- 1 - !" !"# #" $% % & '( $ % ! "# $ % & Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' ' (")###* ! ''' +","# $ - ' ' ' (#* $' % '!-. ,#!!#!" ' '& ' !" ' ' !' ' ' ' ' ' !##"- !#) #*!#! /( ' ' ' - 3 - % &$ % ' ' ' +")###* ! ''' +","# - ''' +","# +")### % & , +","# ! " +","# - 4 - - '/ '' 0 +","# % & ' ' ' #*!#! !##"- !#) %(& ' 1 234 1 %1 & % &$ 567896:2;;<2=67>6=<4?@:5<:2:<A52==<3B63B:5< AC99<A:3<77C>:5<C94<942:<4#*!#!;277<4?@:5< =<293<463B=<D4B<C>:567CD9:63C!##"- !#) ?@ 856A5 :5< ?<3<>6:7 C> :5< 2932:2E2 26=@ 2B< - 5 - F;=C@<<7 <=>29< A: !#! %>C9 75C9: G:5< A: !#!H& 827<I:<34<4:C:5<;<:6:6C3<97 ! 5< ;<:6:6C3<97 AC3:<34<4 :52: :5<@ 8<9< 2== 426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<<7 <F;=C@<4 :59CDB5 23 CD:7CD9A<4 2B<3A@ : 827 7D?F6::<4 :52: ;<:6:6C3<9 C 827 2;;C63:<4C3#)**!234;<:6:6C3<9C!63:5<FC3:5 C> D=@ !## 234 :52: :5<@ 524 8C9E<4 AC3:63DCD7=@ >C9 FC9< :523 !# @<297 234 8<9< :5<9<>C9< <3:6:=<4 :C ?< 9<BD=296J<4 - 5< 896: ;<:6:6C3 827 C;;C7<4 ?@ :5< :2:< AC3:<3463B:52::5<;<:6:6C3<978<9<2;;C63:<4:59CDB523 CD:7CD9A<4 2B<3A@ 234 3C: ?@ :5< :2:< 234 :5<9<>C9< :5<@8<9<3C:<3:6:=<4:C?<9<BD=296J<427:5<9<8273C 9<=2:6C3756;C><F;=C@<9234<F;=C@<< 5< =<293<4 63B=< D4B< 2>:<9 ;<9D763B :5< AC3:<3:6C37 D9B<4 5<=4 :52: :5< 8C9E ;<9>C9F<4 ?@ :5< ;<:6:6C3<97 8<9< ;<9F23<3: 63 32:D9< <7;6:< :5< >2A: :52::5<@8<9<7CD9A<4>9CF23CD:7CD9A<42B<3A@6:827 - 6 - 5<=4:52::5<:2:<CK<93F<3:5244C3<7CC3=@:C2KC64 :5<AC37<LD<3A<7C>23<F;=C@<9(<F;=C@<<9<=2:6C3756; 5<=<293<463B=<D4B<:5CDB59<>D7<4:C9<BD=296J<:5< 7<9K6A<7C>:5<;<:6:6C3<97469<A:<4:5<:2:<CK<93F<3: :C<I:<34:5<?<3<>6:7;9CK64<4D34<9:5<A:!#! " <63B 2BB96<K<4 ?@ :5< 7264 C94<9 :5< :2:< 527>6=<4:56763:92(ACD9:2;;<2= ) 5< =<293<4 446:6C32= CK<93F<3: 4KCA2:< 7D?F6::<4:52:2M426=@82B<<F;=C@<<N274<>63<4D34<9 :5< A: !#! 4C<7 3C: 63A=D4< 2 426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<< <3B2B<4 :59CDB5 23 CD:7CD9A<4 2B<3A@ 5<9<>C9< 5< AC3:<347 :52: :5< ;<:6:6C3<97 29< 3C: <3:6:=<4 :C :5< ?<3<>6:7C>:5<A:!#! 5<=<293<4ACD37<=>C9:5<9<7;C34<3:7C3:5< C:5<95234AC3:<34<4 :52:;<:6:6C3<9 C 827 <F;=C@<4 27282:A5F23C3#)**!856=<;<:6:6C3<9C!827 <F;=C@<4 27 2 ACCE 63 D=@ !