- 1 - ! "#$$ #%% &'(&) * ! " ## $# % #& #' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ##( # #& # # #( # ) #&#* (+ # # #&# $ # % ( , # ( ' # ( ( # %' # # # # & # " # # # # % #" *# # # # ( # (( ( !% '%-' % ' %'% '%' %'%.' % '%/' ( # # "" # # #( # (( %'( # ( ( # # # % # " ' # # #(#*# # & ( & # &# # 0 &0 1& # - 3 - $# #234 566758 34 9387: ;<:7= 7>?3@< %' @9 ?27 >27:;87: 54?74 5<: >27:;87: #=3A74 %=7/7<?3@< @9 ?=@>3?374'>?""B9@=42@=?C?27 #%'>?DE?@ 47?543:7?273-6;F<7:@=:7=:5?7:" 65447:AG ?27 ::8 34?=3>? 5<: 7443@<4 ;:F7 5? 585A;=5F3 %27=73<59?7= =797==7: ?@ 54 C875=<7: 67>358 ;:F7D' 3< 67>358 547 % #' @" 5<: >@<47H;7<?8G ?@ :34>25=F75667885<?@9@=?27@997<>746;<3425A87;<:7= 7>?3@<4!% '%-'% '5<: = .7>?3@<%'@9 5<:7>?3@<4%'%='%4'%'%.'5<:% '%/'@9 # >? 5<: :34>25=F7 5667885<? @4 ?@ 9@= ?27 @997<>74 6;<3425A87 ;<:7=7>?3@<4 !% '%-' % ' 5<: = .7>?3@<%'@95<:7>?3@<4%'%.'5<: % '%/' @9 # >? 3< 67>358 547 % #' @" 67<:3<F@<?279387@9875=<7:67>358;:F7 #27 95>?;58 -5?=3I @9 ?27 >547 34 ?25? 3< ?27 G75= ?27>@-6853<5<? =746@<:7<?@ .54.@=J3<F 3< G;<:53 2@.=@@- 565<;= 5<: =743:3<F 58@<F .3?2 - 4 - 27= F=5<:-@?27= < 5>>;47: @ 3<?=@:;>7: 23-4789 AG 7I6=7443<F 234 8@/7 ?@.5=:4 =746@<:7<? @ 5<: 584@ 6=@-347: ?25? 27 .@;8: -5==G 27= 6@< 4;>2 6=@-347 5>>;47: @ 25: 47I;58 3<?7=>@;=47@<27=5?7=427584@>@<47<?7:9@=4;>25>? 5<: ?27G A@?2 .7=7 47I;588G 5>?3/7 9@= 5 67=3@: @9 9@;= G75=4 < ?27 -75<?3-7 427 A7>5-7 6=7F<5<? 5<: 584@ F@?5A@=?7: < )) 5? 5A@;? 0 6- =746@<:7<?@ 58@<F.3?24?@ 25:A77<?@?27 2@;47 @9 5>>;47: @ 5? @@K5 @8@<G ? ?25? ?3-7 5>>;47: @4 ?@ 65=7<?4 5<: 434?7=4 @9 5>>;47: @ 25/7 4?@;?8G :7<37: ?@ 67=9@=- ?27 -5==35F7 @9 5>>;47: @ .3?2 =746@<:7<? @ 54 ?27G A78@<F ?@ :3997=7<? >@--;<3?G27<=746@<:7<?@ H;74?3@<7:?2745-7 5>>;47: @ 5445;8?7: 5<: ?2=75?7<7: 27= AG 4?5?3<F ?25? 39 427 -5==G 27= A=@?27= 427 .@;8: F7? :3/@=>7 .3?23< 5 -@<?2 4 4;>2 ?27 >@-6853<? 254 A77< 8@:F7: AG =746@<:7<? @ A79@=7 ?27 =746@<:7<?