- 1 - !"!# $ %&" " %&" !"'! $$ ( ) !! " # $ # % Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $& '( $ & '!)((! $& '!*)(+ $& & '!*)(+ ! $,$$ '!*)(+ ) - '!*)(+ . $$ $$ & '!*)( " # $ / $ !% - 3 - $ $ ((+(! ()* (!#% $ 0 123 0 "& # 0 % 456 177819 56 :5983 ;419982<52< 12 =>38> 31?83 ((+(! 716683 @A ?48 981>283 52<98 B3<8 52 =()* (!@AC45;4128D&71>?852?8>5E7>1A8> C162=?<>12?83 ? 56 ?48 ;168 =: ?48 17789912?6 ?41? 17789912? =6 123 1>8 ?48 656?8>6 =: >867=2382? =) 123 17789912?=56?48E=?48>123?48A199;=26?5?B?81F=52? :1E59A 99 =: ?48E 413 8GB19 641>86 52 ?48 7>=78>?586 @81>52< A=+ E816B>52< ( 1;>86 (! <B2?16 123 A=!( E816B>52< ( 1;>86 (! <B2?16 65?B1?8 1? =23H12 5991<8 235 19BI =C8H8> 3B8 ?= 6=E8 - 4 - =@95<1?5=26 52 ?48 :1E59A 17789912? =6 123 177>=1;483>867=2382?=)123>8GB86?83:=>71>?5?5=2=: ?4812;86?>197>=78>?586482>867=2382?=)>8:B683?= 71>?5?5=2 ?48A :5983 =!* (! :=> 71>?5?5=2 48 >867=2382? =) =::8>83 ?= 68??98 ?48 3567B?8 123 1 ;=E7>=E56878?5?5=2C16:598352?8>E6=:C45;4?486B5? C163567=683=::=2(!( ;;=>352<9A?48EB?1?5=2 7>=;88352<6 C8>8 525?51?83 52 1;;=>312;8 C5?4 ?48 ;=E7>=E56838;>88 48 17789912?6 ;915E ?41?12 1B;?5=2 2=?5:5;1?5=2 C16 7B@956483 52 122131 159A 28C67178> J5F1A1>21?1I1K=2(!(!?=1B;?5=2?487>=78>?586 @81>52< A=6+ 123 !( 8 ?48>81:?8> 177>=1;483 >867=2382?=)C4=C16C=>I52<1??48>867=2382?=! 123 ;1E8 ?= I2=C ?41? 12 =>38> C16 716683 B238> 8;?5=2 )+ =: ?48 1>21?1I1 =&=78>1?5H8 =;58?586 ;? +!+ 1<1526? >867=2382? =) 123 =?48> 8E79=A886 123 @1683=21>87=>?B238>8;?5=2)=:?481>21?1I1=& =78>1?5H8=;58?586 ;?+!+ 5? C16 4893 ?41??48>8 C16 - 5 - E56177>=7>51?5=2 =: 6(((( & C45;4 C16 6=B<4? ?= @8>8;=H8>83 48 17789912?6 ;915E ?41? 7>=;88352<6 C8>8 525?51?83 1<1526? >867=2382? =) 123 =?48> 8E79=A886 123 ?48 >867=2382? =) 413 ;=2?86?83 ?48 7>=;88352<6 48 >867=2382? =) 13E5??83 ?41? 48 413 E56177>=7>51?83 ?48 1E=B2? 123 48 C16 >813A ?= >871A ?48 61E8 52 64=>? ?5E8 48 >867=2382? =! ?48>81:?8> 7>=;88383?=716612=>38>31?83((4=9352<?41? ?48 >867=2382? =) 56 6=989A 951@98 ?= >871A 1 6BE =: 6(((( & 123 35>8;?83 >8;=H8>A 19=2< C5?4 52?8>86? 1?L78>122BE4817789912?61:?8>;=E52<?=I2=C =: ?48 1B;?5=2 6198 =: ?48 7>=78>?586 E82?5=283 1@=H8 177>=1;483?486198=::5;8>?=;=E789>867=2382?=)?= 85?48> >871A ?48 1E=B2? =: 6(((( & => ?= 525?51?8 1;?5=2167>=H5383B238> B986+)(48>867=2382?= ?482 566B83 12 1??1;4E82? 2=?5;8 B238> B98 *#1%123 #@%=: B986+)(?=?48>867=2382?=);19952<B7=245E ?=>871A 6(((( &:15952<C45;4?487>=78>?586C=B93 - 6 - @8 1??1;483 48 17789912?6 ?482 >8GB86?83 ?48 >867=2382?=!123>867=2382?=.2=??