Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54834 (KAR)

VIJAYKUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.RP/200137/2023 · 2026-01-22

Rajesh Rai K

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" " %& '(')*+ ' * , ! " " #$% ! " %& ' ($# " ' " " ###$% #$$ ' " " $$%$$ " &#$#% " "" & %% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %$( ! " %## " " " " " " ' ) ) * +,- ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12 ,- 5,./64/5 787,2-4 4+/ 9:58;/24 574/5 ###$% 37--/5 ,2 .<1#$$ => 4+/ 55< ,-4.,64 725 /--,12- :58/7,6+:. ?1. =./0,4> @",.-4 33/<<74/ 1:.4A! B+/./=> 4+/ ",.-4 33/<<74/1:.45,-;,--/54+/733/7<?,</5=>4+/./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. => 612?,.;,28 4+/ 9:58;/24 1? 6120,64,12 725 1.5/. 12 -/24/26/ 37--/5 ,2 1#&$#% 574/5 $$%$$ => 4+/ ,0,< :58/ 725 " 720, ?1. =./0,4>C4+/.,7<1:.4D! "1. 4+/ -7E/ 1? 6120/2,/26/ 4+/ 37.4,/- 7./ ./?/../5417-3/.4+/,..72E,28-=/?1./4+/.,7<1:.4 - 3 - % +/?764:7<;74.,F1?4+/3.1-/6:4,12,-4+7412 #$&$#%747=1:4$#$$7;,24+//7.<>;1.2,284+/ 766:-/5./0,-,123/4,4,12/.=/,284+/5.,0/.1?<1..>=/7.,28 ./8,-4.74,12 1&%($ 5.10/ 4+/ -7;/ ,2 7 +,8+ -3//5 725 .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 ;722/. 74 4+/ =.,58/ 1? 720,7,6+:.1757254+/./=>57-+/54+/4.7,</.4.7641. =/7.,28 ./8,-4.74,12 1 %G#G B+/./,2 4+/ 0,<<78/.- 1? /<7+7<<, 0,<<78/ 4.70/<,28 ,2 4+/ -7,5 4.7641. 4.7,</.?1.,;;/.-,121?1.572/-+7,51<,27-4./7;-7 ./-:<4 4+.// 3/.-12- 27;/<> 7<<7337 :<,8/337 725 7;/-+7 -:-47,2/5 8.,/01:- ,29:.,/- 725 <74/. 4+/> -:66:;=/5 41 4+/ ,29:.,/- 55,4,127<<> ' 725 ' -:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/- 5:/ 41 4+/ 766,5/24 - -:6+ 12/ ,-+B7.75>7 ,/ ' <158/5 4+/ 61;3<7,24 =/?1./ 4+/ ./-3125/24 1<,6/ B+,6+ B7- ./8,-4/./5 ,2 .,;/ 1#&#$#% ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/- 3:2,-+7=</ :25/. /64,12- &%%%$( !1?:=-/H:/24<>4+/./-3125/24I 1<,6/6125:64/54+/,20/-4,874,12725<7,56+7.8/787,2-4 766:-/5=/?1./4+/.,7<1:.4?1.4+/1??/26/-3:2,-+7=</ - 4 - :25/./64,12-&%%%$( !1?725/64,12-%725 ##1?64 ( 1 3.10/ 4+/ 6+7.8/- </0/<</5 787,2-4 4+/ 766:-/5=/?1./4+/.,7<1:.44+/3.1-/6:4,12/F7;,2/5& B,42/--/- 7-'#41'&725 ;7.E/5 #516:;/24-7- F-#41#+/766:-/52/,4+/./F7;,2/572>B,42/-- 12+,-=/+7<?21.;7.E/572>516:;/24- 2 7--/--;/24 1? 1.7< 725 516:;/247.