Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54810 (KAR)

THE REGISTRAR UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND ORS v. NAVEEN NANDINI

WA/200021/2024 · 2026-01-30

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $ %&"" %&"!"'! $$ () !" # $ $$%& Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " & ' !" ' # & '' (( & %$ " ) * & ) * & ) & +") ) ,-. +") ) "& !+") )# /01,223,4015043.6/,443-70-78/369::368-31195,- 9:.3: .,83. 2,113. ;< 8/3 43,:-3. 0-743 )=.73958/019=:80-&9%$;<>/06/8/3 43,:-3. 0-743 )=.73 /34. 8/,8 ,- ,.9283. 19- 01 ,419 3-80843.59:,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.1 /3 :3129-.3-8 /3:30- 5043. & 9%$ 6/,443-70-7 ,- 3-.9:13?3-8 .,83. - 3 - 011=3. ;< 8/3 ,22344,-8 9 :3@3680-7 8/3 :3A=31859:,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.19-8/3 7:9=-.8/,8/3>,1,-,.9283.19-958/3.363,13./3 43,:-3. 0-743 )=.73 0- 83:?1 95 8/3 9:.3: .,83. ,449>3. 8/3 >:08 2380809- 59449>0-7 8/3 @=.7?3-80- B 0- $ *+ .,83. "30-7 ,77:03B3. ;< 8/3 1,0. 9:.3: 8/3 ,22344,-81,:3;359:38/019=:8 !0# /3 43,:-3. 69=-134 59: 8/3 ,22344,-81 69-83-.3.8/,88/343,:-3. 0-743)=.735,043.8969-10.3: 8/,88/3.363,13.3?249<33.03.9-C,8>/06/ 290-80-80?38/3',:-,8,D,0B04 3:B0631!2290-8?3-89- 9?2,1109-,83:9=-.1#=431EE%!/3-6359:8/:353::3. 89,1F8/3=431EE%G#>,10-59:63123:=43!#95 8/3=431EE%,-,.9283.19-9:.,=7/83:95,.363,13. 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8 >,1 3H64=.3. 5:9? ,2290-8?3-8 =-.3:8/3,59:31,0.:=431 -8/01:37,:.:340,-630124,63. 9- 8/3 @=.7?3-8 95 8/01 9=:8 0- 8/3 6,13 95 - 4 - B1 !" #$%>/3:308>,1/34.8/,8I !" !# ! $%"&% & %& "''( %#& # ) ) J !00# 3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 :3129-.3-8 >,1 ;9:- 9- %123:=43958/3=431EE%,?0-9:19- ?=18/,B3,88,0-3.8/3,7395<3,:1>08/0-<3,:5:9? 8/3 .,83 95 .3,8/ 95 8/3 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8 ,-. /3 - 5 - ?=18 ?,D3 ,- ,22406,809- >08/0- <3,: 8/3:3,583: 8 01 69-83-.3.8/,88/3:3129-.3-8/,1-98,88,0-3.8/3,7395 <3,:1>08/0-<3,:5:9?C,-.8/3:359:3/3 01 -98 34070;43 89 ?,D3 ,- ,22406,809- =-.3: 8/3 =431 EE% !000# 3 -3H8 69-83-.3. 8/,8 8/3 ,2290-8?3-8 9- 69?2,1109-,83;,10101,-3H632809-898/373-3:,4:=4359: ,2290-8?3-8 3 69-83-.1 8/,8 0- 6,13 95 69?2,1109-,83 ,2290-8?3-8 8/3 1,?3 1/9=4. ;3 0- ,669:.,-63 >08/ 8/3 3H8,-816/3?31,-.:=431,-.8/3:359:38/3.323-.3-8195 8/379B3:-?3-813:B,-8,:334070;43;<B0:8=3958/329406< 95 69?2,1109-,83 ,2290-8?3-8 ,-. 8/3< ?=18 5=45044 8/3 83:?1 95 29406< >/06/ ,:3 5:,?3. ;< 8/3 8,83 - 8/01 :37,:. :340,-63 01 24,63. 