- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#! !" '&( !"#"$%$ $ ! !"#"$%$ !"#"$ & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' !"#"$%$ " ' !"#"$%$ ( !"#"$%$ ' $$( $$ ' ' ' ' ' )! %$ $$%$& ' $ %#%&$%$ )! ' *+ ,- - 3 - ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 123/3/452; 022</5= 3.2 64774>/5=;27/260 !" # $! % & " " ' $ 3 /0 ? @?02 46 3.2 123/3/452; 3.?3 .2 /0 3.2 4>52; 46 3.2 ?=;/@A73A;?7 7?58 /5 A;B2: 4$% C2?0A;/5= %$ ?@;20 =A53?0 ?58 A;B2: 4&( C2?0A;/5= % ?@;2 =A53?0 943. 0/3A?328 ?3 ?52<?7 /77?=2A;AC/3<?7 ?7A<3/0./06A;3.2;@453253/453.?3 452 ;/41?7 ?;211? ?88?; ?58 ./0 ?004@/?320 >2;2 /532;62;/5=>/3.3.212?@26A71400200/45?5825D4:C25346 3.2 123/3/452; 4B2; 3.2 1;412;3/20 /5 EA203/45 .2;264;2 3.2123/3/452;>?0@4C127728346/72?0A/364;3.2;27/2646 12;123A?7 /5DA5@3/45 /5 4 "#$% ?=?/503 02B2;?7 12;0450 /2 ;/41?7 ?;211? ?88?; ?58 43.2;0 .2 - 4 - 0?/8 0A/3 @?C2 34 92 82@;228 9: DA8=C253 8?328 $"%"$% $ 3 /0 ./0 6A;3.2; @453253/45 3.?3 8201/32 3.2 82@;22 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 3.2 0?/8 12;0450 >.4 ?;2 826258?530 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 >2;2 /532;62;/5= >/3. 3.2 12?@26A71400200/45?5825D4:C253463.21;412;3:463.2 123/3/452; 5 B/2> 46 3.2 /532;62;25@2 C?82 9: 3.2 826258?530 3.2;2/5 >/3. 3.2 123/3/452;+0 1400200/45 4B2; 3.2 1;412;3: /5 EA203/45 3.2 123/3/452; ?11;4?@.28 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; ?8?=/;/ A582; 3.2 ?/5325?5@2 ?58 276?;2 46 ?;2530 ?58 25/4; /3/F250 @3 $%% 34 =/B21;432@3/4534./C?5864;;2@4B2;:46./01;412;3:9: ;2C4B/5= 32C14;?;: 25@;4?@.C2530 C?82 9: ;/ 41?7 ?58./0?004@/?32046?52<?7/77?=2?58C3.?58?CC? ?58 .2; ?004@/?320 46 27.2;/ /77?=2 943. 6?77/5= A582; ?72927?=A58/;?C?5@.?:?3A;AC/3<?7 ?7A< & ./092/5=3.203?3246?66?/;0;2014582534$ 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; ?774>28 3.2 ?117/@?3/45 - 5 - ;21;20253?3/45 C?82 9: 3.2 123/3/452; 8/;2@328 3.2 826258?530 /5 3.2 0A/3 34 ;2C4B2 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 ?58 4;82;28 3.2 4C2 21?;3C253 34 1;4B/82 ?11;41;/?32 1;432@3/45 34 ./C /5 B/2> 46 3.2 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22 1?0028 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 3 /0 ?704 @45325828 9: 3.2 72?;528@4A50273.?33.2?5@.?:?3. 2B2741C25366/@2; 46 ?72927?=A58/ ;?C ?5@.?:?3. .?0 ?704 ;214;328 34 ;201458253 4 ?.0/78?; 3.?3 .?58?11? ?58 43.2;0 .?B2 543 ;2C4B28 3.2 /772=?7 03;A@3A;2 25@2 3.2 123/3/452; .?0 ?11;4?@.28 3./0 4A;3 @453258/5= 3.?3 8201/323.2DA8=C253?5882@;221?00289:3.2/B/74A;3 /53.24;/=/5?70A/3?=?/5033.20?