> /0,5/26/4+/.,7<1:.46120,64/54+/766:-/5?1.4+/& %%%$( !1?725/64,12-%725##1?64725 -/24/26/5+,;7-:25/.) !" #$ %& ' (###)* + ,-./0 12 +'23 !'% ,!' 45 -2& '" 6&1"7 88 !" #$ %& ' (###)* + ,-./0 12 +'23 !'% ,!' 45 -2& '" 6&1"7 8#49:; !" # '<& ' (#=###)* + - 5 - ,-./0 12 +'23 !'% ,!' $ %& '" 6&1"7 8= (>( ? : , 7 !" 5##)* + ,-./0 12 +'23 !'% ,!' -2& '" 6&1"7 : +2&23 12 @" 2 ,1"7 '1A 12 B/ C2 C-.D27 /'-23 4> !E 'F 'GH '+ /0 I G 88.,/0/5 => 4+/ -7,5 9:58;/24 4+/ 766:-/53/4,4,12/. 3./?/../5 72 733/7< =/?1./ 4+/ ",.-4 33/<<74/ 1:.4 ,2 .<1#$$ +/ ",.-4 33/<<74/ 1:.4 12 ./7--/--,28 4+/ /0,5/26/ 725 516:;/24- 12 ./61.5612?,.;/54+/9:58;/241?6120,64,127251.5/.1? -/24/26/37--/5=>4+/.,7<1:.47254+/./=>5,-;,--/5 4+/733/7<?,</5=>4+/766:-/53/4,4,12/.+7<</28/414+/ -7;/,-=/?1./4+,-1:.4 /7.5</7.2/561:2-/<?1.4+/./0,-,123/4,4,12/. 725 4+/ </7.2/5 ,8+ 1:.4 10/.2;/24 </75/. ?1. 4+/ ./-3125/24474/ 37.4 ?.1; :.8,28 -/0/.7< 6124/24,12- </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. 3.,;7.,<> 6124/24/5 4+74 - 6 - 9:58;/24- :25/. 4+,- ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12 -:??/.- ?.1; 3/.0/.-,4>725,<</87<,4>-,26/4+/.,7<1:.47254+/",.-4 33/<<74/1:.48.1--<>/../5B+,</6120,64,284+/766:-/5 725 -/24/26,28 +,; B,4+1:4733./6,74,28 4+//0,5/26/ 12 ./61.5 ,2 7 .,8+4 3/.-3/64,0/ / ?:.4+/. 6124/25/5 4+74 12 3/.:-7< 1? 4+/ /0,5/26/ 1? ,29:./5 />/B,42/--/- ,/ ' 725 ' 4+/./ 7./ ;:6+ 5,-6./3726,/- 725 4+/> ?7,</5 41 ,5/24,?> 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. 7- 7 5.,0/. 5:.,28 4+/ 61:.-/ 1? 766,5/24 -,26/ 4+/ 766,5/24 B7- 67:-/5 /7.<> ;1.2,28 74 $#$$ 7; 12 #$&$#% / 7<-1 6124/25/54+74742131,241?4,;/4+/766:-/55.10/4+/ <1..>,2H:/-4,12725,2?7644+/766:-/5B7-76</72/.1? 4+/ -7,5 <1..> /-3,4/ 4+/ 20/-4,874,12 ??,6/. ?7<-/<> <7,5 6+7.8/ -+//4 787,2-4 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. B,4+1:4 3.13/.<> 6125:64,28 4+/ ,20/-4,874,12 12/4+/</-- 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12+7-214/F7;,2/54+/20/-4,874,12 ??,6/.2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/ 4+/ =/2/?,4 1? 51:=4 +7- 41 =/ /F4/25/5 41 4+/ 766:-/5./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. <4/.274,0/<> +/ 6124/25/5 4+74 4+/ .,7< 1:.4 725 ",.-4 33/<<74/ - 7 - 1:.4/../5,2,;31-,28;7F,;:;3:2,-+;/241?>/7.- ?1.4+/1??/26/3:2,-+7=</:25/./64,12%$(1?725 12 4+/ ?764 725 6,.6:;-4726/- 1? 4+,- 67-/ 725 7<-1 612-,5/.,284+/78/1?4+/766:-/54+74+/B7-$>/7.