Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54843 (KAR)
SHIVAKUMAR v. THE UNION OF INDIA
CRL.P/201434/2025 · 2026-01-28
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54843 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54843 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%""
%
&
'&()*
&)
+
!"! #
$ %
&
'
(
'
'
!"!) #
$
&
'
*'
$& " ' $+&
! $
"!(
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
& ' '
'
''
"$& +$,&$--&$.&!)$&" * ' *"! ' /
'
+
0
12 324-4-56278..9:2; 5 <-=2; 41-: 324-4-56 :22>-6? -6427-@ ,8-= 56 @2;-.8= ?7596;: -6 32.-8= 8:2 5
! $87-:-6? 594 5<
7-@2 5
"!( -:47-.4 -;87 72?-:4272; ,A 412 6-56 5< 6;-8 87.54-. 56475= 97289 86?8=572 (568= 6-4&326;-6?56412<-=25<7-6.-38=-:47-.486;2::-56: 9;?2 -;87 <57 412 5<<26.2: 396-:18,=2 96;27 2.4-56:
"$.&728;B-412.4-56$,&$--&$&!)"86;*5< .4*"! 4 -: .56426;2; ,A 412 =28762; .596:2= <57 412 324-4-5627 4184 412 324-4-5627 -: .187?2 :12242; <57 412 8<572@264-562; 5<<26.2: 8=56? B-41 54127 <597 8..9:2;
- 3 -
12 324-4-5627 -: <8.-6? :27-59: 8-=@264: 5< $& 15=2=-41-8:-: $& -8,24-. -;62A -:28:2 B-41 -8,24-. 29753841A$78;2&$&A327426:-56B-41A327426:-C2
24-653841A $& '5==-.9=-4-: $!& =; 9=@5687A 9,27.9=5:-:86;1218:,22696;2772?9=87@2;-.84-56-6 412 26478= 7-:56 :5 8=:5 84 5:3-48= 8=8,978?- : :9.1 41-: 5974 C-;2 57;27 ;842; "
! .8==2; <57 412 @2;-.8= 72.57;: 32748-6-6? 45 412 324-4-5627 <75@ 412 2;-.8= 9327-6426;264 5< 9=,87?8 6:4-4942 5< 2;-.8= .-26.2: 28.1-6? 5:3-48= 84 8=8,978?- 45 8:.2748-6 B124127 412 .1756-. 8-=@264: :9<<272; ,A 412 324-4-5627 72D9-72: 8;C86.2; @2;-.8= 47284@264 62.2::-484-6?15:3-48=-E84-568:86-6384-264
..57;-6?=A 412 9327-6426;264 5< 26478= 7-:56 18: <57B87;2; 412 @2;-.8= 723574 8=56? B-41 @2;-.8= 372:.7-34-56: 5< 412 324-4-5627 <57@ 412 2;-.8= <<-.27 5< 26478= 7-:56 8=8,978?-B1-.1728;:8:96;27
! "
#$%#&
- 4 -
! '() *
"
%+#,+#- ! . * / 0 1) 0
2&
! '() *
"
%+#,+#-
%+#+#-
(
/&#-%%-%&
3 0
0 ! %2
1 ) ! 1 / 2 4 * ,2 5 /
1 6 ./162 ! ) .)72 2 8
&
0
%##- .9
! 2&
4
! '()
"
%:+#+#-
! &
! %:+#+#-
%+#+#-
(
/& #-%-,:$&
3 0
0 ! 1 ) ! 1
"
! * ! 5 /16 ! 9
*&
0
%+#+#-& 4
& 4
! ,#
) 81& 4
! '() *
"
$+#+#-
81
;*(1 /<#-#%%#=# 1<$+#+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%+#-+#-
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#%,%%=, 1<%+#-+#-&
.) 0 8 81 2 3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#=+#-
! - 5 -
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#%,-% 1<#+#=+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%#+#=+#-
&
!
