- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %&' %()* '%) + !" # $# $ % & "" !'( # $ ) #& $ * !'( & * && !'('+ % & & % !'( #!* $ ) #& & $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * '%( * &! %%"$ % " # $ + %% ** * % %% & * ** & "+ ' "% %% %% * "#%$#$* (* &$ & * & ,& * * * * -& ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582: 2;3/45 '%( 46 &.<:<3/=< <><:/?9:<?0.<<5./3<%%"022?/5>34@9<0.1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 <;;9028 40% <58 " /5 17# $ 4+ %%#<:/0/5>49346:/A24% %%$:2>/032:28B=3.2 7A27 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 "+ ' "% %% %% 46 <58 2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46 - 3 - #:2C253/45 46 3:4;/3/20$ A258A253 ;3 %' #64: B:2C/3= D #$;3E$1258/5>453.26/724688/3/45<7/03:/;3 <58200/45<5812;/<7 98>2/F<=<19: % .2 6<;39<7 A<3:/G 46 3.2 ;<02 /0 3.<3 45 '%% <3 <B493 " 1A H.25 :201458253 4% <58 ./0 6<3.2: #54H 82;2<028 /5 3./0 ;<02$ H2:2 1:4;228/5> /5 < A434: ;=;72 6:4A 3.2/: <>:/;9739:<7 7<58 34H<:80 7A27 <58 H.25 3.2= :2<;.28 52<: <:5<3<?< &<5? /5 7A27 /3= 04A2 95?54H5 <;;9028 12:045 H<0 1:4;228/5> 34H<:80 3.2A /5 < H:45>8/:2;3/45 .2 0<A2 H<0 @9203/4528B= 3.2 :201458253 4%<33.<33/A2.2/564:A283.<3<3:<;34:/01<:?28453.2 :/>.30/82463.20</8:4<8.25;2.2/01:4;228/5>/53.2H:45> 8/:2;3/45 9:/5> 09;. <732:;<3/45 3.2 0</8 12:045 <00<97328 :201458253 4% 45 ./0 ;.22? <58 <B9028 ./A /5 6/73.= 7<5>9<>2 .2 0<A2 H<0 @9203/4528 B= 3.2 6<3.2: 46 :2014582534%33.<33/A23.20</812:045344?493<?5/62 H./;.H<0B252<3.3.202<3463.2A434:;=;72<5803<BB28/534 3.2 034A<;. 46 :201458253 4%,0 6<3.2: .25 :201458253 4% A<82 <5 <332A13 34 :20;92 ./0 6<3.2: 3.2 0</8 12:045 <7043:/2834<00<973./A632:/567/;3/5>09;./5F9:=3.219B7/; ><3.2:28 3.2:2 <58 @9203/4528 3.2 12:045 H.4 03<BB28 - 4 - :2014582534%,06<3.2:<58<33.<33/A2/3H<0:2C2<7283.<3 ./05<A2H<0F/3.045465<58<58<:>/<58.2H<0<6:9/3 C2584:<32::2014582534%<58./06<3.2:H<0<8A/3328/5 3.2 .401/3<7 <58 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</53 <></503 3.2 0</8 F/3. /2 <;;9028 4 45 '%% 9:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 3:2<3A253:2014582534%,06<3.2:09;;9AB28343.2/5F9:/20 45%% " 5 3.2 03:25>3. 46 ;4A17</53 3.2 * ;<A2 34 B2 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4% %% 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/45 "%" "% "+ <58 ' 46 9B02@92537= 89:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45 :201458253 4!47/;2 <::203283.2<;;9028445%%(%%9:/5>3.2;49:0246 ./0 /5C203/><3/45 /5 ./0 C47953<:= 03<32A253 .2 :2C2<7283.<3 <632:3.2/5;/8253.220;<128<58H2533458.:<:<820.<58 3.2:2<632: 34 <.<:<0.3:< <58 123/3/452: 4 /2 <;;9028 4%/0B:43.2:46<;;90284<5823/3/452:4%/2<;;9028 4" B2/5> ./0 :27<3/C2 2G325828 A4523<:= .271 34 ./A 34 20;<126:4A3.2;793;.204647/;2<58<;;90284".<0>/C25 0.2732: 34 <;;9028 4 0 09;. :201458253 4!47/;2 /A17/;<328 3.202 123/3/452:0 /5 3.2 ;:/A2 64: 3.2 46625;2 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 %% <58 %% 46 632: - 5 - ;4A1723/5> 3.2 /5C203/><3/45 :201458253!47/;2 7</8 ;.<:>2 0.223 <></503 <;;9028 4 <58 3.202 123/3/452:0 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 "+ ' "% % <58 %% 46 <58 2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46 3.2 #$ ;3 .2 72<:52812;/<7 98>2344?;4>5/I<5;24646625;20 25;23.2 123/3/452:06/7283./0123/3/4534@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0<></503 3.2A 2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58 72<:528 />. 