Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54732 (KAR)
ASHOK v. SAYED MD. KHALIQUAZAMA
WP/201970/2025 · 2026-01-13
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54732 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54732 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#"$
%&# "
'&(
!"
#
$ %
& '
()' '
'* ' +
" '
' ! '
' ,
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' ! , ' (
' ! & ' ' &!&
'
-
'
!"
'
+
! &! '
&&
! '
. - 3 -
&
'
"! . &"
"
&
+
&
! &
!"
#
$
(* &/,. !"& ! " / & **. 0*. /& %
*
,* *
* (
**
,!& ! ' * '* 1 ! ! 1*% * ' '
*
*
1
- 4 -
$ ''% * ' '
*
'
' * '
' -
'
2345673738934:3;6<=><6:69<?978397268@3A39?; 4B37?9<CB<AD697<6=78@8397266E6FB738956737389
*8@ 6?4> B9<6@47?9<39A 726 5?@7364 42?;; =6 @6:6@@6< 78 ?4 CB<AD697 <6=78@ ?9< <6F@66 28;<6@
" 26 5@?>6@ 48 BA27 39 7234 5 6737 389 => CB<AD697<6=78@834?4B9<6@
! "
# $ %
!! &'()*(&)&+ ! ,
- .$ ./ %- %$0
- 5 -
1(2(&)3&)&& 0
"
! 4
"(
! /
" $
" !0 " ! 0
$ 1
! $ $ ""
- ! $
"
"
! 4
"(
5 0
"
! $
"
"
" ! "
! 4
"(6
@36::?F748:726F?46?@672?7 26 <6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< ? 4B37 ?4 5;?3973::4 39 8, !& 89 726 :3;6 8: 726 <<37389?; 3G3; B<A6 ?4?G?9? ?A6H?<3 ?A?3947 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4<6:69<?974 726@639 466I39A @6;36: 8: @6F8G6@> 8:
5844644389 26 4B37 F?D6 78 =6 <6F@66< G3<6 CB<AD697 <?76< !+ ! !?9<726CB<AD697<6=78@4H6@6<3@6F76< 78 2?9<8G6@ & AB97?4 69F@8?F26< ?@6? 36 J
K ?@6? H23F2 34 5?@7 ?9< 5?@F6; 8: ;?9<4 =6?@39A
- 6 -
>8+&L LL !" D6?4B@39A && ?F@64 !+ AB97?4 >8+&L L D6?4B@39A
" ?F@64 >8+&L LL& D6?4B@39A
" ?F@64 >8+&L L"D6?4B@39A?F@64 B@4B?9778726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 <6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 6E6FB7389 56737389 39 8 ! ! 78 6E6FB76 726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@665?446<=>726;6?@96<3G3;B<A697266E6FB7389 56737389 G3<6 8@<6@ <?76< "!&! ! ? 58;3F6 5@876F7389 H?4 8@<6@6< :8@ @6F8G6@> 8: 5844644389 8: 726 5@856@7> :@8D 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 ?9< 5844644389 H?@@?97 H?4 344B6< B@4B?97 726@678 726 =?3;3:: G3<6 8@<6@ <?76< ,!& ! :3;6< ?
@658@7 8: F8D5;3?9F6 47?739A 72?7 5844644389 8: & AB97?4 8: ;?9< 2?< =669 4BFF644:B;;> @6F8G6@6< :@8D 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 9 726 =?3;3::-4 @658@7 37 34 47?76< 72?7 726@6 ?@6 47?9<39A F@854 ?9< =8@6H6;; ?;89A H372 6MB35D697 26 F@854 ?@6 G?;B6< ?7 4&!!!?9<=8@6H6;;?;89AH3726MB35D697?@6G?;B6< ?74&!!!!!FF8@<39A;>726=?3;3::4B=D3776<?@658@7 47?739A 72?7 726 47?9<39A F@854 ?4 H6;; ?4 =8@6H6;; ?9<
- 7 -
6MB35D697 G?;B6 34 ?7 4&&!!! ?9< 72?7 726 <6F@66 28;<6@4?@6@6?<>78D?I67265?>D6978:7264?D6
7 34 726 F897697389 8: 726 ;6?@96< F8B946; :8@ CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 72?7 726 =?3;3:: 2?4 :?;46;> :3;6< ? @658@7?4985844644389H?42?9<6<8G6@8@<6;3G6@6<?9< 98 9873F6 8: D6?4B@6D697 8: ?;;6A6< 69F@8?F26< 58@7389 H?4 A3G69 78 CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 H372 @6A?@< 78 726 G?;B?7389 8: 47?9<39A F@854 8@ 6MB35D697 6E34739A 39 726 58@7389?;;6A6<78=669F@8?F26<26@6:8@6?AA@36G6<=> 726 @658@7 4B=D3776< => 726 =?3;3:: <?76< ,!& ! 726 567373896@CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 34 =6:8@6 7234 8B@7 F2?;;69A39A 726 4?D6 89 46G6@?; A@8B9<4
