- 1 - !""# $%& & % '( ')*+ ' * , !!!" # $ %% & ' ' "!( ( ( "!( # $ ' ) %* ' (& Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' "(' $ & (" ' $ & + (( (!( '' % %' ' '' " ( ! ! (!(!( * ' % + ' , , - % % ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582: 2;3/45 (" 46 .<:<3/=< <><:/? 9:<?0.< <5./3< (!( 34 @9<0. 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></5033.2123/3/452:<;;90284(/5(( (!( <:/0/5> 49346:/A24(!(!( :2>/032:28B= 4A2547/;23<3/45 <7<B9:<>/ /3= 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 "$&(! <58!:C2;3/45 46<582;3/450 <58 46 4C:= :4./B/3/45 ;3 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46 88/3/45<7/D/7%98>2<58%'<7<B9:<>/ ( .2 6<;39<7 A<3:/E 46 3.2 ;<02 /0 3.<3 :201458253 4(A<::/28<;;90284/2/5<=<?<4?<:?<:/204546 3./0 123/3/452: 45 !(!(! 9:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 A<::/<>2 - 3 - 3.2 :201458253 4(-0 6<A/7= >/D25 347<0 46 >478 <58 0!!!!!46;<0.<5843.2:.4902.478<:3/;72034<;;9028 4<0<84C:=632:3.2A<::/<>2:2014582534(03<:328 34 :20/82 /5 3.2 A<3:/A45= .4A2 <745> C/3. .2: .90B<58 <;;9028 4 <58 3./0 123/3/452:<;;9028 4( C.4 /0 .2: A43.2:/57<C 4C2D2: 3.2= 744?28 <632: .2: ;4:8/<77= 64: < 12:/4846(=2<:0.2:2<632:3./0123/3/452:<745>C/3.<;;9028 4 03<:328 34 .<:<00 :201458253 4( B43. 1.=0/;<77= <58 A253<77=B=82A<58/5><5<88/3/45<784C:=5!!(!( <3 <B493!!!1A<;;90284<583./0123/3/452:82A<5828 0!!!!!! <88/3/45<7 84C:= <58 C.25 :201458253 4( @9203/4528 3.2 0<A2 B43. 46 3.2A 3.:4C5 .2: 493 46 3.2 A<3:/A45/<7 .4A2 0 09;. 0.2 03<:328 34 :20/82 <3 .2: 1<:253<7.4A2<32:45("!(!( <3<B493!(!!1A.2: .90B<58 /2 <;;9028 4 D/0/328 .2: 1<:253<7 .4902 <58 1/;?2891<@9<::27C/3..2:<00<97328.2:<58<70464/0328< 7/62 3.:2<3 25;2 :201458253 4( 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</53 45 (!((!( B264:2 :201458253 447/;2 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: <58 .2: 045 C./;. ;<A2 34 B2 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4(!(!( 64: 3.2 <64:2A253/4528 46625;20 9B02@92537= :201458253 447/;2 /5D203/><328 3.2 ;<02 <58 7</8 ;.<:>2 - 4 - 0.223<></5033.2123/3/452:<58.2:04564:3.2<64:2A253/4528 46625;20 B= <::<=/5> 3./0 123/3/452: <0 <;;9028 4( .2 72<:528<>/03:<32344?;4>5/F<5;2463.246625;20>>:/2D28 B=3.20<A23.2123/3/452:<;;90284(1:262::283./0123/3/45 34@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0<></503.2: 2<:872<:528;49502764:3.2123/3/452:<5872<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 64: 3.2 :201458253 4 G 3<32<5872<:528;49502764::2014582534( 1<:36:4A9:>/5>02D2:<7;453253/4503.272<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: .<0 ;45325828 3.<3 3.2 123/3/452: B2/5> <;;9028 4( .<0 54 ?54C728>2 C.<3042D2: <B493 3.2 <772>281.=0/;<7<58A253<7.<:<00A253A2328493B=<;;9028 4 34 :201458253 4( '9:3.2: /3 /0 ;45325828 3.<3 3.2 <772><3/450 /5 3.2 ;4A17</53 <58 03<32A253 46 C/3520020 <:2 4A5/B90 <772><3/450 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 /3 /0 1:<=28 34 @9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 3.272<:528;49502764::2014582534( .<0;453258283.<354C3.2/5D203/><3/45.<0B225;4A172328 <58 ;.<:>2 0.223 .<0 B225 7</8 B= :201458253 447/;2 <></503 <;;9028 4 <58 3.2 123/3/452:<;;9028 4( - 5 - '9:3.2:3.203<32A25346 (<58/22=2C/3520020343.2 /5;/8253 <704 ;<32>4:/;<77= 03<328 3.2 /5D47D2A253 46 3./0 123/3/452: /5 3.2 <772>28 46625;2 4:24D2: 3./0 123/3/452: /0 :20/8/5> /5 3.2 0.<:28 :446 <745> C/3. <;;9028 4G.2: 045 <58 :201458253 4( 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 1:4;228/5>0 ;<5543 B2 @9<0.28 <></503 .2: ;;4:8/5>7= 1:<=0 34 8/0A/00 3.2123/3/45 2<:528<704411402834123/3/45<581:<=034 8/0A/003.20<A2 H .<D2>/D25A=<5E/490;450/82:<3/45B43.453.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D2 1<:3/20<58<70412:90283.2A<32:/<7017<;28B264:23./049:3 " 0 ;4978 B2 ><3.2:28 6:4A :2;4:80 3.2 ;4A17</53 <D2:A2530 ;72<:7= 8/0;7402 3.<3 <632: 3.2 A<::/<>2 46 :2014582534(C/3.<;;902840.2:20/828C/3.<;;9028 40<58(/2.2:.90B<58<58A43.2:/57<C:2012;3/D27= 64: < 12:/48 46 ( =2<:0 <58 B43. .2: .90B<58 <58 3./0 123/3/452:<;;9028 4( 03<:328 34 .<:<00 .2: 34 B:/5> <88/3/45<784C:=3/0012;/6/;<77=03<328/53.2;4A17</533.<3 45 !!(!( B43. <;;9028 4 <58 3./0 123/3/452: - 6 - 82A<5828 0!!!!!! 6:4A:201458253 4( <0 <88/3/45<7 84C:= 34 ;72<: 3.2/: 82B30 '9:3.2: 45 12:90<7 46 3.2 03<32A2530 46 ( <58 /2 2=2C/3520020 34 3.2 /5;/82533.2=.<D2;<32>4:/;<77=03<3283.2<;3463.2<;;9028 4<583./0123/3/452:<;;90284(509;.;/:;9A03<5;20 <0 :/>.37= ;45325328 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: :201458253 4( 3.2 123/3/452: /0 0.<:/5> 3.2 ;4AA45 :446 C/3. <;;9028 4<33./003<>23.21:4;228/5>0;<5543B2@9<0.28<></503 3.2 123/3/452:<;;9028 4( 0/5;2 3.2:2 <:2 <772><3/450<58A<32:/<70<:264:3.;4A/5><></503.2: 25;2 3.2 123/3/45 7<;?0 A2:/30 <58 3.2 0<A2 /0 -+ '& * & /034,74,((