Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54759 (KAR)
SRI YANKANNA v. SRI SUDHAKAR A
WP/202450/2025 · 2026-02-04
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54759 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54759 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$% ! &$'
! "
# $
%
& ' ( ! & )
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ! " # $
%
*
+
&&' + +
* +
!!&!& , &!&
$ ) )+ *
+
+ - #% * ! +
+ $ + ! !,&!& + ,. & +
+ $ , &!&
$ ) )+$
$ -
+ ,.
& + + $ , &!& $))+$ $- + /0 * 1) - 3 - 2345 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 ?2=@=@9724 375 6234725 89:7;263??234@7A<94=>242;?97527=; & >@; ?2=@=@97 @; <@625 BC =>2 ?2=@=@9724 D>9 D3; 52<27537= @7 9, &!& 3AA4@2E25 BC =>2 @F?:A725 94524?3;;25@7=>2;3@594@A@736;:@=979 <@625:7524 4524----:62 375&9<=>29529<@E@649825:42#<94 ;>94=/0%BC55@=@9736@E@6):5A2375)+$3@8>:4 #>242@73<=24 42<24425 =9 3; /=4@36 9:4=0% D>@8> D3; 3669D25 375 =>2423<=24 897<@4F25 @7 9 , &!& E@52 94524 53=25!!&!&?3;;25BC=>255@=@973627@94@E@6):5A2 375 )+ 3@8>:4 #>242@73<=24 42<24425 =9 3; /<@4;= 3??2663=29:4=0% , >2?34=@2;=9=>2?498225@7A;;>366B242<24425=9 3; ?63@7=@<<; 375 52<27537= <94 =>2 ;3G2 9< 23;C :7524;=375@7A >2?63@7=@<<;<@625;:@=<94?24F3727=@7H:78=@97@7 9, &!& ;22G@7A 528422 <94 ?24F3727= @7H:78=@97 - 4 - 3759=>24897;2I:27=@36426@2<;:4@7A=>2?275278C9<=>2 ;:@= 37 3??6@83=@97 @7 9 83F2 =9 B2 <@625 BC =>2 ?63@7=@<<;:75244524----:62 375&9<<94A437=9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 >2 ;3@5 3??6@83=@97 83F2 =9 B2 3669D2597897=2;=375379452483F2=9B2?3;;25@7<3E9:4 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 42;=43@7@7A =>2 52<27537= >@; F27 3A27=; ;24E37=; 3==9472C; <49F 83:;@7A 37C @7=24<242782 D@=> =>2 ?9;;2;;@979<=>2?63@7=@<<;9E24=>2;:@=;8>25:62?49?24=C=@66 5@;?9;36 9< =>2 ;:@= = D3; 36;9 ;=3=25 =>3= =>2 94524 9< =2F?9434C@7H:78=@97D9:6579=89F2@7=>2D3C=9?42E27= 37C ?24;97 94 =>2 897824725 3:=>94@=@2; D>9 >3E2 =9 F23;:42 =>2 637525 ?49?24=@2; @786:5@7A =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C375<@J=>2B9:7534@2;897;@524=>242?42;27=3=@97 9< =>2 52<27537= 375 =3G2 3??49?4@3=238=@97 @7 3889453782 D@=>63D3;?24=>2945249<=>@;9:4= 2@7A3AA4@2E25BC=>2945249<=>26234725=4@36 ):5A2=>252<27537=?42<24425373??236@79 , &!