F89769<39A 72?7 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 H?4 B9CB473:36< 39 ?FF65739A 726 @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3:: ?9< 72?7 963726@ 39 726 8@3A39?; 4B37 98@ 39 726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4 726 8B@7 8DD3443896@ H?4 ?5583976< 78 ?4F6@7?39 ?F7B?; 69F@8?F2D6978:726;?9<?9<72?7726@63498@658@78:726 44347?97 3@6F78@8:
?9<6F8@<4$
%4B=D3776<=6:8@6 726 8B@7 H372 @6A?@< 78 D6?4B@6D697 8: 726 ;?9< ?;89A
- 8 -
H372726@658@726@6:8@63734F8976976<72?7H269726@6 3498D6?4B@6D69737H8B;<2?G6=6693D58443=;6:8@726 <6F@6628;<6@48@726=?3;3::78?4F6@7?39H2?734726?F7B?;
69F@8?F2D697 7 34 ?;48 F8976976< 72?7 726 G?;B?7389 48 5B7 :8@72 => 726 =?3;3:: H372 @6A?@< 78 726 47?9<39A F@854 ?9< 726 =8@6H6;; 8: 4&&!!! 34 987 CB473:36< FF8@<39A;> CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 466I4 78 467 ?43<6 726 8@<6@?9<?;;8H723456737389
5 " ;6?@96< F8B946; ?556?@39A :8@ @64589<697 84& ?9< ,<6F@66 28;<6@ 84& ?9< , G626D697;>F89769<472?77265;6?8:9893<6973:3F?73898:
726 69F@8?F26< 5@856@7> H?4 987 7?I69 B5 39 726 8@3A39?;
4B37 ?9< <645376 CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 ?556?@39A =6:8@6 726 @3?; 8B@7 26 <3< 987 F28846 78 :3;6 ?
47?76D697 8@ F897647 726 F?46 89 D6@374 :76@ 726 <6F@66 726 5;?3973::4<6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 6E6FB7389 56737389 G69 39 726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 2?G6 963726@?556?@6<98@:3;6<?9>8=C6F73894787266E6FB7389 56737389 8@ 78 726 ?55;3F?7389 84 ?9< :3;6< => 726
- 9 -
<6F@66 28;<6@4 :8@ 344B?9F6 8: H?@@?97 8: <6;3G6@> 8:
5844644389 8: 4B37 5@856@7> H372 726 ?44347?9F6 8: 726 ?;BI?B@G6>8@?9<H372726?3<8:58;3F6F8947?=;64?9< H8D?9 58;3F6 F8947?=;6 8: '?9?AB;3 8;3F6 7?7389 26@6:8@6H269726CB<AD697<6=78@42?G6987F8976476< 726 4B37 <3;3A697;> 4B37 2?G39A =669 <6F@66< 6E6FB7389 56737389F?D678=6:3;6<H23F2 34 ?;489878=C6F76<788@ 46@38B4;> F8976476< => CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 ?9< 39 45376 8: 2?G39A :3;6< 84 ?9< 466I39A <6;3G6@> 8: 5844644389H372726?44347?9F68:?;BI?B@G6>8@?9<H372 726 ?3< 8: 726 58;3F6 F8947?=;64 8=C6F73894 78 726 4?3< ?55;3F?73894 H?4 ?;48 987 :3;6< => 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 726@6 34 987239A 89 @6F8@< :8@ 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 8=C6F739A78?9>7239A@3A27:@8D:3;39A7264B3773;;726@658@7 8:726=?3;3::H23F22?4A896B9F8976476< , 6:B@726@F89769<472?7726CB<AD697<6=78@4 2?G6 987 6G69 =8726@6< 78 :3;6 8=C6F73894 78 726 =?3;3::-4 @658@7 ?9< CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 ?55@8?F26< 7234 8B@7 H23F2345@3D?@3;>5@6D?7B@6?9<=6;?76<3:37347?I69:@8D
- 10 -
726 <?76 8: :3;39A 8: 726 4B37 26@6:8@6 26 F89769<4 72?7 726@6 34 98 3;;6A?;37> 8@ ?@=37@?@39644 8@ 56@G6@437> 39 726 8@<6@ 5?446< => 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 ?9< 39 726 @658@7 8:
726 =?3;3:: 8H H2?7 34 MB6473896< => CB<AD697 <6=78@ 834H372@6A?@<78726=?3;3::@658@7<?76< ,!& ! 26@6:8@6 26 F89769<4 72?7 726 8@<6@ 8: 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 89 ?55;3F?7389 84 ?9< 47?9<4 397?F7 H3728B7 =639A<347B@=6<?9<?55?@697;>726@63498F2?;;69A678726 4?D6 ?4 H6;; 9<6@ 72646 F3@FBD47?9F64 26 466I4 <34D344?;8:723456737389