@83>7 @< - 5 - " 5F53<4??275667885<?4.23>2.54=7F34?7=7:3< =3-7 @" 9@= ?27 @997<>74 6;<3425A87 ;<:7= 7>?3@<4!% '%-' 5<:% '= .7>?3@<%'@9 5<: 7>?3@<4 %'%='%4' %'%.' % '%/' @9 # >? ;A47H;7<?8G ?27 =746@<:7<?@83>7 >@-687?7:?273</74?3F5?3@<5<:853:>25=F74277?5F53<4? ?275667885<?4AG5==5G3<F?27-545>>;47:@4?@9@= ?27 59@=7-7<?3@<7: @997<>74 A79@=7 ?27 67>358 @;=? 547: @< ?27 45-7 ?27 875=<7: 67>358 ;:F7 ?@@J >@F<3L5<>7@9?27@997<>74 7<>7?275667885<?4 5>>;47: 9387: 5< 56683>5?3@< ;<:7= 7>?3@< @9 477J3<F :34>25=F79=@-?27>25=F7487/787:5F53<4??27- < 544744-7<? @9 ?27 >25=F7 4277? -5?7=3584 ?27875=<7:67>358;:F765=?8G588@.7:?2756683>5?3@<AG :34>25=F3<F5>>;47:@4 ?@9@=?27@997<>746;<3425A87 ;<:7= 7>?3@<4 %'%=' 5<: %'%4' @9 # >? FF=37/7: AG ?27 45-7 ?27 5667885<?4 25/7 9387: ?234 566758 - 6 - 75=: 875=<7: >@;<478 9@= 5667885<?4 875=<7: 3F2@;=?@/7=<-7<?875:7=9@=?27=746@<:7<?@ ?5?75<:875=<7:>@;<4789@==746@<:7<?@ ! 65=? 9=@- ;=F3<F 47/7=58 >@<?7<?3@<4 875=<7: >@;<478 9@= ?27 5667885<?4 6=3-5=38G >@<?7<:7: ?25? @< 67=;458 @9 ?27 >@-6853<? 5<: >25=F7 4277? -5?7=3584 5A4@8;?78G <@ >547 254 A77< -5:7 @;? 5F53<4? ?2747 5667885<?4 9@= ?27 @997<>74 ?27G 25/7 A77< >25=F7 4277?7:>>@=:3<F?@23-=746@<:7<?@ /3>?3-A73<F5 -5K@= 5F7: 5A@;? G75=4 25: >@<47<4;58 47I .3?2 5>>;47: @ 5<: ?27G A@?2 .7=7 47I;588G 5>?3/7 9@= 5 67=3@:@99@;=G75=4(;=?27=<@.27=73<?27>25=F74277? -5?7=3584 3? 34 9@=?2>@-3<F ?25? ?27 5667885<?4 .3?2 5< 3<?7<?3@< J<@.3<F9;88.788?25? =746@<:7<? @ A78@<F4 ?@ ?27 >27:;87 54?7 3<4;8?7: 27= >54?7 5<: >@--3??7: ?275>? ) #27 >@-6853<? 5<: @?27= 5/7=-7<?4 >875=8G =7/758 ?25? 3<3?3588G ?27 5667885<?5>>;47: @ .54 <@? 5.5=7 5A@;? 27= >54?7 #27 5887F5?3@< 5F53<4? 5>>;47: - 7 - @5<:@?27=434?25??27G>@--3??7:?27@997<>74;<:7= ?27=@/343@<4@9 #%'>?@<8G.27<427/343?7: ?27 2@;47 @9 5>>;47: @ 58@<F .3?2 4 ?@ < 4;>2 >3=>;-4?5<>7 A@?2?27 @997<>74;<:7= 5<:?27 6=@/343@<4@9 #%'>?:@<@?5??=5>?45F53<4??27 5667885<?4>>@=:3<F8G276=5G4?