9- 8/3 @=.7?3-8 95 8/3 23H 9=:80-#B1& :329:83.0- ( ) , >/3:3 08 >,1 /34. I ) - 6 - !J 3 8/3:359:3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 0?2=7-3. 9:.3: 2,113. ;< 8/3 43,:-3. 0-743 )=.73 01 0- B094,809- 95 8/3 :=431 ,-. 8/3:359:3 :3129-.3-8 01 -98 3-80843. 89 ,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,83;,101 !0B# 3 ,419 69-83-.3. 8/,8 59: 8/3 =431 EE% 89 ,224< 8/3 5,?04< 95 8/3 .363,13. 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8 1/9=4. ;3 0- 50-,-60,4 6:0101 3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8 .03. 9- C ,-. 8/3 :3129-.3-8 ,88,0-3. ?,@9:08< 9- E ,-. ,- ,22406,809-133D0-7,2290-8?3-8>,15043.9-E /3:359:38/3:301-9.323-.3-6<,-.8/35,?04<01-980- 50-,-60,4 6:0101 ,-. /3-63 8/3 ,2290-8?3-8 9- 69?2,1109-,83 7:9=-.1 -98 ;30-7 , B3183. :07/8 8/3 :3129-.3-801-983-80843.89;3,2290-83. * 8/3 43,:-3. 69=-134 59: :3129-.3-8 69-83-.3.8/,88/3,.92809-95:3129-.3-8>,13B0.3-63. ;<,:370183:3..33..,83.%,-.,-,22406,809- 133D0-7,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.1>,15043. 9- E 9>3B3: ,- 3-.9:13?3-8 >,1 011=3. ;< - 7 - 8/3,22344,-819-.0:3680-78/3:3129-.3-889 9;8,0- , 1=6631109- 63:80506,83 3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 :3129-.3-8,669:.0-74<5043.K9C$,-.9;8,0-3. ,1=6631109-63:80506,839-%/3:3,583:/35043. ,-98/3: :32:313-8,809- .,83. %C :3A=3180-7 8/3 ,22344,-81 89 2:9B0.3 ,2290-8?3-8 9- 69?2,1109-,83 7:9=-.1 3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 ,22344,-81 :3@3683. 08 9- 8/3 7:9=-. 8/,8 8/3:3 01 -9 2:9B0109- 59: ,2290-80-7 ,- ,.9283. 19- 9- 69?2,1109-,83 ;,101 3 8/3:359:3 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 7:9=-.1 =:73. 0- 8/3 >:08 ,223,4 >3:3 -98 18,83. 0- 8/3 0?2=7-3. 3-.9:13?3-8 3 8/=1 69-83-.1 8/,8 8/3 1,?3 ;30-7 04437,4 ,-. ,:;08:,:< >,1 40,;4389;3138,10.3,-.8/343,:-3. 0-743)=.73:07/84< .0. 19 3 ,419 0-B083. 8/3 ,883-809- 95 8/3 9=:8 89 8/3 @=.7?3-8 95 , 0B0109- "3-6/ 95 8/01 9=:8 0- &9$ .,83. EE /3 0B0109- "3-6/ 95 8/01 9=:8 >/043 69-10.3:0-7 , 10?04,: A=31809- :3403.=29-8/3@=.7?3-82,113.0-+ 0-& '& &( - 8 - )*(**+>/3:308>,1/34.8/,8F "''( + , /3:359:3 08 01 69-83-.3. 8/,8 8/3 ,22344,-81 6,--98 69-80-=3 89 69-83-. 8/,8 ,- ,.9283. 19- 9: .,=7/83: 01 -983-80843.89;3,2290-83.9-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.1 &3 /,B3 69-10.3:3. 8/3 1=;?01109-1 95 8/3 43,:-3. 69=-134 59: 8/3 ,22344,-81 ,1 >344 ,1 8/3 43,:-3. 69=-13459:8/3:3129-.3-8 % /3 8,839B3:-?3-80-83:?195,-980506,809- .,83.E,?3-.3.8/3=431EE%893H2,-.8/3 .350-0809- 95 , .323-.3-8 95 , .363,13. 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8890-64=.3.,=7/83:1>/9,:3.323-.3-8=29-/0? ,1 ,7,0-18 8/3 3,:403: :=431 >/06/ 2:9B0.3.8/3;3-3508 89 ,-=-?,::03..,=7/83:/3,?3-.3.