> .) 5 ;2
'() * ? (
/<#-,#,&
! * ! 1 ) ! "
! ? ! %#+#=+#-
%,+#=+#-&
! '() *
"
#+#9+#-
0
81
;*(1 /<#-#%9,9= 1<#+#9+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%:+#9+#-
0
81
;*(1 /<#-#%$%=# 1< %:+#9+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#:+#-
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#=#, 1<#+#:+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%+#:+#-
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#=$-:
- 6 -
1<%+#:+#-&
3 0
0
0 / &
! '() *
"
#,+#$+#-
! /
81
;*(1 /<#-##=#, 1<#,+#$+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#$+#-
! ! 81
;*(1 /<#-#=#%:$ 1<#+#$+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
$+%+#-
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#,-$,: 1< $+%+ #-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%+#%+#=
&
! 3 0
. 4
0 ) 4 2
81
;*(1 /<#=##%%9% 1<%+#%+#= 0
;' 4
&
0
! *
! & (
/ &@
5B2C27 -6 412 :8-; 723574 -4 B8: :4842; 4184 56
F56412.5@3=8-645<8,;5@-68=38-612B8:
- 7 -
8;C-:2; <57
,;5@26 86; 4184 412 ;248-=2; -6C2:4-?84-5686;47284@264B-==,2-6<57@2;4541-:5974 ::9.141-:597456.28?8-6.8==2;<57412:8-;72357456 *
F
6 .5@3=-86.2 5< 412 :8-; 57;27 412 9327-6426;2645<26478=7-:5618:56.28?8-6<57B87;2; 412 2;-.8= 2357486;:4842;412372:264128=41.56;-4-56 5< 412 324-4-5627 C-;2 723574 ;842; )
F B1-.1 728;:8:96;27
! "
#$%#&
! '() *
"
%+#,+#- ! . * / 0 1) 0
2&
! '() *
"
%+#,+#-
%+#+#-
(
/&#-%%-%&
3 0
0 ! %2
1 ) ! 1 / 2 4 * ,2 5 /
1 6 ./162 ! )
.)72 2 8
&
0
%##- .9
! 2&
4
! '()
"
%:+#+#-
! &
! %:+#+#-
%+#+#-
(
/ #-%-,:$&
3 0
0 ! - 8 -
1 ) ! 1
"
! * ! 5 /16 ! 9
*&
0
%+#+#- 4
& 4
! ,#
) 81 4
! '() *
"
$+#+#-
81
;*(1 / #-#%%#=# 1 $+#+#-&
3 0
0
&
!
'() *
"
%+#-+#-
! 81
;*(1 /&#-#%,%%=, 1 %+#-+#-&
.) 0 8 81 2 3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#=+#-
! ! 81
;*(1 /<#-#%,-% 1<#+#=+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%#+#=+#-
&
! > .) 5 ;2
'() * ? (
/<#-,#,&
! * ! 1 ) ! "
! ? ! %#+#=+#-
%,+#=+#-&
! '() *
"
#+#9+#-
0
81
;*(1 /<#-#%9,9= 1<#+#9+#-&
- 9 -
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%:+#9+#-
0
81
;*(1 / #-#%$%=# 1< %:+#9+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#:+#-
! 81
;*(1 /& #-#=#, 1 #+#:+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
%+#:+#-
! 81
;*(1 /<#-#=$-: 1 %+#:+#-&
3 0
0
0 / &
! '() *
"
#,+#$+#-
! /
81
;*(1 /<#-##=#, 1<#,+#$+#-&
3 0
0
&
! '() *
"
#+#$+#-
! ! 81
;*(1 /<#-#=#%:$ 1 #+#$+#-&
3 0
0
! '() *
"
$+%+#-
! - 10 -
81
;*(1 /<#-#,-$,: 1 $+%+ #-&
3 0
0
&
4
! '() *
"
%#%#=
&
! ! ) 4 ;
%#%#=
##%#=
( /<#=%-:#&
! 3 0
0
%2
2 1
" 1 ! 1 / .' (2 ,2 * ! * 6 2 A -2 8
&
! 0
##%#=&
&
0
&@
6 3279:8= 5< 412:2 @2;-.8= 723574: -4 -: 2C-;264 4184 412 324-4-5627 -: :9<<27-6? <75@ & 15=2=-41-8:-: & -8,24-. -;62A -:28:2 B-41 -8,24-. 29753841A$78;2&&A327426:-56B-41A327426:-C2
24-653841A&'5==-.9=-4-:!&=;9=@5687A9,27.9=5:-:
86; 412 -6@842 B8: 472842; .56:27C84-C2=A 86; 12 -:
72D9-72;72?9=87@2;-.84-56
4-::9,@-442;,A412=28762; .596:2=<57412324-4-56274184-<412324-4-5627-:26=87?2; 56 ,8-= <57 8 =-@-42; 327-5; 412 324-4-5627 -6426; 45
- 11 -
96;27?5 :97?27A <57 >-;62A ;-:28:2 -6 8 5:3-48= 84 26?8=979
..57;-6?=A12378A:4526=87?2412324-4-5627 56,8-=56@2;-.8=?7596;<578=-@-42;327-5;
! =28762; 2394A 5=-.-457 26278=5< 6;-8 833287-6?
<57 412 72:356;264 :9,@-442; 4184 412 324-4-5627 -: -6C5=C2; -6 8 12-659: 5<<26.2: 96;27 412 375C-:-56: 5< .4 86; 12 18; @2;-.84-56 -6 412 5:3-48= 84 26478= 7-:56 8=8,978?- 86; 8=:5 96;27 47284@264 84
5:3-48= 8=8,978?- 6 :9.1 .-7.9@:486.212378A:4572G2.4412378A27
F 18C2?-C26@A86H-59:.56:-;2784-56,54156 412 :9,@-::-56 @8;2 ,A 412 =28762; .596:2= <57 412 72:32.4-C2 3874-2: 86; 3279:2; 412 ;5.9@264: @8;2 8C8-=8,=25672.57;
) : :4842; 8 3279:8= 5< 412 @2;-.8= 723574 412 324-4-5627 -: :9<<27-6? <75@ :27-59: 8-=@264: 86;-<41-:327:-:4:41272-:8417284451-:=-<2
- 12 -
" 12 56I,=2 9372@2 5974 -6 412 .8:2 5<
7235742;-6 -63878?78315
)18:5,:27C2;8:<5==5B:J 9&
&
B
&
! ! ! &
! &@
* '97412741256I,=29372@25974-6412.8:2 5< 7235742;-6 !" ! # 84 3878?7831 5:
86; !"