## < >D9:5<9 AC3:<347 :52: :5< ;<:6:6C3<97 52K< 8C9E<4 AC3:63DCD7=@ >C9 FC9< - 7 - :523 # @<297 86:5CD: 23@ ?9<2E 234 C3 F<2B9< 72=29@ 2345<3A<:5<;<:6:6C3<9729<<3:6:=<4:C?<:9<2:<4C3;29 86:5426=@82B<<F;=C@<<785C29<ACK<9<4D34<9:5<A: !#! , < 52K< AC3764<9<4 :5< 7D?F6776C37 C> :5< =<293<4 446:6C32= CK<93F<3:4KCA2:< >C9:5< :2:<27 8<==27:5<=<293<4ACD37<=>C9:5<9<7;C34<3:7 * 5< ;D9;C7< C> :5< A: !#! 67 :C ;9CK64< 8<=>29< F<27D9<7 :C 426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<<7 8C9E63B >C9 FC9< :523 # @<297 63 K296CD7 <7:2?=675F<3:7 234 :C ;9CK64< :5<F F636FDF 7<AD96:@ C> :<3D9< ?<::<9 82B<7 234 A<9:263 7CA62= 7<AD96:@ ?<3<>6:7 C3 :<9F632:6C3 >9CF =C3B ;D?=6A 7<9K6A< C 4CD?: :5< 8C94 M426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<<N674<>63<4D34<9:5<A::CF<2323<F;=C@<< <3B2B<4 86:5 :5< CK<93F<3: C9 =CA2= ?C46<7 C3 426=@ 82B<72346:4C<73C:<I;9<77=@63A=D4<:5C7<<F;=C@<<7 85C 29< 7CD9A<4 >9CF 23 CD:7CD9A<4 2B<3A@ 2K63B 9<B294 :C :5< >2A: :52: :5<7< ;<:6:6C3<97 52K< ?<<3 - 8 - ;<9>C9F63B 76F6=29 4D:6<7 :52: 2 426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<< 8CD=4C:5<9867<;<9>C9F6>5<827<3B2B<486:5:5<:2:< CK<93F<3::5<;<:6:6C3<9729<2=7C<3:6:=<4:C?<:9<2:<4 C3 ;29 86:5 :5< 426=@ 82B< <F;=C@<<7 <3B2B<4 ?@ :5< :2:<CK<93F<3: # 3:52:K6<8C>:5<F2::<98<4C3C:>63423@ <99C963:5<C94<9C>:5<=<293<463B=<D4B<63469<A:63B :5< :2:< CK<93F<3: :C <I:<34 :5< ?<3<>6:7 C> :5< ;9CK676C37C>:5<A:!#!5<9<>C9<:5<896:2;;<2=>26=7 234672AAC9463B=@ $ 567 AC3:<F;: ;<:6:6C3 67 >6=<4 2==<B63B 3C3( ACF;=623A< C> :5< C94<942:<4 #*!#! ;277<4 ?@:5< =<293<463B=<D4B<C>:567CD9:63C!##"- !#) ! @:5<2>C9<7264C94<9:5<=<293<463B=<D4B< C>:567CD9:524469<A:<4:5<:2:<CK<93F<3::C<I:<34 :5< ?<3<>6:7 C> :5< 2932:2E2 26=@ 2B< F;=C@<<71 - 9 - <=>29< A: !#! :C :5< ;<:6:6C3<97 86:563 :8C FC3:57 >9CF:5<42:<C>9<A<6;:C>2AC;@C>:5<C94<9567C94<9 67D;5<=4?@:567CD9:63C!##!#* !#!" - 3 K6<8 C> :5< 2?CK< :5< AC3:<3:6C3 C> :5< :2:< CK<93F<3: :52: :5< ;<:6:6C3<97 29< 3C:<3:6:=<4 :C :5< ?<3<>6:7 C> :5< ;9CK676C37 C> :5< A: !#! 3C =C3B<9 7D9K6K<7 <3A< :5< 2AAD7<4 67 469<A:<4 :C ACF;=@ 86:5 :5< C94<9 86:563 2 ;<96C4 C> >CD9 8<<E7 >9CF :5< 42:< C> 9<A<6;: C> 2 AC;@ C> :567 C94<9 >26=63B 856A5 :5< ACF;=26323:7 29< 2: =6?<9:@ :C 9<K6K< :567 AC3:<F;: ;<:6:6C35<AC3:<F;:;<:6:6C367A=C7<47D?O<A::C:5<2?CK< )$ '( )$ '#( 67:C=C-