=431,:3;<>,<95 1=;1808=809- 89 8/3 3,:403: :=431 ,-. 8/3:359:3 /,. 69?3 0-89 355368 5:9? 8/3 .,83 8/3 :=431 6,?3 0-89 355368 /3 9(9:.0-,83 "3-6/ 95 8/01 9=:8 0- &9$ - 9 - /,. /34. 8/,8 8/3 ,.9283. 19- 01 ,419 3-80843. 89 ;3 69-10.3:3. 9- 2,: >08/ 8/3 19- ,-. /01 6,13 59: ,2290-8?3-8 9- 69?2,1109-,83 7:9=-.1 1/9=4. ;3 69-10.3:3.9.9=;88/3:3?,<;36,131>/3:3,.92809-1 ,:3 ?,.3 9-4< 59: 8/3 2=:2913 95 73880-7 8/3 ;3-3508 95 ,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.1/3136,131?,< ;3 5,: ,-. 53> ,1 8/01 ?,< ;3 0- :312368 95 79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-81 >/9 ,:3 ;,6/349:1 9: 120-183:1 /3:359:3 8/3 ,22344,-81 ,:3 ;9=-. 89 ;3 >,:< 95 1=6/ 6,131 - 8/3 0-18,-86,138/379B3:-?3-813:B,-8>,1,;,6/349:,-. >,1 ,73. <3,:1 ,8 8/3 80?3 95 /01 .3,8/ 3 ,.9283. 8/3 :3129-.3-8 9- % ,-. 4,83: .03. 9- C /3 ,.92809- 01 3B0.3-63. ;< , .33. .=4< :370183:3. ,-. 8/3 ,22344,-81 /,B3 -98 .9=;83. 8/3 73-=0-08<958/3,.92809-/3:359:3>3,:3958/3920-09- 8/,88/3:3129-.3-8;30-7,-,.9283.19-958/3.363,13. 79B3:-?3-813:B,-8>,13-80843.89133D59:,2290-8?3-8 9-69?2,1109-,837:9=-.1 - 10 - C 1:37,:.198/3:7:9=-.1=:73.;<8/343,:-3. 69=-13459:8/3,22344,-810801:343B,-889-9838/,80-8/3 3-.9:13?3-8 0?2=7-3. ;359:3 8/3 43,:-3. 0-743 )=.73 8/3,22344,-81.0.-98?3-809-8/,88/3,22406,809-958/3 :3129-.3-8 >,1 :3@3683. 9- 8/3 7:9=-. 8/,8 8/3 :3129-.3-8/,.5,043.89,88,0-8/3,7395?,@9:08<>08/0- <3,:5:9?8/3.,8395.3,8/958/3.363,13.79B3:-?3-8 13:B,-8 ,-. 8/,8 /3 5,043. 89 5043 ,- ,22406,809- >08/0- <3,:/3,22344,-816,--981=2243?3-8,..0809-,4:3,19-1 0-8/3,223,4?3?9@=1805<0-78/3:3@36809-958/3:3A=318 95:3129-.3-8 -8/369-8:,:<0801133-5:9?8/3:369:.18/,8 ,-,22406,809-59:133D0-7,2290-8?3-89-69?2,1109-,83 7:9=-.1 >,1 5043. 9- ;3/,45 95 8/3 :3129-.3-8 9- E ,-. 8/3 ,22344,-81 /,. .0:3683. 8/3 :3129-.3-8 89 9;8,0- , 1=6631109- 63:80506,83 /3 :3129-.3-8 9;8,0-3. 8/3 1=6631109- 63:80506,83 9- % ,-. 8/3:3,583: ,22:9,6/3. 8/3 ,22344,-81 5 8/3 :3129-.3-8 >,1 -98 3-80843. 59: ,2290-8?3-8 9- - 11 - 69?2,1109-,837:9=-.18/3,22344,-81?=18/,B3:3@3683. 08 9=8(:07/84< 9>3B3: 8/=1 69-53::3. :3129-.3-8 89 :31=;?0808,583:73880-7,1=6631109-63:80506,83>/06/>,1 .=4< .9-3 /3:359:3 8/3 69-83-809- =:73. ;< 8/3 ,22344,-818/,88/3:3129-.3-8.0.-9850438/3,22406,809- >08/0- 80?3 ,-. 01 ,419 >08/9=8 ;,101 ,-. 01 40,;43 89 ;3 :3@3683. 9-13A=3-84< 8/01 ,223,4 4,6D1 ?3:08 ,-. 01 E -B03>95.01291,495,223,4 9$59: 18,< .931 -98 1=:B0B3 59: 69-10.3:,809- 669:.0-74< 08 01 .012913.955 -+ (") " -+ (!"'!) " 0189 49