- 1 - ! " #$!! $ % & %'() &%( * !! " # $ $ ! $ $ $ % !! # # #& $ ! # #$ $ $ !! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$ $$ $ ! ! $# !! ' !! ( )$$ # * $ $ $$ $ ' ! " # % $+ ' ( )$ $ , "* "' $ '" "' $ "" $ - 3 - '% "" $ $ # $ -')*" - !"" ' # . . /$ ## 012 34515167 12 8194:;7:4< 4=5167 "' 68 $0><>51?> >@><1A ;<>A20> >7015> "" 244A17@ 56 B;>20 504 3<6=44:17@2>@>1725504345151674<2>==;24:6256'17 6!"" )><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4 6""* <4@1254<4: D? 6C47 691=4 >9>D;<>@1 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 ::15167>9 1E19 #;:@4 >7: # >9>D;<>@1 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>D94 ;7:4< 24=51672 -')* " <4>:F1504=5167-68 " 04 >D<1:@4: 8>=52 68 504 =>24 ><4 50>5 <42367:475 6" 12 504 F184 68 345151674< 6>==;24: 6 + >7@>2F>C1 041< C><<1>@4 F>2 2694C71G4: 67 !"" >7: 504? <421:4: 56@4504< 86< > 34<16: 68 " - 4 - ?4><2 ;5 68 504 F4:96=A 504? D4@65547 =019:<47 2 34< 504 >E4<C4752 17 504 =6C39>175 25>54: D? 504 =6C39>17>75 345151674< 6 >967@ F150 04< 17+9>F2 14 8>504<+17+9>FC6504<+17+9>FD<6504<+17+9>F>7:21254<+17+ 9>F25><54:560><>2204<D65030?21=>99?>7:C475>99?86< 504 <4>267 50>5 204 0>: > 96E4 C><<1>@4 F150 345151674< 61404<0;2D>7:==6<:17@9?504?;2456>D;2404< 17 > 81950? 9>7@;>@4 5 12 8;<504< >994@4: 50>5 67 "" >5 >D6;5 " 3C 45151674< 62 >7:">==;24:62>7:"1404<0;2D>7:>7:C6504<+ 17+9>F B;><<494: F150 04< >22>;954: >7: 504<4>854< 50<6F7 04< 6;5 8<6C 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 47=4 9485 F150766504<63516720425><54:56<421:41704<3><475>9 06;24 04<4>854< 204 96:@4: 504 =6C39>175 67 """ >7: 504 2>C4 F>2 <4@1254<4: 17 <1C4 6"" :>54: """ 86< 504 68847=42 25>54: ;D24B;4759? <42367:475 6 + 3691=4 =67:;=54: 504 17E4251@>5167 >7: 9>1: =0><@4 20445 >@>1725 504 345151674<2 86< 504 >86<4C4751674: 68847=42 D? ><<>?17@ - 5 - 504C>2>==;24:6256'@@<14E4:D?5042>C4504 345151674<23<484<<4:501234515167 4><:50494><74:=6;724986<504345151674<2>7: 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6E4<7C475 94>:4< 86< <42367:475 6 + 5>54 06;@0 7651=4 24<E4: 56 <42367:475 6" 204<4C>174:>D2475 3><5 8<6C ;<@17@ 24E4<>9 =6754751672 15 12 =67547:4:D?50494><74:=6;724986<504345151674<250>5 67 34<;2>9 68 504 =6C39>175 >E4<C4752 4H=435 504 >994@>5167 >@>1725 345151674< 62 >7: " >D269;549? 76 6504<C>54<1>92><439>=4:>@>17256504<345151674<2512 >926=6754754:50>55046504<345151674<2D417@17+9>F268 504=6C39>17>75504?><4<421:17@243><>549?>7:76F04<4 =6774=54:56504>994@4:17=1:4755128;<504<=6754754: 50>5 <42367:475 6" <421:4: >967@ F150 345151674< 6 86< > 34<16: 68 " ?4><2 >7: 504? 0>E4 =019:<47 >7: <42367:4756"04<2498B;><<494:F150345151674<6>7: 9485504C>5<1C671>906C472;=0=1<=;C25>7=4043<>?2 56>996F50434515167>7:56B;>205043<6=44:17@2 - 6 - 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6E4<7C475 94>:4<>334><17@86<<42367:4756+5>54633624:504 34515167 0>E4@1E47C?>7H16;2=6721:4<>5167D65067 504 2;DC1221672 C>:4 D? 504 94><74: =6;7249 86< <4234=51E43><5142>7:34<;24:504:6=;C4752>E>19>D9467 <4=6<: ! 