- 1 - ! " #$ #$ % "" &'( !" # !$ ! % &"'! ( #% ) % $ *'*( +## , ##% Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % #% &*''' ! &"'! &"'! $ $ % - % %. # . $ # . $ % . $ ## . $ .% ## . $ ## % . % &"'! ( + # , # %$/ - 3 - ## $ /* # ## # ''/!'! # . # !!** !'!' . ( ## . % 0. . 0. . % $ ,#0. . 12 3442553678 1392 :135526;2< 36 =><2> <372< ''/!'! 43882< ?@ 712 523>62< A6;52 .B<;2 A6 #=!!** !'!' ! 123442553678:53AC7137712A>4>2<2:288=>D38 3 726367 A6 >2842:7 =E 536< ?23>A6; 8B>92@ = =E 2?5A 9A553;2 536< 35BF3 2 4B>4=>72<5@ 13< EA52< =>C = - 4 - 822FA6;;>367=E=::B436:@>A;178B6<2> 2:7A=6$=E712 3>6373F32>73A6 63C8?=5A7A=6:7 /12>A?B635 A6 72>C8 =E 36 =><2> <372< '' //! 355=D2< 712 3445A:37A=6 36< :=6E2>>2< =::B436:@ >A;178 B4=6 1AC B6<2> 2:7A=6=E7123>6373F32>73A6 63C8?=5A7A=6 :7 / =6; 712>23E72> 712 >284=6<267 =$ EA52< #=!!** !'!':135526;A6;712=><2>43882<?@712 36< >A?B635 12 523>62< A6;52 .B<;2 =E 71A8 =B>7 A6 72>C8=E=><2><372<''/!'!355=D2<712D>A7427A7A=6 36<827&38A<2712=><2>=E71236<>A?B635=6712;>=B6< 7137712>284=6<267=$=B;177=1392?226123><?2E=>2 73FA6;36@<2:A8A=67=;>367=::B436:@>A;178A6>2842:7=E 712536<A6GB287A=638A7D38>2:=><2<3836 63C36<A6 712 >2926B2 >2:=><8 12 3442553678 3>2 712>2E=>2 3;;>A292<?@71283A<=><2>36<1392EA52<71A8A67>3=B>7 44235 23>62< :=B6825 E=> 712 3442553678 8B?CA772< 7137712=><2>43882<?@712>A?B635D38A6712@23> //! 36< 712 83C2 A8 GB287A=62< 3E72> 623>5@ !" @23>8 ?2E=>2 - 5 - 71A8=B>72712>2E=>2:=6726<2<7137712=><2>43882< ?@712>A?B635:=B5<6=71392?226<A87B>?2<=63C2>2 3882>7A=6?@712>284=6<267=$7137712@D2>26=7123>< A6712C3772>2:=6726<87137E=55=DA6;712=><2>43882< ?@ 712 >A?B635 >2926B2 >2:=><8 1392 ?226 CB7372< 7= 712 63C2 =E 712 3442553678 36< 126:2 712 >284=6<267 =$D38?=B6<7=1392F6=D52<;2=E712=><2>43882<?@ 712 >A?B635 2 712>2E=>2 :=6726<8 7137 712 <253@ A6 :135526;A6; 712 =><2> 43882< ?@ 712 >A?B635 A8 6=7 2H453A62< 837A8E3:7=>A5@ 36< 712>2E=>2 712 523>62< A6;52 .B<;2 :=B5< 6=7 1392 5A;175@ A672>E2>2< DA71 712 =><2> 43882<?