- 1 - ! " # $%!! $%! !& &%## '( (## )* ' ( !"#$% & ' (''' ) # ** !"#+# $ , Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' !"#+# * ' ' *- . +++# & ('* #/0 * $) '' * ## * ' * #%1# ' ' * ' * * $!##$+$" -' $+#$+$" ' , ' ' ' * * ( ' ( , ' ' !"#+# '' ( ) # !"#$% - 3 - $ ** !"#+# ' ('* $) - '' * " * #%# ' * -' $+#$+$"/ * $"##$+$" ' - ' $+#$+$" ' ' - '' * - 2 2 (' 2) -345 677869 :$+++$$$+$4 ;498< =>6998?@4?@ 5>8 :3<83 <658< $!##$+$" 768< AB 5>8 9863?8< 4?@98 C<@84?-':$+#$+$" $ :$++$$#$+$ 4 ;498< 6998@4?@ 5>8 ?:?=:D7946?=8:;5>8:3<83<658<$!##$+$"768<AB 5>89863?8<4?@98C<@84?-':$+#$+$" - 4 - >8 96?< A8634?@ C3E8B :## D86C34?@ # 6=38 6?< @C?56 45C658< 65 6D6<C3@6 4996@8 65 8:<C3@669CF64=>C3 4534=5A89:?@4?@5:387:?<8?5 :# G6 6=HC438< AB 5>8 5658 :E83?D8?5 ;:3 5>8 A8?8;45 :; 5>8 63?656F6 8836E634 4@6D 4D458< 4? 5>8 B863 #%%" ->8? 6? 67794=654:? G6 D6<8 AB 5>8 387:?<8?5:#C?<838=54:?$!:;5>86?<=HC4454:? =5 #!%" 5>8 6?< =HC4454:? ;;4=83 >6< @36?58< 8?>6?=8<=:D78?654:?:;$+ + !:G8E835>8 64< =:D78?654:? G6 ?:5 764< 5: 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# G>4=>=:D78998<>4D5:;498-':!++$$$+#+>8: 3<4?658 8?=> :; 5>4 :C35 4? 583D :; 6? :3<83 <658< +"#+$+#+ ?:54=8< 5>65 6 CD :; #++++++ G6 764< 5: 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# AB G6B :; 6 =>8HC8 4? 5>8 :C356?<6CD:;+++++G669386<B764<>4 :C355>838;:38>89<5>655>8387:?<8?5:#G68?54598< 5: 5>8 A696?=8 6D:C?5 :; 1 + ! >838;:38 5>4 :C35 <47:8< :;; 5>8 G345 785454:? @36?54?@ $ D:?5>2 54D85:76B5>8A696?=8:;=:D78?654:?:;1 + ! - 5 - >8 64< :3<83 G6 ?:5 =:D7948< 6?< 5>838;:38 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# G6 =:?5364?8< 5: CAD45 6 387388?5654:? <658< ##+$+$ <8D6?<4?@ 5>8 A696?=8 6D:C?5 :; 1 + ! 69:?@ G45> 4?58385 4?=8 5>8 6D8 G6 ?:5 =:?4<838< 5>8 387:?<8?5 ;498< -' :$+$+$" 88F4?@ ;:3 6 <438=54:? 5: =:?4<83 5>8 387388?5654:?<658<##+$+$4?5>894@>5:;5>8:3<83 768< 4? -' :!++$$$+#+ >8 G345 785454:? G6 699:G8< E4<8 :3<83 <658< $!##$+$" 6?< 5>8 6778996?5 G838 <438=58< 5: 6<<38 5>8 @348E6?=8 :; 387:?<8?5 :# 84?@ 6@@348E8< AB 5>8 64< :3<83 5>4 677869 4 ;498< " >89863?8<=:C?89;:35>86778996?5CAD4558< 5>65 5>8 6778996?5 >6 A88? ;:99:G4?@ C7 G45> 5>8 387:?<8?5 :$ 38@63<4?@ 5>8 76BD8?5 :; 5>8 A696?=8 CD :; 1 + ! 8 CAD45 5>65 8E8369 985583 =:3387:?<8?=8 >6E8 8?C8< A85G88? 5>8 6778996?5 6?< 387:?<8?5 :$ =:DD8?=4?@ ;3:D #1+%$+## +#+$+$ ##+$+$ $##+$+$ 6?< # ##$+$ - 6 - >8386;583 4? E48G :; 5>8 =:?58D75 785454:? ;498< AB 5>8 387:?<8?5 6?:5>83 985583 <658< $"##$+$ G6 6<<388< 5: 5>8 <D4?45365:3 5: 389868 5>8 A696?=8 =:D78?654:?6D:C?5 76B6A98 5: 5>8 387:?<8?5 :#;3:D>4783:?69<87:458CAD455>656?:5>83 985583 <658< ###$+$ 4 6<<388< AB 5>8 63?656F6 8836E634 4@6D 4D458< <438=54?@ 76BD8?5 :; =:D78?654:? 5: 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# ;3:D 5>8 783:?69 6==:C?5 :!"$++#+ 8 =:?58?< 5>65 699 5>88 <:=CD8?5 =:C9< ?:5 A8 796=8< A8;:38 5>4 :C35 4?-' :$+#$+$"85>838;:38CAD455>655>8<438=54:? 