7 34<;2>9 68 504 =6C39>175 >7: =0><@4 20445 C>54<1>92 15 =6;9: D4 @>504<4: 50>5 504 =6C39>175 F>2 96:@4: D? <42367:475 6" 67 """ >994@17@ 50>5 67 "" 17 504 C1:71@05 06;<2 45151674< 62 >7:">==;24:62>7:"1404<0;2D>7:>7:C6504<+ 17+9>F B;><<494: F150 04< >7: 50<6F7 04< 6;5 8<6C 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 H=435 2;=0 >E4<C4752 504<4 ><4 76 234=181= >994@>51672 C>:4 >@>1725 <4C>1717@ >==;24: 14 345151674< 62 56 ' 7 34<;2>9 68 504 =0><@4 20445 C>54<1>92 4H=435 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 C>:4 >@>1725 345151674< 62 56 ' 504<4 12 76 234=181= >E4<C4752 68 0><>22C4751286<50=6C17@>7:>:C1554:9?5048>=51250>5 - 7 - 345151674<6256'><4<421:17@17>243><>5406;247 2;=0=1<=;C25>7=450467/D9434H6;<517504=>2468 <436<54:17 !"#$%& >53><>@<>306049:50>5 504 6;<5 206;9: D4 =><48;9 17 3<6=44:17@ >@>1725 504 :125>75 <49>51E42 17 =<1C42 34<5>1717@ 56 C>5<1C671>9 :123;542 >7::6F<? :4>502 04 <49>51E42 68 504 0;2D>7: 206;9:765D4<634:+1767504D>212686C71D;2>994@>51672 ;79422 234=181= 1725>7=4 68 5041< 17E69E4C475 17 504 =<1C4 ><4 C>:4 6;5 5 12 >926 245594: 36215167 68 9>F 50>5 18 > 34<267 12 C>:4 56 8>=4 > =<1C17>9 5<1>9 67 26C4 @474<>9 >7: 2F44317@ >994@>51672 F1506;5 D<17@17@ 67 <4=6<: >7? 234=181= 1725>7=42 68 =<1C17>9 =67:;=5 15 12 765017@ D;5 >D;24683<6=422685046;<5046;<523624>:;5?56 2;DI4=5 504 >994@>5167 94E4994: 17 504 =6C39>175 56 > 506<6;@02=<;517?56817:6;5F04504<504<412>7?@>1768 5<;50 17 504 >994@>51672 6< F04504< 504? ><4 C>:4 679? F150 504 2694 6DI4=5 68 17E69E17@ =4<5>17 17:1E1:;>92 17 > - 8 - =<1C17>9 =0><@4 C6<4 3><51=;9><9? F047 > 3<624=;5167 ><1248<6C>C>5<1C671>9:123;54 ' 7 504 1725>75 =>24 > D><4 34<;2>9 68 =0><@4 20445C>54<1>92=94><9?206F250>5504>994@>51672C>:4D? 504=6C39>17>75<42367:4756"><4E>@;4>7:6C71D;2 504< 50>7 =9>1C17@ 50>5 504 0;2D>7: 14 >==;24: 6 >7: 012 8>C19? C4CD4<2 C475>99? 0><>224: 04< 504 =6C39>17>75 0>2 765 3<6E1:4: >7? 234=181= :45>192 6< :42=<1D4:>7?3><51=;9><1725>7=4680><>22C475040>2 765C4751674:50451C4:>5439>=46<>C>774<17F01=0 504 >994@4: 0><>22C475 6==;<<4: 6< 504 :45>192 68 504 7>5;<4 68 :4C>7: 6< 152 3><51=;9><2 04<486<4 504 9>=A2=67=<454>7:3<4=124>994@>516720454<CJ=<;495?K =>7765D4425>D91204:F1506;5234=181=1725>7=4042>C4 F4>A472 504 =>24 68 504 3<624=;5167 >7: =>252 24<16;2 :6;D5675043<6D>D1915?68504E4<216768504=6C39>17>75 04 C4<4 @474<>9 >994@>51672 68 0><>22C475 F1506;5 3617517@6;5504234=181=:45>192F6;9:765D42;881=147556 =67517;4=<1C17>93<6=44:17@2>@>1725>7?34<267 - 9 - - 512245594:36215167689>F50>56;<520>E456 D4=><48;9>7:=>;516;217:4>917@F150=6C39>175>7:C;25 5>A4 3<>@C>51= <4>915142 1756 =6721:4<>5167 F0194 :4>917@ F150 C>5<1C671>9 :123;542 F04<4 504 >994@>51672 0>E4 56 D42=<;5171G4:F150@<4>5=><4>7:=1<=;C234=5167176<:4< 563<4E475C12=><<1>@468I;251=4>7:>D;24683<6=42268 6;<5 7C?=6721:4<4:E14F=67517;>516768=<1C17>9 3<6=44:17@ >@>1725 345151674< 62 56 ' 14 >==;24: 62 56 ' 12 765017@ D;5 >D;24 68 3<6=422 68 6;<5 ==6<:17@9?50486996F17@, 1 043451516712 ' 11 4515167 >@>1725 345151674< 62 56 ' 14 >==;24: 62 56 ' 12 ' 04 3<6=44:17@2176!"" )><1217@6;568 <1C4 6""* <4@1254<4: D? 504 6C47 691=4 >9>D;<>@1 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 - 10 - ::15167>91E19#;:@4>7:# >9>D;<>@186< 50468847=423;7120>D94;7:4<24=51672-')* " <4>: F150 4=5167 - 68 17 <4234=5 68 345151674< 62 56 '>==;24: 62 56'><404<4D?B;>204: 111 4515167 >@>1725 345151674< 62 >7: " 14 >==;24:62>7:"1204<4D? +) %!( ! 1256.96.