- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %&' %()* '%) + !"#" $%" " & % '$""% (& ( ) " ! "!%%!$$ %# '$""% (& ( ) " $$!$!$$" # & %" '%" "$"# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( %# '%" !# $$" % # '%" ' #% #!%!$$! ! * & * + "" #$$"$# * ( ! + "" %! " $ & "$ ' % * # # " # !#%! " ' % * # %$#"!$% - 3 - & # '#!# * # $# "" " * * * " %" %"#%$ ( , - ! * '"" % ('' # $$!!$$!!$ # # + "" #! ## . , - & , - 4 - !- " & " $$ %$%"" . , / ( "- " #" + !"""" ( ( , "" & - #$, - " "##$ & #$ & 0 0 1( ( 2345267895:2;<84=>2?2=@=@8524:<@;2:3A2A8:22B@5C ;23D2 8< =>@: 894= =8 E@=>643E =>2 ?2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@85248@23779:268 " >2A2A8@:=3B2585427846 - 5 - 5D@2E8<=>2A2A8=>2?2=@=@85@:6@:A@::263: E@=>643E5@542:?27=8<?2=@=@852483779:268 &* " $ # >@:?2=@=@85@:<@;269562427=@85"8<>343=@F3 3C34@B943B:>335>@=3"" :22B@5C=8G93:>?487226@5C: 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524:3779:26 8: =8 @5 8 !"""" ,34@:@5C 89= 8< 4@A2 8""- 42C@:=2426HF3;3H943C@@=F&8A258;@72=3=@85?256@5C85 =>2 <@;2 8< 66; @D@; (96C2 I ( 3;3H943C@ <84 =>2 8<<2572:?95@:>3H;29562427=@85:#$ " "##$ 4E27=@85#$8<56@35253;862%,<84:>84=JK- >2 <37=: 8< =>2 73:2 @: =>3= 3779:26 8'6 H43>@A>3422<@:=>2>9:H3568<42:?85625=8"@23;@F3 3=@A3 356 =>2@4 A344@3C2 E3: :8;2A5@L26 85 "%$$" 3: ?24=>279:=8A:8<8>3AA26353E9=8<=>2E26;87B=>2F H2C8==25$7>@;6425356=>2F>3??@;F;@D26=8C2=>24=@;;=>2F234 "" = @: 3;;2C26 @5 =>2 78A?;3@5= =>3= 3<=24 "" 3779:26 8H2@5C=>2>9:H3568<42:?85625=8"3;85CE@=>3779:26 - 6 - 8" :=34=26 =8 >343:: 42:?85625= 8" H8=> ?>F:@73;;F 356 A25=3;;F HF 62A356@5C 366@=@853; 68E4F 3=24 =>2F H8=> @5:@:=26 <84 3 6@D8472 <48A 42:?85625= 8" <84 E>@7> :>2 625@26 8E2D243779:268?24<84A26=>2:27856A344@3C2 E@=> ?2=@=@8524 8 @2 3779:26 8" 85 $"" >2 :3@6A344@3C2E3::9??84=26HF3779:268: =8@2=>2 ?2=@=@8524: : :97> 42:?85625= 8" ;86C26 =>2 78A?;3@5= H2<842 =>2 42:?85625='8;@72 85 "" @5 4@A2 8"" <84 =>2 8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624 27=@85: #$' " "# # #$# 4E 27=@85 #$ 8< 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524: 9H:2G925=;F =>2 42:?85625='8;@72 785697=26 @5D2:=@C3=@85 356 ;3@6 7>34C2 :>22= 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524: HF 3443F@5C =>2A 3: 3779:26 8: =8 <84 =>2 8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624 27=@85: #$' " "# # $ 4E 27=@85 #$ 8< 5 4272@?= 8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22= =>2 3C@:=43=2 =88B 78C5@L3572 <84 =>2 3<842:3@6 8<<2572: CC4@2D26 HF =>2 :3A2 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: ?42<24426 =>@: ?2=@=@85 :22B@5C=8G93:>=>2?487226@5C: % 2346 ;234526 7895:2; <84 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: 356 ;234526 @C> 894= 8D245A25= ;23624 <84 =>2 42:?85625= 8=3=2:83;:8;2345267895:2;<8442:?85625=8" - 7 - ! ?34= <48A 94C@5C :2D243; 785=25=@85: ;234526 