49:3 4C2:5A253 72<82: 64: 3.2 :201458253 4 ! 3<32 201/32 02:C/;2 46 543/;2 :201458253 4% .<0 543<112<:28B264:23./049:3 ' 1<:36:4A9:>/5>02C2:<7;453253/4503.272<:528 ;49502764:3.2123/3/452:0.<0;453258283.<3<8A/33287=3.2 /5;/8253 H<0 ;<9028 45 '%% B23H225 3.2 :201458253 4%./082;2<0286<3.2:<58<;;902842014582534% /0 <5 2=2 H/35200 34 3.2 /5;/8253 <58 <;;4:8/5> 34 ./A 3.2 <;;902841/;?2891<@9<::27H/3../A<58./06<3.2:<58 892343.2<732:;<3/45.2344?493<?5/626:4A./0A434:;=;72 <5803<BB28453.2<B84A25463.282;2<028/23.26<3.2:46 :201458253 4% 0 < :20973 ./0 6<3.2: 0903</528 02C2:2 - 6 - B7228/5>/5F9:/20<5809B02@92537=09;;9AB28343.2/5F9:/20 8A/33287= 3.202 123/3/452:0 H2:2 52/3.2: /5 3.2 0;252 46 4;;9::25;254:1<:3/;/1<328/53.2/5;/82538/:2;37=4:/58/:2;37= .2 <772><3/45 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 /0 3.<3 <;;9028 4 H./72<B0;458/5>.2344?0.2732:H/3.3.2.27146<;;90284" <58 <;;9028 4% 2G325828 A4523<:= .271 34 ./A <3 <.<:<0.3:<&933.2;.<:>20.223A<32:/<784205438/0;7402 3.<3 <;;9028 4% 2G325828 A4523<:= B2526/3 <58 <;;9028 4" >/C25 0.2732: 34 ./A ?54H/5> 6977= 3.<3 <;;9028 4 /5C47C28 /5 3.2 ;4AA/00/45 46 3.2 <772>28 ;:/A2 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 2G;213 3.2 C47953<:= 03<32A253 46 <;;9028 4<B0479327=5443.2:1/2;2462C/825;2 A<32:/<70<C</7<B72 45 :2;4:8 34 /A17/;<32 3.202 123/3/452:0 /5 3.2 <772>28 ;:/A2 &= :27=/5> 45 3.2 F98>A253 46 3.2 4!4:8/5<32 &25;. 46 3.2 2:<7< />.49:3/53.2;<0246 .2;453253283.<3/54:82:34/5C4?22;3/45 %%<58%%46<021<:<32;<02.<034B2:2>/032:28<58/3 .<0 34 B2 /5C203/><328021<:<327= <58B<028 453.2 C47953<:= 03<32A2533.243.2:<;;9028;<5543B2/A17/;<328/53.2A</5 ;<02 <58 ;.<:>2 0.223 ;<5543 B2 7</8 <></503 3.2A ;;4:8/5>7=.21:<=034<774H3.2123/3/45 - 7 - 3.2 72<:528 4114028 3.2 1:<=2: B=;453258/5>3.<33.<33.2;.<:>20.223A<32:/<708/0;74023.<3 <;;90284%2G3258283.2A4523<:=.27134<;;90284<58 <;;90284"1:4C/8280.2732:34<;;90284/5<3./50.28<3 9AB</3420;<126:4A3.2;793;.20463.247/;2B=?54H/5> 6977= 3.<3 <;;9028 4 ;4AA/3328 3.2 .2/5490 46625;2 9582: 2;3/45 "% 46 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 ;<5543 B2 @9<0.28 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 ;;4:8/5>7= .2 1:<=0348/0A/003.2123/3/45 + .<C2>/C25A=<5G/490;450/82:<3/45B43.453.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/C2 1<:3/20<5812:90283.284;9A2530A<82<C</7<B7245:2;4:8 ( 0 ;4978 B2 ><3.2:28 6:4A :2;4:80 /3 /0 543 /5 8/01932 3.<3 3.2 /5;/8253 H<0 ;<9028 45 '%% <3 <B493 " 1A H.25 3.2 82;2<028 <58 :201458253 4% H2:2 3:<C27/5>/53.2/:A434:;=;7252<:<:5<3<?<&<5?/57A27;/3= ;;4:8/5> 34 :201458253 4% <;;9028 4 ;<A2 6:4A 3.2 H:45> 8/:2;3/45 /5 < A434:;=;72 <58 3.2:2 H<0 < C2:B<7 <732:;<3/45B23H2253.2AH./;.39:528/534<@9<::27B23H225 :201458253 4% ./0 6<3.2: <58 3.2 <;;9028 4 .2:2B= - 8 - 3.2 <;;9028 4 344? 493 < ?5/62 6:4A ./0 A434:B/?2 <58 03<BB28 3.2 82;2<028 /2 6<3.2: 46 :201458253 4% .2:2<632:./06<3.2:H<00./632834.401/3<7<58.209;;9AB28 34 3.2 /5F9:/20 C2:0/5;2 3.25 <;;9028 4 H<0 <B0;45828 <58<632:<7<10246(A453.045%%(%%.2H<0<::20328 B= 3.2 :201458253!47/;2 .2:2<632: ./0 C47953<:= 03<32A253 H<0:2;4:828 3/03.2<772><3/45/53.2;.<:>20.2233.