=;=23B;??48 1B;?5=2 652;8 ?485> 641>86 52 ?48 7>=78>?586 1>8 196= 52;9B383 =26538>52< ?48 1@=H8 ?48 1B;?5=2 C16 2=? ;=23B;?83 =2 (!(! 1?8> =2 5? ;1E8 ?= ?48 I2=C983<8 =: ?48 17789912?6 ?41? 12 82?>A C16 E138 52 ;=9BE2==:?48 1@=B?E=>?<1<8=:?487>=78>?A 52 :1H=B> =: >1?4E5I1 >B645 1??521 141I1>1 12<4 5A1E5?41 #% 199=995 48 17789912?6 ?48>8:=>8 ;419982<83?481;?5=252=()* (!48981>283 52<98 B3<8 716683 12 =>38> 31?83 ((*(! 566B52< 2=?5;8 123 4893 ?41? ?48 52?8>5E >8958: C599 @8 ;=26538>83 =29A1:?8>68>H5;8=:2=?5;8?=?48126C8>52<>867=2382?6 48>81:?8> =2 ((+(! C482 ?48 C>5? 78?5?5=2 C16 956?83?48;168C1613F=B>2831C15?52<68>H5;8=:2=?5;852 >8678;? =: >867=2382? =6! ?= . ?48>852 48 17789912?6 @852<1<<>58H83@A?486153=>38>1>8@8:=>8?456=B>? - 7 - ! 48 981>283 ;=B2689 :=> ?48 17789912?6 6B@E5??83 ?41? 5: ?48 52?8>5E =>38> 56 2=? <>12?83 17789912?6C=B93@87B??=41>3645716?485>641>8652?48 6B5? 7>=78>?A 56 1? 6?1I8 8 ?48>8:=>8 ;=2?8236 ?41? ?48 981>283 52<98 B3<8 =B<4? ?= 41H8 <>12?83 8D&71>?8 52?8>5E=>38>6=16?=E152?1526?1?B6GB==:?487>=78>?A 52GB86?5=2 ) 48981>283;=B2689:=>?48>867=2382?=6!?= . 6B@E5?6 ?41? 2= =>38> 56 716683 @A ?48 981>283 52<98 B3<885?48>>8F8;?52<=><>12?52<?4852?8>5E>8958:6=B<4? :=>@A?4817789912?648>8:=>8?48>8562=;1B68=:1;?5=2 :=>?4817789912?6?=:59812177819@8:=>8?456=B>?H82 =?48>C56848;=2?8236?41?2=C>5?78?5?5=256E152?1521@98 1<1526??481;?5=2=:1;=&=78>1?5H86=;58?A123?48>8:=>8 ?48 C>5? 78?5?5=2 5?689: 56 2=? E152?1521@98 8 ?41? 16 5? E1A 48 6B@E5?6 ?41? ?48 17789912?6 E1A >828C ?485> >8GB86? @8:=>8 ?48 981>283 52<98 B3<8 :=> ;=26538>52< ?485> 52?8>5E 7>1A8> 6==2 1:?8> 68>H5;8 =: 2=?5;8 ?= ?48 >867=2382?652?48C>5?78?5?5=2 - 8 - . 8 41H8 ;=26538>83 ?48 6B@E5665=26 E138 @A 981>283;=B2689:=>?4817789912?6123?48981>283;=B2689 :=>?48>867=2382?=6!?=. * 48 =>38> 31?83 ((+(! 64=C6 ?41? ?48 ;168 C16 13F=B>283 1C15?52< 68>H5;8 =: 2=?5;8 ?= ?48 >867=2382? =6! ?= . 52 ?48 C>5? 78?5?5=2 48>8:=>8 2= =>38> C16 716683 85?48> >8F8;?52< ?48 >8GB86? =: ?48 17789912?6 :=> <>12? =: 12 52?8>5E >8958: =C ?41? ?48 >867=2382? =6! ?= . 41H8 82?8>83 17781>12;8 52 ?456 C>5? 177819 5? 56 =29A 177>=7>51?8 ?= 35>8;? ?4868 >867=2382?=6!?=.?=17781>@8:=>8?48981>28352<98 B3<8 123 ;=2?86? ?48 E1??8> =2 E8>5?6 48>8:=>8 ?456 C>5?17781956>8GB86?52<?48981>28352<98 B3<8?=;=26538>?48>8GB86?=:?4817789912?6:=><>12?=: 52?8>5E7>1A8>16?48>867=2382?=6!?=.41H82=?5;8=: ?48 7>=;88352<6 52 =()* (! : 1 >8GB86? 56 E138?48981>28352<98B3<8E1A;=26538>6B;4>8GB86? 168D7835?5=B69A167=665@98 - 9 - + 2 H58C =: 3567=619 =: ?48 177819 199 ?48 782352<52?8>9=;B?=>A17795;1?5=266?1233567=683=:: *+ (") " *+ (!"'!) " 56?=9=+