7895:2;<84=>2?2=@=@8524:785=25626=>3=858D243;;?249:3;8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: =>2 3;;2C3=@85: 3C3@5:= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: @2 3779:26 8: =8 =>3= =>2F @5:=@C3=26 ?2=@=@8524 83779:26 8 =8 @5:@:= 42:?85625= 8" =8 C2= 366@=@853;68E4F3563;:8?34=@7@?3=26@5=>2:27856A344@3C2 8< 3779:26 8 E@=> ?2=@=@8524 83779:26 8" 77846@5C =8 >@A =>242 342 58 :97> A3=24@3;: <84=>78A@5C @5 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= =>3= 3779:26 8 ?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2E@=>3779:268"2M72?==>2843;:3F8<42:?85625= 8" 23;:8785=25626=>3=3;;=>2:2?2=@=@8524:34242:@6@5C :2?343=2;F3=3;3H943C@356=>23;;2C3=@85@5=>27>34C2:>22= @: =>3= 3779:26 8 ?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26 8" 3= 25C3;949 5 :97> 7@479A:=3572 =>2 @5D8;D2A25=8<=>2:2?2=@=@8524:@:7;234;F89=8<D25C23572356 =>242 @: 58 :97> :?27@<@7 A3=24@3; ?;3726 3C3@5:= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: 77846@5C;F?43F:=83;;8E=>2?2=@=@85 ;234526 7895:2; <84 42:?85625= 8"78A?;3@535= 8??8:26 =>2 ?2=@=@85 HF 785=256@5C =>3= 85 ?249:3; 8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: =>242 342 3;;2C3=@85:<84=>78A@5C3C3@5:==>2:2?2=@=@8524:=>3==>2F>3D2 - 8 - @5:=@C3=26 3779:26 8 =8 >343:: 42:?85625= 8" =8 H4@5C 366@=@853; 68E4F 94=>24 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3; 3;:8 6@:7;8:2:=>3==>2:2?2=@=@8524:>3D237=@D2;F?34=@7@?3=26@5=>2 :27856A344@3C28<3779:268E@=>3779:268"5:97> 7@479A:=3572>2?43F:=86@:A@::=>2?2=@=@85 $ 234526 @C> 894= 8D245A25= ;23624 8??8:26 =>2?2=@=@85356?43F:=86@:A@::=>2?2=@=@85 : 789;6 H2 C3=>2426 <48A 427846: @= @: 58= @5 6@:?9=2=>3==>2A344@3C28<42:?85625= 8"E3::8;2A5@L26 E@=> 3779:26 8'6H43>@A >3422< @5 =>2 F234 $$" 356 =>2F >3D2 C8==25 $ 7>@;6425 89= 8< =>2@4 E26;87B >2 3;;2C3=@85: 3C3@5:= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: @5 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= 342 =>3= =>2F >3D2 >343::26 42:?85625= 8" =8 H4@5C 366@=@853; 68E4F 8E2D2485?249:3;8<=>27>34C2:>22=A3=24@3;:356 6879A25=:?;3726HF=>2;2345267895:2;=>2:2?2=@=@8524:342 42:@6@5C :2?343=2;F 3E3F <48A =>2 A3=4@A85@3; >8A2 356 <94=>243;;2C3=@85=>3==>2:2?2=@=@8524:>3D237=@D2;F@5D8;D26 @5=>2:27856A344@3C28<3779:268E@=>3779:268"@: 785724526 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: 6@:7;8:2 =>3= 3779:26 8 ?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26 8" 3= - 9 - 25C3;949 @5 =>2 F234 "" 2M72?= =>2 843; :=3=2A25= 8< 42:?85625= 8" 95624 27=@85 3H:8;9=2;F 58 :97> A3=24@3;:?;3726@5=>27>34C2:>22==8?48D2=>3==>23779:26 8 >36 ?24<84A26 =>2 A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26 8" 3= =>2 @5:=@C3=@85356@5D8;D2A25=8<=>2:2?2=@=@8524: 5:97>7@479A:=3572=>2 851H;2 ?2M894=@5=>2 73:28< 42?84=26@5 !"#$%& 3=?343C43?