@588@.?27566758 75=<7:>@;<47856675=3<F9@==746@<:7<?@ @66@47: ?27 566758 AG >@<?7<:3<F ?25? ?27 4?5?7-7<? @9 /3>?3-4?@ >875=8G:34>8@47?25?5>>;47:@4?@ <@? @<8G 5A;47: ?27 /3>?3- AG -7<?3@<3<F 27= >54?7 ?27G 584@ -5:7 5< 5??7-6? ?@ 5445;8? 27= 27 9;=?27= >@<?7<:7: ?25? 5>>;47: @ 25: >@--3??7: 9@=>3A87 47I;583<?7=>@;=47@<?27/3>?3->@<?3<;@;48G9@=567=3@: @9 9@;= G75=4 < 4;>2 >3=>;-4?5<>74 A@?2 ?27 @997<>74 ;<:7=?276=@/343@<4@95<: #%'>?5??=5>?4 5F53<4? ?27 5667885<?4 >>@=:3<F8G 27 6=5G4 ?@ :34-344 ?27566758 " 75=<7: 584@ @66@47: ?27 566758 @<?27 F=@;<: ?25?<@. ?27 >25=F74277?254 A77< 853: 5F53<4? - 8 - ?275667885<?443<>7?27=734583-3?7:4>@67@9:34>25=F7 >>@=:3<F8G276=5G4?@:34-344?27566758 25/7F3/7<-G5<I3@;4>@<43:7=5?3@<A@?2@< ?274;A-3443@<-5:7AG?27875=<7:>@;<4789@==7467>?3/7 65=?3745<:?27>@-6853<?5<:@?27=-5?7=35845/5385A87@< =7>@=: 4>@;8:A7F5?27=7:9=@-=7>@=:43?34<@?3< :346;?7?25??275667885<?5>>;47:@5<:>@-6853<5<? =746@<:7<? @ .7=7 3< 8@/7 5<: A@?2 .7=7 47I;588G 5>?3/7 9@= 5 67=3@: @9 9@;= G75=4 < ?27 >@-6853<? ?27 4?5?7-7<? @9 ?27 /3>?3- >875=8G :34>8@474 ?25? 427 .54 5 >@<47<?3<F 65=?G 5<: /@8;<?5=38G 25: 47I;58 5>? .3?2 5>>;47:@43<>75>>;47:@6=@-347:?@-5==G27= 75=<7:>@;<4789@=?275667885<?4=7837:@<?27K;:F-7<? @9 @<DA87 67I @;=? 3< ?27 >547 @9 3< 67>358 75/7 7?3?3@< % '@ ! .27=73< ?27 @<DA87 67I @;=? AG =797==3<F >5?7<5 @9 K;:F-7<?4 5? - 9 - 65=5F=562 @ ) 278: ?25? ?27 @83>7 42588 <@? 7<?7=?53< ?27 ?7<:7<>G @9 8@:F3<F ?27 >@-6853<? .27=73< 95387: @= A=@J7< =785?3@<42364 25/7 F3/7< ?27 >@8@;= @9 >=3-3<583?G #2@;F2?27@997<>7@9=567A73<F@9?27F=5/74?J3<:-;4? A7 3</@J7: @<8G 3< >5474 .27=7 ?27=7 7I34?4 F7<;3<7 47I;58 /3@87<>7 >@7=>3@< @= 5A47<>7 @9 9=77 >@<47<? #@ >@</7=?7/7=G=785?3@<42363<?@5<@997<>7@9=567<@?@<8G ?=5/784?2747=3@;4<744@9?27@997<>7A;?584@3<983>?4;6@< ?275>>;47:5<3<:783A874?3F-55<:5F=5/73<K;4?3>7 668G3<F ?27 5A@/7 6=3<>36874 ?