-74 4+/ 4,;/ 1? ,26,5/24 4+/ </2,/26/ 672 =/ -+1B2 41 4+/ 766:-/5./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. => ;15,?>,28 4+/ -/24/26/ ',4+ 4+/-/ -:=;,--,12- +/ 3.7>- 41 7<<1B 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12 & </7.2/5 +7- 6124/25/5 4+74 4+/.,7<1:.4725",.-433/<<74/1:.47?4/.;/4,6:<1:-<> /F7;,2,284+//24,.//0,5/26/12./61.5.,8+4<>6120,64/5 4+/ 766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. B,4+ 7 ./7-12/5 9:58;/24- B+,6+ 51 214 67<< ?1. 72> ,24/.?/./26/ 74 4+/ +725-1?4+,-1:.4/7<-16124/25/54+744+//0,5/26/ 1?'725'B+1B/./4+/,29:./5/>/B,42/--414+/ ,26,5/246</7.<>5/3,64-4+74124+/574/1?766,5/244+/ 766:-/5./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. 5.10/ 4+/ <1..> ,2 7 .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24;722/.72557-+/54+/4.7641.4.7,</.,2B+,6+ - 8 - 4+/ 5/6/7-/5 725 4+/ ,29:./5 B/./ 4.70/<,28 ?1. 4+/ ,;;/.-,121?72/-+751< #$ /?:.4+/.6124/25/54+747-4+/<1..>B7-?/<< 51B2 ,2 4+/ -4./7; 4+/ 766:-/5./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. 7<-1 -:-47,2/5 ,29:.> ,2 4+/ 766,5/24 2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/- 4+/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5 4+74 +/ B7- 214 5.,0,28 4+/ <1..> 672214 =/ =/<,/0/5 0/2 14+/.B,-/ +/ +7- 214 -474/5 /,4+/. ,2 +,- %#% -474/;/24 21. /F7;,2/5 +,;-/<? => 3.10,5,28 +,- 5/?/26/ /0,5/26/ 661.5,28<> +/ 3.7>- 415,-;,--4+/./0,-,123/4,4,12 ## +70/8,0/2;>72F,1:-612-,5/.74,12=14+12 4+/ -:=;,--,12- ;75/ => 4+/ </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ ./-3/64,0/37.4,/-7254+/516:;/24-707,<7=</12./61.5 # 7-/5124+//0,5/26/12./61.5,24+/,2-4724 67-/ 4+/ 766,5/24 ,2 H:/-4,12 =/4B//2 4+/ <1..> =/7.,28 ./8,-4.74,12 1&%($ 725 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</. =/7.,28 ./8,-4.74,12 1 %G#G 74 4+/ =.,58/ 1? 720,7,6+:. 175 12 4+/ ,24/.0/2,28 2,8+4 1? - 9 - #$&$#% 725 #$&$#% 74 7=1:4 $#$$ 7; ,- 214 -/.,1:-<>,25,-3:4/":.4+/.,4,-7<-1214,25,-3:4/4+74 5:/ 41 4+/ 766,5/24 4+.// 3/.-12- ,/ 12/ 7<<7337 :<,8/337 725 7;/-+7 -:66:;=/5 41 4+/ ,29:.,/- 725 ' 725 ' -:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/- 55,4,127<<> 41 3.10/ 4+/,. 5/74+ 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 +7- ./<,/5 12 4+/ ,2H:/-4 3726+727;7 74 F-# 725 G 725 7<-1 4+/ 7:413-> ./31.4 74 F-#$ 41 # << 4+/-/ 516:;/24- 674/81.,67<<>/-47=<,-+4+747<<4+/5/6/7-/57./5,/55:/ 414+/766,5/24--:6+4+/H:/-4,12?1.612-,5/.74,12,2 4+/,2-472467-/,-B+/4+/.4+/-7,5766,5/24B7-67:-/5 5:/ 41 4+/ .