2?G626?@<726;6?@96<F8B946;:8@CB<AD697 <6=78@8?9<<6F@6628;<6@84&?9<, + 26@6 34 98 <345B76 78 726 :?F7 72?7 726 4B37 F?D6 78 =6 <6F@66< => H?> 8: ? CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 <?76< !+ ! ! 9 726 4?3< CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 726 7@3?; 8B@7 2?4 <3@6F76< 726 <6:69<?974 78 2?9< 8G6@ & AB97?4 69F@8?F26< ?@6? 36 J
K H23F2 34 ? 5?@7 ?9< 5?@F6; 8: 726 4B37 4F26<B;6 5@856@7> 26 69F@8?F26< 58@7389 2?4 =669 456F3:3F?;;> D6973896< 39 726 CB<AD697
- 11 -
3746;:
B@4B?97 726@678 ?9 6E6FB7389 56737389 F?D6 78 =6 :3;6<=>726<6F@6628;<6@47264BFF644:B;5;?3973::4H23F2 F?D678=6:3;6<89!!" ! 645376:3;39A?I?;?7289 &! ! CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 2?4 987 :3;6< ?9> 8=C6F73894787266E6FB7389567373898@7?I69?9>5;6?H372 @6A?@< 78 726@6 =639A 98 3<6973:3F?7389 8: 726 69F@8?F26< 58@73898:7265@856@7>H23F23448BA2778=66E6FB76<9
"!&! !
<6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 7H8 ?55;3F?73894 :8@ 344B?9F6 8: H?@@?97 8: <6;3G6@> 8: 5844644389 8: 4B37 4F26<B;6 5@856@7> H372 726 ?44347?9F6 8: ?;BI? B@G6>8@ ?9< :8@ 5@8G3<39A 726 58;3F6 ?3<5@876F7389 ?;89A H372 H8D?9 F8947?=;6 8: '?9?AB;3 58;3F6 47?7389 G69 78 7234 ?55;3F?7389 728BA2 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 H6@6 5@64697 =6:8@6 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 72@8BA2 7263@ F8B946; ?9< <645376 4B::3F3697 8558@7B937364 2?G39A =669 A@?976< 8=C6F73894 H6@6 987 :3;6< ?9< ?FF8@<39A;> 8=C6F73894 78 84 ?9< H6@6 7?I69 ?4 987 :3;6< 26@6?:76@ 726 4?3< ?55;3F?73894 F?D6 78 =6 ?;;8H6< B=46MB697 726@678 7265844644389H?@@?97H?4@6344B6<78=6F?@@36<8B789
- 12 -
8@ =6:8@6 "&& ! ?9< 78 4B=D37 ? @658@7 26@6?:76@ 726 =?3;3:: 2?4 4B=D3776< ? @658@7 645376 726 4B=D344389 8:@658@7=>726=?3;3::?9<726D?776@=639A58476<=6:8@6 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 726 8=C6F73894 ?@6 987 :3;6< => 726 CB<AD697<6=78@4787264?3<@658@78:726=?3;3::6G6973;;
<?76 B<AD697 <6=78@ 8 2?4 ?55@8?F26< 7234 8B@7 H3728B7 6G69 :3;39A 8=C6F73894 78 726 4?3< @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3::?9<=>H?>8:?93976@3D8@<6@A@?976<=>72348B@7 89 !"& ! 34 69C8>39A 726 3976@3D 8@<6@ ?9< 2?4 987 =8726@6<78 ?556?@ =6:8@6 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 78 :3;6 ?9> 8=C6F7389478726=?3;3::@658@78@6G6978726?55;3F?738948@ @?346234;377;6:39A6@H372@6A?@<787263<6973:3F?73898:726 5@856@7>H23F22?498H=6697?I69B5:8@726:3@4773D639 7234H@3756737389 &! 265@8F6<B@6F8976D5;?76<B9<6@7268<68: 3G3; @8F6<B@6345B@4B?9778726CB<AD697?9<<6F@667 34726;3=6@7>?9<<34F@673898:7264BFF644:B;5?@7>39726 5@64697F?467265;?3973::478:3;67266E6FB73895673738978 6E6FB76726CB<AD697?9<<6F@66?9<7869C8>726:@B3748:
- 13 -
726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 9 726 6E6FB7389 56737389 ?55?@697;> 728BA2 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 ?556?@6< H?> =?FI 89 &! ! 726> 2?G6 987 =8726@6< 78 :3;6 7263@ 8=C6F73894787266E6FB738956737389?9<78726?55;3F?73894 :3;6<=>726<6F@6628;<6@4787?I6<6;3G6@>8:58446443898: 7264B375@856@7>39F;B<39A?44347?9F68:7264B@G6>8@?9< 726 58;3F6 ?3< ?9< ?;48 78 726 =?3;3:: @658@7 9<6@ 726 F3@FBD47?9F64 37 34 96F644?@> :8@ 7234 8B@7 78 6E7@?F7 6F7389,8:7268<68:3G3; @8F6<B@6H23F2@6?<4?4 B9<6@
7 * 8 #
$ 0
0
" " 0
- $ 1"
"$ !" ! "
1" $ "
( & 9:::; 8" *)< ! *='>( ? #
0
- ! "
- 14 -
# ! ! "
( 91 (@ ! "
!! 0
! $ 0
( 1 (@ ! "
" ! 1" ! "
0
" "
8 #
$ - ! ! " " "
-
#
$ 1"
"$ !" ! " 0
$ !