@ ?27 >547 @< 25<:3?347/3:7<??25?8@<F4?5<:3<F=785?3@<4236A7?.77< 5>>;47: @ 5<: =746@<:7<? @ 34 ?@?588G >@<47<4;58 5<: .27< 5>>;47: @ 254 584@ <@? @A?53<7: 5<G 4;>2 >@<47<?AG>@7=>3<F=746@<:7<?@ ?27@997<>74>25=F7 4277?7: ;<:7= ?27 6=@/343@<4 @9 :@ <@? 5??=5>?4 5F53<4? 23- #27 @?27= @997<>74 5887F7: 3< ?27 >25=F7 4277?;<:7=?27=@/343@<4@9 #>?34>@<>7=<7: 5>>@=:3<F ?@ 4 ?@ ?27G .3?<7447: ?27 453: 3<>3:7<? .23>2 .54 >5;47: 3< ?27 2@;47 @9 5>>;47: @ - 10 - 5<: <@? .3?23< ?27 6;A83> /37. 4 4;>2 ?27 =@/343@<4 ;<:7= #%'>?:@74<@?5??=5>?5F53<4??27- #27 @<1A87 67I @;=? 3< ?27 >547 @9 !278:?25??27@997<>7;<:7=7>?3@<%'%=' @9 ?27 >? .@;8: 3<:3>5?7 ?27 3<F=7:37<? @9 3<?7<?3@<58 3<4;8? 5<: 3<?3-3:5?3@< .3?2 5< 3<?7<? ?@ 2;-3835?7 5 -7-A7= @9 5 >27:;87: 54?7 @= 5 >27:;87: #=3A7 88 3<4;8?4@=3<?3-3:5?3@<4?@567=4@<.388<@?A75<@997<>7 ;<:7= ?27 >? ;<8744 4;>2 3<4;8? @= 3<?3-3:5?3@< 34 @< 5>>@;<? @9 /3>?3- A78@<F3<F ?@ >27:;87: 54?7 @= >27:;87: #=3A7 #27 @AK7>? @9 ?27 >? 34 ?@ 3-6=@/7 ?27 4@>3@7>@<@-3>>@<:3?3@<4@9?27>27:;87:54?745<:?27 >27:;87:#=3A7454?27G5=7:7<37:<;-A7=@9>3/38=3F2?4 #2;45<@997<>7;<:7=?27>?.@;8:A7-5:7@;?.27<5 -7-A7= @9 ?27 /;8<7=5A87 47>?3@< @9 ?27 @>37?G 34 4;AK7>?7:?@3<:3F<3?3742;-3835?3@<45<:25=544-7<?#27 5447=?3@<@9 ?3?87 @/7=?27 85<:AG73?27= @9 ?2765=?37434 <@? :;7 ?@ 73?27= 3<:3F<3?374 2;-3835?3@<4 @= 25=544-7<? - 11 - /7=G >3?3L7< 254 5 =3F2? ?@ 5/538 ?273= =7-7:374 3< 5>>@=:5<>7 .3?2 85. #27=79@=7 39 ?27 5667885<? @= 234 95-38G -7-A7=4 25/7 3</@J7: K;=34:3>?3@< @9 ?27 >3/38 >@;=?@=?25?=746@<:7<?@ 2543</@J7:?27K;=34:3>?3@< @9 ?27 >3/38 >@;=? ?27< ?27 65=?374 5=7 5/5383<F ?273= =7-7:3743<5>>@=:5<>7.3?2?276=@>7:;=774?5A83427:AG 85. ;>2 5>?3@< 34 <@? 9@= ?27 =754@< ?25? =746@<:7<? @ 34-7-A7=@9>27:;87:54?7 #27 5<@?27= J7G 3<F=7:37<? @9 ?27 6=@/343@< 34 3<4;8? @= 3<?3-3:5?3@< 3< M5<G 685>7 .3?23< 6;A83> /37.N 25?34?@A7=7F5=:7:54M685>73<6;A83>/37.N25:>@-7 ;6 9@= >@<43:7=5?3@< A79@=7 ?234 @;=? 3< ?27 K;:F-7<? =76@=?7: 54 #27@;=?25::=5.