& B2<942 =>2 55@=@9736 27@94 @E@6 ):5A2 375 )+ 3= 3@8>:4 7 897;@5243=@97 9< =>2 ;:BF@;;@97; 3<=24 3??2343782 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; =>2 ;3@5 3??236 83F2 =9 B2 - 5 - 42H28=25 375 =>2@7=24@F 94524?3;;25 BC =>2 =4@369:4= 97 9 83F2 =9 B2 3<<@4F25 = @; =>@; 94524 9< B9=> =>2 9:4=;=>3=@;I:2;=@9725@7=>@;?2=@=@97BC=>252<27537=97 =>2<9669D@7AA49:75; = @; =>2 E2>2F27= 897=27=@97 9< =>2 6234725 89:7;263??234@7A<94=>252<27537==>3==>294524;?3;;25 BC B9=> =>2 9:4=; 342 ?24E24;2 34B@=434C @662A36 375 =>2 ;3F2 42I:@42; =9 B2 ;2= 3;@52 375 42E24;25 234725 89:7;26 <:4=>24 897=275; =>3= =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2 9:4= D@=>9:=3??6@83=@979<@752?27527=H:5@8@9:;F@75>3;;@F?6C 27594;25 =>2 <@75@7A 375 423;97@7A 9< =>2 =4@36 9:4= @; D@=>9:=699G@7A@7=9=>2F24@=;9<=>2F3==24=>2598:F27=; ?495:825375=>2;3F2@;79=;:??94=25BC=>2423;97;375 =>2 34A:F27= ?:= <94=> BC =>2 52<27537= = @; <:4=>24 897=27525 =>3= A437= 9< @7H:78=@97 @; 3 5@;842=@9734C 375 2I:@=3B62 94524 >@; D9:65 >3E2 =9 B2 ?3;;25 B3;25 97 ;2E2436 F3=24@36; ?63825 B2<942 =>2 9:4= 782 =>242 @; 3 ;24@9:;869:597=>2=@=629<=>2?63@7=@<<;@786:5@7A=>263D<:6 ?9;;2;;@97 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; @7 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C B9=>=>2=4@369:4=3;D2663;=>2<@4;=3??2663=29:4=89:65 - 6 - 79= >3E2 A437=25 375 3<<@4F25 =>2 94524 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 9 36;9 >2 897=275; =>3= 3 83;2 42I:@42;=9B2=3G2779=29<3753==>2;3F2=@F2=>263D<:6 ?9;;2;;@97<69D9<=@=6263D<:6=@=62375=>2 =@=62 >3; 79= B227 897;@52425 BC B9=> =>2 9:4=; 2782 =>2 @F?:A72594524;34279=;:;=3@73B62375=>2;3F242I:@42; =9B2;2=3;@52 ' = @; 36;9 897=27525 BC =>2 6234725 89:7;26 =>3= B9=> =>2 9:4=; D>@62 ?3;;@7A =>2 @F?:A725 94524 >3E2 =3G27 @7=9 897;@5243=@97 42A345@7A 797?495:8=@97 9< 598:F27=; BC =>2 52<27537= =9 ?49E2 >@;
=@=62 3; D266 3; ?9;;2;;@97 9E24 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C D>@8> @; 2449729:; 3; 52<27537= >3; ?63825 366 F3=24@36; 5@;869;@7A >@; 4@A>= 9E24 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C B234@7A :4E2C 9; #:4E2C 9 &% 9E24 D>@8> =>2 ?69=; 342 <94F25 >2 52<27537= >3; 36;9 ?63825 F:=3=@97 42A@;=24 5@;869;@7A94@A@7369D724;>@?9E24=>26375@7I:2;=@97=@; 36;9 897=27525 =>3= =>2 52<27537= >3; ?495:825 3B:7537= F3=24@36;B2<942=>29:4=375>3;36;9B49:A>==9=>279=@82 - 7 - 9<=>29:4=42A345@7A:763D<:6@662A36897;=4:8=@97;9E24=>2 ;:@=?69=;BCE@963=@7A=>2B:@65@7ABC263D; = @; 36;9 897=27525 BC 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 52<27537= =>3= =>2 =4@36 9:4= >3; F2426C 89F2 =9 =>2 89786:;@9797=>25:F?