- 1 - !!" !#$#% & $""!" ""'' (') ""'' ""'' !!"# $ %& ' ! ( ) ( "!%' & Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " * ( + !! ( "# !!"# ( !, ( !! ( )" ( + ( & ) ! ( !) ( ! , ( & ) ( (( # ( !!"# # (( # !!"# $ % - - !) # ' - 3 - +%' ,"" & & """ . ( ( !!"# %& ' ! ( ( ( "!%' & " * ( + ! ( "# !!"# - 4 - ( ! ( !! ( )" ( +( &) ! ( !# ( ! , ( & ) ( (( ( !!"# # (( !!"# % - ' %' ,"" & & """ . ( - 5 - (( ( ) . !! " * ( + ) . !! !! ( !, . ( !! % ' ! - 6 - !! " ( ) . !! / . 0)) ( ! . !! ( ( # . !! ! ( & ( ( ( & . ! %& - "- ","") (' ++++%1' ' ,"" ( - 7 - & ++++ " """ & & ' ' 2 & ( 3& $! 4565788579671571:6:;<=>?=@?45 1A51A7?5A ,"" 87665A =; =6 " 7;A :; = """=;?45@:95=@5;:=1:B:9&>A<57;A& =>1?767B7C79D7;%@=16=1?E?451:79=>1?2' " =1 ?45 67C5 =@ F=;B5;:5;F5 ?45 871?:56 G:99 H5 15@5115A?=76851?45:117;C:;<H5@=15?451:79=>1? 45 1595B7;? @7F?6 @=1 7AI>A:F7?:=; =@ ?4565 7885796 715 ?47? ?45 897:;?:@@6 47B5 815@5115A = """ 7<7:;6? ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 655C:;< 159:5@ =@ 871?:?:=; 7;A 658717?5 8=66566:=; :; 15685F? =@ ?45 6>:? - 8 - 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 5@5;A7;? = :6 ?45 @7?451 =@ ?45 897:;?:@@6 45897:;?:@@647B5815@5115A=>;A51=1A51 ,>957;A"=@655C:;<:;?51:JJ576>15156?17:;:;< ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 ;=? ?=79:5;7?5 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 4567:A7889:F7?:=;F7J5?=H5799=G5AHD?451:79=>1?HD ?45 :J8><;5A =1A51 A7?5A ,"" 7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A HD ?45 67J5 A5@5;A7;? = 476 815@5115A =") "" ! 45 5@5;A7;? = 476 @:95A = 655C:;< :;?51:JJ576>15156?17:;:;<?45897:;?:@@=6"7;A7;A A5@5;A7;? =6" 7;A ! @1=J :;?51@51:;< G:?4 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 7;A ?45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; F7J5 ?= H5 A:6J:665A HD ?45 1:79 =>1? 7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A HD ?45 67J5 ?45 A5@5;A7;? = 476 815@5115A ="") "" ) 97:;?:@@647B5@:95A=">;A51 1A51,>95 7;A " 157A G:?4 5F?:=; ! =@ ?= 156?17:; ?45 A5@5;A7;? =! @1=J :;?51@51:;< G:?4 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 - 9 - 81=851?:567;A?4567:A7889:F7?:=;F7J5?=H5871?9D799=G5A HD ?45 1:79 =>1? 7;A H5:;< 7<<1:5B5A HD ?45 67J5 ?45 897:;?:@@647B5815@5115A=", "" # 571A 1: 7F4:; 747I7; 9571;5A F=>;659 788571:;<@=1?45A5@5;A7;?=1:7B:7?:99571;5A F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 897:;?:@@6 7;A 1: 71647B71A47; 79:87?:99571;5AF=>;659@=1?45A5@5;A7;?= 1: 7F4:; 747I7; 9571;5A F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;? = F=;?5;A5A ?47? ?45 1:79 =>1? 476 5115A :; 799=G:;< =6 7;A " @:95A HD ?45 897:;?:@@6 655C:;< 159:5@ =@ :;?51:J :;I>;F?:=; 7<7:;6? ?45 A5@5;A7;?6;=??