<:34?3<>?3@< A7?.77< ?27 7I6=7443@< M6;A83> 685>7N 5<: M3< 5<G 685>7 .3?23< 6;A83> /37.N ? .54 278: ?25? 39 5< @997<>7 34 >@--3??7: @;?43:7 ?27 A;38:3<F 7F 3< 5 85.< @;?43:7 5 2@;47 5<: ?27 85.< >5< A7 477< AG 4@-7@<7 9=@- ?27 =@5: @= 85<7 @;?43:7 ?27 A@;<:5=G .588 ?27< ?27 85.< - 12 - .@;8:>7=?53<8GA75685>7.3?23<?276;A83>/37.<?27 >@<?=5=G39?27=7-5=J34-5:73<43:75A;38:3<FA;?4@-7 -7-A7=4@9 ?27 6;A83> 5=7 ?27=7%<@? -7=78G =785?3/74 @= 9=37<:4'?27<3?.@;8:<@?A75<@997<>743<>73?34<@?3< ?276;A83>/37.#27@;=?278:54;<:7=0 " !"" #$ % & & '( & & ") " " & "& "&& & "& "& & & & "& * & & & & "& "& ! ) "& % ( && "& + & ," "& "&' ,""&"&' !"&&""& "& "& "& "& & - &" % & ( " " " ' < ?27 3<4?5<? >547 54 :34>;447: 4;6=5 ?27 5887F7:3<>3:7<?.54<@?>5;47:3<56;A83>685>75<:?27 5667885<?@ 5>>;47:@<73?27=@A?53<7:?27>@<47<? AG>@7=>3@<@=?2=75?<@=>@-67?7:47I;583<?7=>@;=47@< - 13 - =746@<:7<? @ ?@ A783??87 27= >54?7 4 4;>2 ?27 6=@/343@<4 @9 # %' >? 5=7 584@ <@? 56683>5A87 5F53<4? ?27 5667885<?4 5<: 5>>;47: @ 254 <@? >@--3??7: ?27 5>? 3< @=:7= ?@ 2;-3835?7 ?27 >54?7 @9 =746@<:7<? @ AG J<@.3<F 9;88G ?25? 427 A78@<F4 ?@ #44;>2?276=@/343@<4@9 #>?5=7584@<@? 56683>5A875F53<4??275667885<?4@:@;A??27=7/343@<58 6@.7=254?@A77I7=>347:465=3<F8G.3?2>5;?3@;4-5<<7= .27< ?27=7 34 5 " & >547 <@? -5:7 @;? 3< ?27 7<?3=7 >25=F7 4277? -5?7=3584 7<>7 >@<?3<;5?3@< @9 6=@>77:3<F4 5F53<4? ?27 5>>;47: 5667885<?4 34 5A;47 @9 6=@>744@9@;=?<4;>2>3=>;-4?5<>743<-G>@<43:7=5?7 /37.?275>>;47:25/7-5:7@;?5F=@;<:9@=:34>25=F7 7<>7?279@88@.3<F0 3 #27=3-3<586675834##$ 33 #27 @=:7= :5?7: " 65447: 3< 67>358 547 % #' @" AG ?27 ::8 34?=3>? 5<: 7443@<4 ;:F7 585A;=5F33427=7AG47?543:7 - 14 - 333 #27 5667885<?4 5>>;47: @4 ?@ 5=7 :34>25=F7: 9=@- ?27 >25=F74 87/787: 5F53<4? ?27- 3< 67>358 547 % #' @" %5=343<F @;? @9 =3-7 @" =7F34?7=7:AG@-7<@83>7 585A;=5F3 3?G' 67<:3<F @< ?27 9387 @9 ::8 34?=3>? 5<: 7443@<4 ;:F7 585A;=5F3 +' &$) $ & 34?@08@0