/812;0450?583.24;82;0 1?00289:3.2 00/03?534CC/00/452;5403210?;23?<25 34 ;2C4B2 3.2 /772=?7 25@;4?@.C253 ?58 03;A@3A;2 1A3 A1 9:3.20?/812;0450 " 3 /0 6A;3.2; @45325828 9: 3.2 72?;528 @4A5027 64;3.2123/3/452;3.?3?=?/545$ $%$&3.2123/3/452; ;2EA20328;2014582534?0>277?0;2014582534(34 /C172C253 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; ?58 - 6 - 3?<2?11;41;/?32?@3/45?02845>./@.;2014582534 8/;2@328;2014582534(343?<2?11;41;/?32?@3/45?012; 3.2;A720;27:/5=A1453.2DA8=C2531?0028/53.24;/=/5?7 0A/3 8201/32 >./@. 54 @45@;232 ?@3/45 .?0 9225 3?<25 25@23.2123/3/452;.?0?11;4?@.283./04A;38A2343.2 /5?@3/45 46 3.2 ;2014582530 ?58 545!@450/82;?3/45 46 ./0 ;21;20253?3/45 ( 2?;528 88/3/45?7 4B2;5C253 8B4@?32 ;21;20253/5= 3.2 3?32 @4532580 3.?3 8201/32 1?00/5= 46 3.2 4;82; 9: ;201458253 4$ 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; ?3 552GA;2! ?58 3.2;2?632; 3.2 0A902EA253 8/;2@3/45 /00A2834 ;201458253 4( 34/C172C253 3.24;82; 46 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; 54 ?@3/45 /0 3?<25 64; 3.2 ;2?045 3.?3 3.2 123/3/452; .?0 34 ?11;4?@.3.2/B/74A;3?586/722G2@A3/45123/3/45?58543 9:>?:46?>;/3?5804?7043.2?5@.?:?3 2B2741C253 66/@2; .?0 543 9225 C?82 ? 1?;3: 34 3./0 123/3/45 .2;264;23./0123/3/45/05430A03?/5?972 - 7 - .?B2 .2?;8 3.2 72?;528 @4A5027 64; 3.2 123/3/452;?5872?;528 88/3/45?74B2;5C253 8B4@?3264; 3.2;201458253!3?32 # 3 /0 543 /5 8/01A32 3.?3 3.2 123/3/452; /5/3/?328 0A/3 /5 4 "#$% >./@. @?C2 34 92 82@;228 45 $"%"$% $ ?=?/503 3.2 826258?530 3 /0 ?704 543 /5 8/01A323.?3/5B/2>463.225@;4?@.C253?588/04928/25@2 46 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2 @/B/7 4A;3 3.2 123/3/452; C4B28 ;201458253 4$ 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; 34 3?<2 ?@3/45 ?=?/5033.2826?A73/5=1?;3:3.2826258?530/53.24;/=/5?7 0A/3?58 ?5 4;82; ?704 @?C2 34 92 1?0028 9: ;201458253 4$ 9: =/B/5= ?11;41;/?32 8/;2@3/450 34 3.2 0?/8 826258?530 3.2;2/5 >.4 .?8 25@;4?@.28 ?58 ?704 34 3.2 47/@2 21?;3C25334/5/3/?32?11;41;/?32?@3/454>2B2; 54 0A@. ?@3/45 /0 3?<25 9: 3.2 ;201458253!47/@2 4; 3.2 @45@2;528?A3.4;/3/20/5@7A8/5=3.272332;463.2 >./@. /0 /00A28 64; ;2C4B?7 46 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 9: 3.2 0?/8 12;0450 >.2;2 3.2 @41: /0 ?704 =/B25 34 3.2 47/@2 A9 5012@34; ?58 3.2 ?.0/78?; 201/32 >./@. 54 ?@3/45 /0 - 8 - 3?<25 9: ;201458253 40 ?58 ( 25@2 3.2 123/3/452; .?0;/=.37:?11;4?@.283./04A;3 H 3 3./0 14/53 46 3/C2 /3 /0 ;272B?53 34 ;262; 34 3.2 /;@A7?; 46 3.2 4B2;5C253 46 ?;5?3?<? 8?328 % $%$$>./@.;2?80?0A582; #()(*+ !+, -. / 0 1/0 % "0 2 3435(4 /6 7 " " 3 . 0 %+3 8888 . 9:" 9 3 , - 2 3333."