>8%>2;6=>3==>2 894= :>89;6 H2 7342<9; @5 ?487226@5C 3C3@5:= =>2 6@:=35= 42;3=@D2: @5 74@A2: ?24=3@5@5C =8 A3=4@A85@3; 6@:?9=2: 356 68E4F 623=>: >2 42;3=@D2: 8< =>2 >9:H356 :>89;6 58= H2 48?26'@5 85 =>2 H3:@: 8< 8A5@H9: 3;;2C3=@85: 95;2:: :?27@<@7 @5:=35728<=>2@4@5D8;D2A25=@5=>274@A2342A36289==@: 3;:8:2==;26?8:@=@858<;3E=>3=@<3?24:85@:A362=8<3723 74@A@53;=4@3;85:8A2C25243;356:E22?@5C3;;2C3=@85:E@=>89= H4@5C@5C8542784635F:?27@<@7@5:=3572:8<74@A@53;785697=@= @:58=>@5CH9=3H9:28<?4872::8<=>2894=>2894=:?8:23 69=F =8 :9HN27= =>2 3;;2C3=@85 ;2D2;;26 @5 =>2 78A?;3@5= =8 3 =>8489C>:749=@5F=8<@5689=E>2=>24=>242@:35FC3@58<=49=> @5=>23;;2C3=@85:84E>2=>24=>2F342A36285;FE@=>=>2:8;2 - 10 - 8HN27=8<@5D8;D@5C724=3@5@56@D@693;:@5374@A@53;7>34C2A842 ?34=@79;34;F E>25 3 ?48:279=@85 34@:2 <48A 3 A3=4@A85@3; 6@:?9=2 " 94=>24=>2 85OH;2 ?2M894=@5=>273:28< '(# 42?84=26@5 ) *$$+*)>2;6@5?3438:"356"3:956240 ) ! " # $% & $' $' $% ( - 11 - ,) !*+, # ! ( - . ! *+, # / . " 0 ! ..!*+, # . #- # 1 5 =>2 @5:=35= 73:2 3 H342 ?249:3; 8< 356 7>34C2:>22=A3=24@3;:7;234;F:>8E:=>3==>23;;2C3=@85:A362 HF =>2 78A?;3@535=42:?85625= 8" 342 D3C92 356 8A5@H9: =>24=>35=>23;;2C3=@85:=>3==>2>9:H356@23779:268 356>@:<3A@;FA2AH24:A25=3;;F>343::26>24E@=>362A356 <8468E4F=>278A?;3@535=>3:58=?48D@62635F:?27@<@762=3@;: - 12 - 8462:74@H2635F?34=@79;34@5:=35728<>343::A25=>2>3:58= A25=@8526 =>2 =@A2 63=2 ?;372 84 3 A35524 @5 E>@7> =>2 3;;2C26 >343::A25= 87794426 84 =>2 62=3@;: 8< =>2 53=942 8< 62A356 84 @=: ?34=@79;34: >242<842 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= ;37B: 785742=2356?427@:23;;2C3=@85:>2=24AJ7492;=FK73558=H2 2:=3H;@:>26 E@=>89= :?27@<@7 @5:=3572 >2 :3A2 E23B25: =>2 73:2 8< =>2 ?48:279=@85 356 73:=: :24@89: 689H= 85 =>2 ?48H3H@;@=F8<=>2D24:@858<=>278A?;3@535=>2A242C25243; 3;;2C3=@85: 8< >343::A25= E@=>89= ?8@5=@5C 89= =>2 :?27@<@7 62=3@;:E89;658=H2:9<<@7@25==8785=@59274@A@53;?487226@5C: 3C3@5:=35F?24:85 # =@::2==;26?8:@=@858<;3E=>3=894=:>3D2=8H2 7342<9; 356 739=@89: @5 623;@5C E@=> 78A?;3@5= 356 A9:= =3B2 ?43CA3=@7 423;@=@2: @5=8 785:@6243=@85 E>@;2 623;@5C E@=> A3=4@A85@3; 6@:?9=2: E>242 =>2 3;;2C3=@85: >3D2 =8 H2 :749=@5@L26 E@=> C423= 7342 356 7@479A:?27=@85 @5 84624 =8 ?42D25=A@:7344@3C28<N9:=@723563H9:28<?4872::8<894= 5 AF 785:@62426 D@2E 785=@593=@85 8< 74@A@53; ?487226@5C:3C3@5:==>2?2=@=@8524:@23779:268: =8@: - 13 - 58=>@5CH9=3H9:28<?4872::8<894= 77846@5C;F?487226=8 ?3::=>2<8;;8E@5C0 @ >2 4@A@53; 2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@8524 83779:268@: -- @@ >2 4@A@53; 2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@8524 8:"=8#3779:268: =8@: - @@@ >2 ?487226@5C: 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524:3779:26 8: =8 @5 8 !"""" ,4@A2 8""-42C@:=2426HF3;3H943C@@=F&8A25 8;@72 =3=@85 <84 =>2 8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624 27=@85: #$' " "# # $ 4E 27=@85 #$ 8< ?42:25=;F ?256@5C 85 =>2 <@;2 8< 66;@D@;(96C2356( 3;3H943C@@:>242HF G93:>26 ,* %!) ! @:=80;80#%