@7A9<824=3@7897;=4:8=@97F3=24@36; BC =>2 ?63@7=@<<; =>3= =>2C >3E2 @7E2;=25 >:A2 3F9:7= 375 =>3= 797A437= 9< @7H:78=@97 D9:65 83:;2 @442?3@43B62 @7H:4C 375 >345;>@? =9 =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 43=>24 =>37 =9 =>2 52<27537= D>@8>@;3;24@9:;24494388945@7A=9623472589:7;26<94=>2 52<27537==@;36;9897=27525BC623472589:7;26=>3==>2 =4@369:4=3;D2663;=>2<@4;=3??2663=29:4=>3;@A79425=>2 7282;;34C 42I:@42F27=; 375 @7A425@27=; D>@62 A437= 9< =2F?9434C@7H:78=@977=>2?42;27=83;2=>2?63@7=@<<;>3E2 <3@625=92;=3B6@;>=>2@463D<:6=@=6237563D<:6?9;;2;;@979E24 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C 7 =>2;2 A49:75; >2 ;22G; =9 3669D =>2 ?2=@=@97 375 897;2I:27=6C =9 ;2= 3;@52 =>2 @F?:A725 H:5AF27=; 9< =>2 =4@36 9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=29:4=
- 8 -
. 6234725 89:7;26 3??234@7A <94 =>2 ?63@7=@<<; ;:;=3@7; =>2 @F?:A725 94524; BC 897=275@7A =>3= =>242@;79@662A36@=C94?24E24;@=C@7=>294524?3;;25BC=>2 =4@36 9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2 9:4= 375 ;22G; 5@;F@;;369<=>2?2=@=@97
! 3E@7A >2345 =>2 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 ?2=@=@9724375623472589:7;26<94=>242;?97527=;=>2?9@7= =>3=34@;2;<94897;@5243=@97@;D>2=>24=>2@F?:A72594524 ?3;;25BC =>2=4@36 9:4= 375 =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2 9:4= 8366; <9437C@7=24<242782
*>27 37 3??6@83=@97 @; <@625 :7524 4524 ---- :62 375 & 9< <94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 =>2 <942F9;= 42I:@42F27=; 342 =>422 7282;;34C @7A425@27=;
73F26C ?4@F3 <38@2 83;2 B363782 9< 897E27@2782 375 >345;>@? =>3= D9:65 B2 83:;25 =9 =>2 3AA4@2E25 ?34=C 7 =>2B3;@;9<=>2?63@7=@<<;>3E@7A<@625=>2;:@=375?6382597 428945 3 42A@;=2425 ;362 5225 375 >3E@7A ;>9D7 824=3@7 F3=24@36; G2?=@7 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C >3E@7A ?49E25 =>2 63D<:6 ?9;;2;;@97 97 =>2 B3;@; 9< =>2 =@=62 D>@8> >2
- 9 -
863@F;=>2=4@369:4=83F2=9389786:;@97=>3==>2?63@7=@<<;
>3E2 F352 9:= 9< 83;2 <94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 375 A437=25 =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 42;=43@7@7A =>2 52<27537=<49F@7=24<24@7AD@=>=>2?2382<:6?9;;2;;@97375 27H9CF27=9<=>2;:@=;8>25:62?49?24=C
>2=4@369:4=D3;
36;9 9< =>2 9?@7@97 =>3= =>2 B363782 9< 897E27@2782 =@6=; @7 <3E9:4 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 375 >345;>@?
D9:65 B283:;25 F942 =9=>2?63@7=@<<;=>37=9=>252<27537=
& = @; 3 <:753F27=36 4:62 9< 63D =>3= D>@62 897;@524@7A373??6@83=@97:75244524----:62 375& 9<D>3=@;=9B2;227BC=>2=4@369:4=@;=9F3G29:=3 83;2BC=>2?34=C<94897;@5243=@979<3 83;2=@;
:759:B=256C 86234 =>3= D@=>9:= 37 @9=3 9< 59:B= =>3= =>2 83;2@;79==9B2897<:;25D@=> =@=62 >2 =@=62 89:65 B2 2;=3B6@;>25 BC 2@=>24 9< =>2 ?34=C 3<=24 =4@36 94 5:4@7A =>2 89:4;2 9< =4@36 83;2 @; F352 9:= 3= =>2 @7@=@36 ;=3A2 F3C B2 2E27 BC 3 ?24;97D>9592;79=>3E23 =@=62==>2=@F29< 5236@7AD@=>373??6@83=@97:75244524----:62 375& 9<D>3=@;=9B2897;@52425=>2;:B;=37=@36I:2;=@97=9