" 18: 5,:27C2;8:<5==5B:J ,& 4
/ ) 6
4 '
3
! '
! ! B
& >
! ! 4 %
+
) 6
&
- 13 -
'
& (
'
! &
'
& (
4 %
'
'
& CCC -:&:&
&
'
&
3
" > 5
1
B
&
'
! &@
6 3279:8= 5< 412 <-6;-6?: 5< 412 56I,=2 9372@25974-64128,5C2G9;?@264:4128..9:2;.86 ,2?78642;-6427-@,8-=5772?9=87,8-=56@2;-.8=?7596;:
- 14 -
56=A8<427-4-:<596;418441237535:2;@2;-.8=47284@264 -:8C8-=8,=2-64128-=5:3-48=
6412-6:4864.8:2-4-:654 -6;-:39424184324-4-5627-:.564-6959:=A48>-6?47284@264 84 5:3-48=8=8,978?-86;:9.18;C86.247284@264 -: 654 8C8-=8,=2 -6 412 26478= 7-:56 8: 327 412 @2;-.8= 723574
18C2?-C26@A86H-59:.56:-;2784-56,54156 412 @2;-.8= 723574: :9,@-442; ,A 412 8-= 94157-4A
6 3279:8=5<412:8@2-4.59=;,2?841272;418441272-:=-<2 41728445412324-4-5627-<412372:264@2;-.8=.56;-4-565< 412324-4-5627.564-692:<578D9-42=56?4-@2
'974127-4 -: 2C-;264 4184 -< 8 :97?27A 96;27?562 ,A 412 324-4-5627 41272 -: 8 78A 5< 1532 5< 1-: :97C-C8=
6 :9.1 .-7.9@:486.2 8: 12=; ,A 412 56I,=2 32H 5974 -6 412 8,5C2 G9;?@264 8@ 5< 412 .56:-;272; C-2B 4184 412 324-4-5627I: 72D92:4 <57 -6427-@ ,8-= -6 57;27 45 96;27?5 :97?27A -6 8 37-C842 15:3-48= 5< 1-: .15-.2 622;: 45 ,2 ?78642;
- 15 -
..57;-6?=A412324-4-56-:$$%
12 324-4-56278..9:2; 5
-: ;-72.42; 45 ,2 72=28:2;56-6427-@,8-=56=A<578=-@-42;327-5;5< <75@ 412 ;842 5< 1-: 72=28:2 -6 7-@2 5
"!( -:47-.4 -;87 72?-:4272; ,A 412 6-56 5< 6;-8 87.54-.
56475= 97289 86?8=572 (568= 6-4<574125<<26.2:396-:18,=296;272.4-56:"$.&728; B-412.4-56$,&$--&$&!)"86;*5<.4 *"!326;-6?-632.-8=8:25
!56412<-=25< 7-6.-38=-:47-.486;2::-56:9;?2-;87:9,G2.445412 <5==5B-6?.56;-4-56:
8& 24-4-5627 :18== 2H2.942 8 327:568= ,56; <57 8 :9@ 5< :
J $ 9322: B5 8>1:56=A&B-414B5:9724-2:<57412=->2:9@ 45412:84-:<8.4-565<412G97-:;-.4-568=5974K
,& 24-4-5627 -: 84 =-,274A 45 ?24 1-@:2=< 5327842; 86; 472842; -6 8 5:3-48= 5< 1-: .15-.2 84 26?8=979 86; 12 :18== 723574 412 :8@24541272:356;264 5=-.286;8=:5412 8-=94157-4-2:
- 16 -
.& 12 324-4-5627 :18== 654 ;-72.4=A 57 -6;-72.4=A 41728426 57 48@327 B-41 412 375:2.94-56B-462::2:K ;& 24-4-5627 :18== 375;9.2 8== 412 72=2C864 47284@26438327:,2<5724127-8=5974 2& 24-4-5627 :18== :97726;27 1-: 38::3574 -< 86A,2<5724127-8=5974 <& 24-4-5627 :18== :97726;27 ,2<572 412 7-8= 5974 -@@2;-842=A 8<427 2H3-7A 5< 41722 @5641:
?& 24-4-5627 :18== 654 =28C2 412 4842 5< 876848>8
,* &")
"
+ -:45
=5 J