Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54765 (KAR)
MATHIN v. THE STATE
CRL.A/200272/2025 · 2026-01-06
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54765 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54765 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
"##
$%&'$($ (
)
!"
#$$ %$ &
$
'$ '$(! ! ()
$$
!"
#
%* + '* !&
$$*$ ( * %&
,"! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"! $
" !"! $*
*$$
$$
) !"!( - ** $ %!&(! %!&")%&%!&)%!&)!!) -" * !"!) - )%!&%.& * % &
*
$
*
-$
/$'
"
012 344536 12 71658 9:85; 5<=1>: (%!& >7 =05 <0589658 32=52 3:8 <0589658 ;1?52 %;5.5:=1>: >7 =;><1=152&<=@7>;20>;=A=05 % &<=BC7>;
D;3:= >7 ?316 1: ;1E5 > !"!( ;5D12=5;58 ?F =05 :81 >61<5 7>; =05 >775:<52 49:1203?65 9:85; 5<=1>:2 %!& (! %!&")%&%!&)%!&)!!);538G1=05<=1>:
">703;3=1F3F3F33:01=3!"!)@7>;20>;=A=05 !"!)BC 3:8 5<=1>: ) %!& %.& >7 =05 % & <= 4;525:=6F45:81:D1:46325% &>,( !"!(>:=05 7165 >7 886 12=;1<= 3:8 5221>:2 3:8 45<136 98D5 1H3F349;
- 3 -
! 05 73<=936 E3=;1I >7 =05 <325 12 =03= ;524>:85:= >! 03E> 3803. 12 =05 ;52185:= >7 :D363D13:833:8;9::1:D0>=56?F:3E5A3D3;'1:3;3B 12 2>: 3:J5= G32 2=98F1:D 1: "=0 2=3:83;8 1:
>.5;:E5:= 1D0 <0>>6 :81 : !!"!) 3= 1.5J3:3:81;<65>7:81=05;5G323K93;;56?5=G55:012 2>:3:J5=3:83=12032.5J3;3:803:3;3H'203=;13= =03==1E50122>:322396=58=05EG1=0=05J:1753:8=05F G5;5 38E1==58 1: ;>DF3803E 0>241=36 3= 1H3F349;3 2 29<0 =05 <>E4631:3:= G5:= => =05 0>241=36 3:8 4318 2"""" =>G3;82E581<365I45:252=>=05E:=012 ;5D3;83<325G32;5D12=5;583D31:2=<>E4631:3:=B22>:L 3:J5=1::814>61<52=3=1>: ) $3=5;>:("!"!(3=3?>9=""4EG05: =05<>E4631:3:=G321:0120>=5636>:DG1=00122>:2>E5 9:J:>G: 45;2>: >;85;58 =05 7>>8 > 8561.5; =05 23E5 <>E4631:3:=B22>:3:J5=3:80127;15:8;55=3EG5:=>:
3E>=>;<F<65?53;1:D5D>'! (,05;537=5;
3=3?>9= (4E=05<>E4631:3:=;5<51.583=56540>:5
- 4 -
<366 7;>E ;55=3E 15 012 2>:B2 7;15:8 =03= G05: =05F G5;5 :53; 3.1:303661 E31: 3:36 D3;J058 ;>38 =05 3445663:= 3:8 >=05;2 ;52=;31:58 =05E 3:8 =05;537=5; 322396=58<>E4631:3:=B22>:L3:J5=G1=03J:175895=> G01<00529<<9E?58=>=051:H9;1523==0524>=3258>: 29<01:7>;E3=1>:=05<>E4631:=G32;5D12=5;58
( 05;537=5;=05;524>:85:=L4>61<53;;52=58=05 3445663:= >: "!"!( $3=5; 37=5; <>E465=1:D =05 1:.52=1D3=1>: <03;D5 2055= 032 ?55: 71658 3D31:2= =05 3445663:= 3:8 71.5 >=05;2 05 3445663:= 038 53;615;