- 10 -
B243@;25375528@525@;976C 83;237579= =@=62
>2=4@369:4=7225;=9B2;3=@;<@2597=>2B3;@;
9< F3=24@36; ?63825 B2<942 @= D>2=>24 >2 >3; F352 9:= 3 83;2 <94 A437= 9< 37 @7=24@F 94524 375 =>3= =>2 B363782 9< 897E27@2782 =@6=; @7 >@; <3E9:4 ;9 36;9 D>2=>24 >345;>@? D9:65 B2 83:;25 F942 =9 D>@8> 9< =>2 ?34=@2;
>242<942 @= D9:65 B2 E24C 84:8@36 <94 B9=> =>2 ?34=@2; 375 <94 =>2 9:4= =9 =3G2 3 ?49?24 897;8@9:; 375 83:=@9:;
5@;842=@9734C 528@;@97 D>@62 A437=@7A 37 94524 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@9737579==9897<:;2375F@J=>2I:2;=@979< 83;2 D@=> =>3= 9< =@=62 782 =>2 9:4= 89F2;=9=>29?@7@97=>3==>242@;3 83;2F352 9:==>27=>29:4=89:65?498225<:4=>24=9A437=3794524 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 =9 =>2 ?34=C @7 D>9;2 <3E9:4 =>2 B3637829<897E27@2782=@6=;375=9D>9F>345;>@?@;83:;25
,
>2971B62?2J9:4=@7=>283;29<
>3; 5236= D@=> =>@; F3==24 375 =>2 ?4@78@?62; <94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 3= ?343A43?> 9;,,375,D>@8>4235;3;:7524
- 11 -
!!"# $%&#$ $' %( '#)!%* +,'%
!"##!$%& '(
#)
)
' ()
* (+)
, ')
&'( ) '(
& - - ) +)
. +( ( (+)
' ) '
'
/( )'
0)
& ' &
" '(
)
+) #)
)
(
*
'(
) ) )
- ' +)(-
( ('
( . +) 0)
- 12 -
+)(
' +)(& &
)
' ( '
(
+)(& ') (
+)()
'
& (
' 0)
( '( ( ' - )
' )
+)
#) )
+)
) . ) +) )
)'
+)( (
' )
&
+) )
( ' )
+) ' ''
+)(
#) )
&
)'+ ) '
) 0)& +) )' ) )&
#)
.
)+)
) +)
)
" 1 2
3)
" 44 "##54 6
= @; 36;9 4262E37= =9 F27=@97 >242 =>3= D>@62 5236@7A D@=> =>2 ?2=@=@97 :7524 4=@862; && 375 &&' 9< =>2
- 13 -
97;=@=:=@979<75@3=>@;9:4=722579=A9@7=9=>2F24@=;
9< =>2 F3==24 3; =>@; 9:4= @; 79= ;@==@7A @7 =>2 3??2663=2 H:4@;5@8=@97
>@; 9:4= D9:65 >3E2 =9 ;22 D>2=>24 =>2 @F?:A725 94524 ?3;;25 BC =>2 =4@36 9:4= @; 3 ?24E24;2 @662A36 94 D>2=>24 @= D9:65 8366 <94 @7=24<242782 375 79= E27=:42@7=9=>259F3@79<=>23??2663=29:4=1;H:4@;5@8=@97 7524=>28@48:F;=3782;>3E@7AA972=>49:A>=>2@F?:A725 94524 9< =>2 =4@36 9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2 9:4= 375=>2;:BF@;;@979<623472589:7;26<94=>2?2=@=@9724375 =>2 42;?97527=; 59 79= <@75 37C A995 A49:75 94 89A27= 423;97=9@7=24<242D@=>=>2D266423;9725945249<=>2=4@36 9:4=3;D2663;=>2<@4;=3??2663=29:4=
= @; 3A3@7 722562;; =9 F27=@97 =>3= @= D9:65 B2 9?27<94=>252<27537==9?6382366;:8>F3=24@36B2<942=>2 9:4=3755@;?49E2=>283;29<=>2?63@7=@<<;3;@=@;364235C >265 BC =>2 6234725 =4@36 ):5A2 =>3= =>2 @F?:A725 94524 ?3;;25@;976C<94528@5@7A=>23??6@83=@9737579==>2F3@7 ;:@=
88945@7A6C?3;;=>2<9669D@7A
- 14 -
>@;?2=@=@97@;5@;F@;;25
() & !' %
''