Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54808 (KAR)

THE RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. LAXMI AND ORS

MFA/204194/2023 · 2026-01-22

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $ %" " %" !"&! $$ '&( ) !" !!! !! ! # $ % ! & #' (" ( '(# # ) # Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *+"! ' ( ! &#' (" ( '(# # ) # *+"! ' ( '(# # ) # *+"! " #' , ( '(# # ) # *+"! - 3 - ' , ( , ' (- (# )'! '( *+"! % !. '!. ' !! , # !/! # - #!+)) ,' ! - - - - # ( ( 0- - 123 0- - - 4 - " ( 0- - 45 267858 96 92 1::51; <41;;52=92= >45 ?73=@52> 123 1A183 31>53 !+ :16653 BC >45 892<9:1; 529D8 9E9;-73=5123 -123339>9D21; 9318 4585921F>58 85F58853 >D 16 G>45 89B721; FD8 B85E9>C 92 D ,' ! 9 45 856:D2352>6 185 >45 ;5=1; 85:85652>1>9E56DF35<5165312@12>4A4D39539218D13 >81FF9< 1<<9352> D2!"!! !+ A49;5 45 A16 >81E5;;92= 92 12 17>D)89<H641A B51892= 5= D)'! 45 856:D2352>6 F9;53 1 <;19@ :5>9>9D2 <;19@92= <D@:5261>9D2 DF 6,') 45C <;19@53 >41> >45 35<51653 12@12>4 A165@:;DC5316 1 12 5<4129<92>45981I 7=18 1<>D8C DF 12215H45;9 123 A16 518292= 1 67@ DF 6 !",+') 5E58C @D2>4 123 >41> >45C ;D6> 12 518292= @5@B58DF>45F1@9;C - 5 - 99 45 <;19@ :5>9>9D2 A16 D::D653 BC 267858 DF >4517>D)89<H641A 999 45 89B721; 1F>58 <D26935892= >45 <D2>52>9D26 78=53 45;3 >41> >45 35<51653 A16 518292= 1 @D2>4;C 92<D@5 DF 6 ! ,+') 1F>58 3537<>92= 6 ') >DA1836 :8DF5669D21;>1J>13353;D66DFF7>78592<D@51>"KDF >4561;18C1231A18353>45FD;;DA92=<D@:5261>9D2( ! D66DF35:52352<C 6" +/ ') D66DF<D26D8>97@ 6 ') D66>D56>1>5 6!') " 8126:D8>1>9D2 DF 3513 BD3C 123 F72581;5J:52656 6!') *+, - #.# / 592=1==895E53BC>45<D@:5261>9D21A18353 >4526785896921::51; " 45 ;518253 <D7265; FD8 >45 267858 <D2>52353 >41>>4535<51653A165@:;DC536516D21;;C123>4585FD85 >45 89B721; <D@@9>>53 12 588D8 92 <D26935892= 496 1ED<1>9D2161:5852291;6D78<5DF92<D@545>4585FD85 <D2>52353>41>>459@:7=253?73=@52>1231A183:16653 - 6 - BC >45 89B721; 96 2D> ?76> 123 :8D:58 123 >45 <D@:5261>9D2 1A18353 BC 9> 96 5J<5669E5 45 1;6D <D2>52353 >41> >45 89B721; 413 1A18353 92>5856> 1> >45 81>5DFK:581227@D2>45<D@:5261>9D2>4D7=4>4585 962D?76>9F9<1>9D2FD81A18392=67<449=45892>5856> >45 ;518253 <D7265; FD8 >45 856:D2352>6 67B@9>>53 >41> #) A16 5J1@9253 123 45 35:D653 >41> >45 5@:;DC@52> DF >45 35<51653 A16 2D> 6516D21;B7>A16:5852291;123>4585FD85>4589B721;A16 89=4> 92 <D26935892= >45 92<D@5 DF >45 35<51653 1> 6 ! ,+') 45 4DA5E58 393 2D> 396:7>5 >45 F1<> >41> >4585962D?76>9F9<1>9D2FD81A18392=92>5856>1>>4581>5DF K:581227@ , #5 41E5 <D26935853 >45 67B@9669D26 @135 BC >45;518253<D7265;FD8>4526785816A5;;16>45;518253 <D7265;FD8>45856:D2352>6 / 4561;18C<58>9F9<1>5A49<496:;1<53D285<D83 16J)+56>1B;96453B5CD233D7B>>41>>4535<51653A16 - 7 - 518292=167@DF6 ! ,+')16496@D2>4;C92<D@5161 12 5<4129< 92 9318 96612 41H418 18H4121 9@9>53 A49<4:D:7;18;C96H2DA216981I7=181<>D8C458596 2D 8516D2 A4C >45 5E9352<5 DF #) 64D7;3 2D> B5 1<<5:>53 + 92<5 >45 ;91B9;9>C DF >45 267858 96 2D> 92 396:7>5 A5 3D 2D> 655 12C 588D8 92 >45 ?73=@52> 123 1A183 :16653 BC >45 89B721; 35>58@9292= >45 <D@:5261>9D2:1C1B;5>D>45856:D2352>6BC>851>92=>45 @D2>4;C92<D@5DF>4535<516531>167@DF6 ! ,+') 123 F1<>D892= "K >DA1836 ;D66 DF F7>785 :8D6:5<>6 DA5E58 16 85=1836 >45 81>5 DF 92>5856> 1A18353 BC >45 89B721; >4585 96 2D ?76>9F9<1>9D2 92 >45 ?73=@52> 123 1A183 >D =812> 92>5856> 1> >45 81>5 DF K :58 1227@ D2 >45<D@:5261>9D21A18353 2>41>E95ADF>45@1>>581::51;96 - 8 - ! 45 9@:7=253 ?73=@52> 123 1A183 31>53 !+ :16653 92 D ,' ! BC >45 <D78> DF >458;529D8 9E9;?73=5123 -12333; 9318 926DF18169>35>58@9253>45<D@:5261>9D2:1C1B;5>D>45 <;19@12>6'856:D2352>61>6"!/ ')962D>396>78B53 DA5E58 >45 92>5856> :1C1B;5 BC >45 267858 >D >45 856:D2352>6D2>45<D@:5261>9D21@D72>968537<53F8D@ K :58 1227@ >D ,K :58 1227@ F8D@ >45 31>5 DF >45 <;19@ :5>9>9D2 >9;; 851;9I1>9D2 45 B1;12<5 <D@:5261>9D2 641;; B5 35:D69>53 B5FD85 >45 89B721; A9>492 D25 @D2>4 F19;92= A49<4 >45 92>5856> :1C1B;5 641;; B5 1> K :58 1227@ F8D@ >45 31>5 DF <;19@ :5>9>9D2 123 641;; B5 85<DE5853 FD8@ >45 :586D2 856:D269B;5 FD8 >45 35;1C 92 35:D69>92=>45<D@:5261>9D2 !! 45D8358:16653BC>4589B721;:58@9>>92=>45 267858 >D :1C 123 85<DE58 >45 <D@:5261>9D2 F8D@ >45 DA258962D>396>78B53 ! 45 1@D72> 92 35:D69> 96 D835853 >D B5 >8126@9>>53>D>4589B721;FD81::8D:891>5D83586 - 9 - ! FF9<5 96 3985<>53 >D 85>782 >45 >891; D78> 85<D8361>>45518;956> 0/ '"( " 0/ '!"&!( " 96> D(!; D(!!