<389:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45 <;;9028 4 C4795322:28 B264:2 3.2 47/;2 3.<3 <;;9028 4% B2/5> ./0 B:43.2: <58 <;;9028 4" B2/5> ./0 :27<3/C2 >/C25 0.2732: <58 2G325828 A4523<:= .27134<;;9028434<B0;4586:4A3.2;<02512:90<746 3.2253/:2;.<:>20.223A<32:/<70<0 :/>.37=;45325328B=3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 2G;213 3.2 C47953<:= 03<32A253 46 <;;9028 4 <B0479327= 54 43.2: 1/2;2 46 2C/825;2<C</7<B7245:2;4:834/A17/;<323.2123/3/452:0/53.2 ;:/A2.203<32A2534643.2:H/3520020<70484205438/0;7402 3.2 /5C47C2A253 46 <;;9028 40% <58 " /5 3.2 ;:/A2 /5 <5= :2012;3C2543.2:H/02/3/05433.2;<0246:201458253!147/;2 3.<3<;;902840%<58"<:2>/C250.2732:4:A45/34:=.271B= ?54H/5> 6977= 3./0 <;;9028 4 H<0 /5C47C28 /5 3.2 .2/5490 - 9 - ;:/A2.2:2<:25409;.<332A130A<82B=3.247/;234:2;4:8 3.203<32A25346<5=A<32:/<7H/3520020343.<32662;3 3 /0 0233728 140/3/45 46 7<H 3.<3 B<028 45 3.2 03<32A25346<;4!<;;90285412:045;<5B2/A17/;<328/53.2 ;:/A2 <0 <5 <;;9028 3 /0 <704 2@9<77= 0233728 140/3/45 46 7<H 3.<3 /5 4:82: 34 /5C4?2 2;3/45 %% 4: %% 46 3.2 /5C203/><3/45 .<0 34 B2 ;4589;328 B= 147/;2 021<:<327= <632: >233/5> 12:A/00/45 6:4A 3.2 <>/03:<32 0/5;2 /3 /0 < 8/03/5;3 46625;2B=:2>/032:/5><;:/A253.21:/5;/1<746625;23.2;4! <;;9028;<5543B2/A17/;<3289582:3.20</81:4C/0/4553.<3 C/2H463.2A<332:2C25/63.2253/:2<772><3/45<></5033.202 123/3/452:0 /0 <;;21328 45 /30 6<;2 C<792 <704 3.2 <772><3/45 A<82<></5033.202123/3/452:084543A<?2493< ;<0264:3.246625;209582:2;3/450%%4:%%46509;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 3.2 ;453/59<3/45 46 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0/0543./5>B93<5<B902463.21:4;20046;49:3 .2 45-B7212G49:3/53.2;<0246 :214:328 /5 !! "!#$%.2783.<33.249:34H20<893=34744?/534 A<5=43.2:<33258/5>;/:;9A03<5;20543457=3.2*4:;.<:>2 - 10 - 0.223<772><3/450H./72@9<0./5>3.21:4;228/5>0<583.249:3 4H20 < 893= 34 744? /534 A<5= 43.2: <33258/5> ;/:;9A03<5;20 2A2:>/5> 6:4A 3.2 :2;4:80 46 3.2 ;<02 4C2: <58 <B4C2 3.2 <C2:A2530<58/6522828B2H/3.892;<:2<58;/:;9A012;3/45 3:=34:2<8/5B23H2253.27/520.249:3H./722G2:;/0/5>/30 F9:/08/;3/45 9582: 2;3/45 (% 46 : 4: :3/;72 %% 46 3.2 4503/393/455228543:203:/;3/30276457=343.203<>246<;<02 B93 /0 2A14H2:28 34 3<?2 /534 <;;4953 4C2:<77 ;/:;9A03<5;20 72<8/5>34 3.2 /5/3/<3/45 4: :2>/03:<3/45 46 3.2 ;<02 <0 H277 <0 3.2 A<32:/<70 ;4772;328 /5 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45 5 3.2 /503<53 ;<02 <0 8/0;90028 3.2:2 <:2 54 A<32:/<7017<;28B=3.21:402;93/4534;453/5923.21:4;228/5>0 <></5033.202123/3/452:0 25;2<A463.2;450/82:28C/2H 3.<3 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 /0 7/<B72 34 B2 @9<0.28;;4:8/5>7=1:4;228341<003.264774H/5>J / .2123/3/45/0 & // .2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 <;;9028 40% <58 " /5 17 # $ 4+ %% #:/A2 4% %%$ - 11 - :2>/032:28 B= 7A27 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;2 195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 "+ ' "% %% %% 46 <58 2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46 #$ ;3 %' 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46 88/3/45<7 /03:/;3 <58 200/45 <58 12;/<7 98>2 /F<=<19: /0 .2:2B= @9<0.28 4H2C2: /3 /0 A<82 ;72<: 3.<3 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 0.<77 ;453/592<></503<;;90284 ,* %!) ! /034%74%