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 5.,0,28 1? 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. 1? 4+/ <1..> =/7.,28 1&%($ 725 4+/./=>57-+/5414+/4.7641.4.7,</.1-:=-4724,74/4+/ -7,5 7-3/64 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 +7- 3.,;7.,<> ./<,/5 12 4+/ /0,5/26/ 1? ' ' 725 ' B+1 7./ 4+/ ,29:./5 />/B,42/--/- 41 4+/ ,26,5/24 << 4+/-/ B,42/--/- B/./ 674/81.,67<<>-474/5,24+/,./0,5/26/4+74124+/574/1? ,26,5/244+/766:-/5B7-5.,0,284+/<1..>,27+,8+-3//5 - 10 - 725.7-+7252/8<,8/24;722/.124+/=.,58/1?7,6+:. 720,.17572557-+/54+/4.7641.4.7,</.,2B+,6+7<<1? 4+/; B/./ 4.70/<<,28 ?1. ,;;/.-,12 1? 4+/ 72/-+ 51< +1:8+4+/-/B,42/--/-B/./6.1--/F7;,2/574</284+=> 4+/,. 5/?/26/ 61:2-/< 214+,28 B1.4+B+,</ +7- =//2 /<,6,4/5?.1;4+/,.;1:4+415,-67.54+/,.4/-4,;12> #% 55,4,127<<>4+/3.1-/6:4,12+7-7<-1/F7;,2/5 '61;3<7,2724,24+,-67-/=>./,4/.74,284+/61;3<7,24 70/.;/24-'+7-674/81.,67<<>-474/54+74124+/574/ 1?,26,5/24+/7<128B,4+5/6/7-/5725'-#72541 B/./4.70/<,28,24+/4.7641.7254+/4.7641.B7--4133/5 12 4+/ /F4./;/ </?4 -,5/ 1? 4+/ 7,6+:.720, =.,58/ 4 4+744,;/4+/3/4,4,12/.=/,284+/5.,0/.1?4+/<1..>67;/ ,27.7-+7252/8<,8/24;722/.72557-+/54+/4.7641.- 7 ./-:<4 4+.// 3/.-12- B/./ 5,/5 725 14+/.- B/./ -:-47,2/5,29:.,/-661.5,2841+,;4+/<1..>7<-1?/<<12 4+/-4./7;7254+/3/4,4,12/.5.,0/.-:-47,2/5,29:.,/-5:/ 41 4+/ -7,5 766,5/24 +,- /0,5/26/ 1? ' 6</7.<> 61..1=1.74/-4+/4/-4,;12>1?'-41 - 11 - #( 1 51:=4 4+/ B,42/--/- ?1. 4+/ -314 ;7+7J7. +70/ 4:.2/5 +1-4,</ 41 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 67-/ 1B/0/. -,26/ 4+/ ,29:./5 />/B,42/--/- -:331.4/5 4+/ 67-/ 1? 3.1-/6:4,12B+1B/./0/.>;:6+3./-/24124+/-6/2/1? 4+/166:../26/4+//0,5/26/1?-314;7+7J7.B,<<2143<7> ;:6+0,47<.1</ # +/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5 4+74 +/ B7- 214 5.,0,284+/<1..>,2H:/-4,12725+/B7-76</72/.744+74 4,;/ 672214 =/ 766/34/5 ?1. 4+/ -,;3</ ./7-12 3.,;7.,<> 4+/766:-/5+7--:-47,2/5,29:.,/-5:/414+/766,5/24725 /F6/34 +,; 21=15> B7- ,2 4+/ <1..> 0/2 14+/.B,-/ +/ +7- ?7,</5 41 /F3<7,2 ,2 +,- %#% -474/;/24 ,? +/ +7- 214 5.10/4+/<1..>4+/2B+1/<-/5.10/4+/-7;/744+/4,;/ 1? 766,5/24 2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/ 4+/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5,-21473.1=7=</12/ #G 2 67./?:< 3/.:-7< 1? 