- 1 - !"! #$" " $ %& %'() % ( * ! " #$ %$ & $$ $!'! # $!'! & ()( * $ +* $ $!'! *!!! " # $ , & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !' #& ' # & - *+! ' $ '! ! * ! ! % % $ % . . / %%$ 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 !' 68 56 >;?20 504 =<1@17?9 3<6=44:17A2 ?A?1725 504 345151674< 17 6 *+! ?<1217A 6;5 68 <1@4 6 ' <4A1254<4:BC$?9?B;<?A115C6@47691=45?516786<504 68847=42 3;7120?B94 ;7:4< 4=51672 ?7: 68 6D<C <601B15167=5#86<206<5E =5F&?7:4=51672'! ! *! !<D4=5167 68347:17A67 504819468::9 1G19%;:A4H%$?9?B;<?A1 04 8?=5;?9 @?5<1I 68 504 =?24 12 50?5 504 =6@39?17?75?I@1 ) ?0?9?I@1 @?<<14: 674 <?G447 #?==;24: 6 & 67 5 504 51@4 68 @?<<1?A4 - 3 - ?==;24: 6 <4=41G4: ' 569?2 68 A69: 6<7?@4752 J KA 219G4< 154@2 2 =?20 ?2 :6D<C ?7: 2 D6<50 06;24069: ?<51=942 854< 5041< @?<<1?A4504=6@39?17?75?7:?==;24:6 0?3319C91G4: 679C 86< 21I @67502 ?7: 504<4?854< ?==;24: 6 ?7: ?==;24: 62 ?7: D06 ?<4 504 179?D2 68 504 =6@39?17?75 25?<54: 56 0?<?22 504 =6@39?17?75 B650 30C21=?99C ?7: @475?99C 5 12 8;<504< ?994A4: 17 504 =6@39?17550?5504345151674<B417A50421254<179?DG12154: 504@?5<1@671?906;24?9968?2;::4767 + ' ?7: 17251A?54:?==;24:62 56?7:?9263?<51=13?54:17504 ?994A4: >;?<<49 D01=0 0?: 5?K47 39?=4 B45D447 ?==;24: 62 56?7:504=6@39?17?75 ?24: 67 504 2?1: =6@39?175 =?@4 56 B4 <4A1254<4: 17 <1@4 6 ' BC 504 $?9?B;<?A1 15C 6@47 691=4 ?A?1725 21I ?==;24: 34<2672 17=9;:17A 5012 345151674< 86< 504 ?86<4@4751674: 68847=42 04<4?854< <42367:475 6 3691=4 17G4251A?54: 504 =?24 ?7: 9?1: =0?<A420445?A?1725?9921I?==;24:34<267217=9;:17A5012 - 4 - 345151674<BC?<<?C17A04<?2?==;24:6 ! AA<14G4:BC 5042?@4504345151674<3<484<<4:501234515167 4?<:94?<74:=6;724986<504345151674<?7:504 94?<74: 1A0 6;<5 6G4<7@475 94?:4< 86< <42367:475 6 5?54 06;A07651=424<G4:56<42367:4756 204 <4@?174:?B2475 ! 3?<5 8<6@ ;<A17A 24G4<?9 =6754751672 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1@?<19C =6754754: 50?5 67 34<;2?968504=0?<A420445@?54<1?924I=4355046@71B;2 ?994A?51672 @?:4 ?A?1725 504 345151674< ?B269;549C 76 6504< @?54<1?92?994A?51672 @?:4 ?A?1725 504 345151674< ==6<:17A 56 01@ 5012 345151674< 12 <421:17A 243?<?549C1704<@?5<1@671?906@4?D?C8<6@50406;24 68 ?==;24: 62 56 ?7: 504 =6@39?17?75 4 ?926 =6754754:50?55047G4251A?5167 881=4<@4=0?71=?99C8194: 504 =0?<A420445 ?A?1725 5012 345151674< D1506;5 @?K17A ?7C 4886<5 56 4I?@174 504 ?=5;?9 3?<51=13?5167 68 5012 345151674< 67 504 :?54 68 ?994A4: 17=1:475 2 2;=0 - 5 - ?==6<:17A5650494?<74:=6;7249504<412?=94?<@?9?81:4 1754751671286<50=6@17A675043?<568504=6@39?17?7556 1@391=?545012345151674<17504=<1@4 ==6<:17A9C3<?C256 ?996D50434515167 * 94?