=:;?51@515G:?4?456>:?6F45A>9581=851?:56 HD?45A5@5;A7;?676G59976156?17:;:;<?45A5@5;A7;?6@1=J 79:5;7?:;<?456>:?6F45A>9581=851?:56?:6F=;?5;A5AHD?45 9571;5AF=>;659@=1?45A5@5;A7;?=?47??451:79=>1? :;?45:J8><;5A=1A516=959DH765A=;?45&>A<J5;?=@?4:6 =>1? :; ?45 F765 =@ 158=1?5A :; 799=G5A?457889:F7?:=;67;A@>1?451F=;?5;A5A - 10 - ?47??45@:;A:;<15F=1A5AHD?451:79=>1?871?:F>9719DG:?4 15685F??=8717<1784=15K>:156?=H5:;?51@515AG:?476 ?451:79=>1?476;=?81=8519D78815F:7?5A?45J7?51:79=; 15F=1A 76 ?= ?45 @7F? ?47? ?45 A5@5;A7;? = H5:;< ?45 71?47=@?45I=:;?@7J:9D=@?45897:;?:@@67;A?45A5@5;A7;? ==><4??=47B5?7C5;F51?7:;6?586:;F9>A:;<?=J7:;?7:; 7;A?=?7C5F715=@?457@@7:16=@?4597;A:;K>56?:=;7;A?45 67:A 7685F? =@ ?45 J7??51 G76 ;=? 81=8519D 78815F:7?5A HD ?451:79=>1?7;A766>F4:?:671<>5A?47??451:79=>1? 511=;5=>69D 799=G5A =6 7;A " G4:F4 15K>:156 ?= H5 :;?51@515AG:?4:;?45657885796 , ? :6 796= F=;?5;A5A HD ?45 9571;5A F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;? = HD 15@511:;< ?= ?45 &>A<J5;? =@ =;2H95 >815J5 =>1? :; ?45 F765 =@ 158=1?5A :; !"# 7;A F=;?5;A5A ?47? ?45 A5@5;A7;?=H5:;<?45 71?47=@?45I=:;?@7J:9D:;?5;A6 ?=?7C5F715=@?457@@7:16=@?4581=851?D@=195<79;5F566:?D 7;A :; ?47? 5B5;? ?4515 :6 7 :J85A:J5;? @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;? =?=A579G:?4?4581=851?:56G4=:6156:A:;<:;?45B:997<5 - 11 - 7;A ?7C:;< F715 =@ ?45 7@@7:16 =@ ?45 97;A :; K>56?:=; 7;A 7FF=1A:;<9D6=><4?@=1:;?51@515;F5=@?4:6=>1? 51 F=;?17 1: 7B: 7?:9 9571;5A F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 897:;?:@@6 F=;?5;A5A ?47? ?4515 G76 7 5719:51871?:?:=;H5?G55;?45871?:5676?=?456>:?6F45A>95 81=851?:56 :6 F=;F51;5A 7;A ?45 67:A 7685F? 476 H55; 7AJ:??5A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;? = 7;A ?4515@=15 ?45 1:79 =>1? 476 1:<4?9D 799=G5A =6 7;A " G4:F4 A= ;=? 15K>:156:;?51@515;F5HD?4:6=>1? ;6=@7176799=G:;<=@=":;871?@:95AHD?45 897:;?:@@6:6F=;F51;5A1:7B:7?:99571;5AF=>;659476 71<>5A?47??451:79=>1?476799=G5A="871?9D=;9D 7<7:;6? A5@5;A7;? =! G:?4=>? 78815F:7?:;< ?45 685F:@:F 7B51J5;?6J7A5:;?45G1:??5;6?7?5J5;?=@A5@5;A7;?= ?47? J=15 685F:@:F799D ?45 97;A H571:;< >1B5D =! J576>1:;<7F1566?7;A:;<:;?45;7J5=@?45897:;?:@@6@=1 J=15?47;"D57167;A?4515@=156=><4?@=1:;?51@515;F5=@ ?4:6=>1? - 12 - " 1: 71647B71A47; 79:87?:9 9571;5A F=>;659 788571:;< @=1 ?45 A5@5;A7;? = 6=><4? ?= I>6?:@D ?45 :J8><;5A=1A5187665AHD?451:79=>1?=;= ; ?45 9:<4? =@ ?45 6>HJ:66:=;6 J7A5 HD ?45 9571;5AF=>;6596@=1?45871?:56:?:6;=?:;A:68>?5?47??45 897:;?:@@6 715 ?45 F4:9A15; =@ A5@5;A7;? = 45 6>:? :; = """ :6 @:95A 655C:;< 159:5@ =@ 871?:?:=; 7;A 658717?5 8=66566:=; :; 15685F? =@ ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 ;A:68>?7H9D ?45 897:;?:@@6 76 G599 76 ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 47B5 F=;6?1>5A ?45 @7F? ?47? ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56715?45I=:;?@7J:9D81=851?:56:;?457889:F7?:=; ; ?45 H7FCA1=8 =@ ?4565 7685F?6 6:;F5 ?45 897:;?:@@6 47B5 ?7C5;7895776?=?4581:=1871?:?:=;:;?45I=:;?@7J:9D7;A ?4567:A7685F?476H55;F=;6:A515A:;?45G1:??5;6?7?5J5;? @:95AHD?45A5@5;A7;?=7;A?4515@=157J=@?45B:5G ?47??451:79=>1?4761:<4?9D799=G5A=67;A"@:95A HD ?45 897:;?:@@6 156?17:;:;< ?45 A5@5;A7;?6 @1=J 79:5;7?:;< ?456>:?6F45A>9581=851?:5676G59976;=??=:;?51@515G:?4 ?45 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 ?:99 ?45 F=;F9>6:=; =@ ?45 81=F55A:;<6715F=;F51;5A?:6796=?=H5;=?5A?47?:;7 - 13 - 6>:?@=1871?:?:=;?45A7><4?516=1?456=;6=@?4581=8=6:?>6 71547B:;<64715:;?456>:?6F45A>9581=851?:567;A:;?47? B:5G=@?45J7??51?45:J8><;5A=1A5187665AHD?451:79 =>1? =; =6 7;A " :6 I>6? 7;A 81=851 7;A ;= :;?51@515;F5:6F7995A@=1:;?45657885796 4=><41:7F4:;747I7;9571;5AF=>;659 788571:;<@=1A5@5;A7;?=15@516?=?45&>A<J5;?=@?45 >99 5;F4 =@ ?4:6 =>1? :; ?45 F765 =@ 7;A ?45 &>A<J5;? =@ =;2H95 >815J5 =>1?:;?45F765=@ %15@5115A6>817'4=G5B51 ?45 1:79 =>1? 47B:;< ?7C5; ;=?5 =@ ?45 @7F?>79 7685F?6 =; 15F=1A 76 ?= ?45 @7F? ?47? ?45 6>:? :6 =;5 @=1 871?:?:=; 7;A 658717?58=66566:=;:;15685F?=@?456>:?6F45A>9581=851?D 7;A:;?47?B:5G=@?45J7??51?45F=;?5;?:=;17:65AHD?45 9571;5AF=>;659@=1?45A5@5;A7;?=F7;;=?H57FF58?5A ! ;6=@7176?45:J8><;5A=1A5187665AHD?451:79 =>1? =; = A:6J:66:;< ?45 7889:F7?:=; @:95A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;? = >;A51 1A51 , >95 7;A " =@ :6 F=;F51;5A G4515:; ?45 67:A 7889:F7?:=; G76 @:95A HD ?45 - 14 - A5@5;A7;? = 156?17:;:;< ?45 897:;?:@@ =6 " 7;A A5@5;A7;?=6"7;A!@1=J:;?51@51:;<7;A=H6?1>F?:;< ?45:197G@>98=66566:=;7;A5;I=DJ5;?=@?45A5@5;A7;?= :; 15685F? =@ 6>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?D 7? 9= :5 4=>65 7;A64=881=851?:56?:99A:68=679=@?456>:?;?4:615<71A =;F715@>9F=;6:A517?:=;=@?45@:;A:;<15F=1A5AHD?451:79 =>1?7?8717<1784=6!?=#J7C56:?F9571?47??456>:? 6F45A>95 81=851?:56 7? 9= :5 4=>65 7;A 64=8 81=851?:56 715 ?45 7;F56?179 81=851?:56 7;A 796= ?45 64=8 81=851?:56 715 F=;6?1>5A 76 F=871F5;516 81=851?:56 7;A :; ?47?B:5G=@?45J7??51?7C:;<:;?=F=;6:A517?:=;76?451:79 =>1?476711:B5A7?7F=;F9>6:=;?47??457AI>A:F7?:=;=@?45 6>:?15K>:156?=A5?51J:;5?451:<4?6=@?45871?:567J=@ ?45 B:5G ?47? ;= :;?51@515;F5 :6 F7995A @=1 :;6=@71 76 A:6J:66:;< = @:95A HD ?45 A5@5;A7;? = 76 851 ?45 :J8><;5A=1A5181=A>F5A7?;;5L>15?=?45788579 ) ;?47?B:5G=@?45J7??517J=@?45B:5G?47? ;=:;?51@515;F5:6F7995A@=1:;?456578857967;A7FF=1A:;<9D ?45:J8><;5A=1A5187665AHD?451:79=>1?=;=6" 7;A15K>:156?=H5F=;@:1J5A - 15 - # 7C:;< :;?= F=;6:A517?:=; ?45 71<>J5;?6 7AB7;F5AHD?459571;5AF=>;6596788571:;<@=1?45871?:56 ?45 1:79 =>1? :6 15K>56?5A ?= 5L85A:?5 5719D 4571:;< @=1 156=9>?:=;=@?45A:68>?5 1A515A7FF=1A:;<9D "* ("!") $! :6?=9=#