#;<+ 0. , - " " = " ! 3 / 0 "" " 6 ) . 3 0 " 0 - 9 - . " " " " > 3 " 0 " " 0" 0 = 0 " / . 2 & . 3 " " 3 " ? " "" " " " " . - 3 0 " ! 3 / . " " " " ; " " 0 """ "" " @. " 0 "" ". + "" 3 3 <& A"/ "" " - 10 - " " """" B & . . " "" " " "" . . / . $ .". + 0 "" "" C & "" " "" "" D 0 / . "" = ) -+ " " . +" 0 " -+ "" . . " "" . "" E& , -3 . ( 4" 0 C$;E & " 0 " "" " " - 11 - 9:" 93 , -09:" / 3 9:" , - / . &" "" . > #FA4 4,&1+ !C+ C < < "" " 3 / +A" / +/ . 9 F D "" " . " F G0 9:" 9 3 , - / 3 ' % A/827/52 4$ 46 3.2 0?/8 /;@A7?; C?<20 /3 @72?; 3.?3 45@2 ?5 4;82; /0 1?0028 9: 3.2 4A;3 ?58 ;2?@.20 6/5?7/3: 3.2 ?A3.4;/3/20 @45@2;528 ?;2 94A58 34 /C172C2533.24;82;/572332;?5801/;/3>./@..?05439225 8452 /5 3.2 1;20253 @?02 3 /0 ?704 543 3.2 @?02 46 3.2 ;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 4; 3.2 1;/B?32 1?;3/20 3.?3 3.2: .?B2@.?7725=283.20?/8DA8=C253?5882@;221?00289: 3.2 3;/?7 4A;3 5 3.2 1;20253 @?02 /3 /0 0225 3.?3 /5 @453/5A?3/45463.24;82;0463.2DA8=C253?5882@;2246 3.2 3;/?7 4A;3 3.2 123/3/452; ?11;4?@.28 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452;/5B4</5=3.21;4B/0/450463.2?/5325?5@2 ?58 276?;2 46 ?;2530 ?58 25/4; /3/F250 @3 $%% 34 - 12 - 1;432@3 ./C0276 ?58 ./0 1;412;3: 6;4C 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 9: 3.2 826258?530 /5 3.2 0A/3 ?8 3.2 ;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20@4C17/28>/3.3.28/;2@3/450/00A289:3.2/B/7 4A;3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; 3.2 EA203/45 4625@;4?@.C253 >4A78 543 .?B2 ?;/025B25/6 3.2;2 >?0 25@;4?@.C253 .?8 3.2: ;2C4B28 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 3.2 EA203/45 46 123/3/452; /5B4</5= >;/3 DA;/08/@3/45>4A78543?;/02 .2/;@A7?;8?328 % $%$$ .?09225/00A289:3.24B2;5C25346?;5?3?<?1;2@/027: 64; 3.2 ;2?045 3.?3 3/C27: ?@3/45 9: 3.2 ;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 >/77 1;2B253 6A;3.2; 7/3/=?3/45 .?;80./1 /5@45B25/25@2 ?58 8;/B/5= 3.2 0A@@2006A7 1?;3: 34 6/72 ? @4532C13 123/3/45 4>2B2; /5 B/2> 46 3.2 6?@3 3.?3 3.2 ;201458253?A3.4;/3/20.?B2543?@328/5?3/C27:C?552; 72?8/5= 34 3.2 A552@200?;: .?;?00C253 ?58 3.2 ?772=28 8?C?=2 3.?3 /0 @?A028 34 3.2 123/3/452; 3.2 0?C2 >/77 .?B2 34 92 ?8.2;28 34 /5 03;/@3 4928/25@2 9: 3.2 ;201458253?A3.4;/3/2053.21;20253@?02/3/00A9C/3328 9: 3.2 72?;528 88/3/45?7 4B2;5C253 8B4@?32 3.?3 .2 - 13 - .?0 54 /503;A@3/450 ?0 34 >.23.2; 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.2 /B/7 4A;3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; .?B2 9225 @4C17/28 8201/32 3.2 72332; /00A28 9: 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452;?583.2?5@.?:?3 2B2741C25366/@2; 3 /0 ?704 ;272B?53 34 C253/45 .2;2 3.?3 3.2 /;@A7?; 8?328 % $%$$ /00A28 9: 3.2 4B2;5C253 46 ?;5?3?