" (;6
&& 7 34 :8@ 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 78 F8943<6@ ?9> 8=C6F73894?9<?;;MB6473894?@3439A=67H6697265?@736439 726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4 ?@3439A 8B7 8: 726 4B37 H23F2 34 98H5B7:8@H?@<786E6FB7389@6;?739A787266E6FB7389?9< <34F2?@A68@4?734:?F73898:726<6F@6626@6:8@6H269726 567373896@CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 2?4 987 =8726@6< 78 ?556?@=6:8@6726E6FB739A8B@778:3;68=C6F7389478726
- 15 -
D?39 56737389 8@ 78 726 ?55;3F?73894:3;6< 26 H3;; 987 2?G6 ?9> @3A27 78 ?55@8?F2 7234 8B@7 B9<6@ @73F;6 , 8: 726 894737B73898:9<3?466I39A78467?43<67268@<6@5?446< => 726 8B@7 9 :?F7 CB<AD697 <6=78@ 8 34 987 6G69 MB64738939A?9>8@<6@8:7268B@7397234567373892?734 MB6473896< 34 ? @658@7 4B=D3776< => 726 =?3;3:: <?76< ,!& ! =6:8@6 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 <8 987 :39< ?9> 3;;6A?;37>8@56@G6@437>8@5@8F6<B@?;6@@8@F8DD3776<=>726 E6FB739A 8B@7 F?;;39A :8@ 3976@:6@69F6 39 7234 56737389 : CB<AD697<6=78@8343976@6476<39@?3439A?9>8=C6F7389 H372@6A?@<78?9>3<6973:3F?73898:72669F@8?F26<58@7389 2634?7;3=6@7>78<848=6:8@6726E6FB739A8B@7?9<726 E6FB739A8B@742?;;F8943<6@3:?9>8=C6F738934@?346<8@ :3;6< 78 726 @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3:: 63726@ 726 F;8FI =6 467 =?FIH?@<4 98@ 726 F?@7 =6 5B7 39 :@897 8: 726 28@46 26@6:8@6<8987:39<?9>A88<A@8B9<8@F8A697@6?489 783976@:6@639726H@37CB@34<3F7389B9<6@@73F;6 ,8:726 894737B7389 8: 9<3? H23F2 34 ;3D376< 78 726 56@G6@437> 8@
- 16 -
3;;6A?;37> F8DD3776< => 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 8@ 726 7@3?; 8B@7397265@64697F?46726E6FB739A8B@7 & 6?@96<F8B946;:8@ CB<AD697<6=78@ 8 2?4 @6;36<B589726:8;;8H39ACB<AD6974. ! "# $%&'(() *)+, -.! /0#12 $'('%3 4+ -5 /5 6 ! ! &5 705 $%&894) :2-:; '+ 26 ?=8G6 4?3< CB<AD6974 ?@6 987 ?55;3F?=;6 78 726 5@64697:?F74?9<F3@FBD47?9F648:726F?469726F?468:
37 34 F;6?@;> 47?76< => 726 89-=;6 56E 8B@7 ?7 5?@?A@?52 8&, 72?7 ?;76@9?73G6;> 726 6E?F7 <64F@3573898:726<6F@67?;5@856@7>D?>=6?4F6@7?396<=> 726 E6FB739A 8B@7 ?4 ? MB647389 @6;?739A 78 6E6FB7389
- 17 -
<34F2?@A6 8@ 4?734:?F7389 8: <6F@66 H37239 726 D6?939A 8: 6F7389,8:7268<68:3G3; @8F6<B@6 &" FF8@<39A;>5@8F66<785?44726:8;;8H39A
$3% 26@37 673738934<34D3446<
)* ' "( #
3478&;8&