4+/ 9:58;/24 37--/5 => 4+/ .,7< 1:.4 725 4+/ ",.-4 33/<<74/ 1:.4 =14+ 4+/ 1:.4-+70/.,8+4<>5/7<4B,4+4+//0,5/26/725;74/.,7<- 12 ./61.5 55,4,127<<> +70/ 3/.:-/5 4+/ 3+1418.73+- - 12 - 725 4+/ -314 ;7+7J7. 3.15:6/5 7- 3/. F 4+/ -7;/ 5/3,64- 4+/ <1..>,2H:/-4,12 B7- 57-+/5 787,2-4 4+/ 4.7641. 10/. 4+/ =.,58/ 725 7- 7 ./-:<4 4+/ -7;/ ?/<< 12 4+/-4./7;7254+/,2;74/-4.70/</.-1?4+/4.7641.4.7,</. 5,/572514+/.-B/./,29:./5 # 1./10/.4+/766:-/5+7521-:6+07<,55.,0,28 <,6/26/744+/4,;/1?766,5/242-:6+6,.6:;-4726/;/./ 212/F7;,274,12 1? 4+/ 20/-4,874,28 ??,6/. ,2 4+/ 67-/ ,4-/<?51/-21447E/7B7>4+/67-/1?4+/3.1-/6:4,12B+/2 7;3</ /0,5/26/ 1? 4+/ />/B,42/--/- 725 14+/. ;74/.,7<- 7./707,<7=</12./61.52-:6+6,.6:;-4726/7;1?4+/ 612-,5/./5 0,/B 4+74 ,24/.?/./26/ ,2 4+/ ,;3:82/5 9:58;/24-5121467<<?1. # 1B/0/. B,4+ ./87.5 41 4+/ 7<4/.274,0/ 6124/24,121?</7.2/561:2-/<?1.4+/3/4,4,12/.,2./-3/64 1? ;15,?,674,12 1? -/24/26/ ,- 6126/.2/5 75;,44/5<> 4+/ 3/4,4,12/.B7-78/57=1:4$>/7.-744+/4,;/1?,26,5/24 661.5,28 41 4+/ </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. - 13 - 3./-/24<>4+/766:-/5,-;7..,/5725+70,28-6+11<81,28 6+,<5./2 #& 2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/ 7; 1? 4+/ 612-,5/./5 0,/B4+744+/-/24/26/1?#>/7.?1.4+/1??/26/3:2,-+7=</ :25/./64,12%$(1?B1:<5;//44+//25-1?9:-4,6/ ,2-4/751?>/7.-,;31-/5=>4+/.,7<1:.4B+,6+B7- 7??,.;/5=>4+/",.-433/<<74/1:.4=>;7,247,2,28./-41? 4+/ -/24/26/- ,;31-/5 => 4+/ .,7< 1:.4 661.5,28<> 3.16//54137--4+/?1<<1B,28) , +/./0,-,123/4,4,12,- ,, +/ 9:58;/24 1? 6120,64,12 725 1.5/. 1? -/24/26/ ,;31-/5 => 4+/ .,7< 1:.4 B+,6+ B7- 612?,.;/5 => 4+/ ",.-4 33/<<74/ 1:.4 ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/- 3:2,-+7=</:25/./64,12-&%%1? 725 /64,12- % 725 ## 1? 64 ,- +/./=>612?,.;/5 ,,, +/ 6120,64,12 ,;31-/5 ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/ 3:2,-+7=</ :25/./64,12%$(1?,- - 14 - 7<-1 612?,.;/5 1B/0/. -/24/26/ ,;31-/5 ?1. 4+/ -7,5 1??/26/ ,- ;15,?,/5 ?1. 7 3/.,15 1? # >/7. ,2-4/75 1? >/7.- B,4+ 7 ?,2/ 1? -#$$$$ ,2 5/?7:<4 1? 37>;/24 1? ?,2/ 766:-/5 -+7<< :25/. 81 -,;3</ ,;3.,-12;/24 ?1. 7 3/.,15 1? G ;124+- ,0 <<4+/-/24/26/--+7<<.:26126:../24<> 0 /8,-4.>,-5,./64/541-/25=76E4+/.,7< 1:.4 ./61.5- 7<128 B,4+ 7 6/.4,?,/5 613> 1? 4+,- 1.5/. 41 4+/ 6126/.2/5 1:.4 ?1.4+B,4+ -+ '" * " ,-41)#<1)% 4)