@712>A?B635 $ 12523>62<:=B6825E=>712>284=6<267=$=6 712 =712> 136< :=6726<2< 7137 712 536< A6 GB287A=6 A8 B6<A84B72<5@ 36 63C 536< 38 712 3442553678 1392 358= EA52<363445A:37A=6A6=>C= :53ACA6;=::B436:@>A;178 A6 >2842:7 =E 712 3E=>283A< 536< 2 :=6726<8 7137 712 >A?B635 358= 6=7A:2< 7137 712 536< A6 GB287A=6 D38 >2:=><2< 38 36 63C 536< A6 712 >2926B2 >2:=><8 2 712>2E=>2 :=6726<8 7137 712 >284=6<267 =$ CB87 1392 - 6 - ?226 3>>3@2< 38 3 43>7@ A6 712 4>=:22<A6;8 ?2E=>2 712 >A?B635 D1A:1 CB87 1392 123>< 712 >284=6<267 =$ ?2E=>2;>367A6;=::B436:@>A;1787=7124>2<2:288=>=E712 3442553678 12 523>62< <<A7A=635 =92>6C267 <9=:372 E=>712>284=6<2678= 7= D1A528B44=>7A6;712=><2> =E71236<>A?B635:=6726<2<71377124>2<2:288=>=E712 3442553678 13< EA52< 36 3445A:37A=6 E=> =::B436:@ >A;178 36< 712 >A?B635 3E72> ;=A6; 71>=B;1 712 C372>A358 D38 837A8EA2< 7137 12D38 :B57A937A6;712 536<A6GB287A=636< 712>2E=>2A7D38IB87AEA2<A6:=6E2>>A6;=::B436:@>A;178 * 21392:=68A<2>2<8B?CA88A=68=E712523>62< :=B6825E=>712344255367838D25538712523>62<<<A7A=635 =92>6C267 <9=:372E=> 712>284=6<2678 = 7= 36< 712523>62<:=B6825E=>712>284=6<267=$ 7A86=7A6<A84B727137712536<A6GB287A=6D38 >2:=><2< 38 36 63C 36< A6 712 >2926B2 >2:=><8 12 83C2 A8 29A<267 E>=C 712 =><2> 43882< ?@ 712 36< >A?B635 A7825E D12>2 A7 125< J=6 92>AEA:37A=6 =E - 7 - >2:=><836< 63C#37>AF3A7D38E=B6<7137712536<A836 63C 536< 36< 712 34425536708 E3712> >A =C3663 8 = 29368A<<3443 %3<A@3> D38 :B57A937A6; 712 536< 38 =6 ' ' /$36<4>A=>7=7137K " 12>2A86=C267A=6387=D12712>71A8536<D38 26<=D2< 7= :13>A73?52 => 3 >25A;A=B8 A63C =D292> 712 >A?B635 138 2H2>:A82< IB>A8<A:7A=6 B6<2> 712 3>6373F3 2>73A6 63C8 ?=5A7A=6 :7 / D1A:1 ;A928 36 A6<A:37A=6 7137 71A8 D38 62A712> 3 >25A;A=B8 A63C 6=> 3 :13>A73?52A63C / 42>B835=E 2:7A=6$=E7123>6373F32>73A6 63C8?=5A7A=6:7 /C3F28A7C=>2713629A<2677137 D126292>363445A:37A=6A6=>C= A8EA52<?@342>8=6 =712> 7136 36 63C<3> 7126 712 63C<3> 81=B5< ?2 3>>3@2< 38 3 43>7@ A6 712 4>=:22<A6;8 <CA772<5@ 712 63C<3> D38 6=7 3>>3@2< 38 3 43>7@ A6 712 4>=:22<A6;8 ?2E=>2 712 >A?B635 6 3<<A7A=6 B52&$ =E B528 358= 842:AEA28 7137 D126 36 3445A:37A=6 A8 C3<2 ?@ 3 42>8=6 - 8 - =712>7136712 63C<3>712 63C<3>81355?23>>3@2<383 >284=6<2677=7123445A:37A=612>2E=>2712=><2>43882< ?@ 712 >A?B635 D38 6=7 A6 3::=><36:2 DA71 53D 36< :2>73A65@<A<6=7?A6<712 63C=>712 63C<3> ' 12>2E=>2D2<=6=7EA6<36@2>>=>A6712=><2> 43882<?@712 A6;52.B<;28277A6;&38A<2712=><2>43882< ?@712>A?B635=6712;>=B6<7137712=><2>43882<?@712 >A?B6354>2IB<A:2<712>A;178=E712 63C<3> 671379A2D=E712C3772>712>2A86=C2>A7A6 71A834423536<71283C2A8 )' & ( )' & %( .. A87= 5=*$