4;6?B5:76B5>8=:D78?654:?DC5>6E85:A84C8<5: 387:?<8?5:$>8384?6?<?:55:5>86778996?5 9863?8<=:C?89;:3387:?<8?5:# CAD455>655>896?<G66=HC438<4?583D:;?:54;4=654:? 4C8< AB 5>8 6778996?5 >8384? 6?< 5>838;:38 45 G6 5>8 6778996?5 G>: G6 387:?4A98 5: 8?C38 76BD8?5 :; =:D78?654:? 5: 387:?<8?5 :# 8 CAD45 5>65 5>8 6D:C?5 :; =:D78?654:? 4 69386<B ;3:I8? 6?< 45 4 5>8 - 7 - 6778996?5 6?< 5>8 387:?<8?5 :$ G>: >6< 5: 56F8 ?8=863B 587 5: 8?C38 76BD8?5 :; =:D78?654:? >C>8=:?58?<5>655>8384?:833:34?5>84D7C@?8< :3<83 768< AB 5>8 4?@98 C<@8 <438=54?@ 5>8 6778996?5 6?< 387:?<8?5 :$ 5: 76B 5>8 A696?=8 =:D78?654:? 76B6A985:387:?<8?5:# -8 >6E8 =:?4<838< 5>8 CAD44:? :; 5>8 9863?8<=:C?89;:35>86778996?59863?8<=:C?89;:35>8 387:?<8?5 :# 6?< 9863?8< <<454:?69 :E83?D8?5 <E:=658;:35>8387:?<8?5:$ 1 >8387:?<8?5:#>6 9:5 96?<;:367CA94= 7C37:8 4? 5>8 B863 #%%" 8 G6 5>838;:38 8?54598< ;:3 =:D78?654:? ?=8 6? :3<83 C?<83 8=54:? $! :; 5>8 6?<=HC4454:?=5#!%"G6768<45G64?=CDA8?5 C7:?5>86778996?56?<5>8387:?<8?5:$5:8?C385>65 5>8 =:D78?654:? 4 764< 5: 387:?<8?5 :# >8 387:?<8?5 :$ >6 764< 6 CD :; #+++++ 6?< 5>8 A696?=8 6D:C?5 :; 1 + ! 4 76B6A98 6?< 5>8 6D846<D4558<4?-':!++$$$+#+>4:C35>6< - 8 - @36?58< $ D:?5> 54D8 5: 5>8 6778996?5 6?< 387:?<8?5 :$5:76B5>8A696?=8:;=:D78?654:?4?583D:;:3<83 <658< +"#+$+#+ >8 6D8 4 ?:5 764< 5499 <658 G>4=> >6 =:D78998< 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# 5: ;498 -' :$+#$+$" ! 9863?8< 4?@98 C<@8 :; 5>4 :C35 ;:99:G4?@ 5>8 :3<83 768< 4? -' :!++$$$+#+ <438=58< 5>8 =:?4<83654:?:;5>8387388?5654:?:;5>8387:?<8?5:# ;:376BD8?5:;5>8A696?=8=:D78?654:?;5>86778996?5 >6 6<<388< 985583 5: 5>8 387:?<8?5 :$ =:D78994?@ 5>876BD8?5:;5>8=:D78?654:?454;:35>86778996?55: 7C3C85>8387:?<8?5:$6?<8?C385>655>86D84 764<G45>:C56?B;C35>83<896B>838;:38G8<:?:588 6?B833:34?5>8:3<83768<AB5>89863?8<4?@98C<@8 G6336?54?@ 4?583;838?=8 4? 5>4 G345 677869 ==:3<4?@9B % 8;:38G87635;3:D5>8=68387:?<8?5:# >6 A88? 9454@654?@ 5: =964D G>65 4 96G;C99B <C8 5: >4D ;3:D5>8B863$+#+>86778996?56?<387:?<8?5:$ - 9 - G>: 638 <C5B A:C?< 5: 8?C38 5>65 5>8 =:D78?654:? 4 764<>6E8C55839B;6498<4?5>843<C5B5:<::>838;:38 5>8A696?=8 :; =:D78?654:? 76B6A98 5: 387:?<8?5 :# >699A8764<G45>4?67834:<:;$G88F;3:D5:<6B69:?@ G45>4?5838565# J7836??CD6;5838K743B:;:?8D:?5> ;3:D 5>8 <658 :; <47:84:? :; 5>8 387:?<8?5 :# ;3:D5>896?<4?HC854:?G45>4?58385667794=6A98C?<83 5>8 6?< =HC4454:? =5 ;3:D 5>8 <658 :; 5>8 6G63< 5499 76BD8?5 >8 4?58385 5>65 D6B A8 764< 5: 387:?<8?5 :# >699 A8 38=:E838< ;3:D 5>8 4?=CDA8?5 :;;4=83 :; 387:?<8?5 :$ :3 5>8 783:? 387:?4A98 ;:3 5>8 <896B 6?<5>86778996?5:C5:;5>8436963B #+ ? E48G :; 5>8 LC<@D8?5 768< 4? - :$+++$$$+$5>8 3883E4?@94A835B5:5>8=:D7964?6?5 5: 88F38E4E69 4? 5>88E8?5 5>8 6==C8< 4? 5>8 =:?58D75 785454:? ;649 5: =:D79B G45> 5>8 :3<83 768< 4? - :$+++$$$+$ - 10 - 863?8< <<454:?69 :E83?D8?5 <E:=658 4 783D4558< 5: ;498 D8D: :; 6778636?=8 ;:3 387:?<8?5 :$G45>4?5G:G88F +' )!* ! +' ) !& * ! 45:#9:##