344;>3<058=012>9;=1:;1E1:3644536>!""" !"! G01<0<3E5=>?5812E12258>:)"!"!G1=061?5;=F=> 344;>3<0=012>9;=>;=05;136>9;=37=5;5I3E1:3=1>:>7 - 5F5G1=:522=>=051:<185:=
<<>;81:D => =05 653;:58 <>9:256 7>; =05 3445663:=3=4;525:==05=;136032<>EE5:<583:8- L 5F5G1=:522 032 ?55: 5I3E1:58 32 -( 5:<5 =05 4;525:=45=1=1>:
- 5 -
03.545;9258=05<03;D52055=E3=5;13623:8 362> =05 854>21=1>: >7 -( 15 - : <3;5796 45;9236 >7 012 5.185:<5 1= 12 255: =03= 05 032 =>=366F =9;:580>2=165=>=054;>25<9=1>:<3250>9D0=059?61< ;>25<9=>; 032 <;>225I3E1:58 =05 2318 G1=:522 :>=01:D 032 ?55: 561<1=58 7;>E 012 E>9=0 *9;=05; 3<<>;81:D => =05 653;:58 <>9:256 7>; =05 3445663:= =05 73=05; >7 =05 85<53258G0>12=05<>E4631:3:=032362>:>=2944>;=58 =05 <325 >7 =05 4;>25<9=1>: : 29<0 <1;<9E2=3:<52 =05 <92=>8136 1:<3;<5;3=1>: >7 =05 3445663:= 12 :>= <36658 7>;
5:<5 G1=0>9= 5I4;5221:D 3:F >41:1>: >: =05 E5;1=2 >7 =05<32529771<5=>0>68=03==054;3F5;2>9D0=7>;?F=05 3445663:= <>968 ?5 D;3:=58 <<>;81:D6F 4322 =05 7>66>G1:D
105;1E1:364453612 11 05 >;85; 83=58 ,"!!"!
432258 1:
;612<>" !"!?F=0588612=;1<=3:8
- 6 -
5221>:23:845<13698D51H3F349;31205;5?F 25=32185 111053445663:= 3<<9258>)1281;5<=58=>?5 5:63;D58 >: ?316 1: 46% & >,( !"!( 45:81:D >: =05 7165 >7 881=1>:36 12=;1<= 3:8 5221>:2 3:8 45<136 98D5 1H3F349;3 3;121:D >9= >7 ;1E5 > !"!( ;5D12=5;58 ?F :81 >61<5=3=1>:7>;=05>775:<5249:1203?659:85; 5<=1>:2 %!& ( ! %!& ")%&%!& )%!& )! !) ;538 G1=0 5<=1>: " >7 !"!) 3:8 5<=1>: )%!&%.& >7 =05 % & <= 29?H5<==>=057>66>G1:D<>:81=1>:2 3&053445663:=203665I5<9=5345;2>:36 ?>:8 7>; 3 29E >7 2""""" G1=0 =G> 29;5=152 7>; =05 61J529E => =05 23=1273<=1>:>7=05H9;1281<=1>:36>9;=+ ?& 05 3445663:= 20366 34453; ;5D963;6F >: 366 =05 83=52 >7 053;1:D ?57>;5 =05 ;136 >9;= 9:6522 =05 ;136 >9;= 5I5E4=2 012 34453;3:<5 7>; .3618 ;532>:2+ <& 05 3445663:= 20366 :>= 81;5<=6F >;
1:81;5<=6F =0;53=5: >; =3E45; G1=0 =05 4;>25<9=1>:G1=:52252+
- 7 -
8& 05 3445663:= 20366 :>= 1:.>6.5 1: 21E163;>775:<521:79=9;5+ 5& 05 3445663:= 20366 :>= 653.5 =05 H9;1281<=1>: >7 =05 ;136 >9;= G1=0>9= 45;E1221>: >7 =05 2318 >9;= 9:=16 =05 <325 ;5D12=5;58 3D31:2= 01E 12 8124>258 >77 7& 05 3445663:= 20366 E3;J 012 3==5:83:<5 ?57>;5 =05 =3=1>: >925
771<5; :81 >61<5 =3=1>: >: 71;2= 9:83F >7 5.5;F E>:=0 ?5=G55: """ 3E 3:8 """ 4E =166 =05 <325 ;5D12=5;58 3D31:2= 01E 12 8124>258 >77 ?57>;5=05;136>9;=
*% $(
-' $12=>6>