<?82?70>/3.3.2@4502EA25@2046543?8.2;/5=34 3.20?/8/;@A7?;9:@4502EA253/?71;4@228/5=0?=?/5033.2 @45@2;528466/@2;0/5@7A8/5=3.2;2014582530.2;2/564;543 492:/5= 3.2 4;82;0 ?58 1;4B/8/5= 52@200?;: ;27/26 34 3.2 123/3/452; /5 B/2> 46 3.2 DA8=C253?58 82@;22 1?0028 9: 3.2 /B/7 4A;3 0 @4532C17?328 A582; A/827/52 4( 8/0@/17/5?;: 1;4@228/5=0 ?;2 34 92 /5/3/?328 ?=?/503 3.2 2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4 52=72@3 34 @4C17: >/3. 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.24A;353.21;20253@?0245.?588201/323.24;82;0 .?B/5= 9225 1?0028 9: ;201458253 4$ 00/03?53 4CC/00/452; 34 1;4B/82 1;432@3/45 ?58 34 ;2C4B2 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2 ?5@.?:?3 2B2741C253 66/@2; 34 3.2 DA;/08/@3/45?7 47/@2 84 543 - 14 - 6/58 ?5: @4C17/?5@2 4; ;2C4B?7 46 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 582; 3.2 @/;@AC03?5@20 /5 B/2> 46 3.2 /;@A7?; 8?328 % $%$$3./0 4A;3822C0/36/3348/;2@33.2;/5@/1?7 2@;23?;: 46 3.2 @45@2;528 21?;3C253 34 /5/3/?32 8/0@/17/5?;: 1;4@228/5=0 ?=?/503 3.2 2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4 .?B2 52=72@328 34 @4C17: >/3. 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.2 4A;30 ?58?70464774>A/827/524463.20?/8/;@A7?;04?704 /664A58=A/73:3464774>A/827/524#463.20?/8/;@A7?; 3 /0 ?704 4125 34 3.2 123/3/452; 34 /5/3/?32 @4532C13 1;4@228/5=0?=?/5033.2826258?530/53.24;/=/5?70A/3>.4 ?;2 ?772=28 34 .?B2 25@;4?@.28 ./0 1;412;3: ?0 12; 3.2 DA8=C253/53.24;/=/5?70A/3/54 "#$% .23>4 1;4@20046@4532C13?=?/5033.2@4532C54;0?58B/47?3/45 46 3.2 4;82;0 9: 3.2 ;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 @4A78 ;A5 1?;?77277: .2 0?C2 >4A78 .?B2 34 92 82@/828 ?632; @458A@3/5=?1;412;25EA/;:943./53.2@4532C13123/3/45 ?0 >277 ?0 /5 3.2 25EA/;: 1;4@228/5=0 9: 1;4B/8/5= ;2?045?9724114;3A5/3:34?77@45@2;5281?;3/20 $ 582;3.2@/;@AC03?5@201?003.264774>/5= - 15 - / .2123/3/45/08/01402846 // .2 123/3/452; /0 ?3 7/92;3: 34 6/72 ? @4532C13 123/3/45 ?=?/503 3.2 826258?530 >.4 .?B2 25@;4?@.28 ?58 B/47?328 3.2 4;82;0463.23;/?74A;3 /// 2@4587: 3.2 ;/5@/1?7 2@;23?;: 46 3.2 @45@2;528 21?;3C253 0.?77 /5/3/?32 ?11;41;/?32 8/0@/17/5?;: 1;4@228/5=0 ?=?/503 3.2 2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4 .?B2 6?/728 ?5852=72@32834@4C17:>/3.3.24;82;046 3.2/B/74A;3?583.?3463.20A902EA253 4;82;0 1?0028 9: 3.2 00/03?53 4CC/00/452;?8=/;/ /B ;214;3343./02662@30.?77926/7289264;2 3./04A;3>/3./53>4C453.06;4C3.28?32 46;2@2/1346@2;3/6/28@41:463./04;82; !)* ' !"( # &#