<74: 1A0 6;<5 6G4<7@475 94?:4< =6754754: 50?5 67 34<;2?9 68 504 =0?<A420445 @?54<1?92 504 345151674< ?926 3?<51=13?54: 17 504 17=1:475 BC ?22?;9517A 504 =6@39?17?75 67 + ' ?5 04< @?5<1@671?906@4 4?926=67547:4:50?5504<412?=94?< 17251A?5167 BC 5012 345151674< 56 ?==;24: 62 56 56 =6@@15 504 68847=4 BC 17212517A 504 =6@39?17?75 56 B<17A ?::15167?9 :6D<C 86< 3;<=0?217A ? =?< ==6<:17A9C 3<?C2 56:12@12250434515167 + 0?G4A1G47@C506;A058;9=6721:4<?516767504 2;B@122167@?:4BC50494?<74:=6;724986<504<4234=51G4 3?<5142?7:34<;24:504:6=;@4752?G?19?B9467<4=6<: ' 2 =6;9: B4 A?504<4: 8<6@ 504 =6@39?175 ?7: 6504<<4=6<:2504?994A?51672@?:4?A?1725504345151674< - 6 - ?<4 679C 6@71B;2 ?994A?51672 50?5 504 345151674< ?99 68 ? 2;::47 G12154: 504 @?5<1@671?9 06;24 68 504 =6@39?17?75 67 + ' ?7:3?<51=13?54:17504>;?<<49?7:504<4BC 8?=1915?54:?==;24:6 5656?22?;95504=6@39?17?75BC 3;9917A 04< G419 :@1554:9C ?3?<5 8<6@ 504 =6@39?17?75 ?7:04<8?@19C@4@B4<2766504<17:4347:475D15742242 =154:17504=0?<A4204450?G425?54:?B6;5504?=568504 345151674< ==6<:17A 56 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<504 =6@39?17?75 ?926 8194: ? @?17547?7=4 =?24 ?A?1725?==;24:6 734<;2?968=69;@76 *68504=0?<A420445 15 =94?<9C :431=52 50?5 345151674< 12 <421:17A ?5 ;74 ?0?<?205<? 047G4251A?517A 881=4<0?276539?=4:?7C 2;=0:6=;@47550?5345151674<0?2G12154:56$?9?B;<?A167 + ' 72;=0=1<=;@25?7=42?@68504=6721:4<4: G14D 50?5 504 =6@39?175 8194: BC 504 =6@39?17?75 ?A?1725 504 345151674< 12 D150 ? @?9?81:4 175475167 17 6<:4< 56 0?<?2204<?22041250421254<68?==;24:6 - 7 - 0467/B9434I6;<517504=?2468 <436<54: 17 ! "#$ %& 049: 50?5 504 6;<5 206;9: B4 =?<48;9 17 3<6=44:17A2 ?A?1725 :125?75 <49?51G42 17 =<1@42 34<5?1717A 56@?5<1@671?9:123;542?7::6D<C:4?502 04<49?51G468 504 0;2B?7: 206;9: 765 B4 <634: 17 67 504 B?212 68 6@71B;2 ?994A?51672 ;79422 234=181= 1725?7=42 68 5041< 17G69G4@47517504=<1@4?<4@?:46;5 7504=?24670?7:504<4?<4762;=0234=181= 1725?7=46817G69G4@47568504345151674<1286<50=6@17A17 504 =0?<A420445 47=4 17 @C =6721:4<4: G14D 504 =67517;?5167 68 504 3<6=44:17A2 ?A?1725 504 345151674< 12 ?B;24683<6=422686;<5 ==6<:17A9C3<6=44:563?22 50486996D17A. #?& 043451516712 ' #B& 04 3<6=44:17A2 17 6 *+! ?<1217A 6;5 68<1@46 '<4A1254<4:BC504$?9?B;<?A1 - 8 - 15C 6@47 691=4 5?5167 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120?B94;7:4<4=51672?7:68 =5?7: 4=51672'! ! *! !<4?:D1504=5167 68 347:17A 67 504 8194 68 ::9 1G19 %;:A4 H % $?9?B;<?A1 17 <4234=5 68 345151674<#?==;24:62 !?234<=0?<A420445&12 04<4BC>;?204: +) %" ( " 1256 . 96 .