138 75< 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 /3 @2280A@4056 01 70839 :; 4/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4 90<3A406? 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 45 2@; @6 @=5B64 57 1 $%###' D04/ @88 A5613IB3640@8 :3637041 @856? D04/ 0643<314 @4 4/3 <@43 57 G 23< @66B= 56 #+ # 856? D04/ 4/3 1@09 @2280A@4056 =3=5 57 A@8AB8@4056 D@1 @815 70839 :; 4/3 D5<>=@6 56 4/3 F3<; 1@=3 9@43 /3 @2280A@4056 A@=3 45 :3 70839 :; 4/3 234040563< 56 # #" /3 56.:83 23H 5B<4 93A0939 4/3 =@443< 56# # #$2B4406?4/314@=257706@804;564/3@D@<9 - 9 - 2@1139 :; 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3 @2280A@40562<373<<39B693<3A4056$$ !574/3A40401 65 856?3< 06 F03D 57 13F3<@8 A@436@ 57 CB9?=3641 57 4/3 56.:83 23H 5B<4 @1 4/3 1@=3 01 06 4/3 ?B013 57 @6 3H3AB4056 23404056 @1 4/3 5B<4 93@806? D04/4/3@2280A@4056B693<3A4056$$ !574/3A4D088 /@F3 45 80=04 041387 45 4/3 @D@<9 @69 654 3HA339 5< ?5 :3;569 4/3 @D@<9 D04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3 A@8AB8@4056 57 4/3 @=5B644/@40145:32@09 # 6 F03D 57 4/3 @2280A@4056 4/@4 01 70839 :; 4/3 D5<>=@6D04/<3?@<945<3A5F3<;574/3@=5B642B<1B@64 454/3@D@<9@65225<4B604;D088/@F345:3?0F36454/3 234040563<'=285;3< 45 2B475<4/ 041 1@; D/34/3< @6; @=5B64012@095<932510439@69@A>65D839?39:375<34/3 @:5B<5B<475<4/32B<251357A@8AB8@406?4/32@;=36457 4/3@=5B64062B<1B@6A3454/3@D@<9D/0A//@1@44@0639 706@804; - 10 - 06A34/3234040563<'=285;3</@16543F3670839 5:C3A4056 45 4/3 1@09 @2280A@4056 70839 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4 04 D5B89 :3 06 4/3 0643<314 57 :54/ 4/3 2@<4031 =5<3 15 75< 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 45 7083 5:C3A4056 14@43=364 5< 28@A3 @6; 1BA/ =@43<0@8 45 1/5D D/@4 01 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 /@1 :336 2@09'932510439 5< D04/9<@D6:;4/3D5<>=@6 /3IB31405657<3523606?4/3 @D@<99531654@<013 /3<375<3D/@4<3=@06145:31336 064/3@2280A@405670839B693<3A4056$$ !574/3A401 D/@4 01 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 01 2@09 5< 932510439 :; 4/3 234040563< 401A83@<@69B6@=:0?B5B14/@44/33=285;3< 01 654 <3IB0<39 45 ?5 :3;569 4/3 @D@<9 :; 83@906? @6; 7B<4/3< 3F0936A3 15 @1 45 A564<@90A4 4/3 CB9?=364 @69 @D@<92@1139:;4/3<0:B6@8D/0A//@1@44@0639706@804; 04 01 <383F@64 45 =364056 4/3 CB9?=364 57 4/3 56.:83 23H 5B<4 06 4/3 A@13 57 !"#$/355<906@4336A/57 4/015B<4064/3A@1357%&' ()* - 11 - + ,%-, # .$ /@1 93A0939 4/01 F3<; IB314056 25<405657D/0A/013H4<@A439/3<306:385D) !" #!!!$ !# #!% & ' ## & ( ) & * + # ! #!,- &' '&. / ( #!, 0 $ 6F03D574/3@2280A@4056/@F06?:33670839@69 4/3@:5B<5B<4D5B89/@F3452@11@65<93<564/31@09 @2280A@4056 4/3 1@=3 D088 /@F3 45 :3 @9F3<439 45 D04/ <3?@<9 45 4/3 @=5B64 4/@4 01 2@09 5< 45 :3 2@09 :; 4/3 234040563<'=285;3<454/3D5<>=@675<D/0A/4/015B<401 57 4/3 5206056 4/@4 4/3 =@443<<3IB0<31 45 :3 <3=04439 45 4/3@:5B<5B<4:;134406?@10934/35<93<2@1139:;4/3 - 12 - @:5B< 5B<4 23<=04406? 4/3 234040563<'=285;3< 45 7083 5:C3A40561 @69 @6; A@8AB8@40561 @1 45 4/3 2@;=364 15 =@935<9325104395<<3A30F3907@6;:;4/3D5<>=@6 " AA5<906?8;2@114/375885D06?) 0 /3D<042340405601 / 00 /3A5==565<93<9@439# #"2@1139:; 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 @8@:B<@?0 56 51 $ @69"062280A@40565 $'#F093663HB<3 01/3<3:;134@1093 000 34040563<'=285;3< 01 23<=04439 45 7083 4/3 5:C3A4056 14@43=364 45 4/3 2280A@4056 5 $'#70839B693<3A4056$$ !574/3A4 @69 28@A3 @88 1BA/ =@43<0@8 :375<3 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 75< 04 45 A5=3 45 @ A56A8B1056 56 4/3 2@;=36407@6;=@935<9B345:32@09454/3 <312569364'D5<>=@6 - 13 - 0F 6 F03D 57 4/3 7@A4 4/@4 4/3 69B14<0@8 012B43 D@1 57 4/3 ;3@< ## 4/3 =@443< /@F06? @44@0639706@804;D04/<3?@<9454/3@D@<9064/3 ;3@< #$ :375<3 4/3 56.:83 23H 5B<4 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 1/@88 93A093 4/3 =@443< 3H2390405B18; D04/06 @6 5B43< 80=04 57 4/<33 =564/17<5=4/39@4357<3A302457A52;574/3 5<93< F 4 01 =@93 A83@< 4/@4 4/3 1A523 57 4/3 @:5B< 5B<4 06 93A0906? 4/3 @2280A@4056 70839 B693< 3A4056 $$ ! 57 4/3 A4 01 80=0439 @69 04 A@6654 ?5 :3;569 D/@4 01 2<5F0939 B693< 4/3 A4 5<?5 :3;5694/3 @D@<9 2@1139 D/0A/ /@1 @44@0639706@804; !)* ' !"( # 0145 )85 )" )