Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54730 (KAR)
KAMARAJ AND ORS v. J AMARAMMA AND ORS
RFA/200205/2024 · 2026-01-20
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54730 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54730 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
"#$ !! %&' (
! "
#
$
"
!%
" &
'(( )& *
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" (( ! ! &
+
$
#
$
+
" &
#
' ( )&
*
, (( , %-
.!,,( % (
" (( (
/ ! !& ,
!! !$
&
,
( (
,, "
((
,
"
- 3 -
0&
0&
# )(
0&
*
12324253657895
/ ! !/571249:2/4712 259/;9<9:=3>2653,2<63=;>6?4/;81/;7@;96:
/=;7AB 16<2 49:23 7198 6CC26: D16::25>95> 712 E=3>F257 65332D;2236723!! !$C68823712;295
! 12 C6;7928 816:: 125D24/;71 G2 ;242;;23 7/ 68 712HI2;26;;6H23G24/;2712;96:/=;7126CC2::6578 12;295 I2;2 712 3242536578 I19:2 712 ;28C/532578 I2;2 712C:69579448
$ )9* 12 8=97 95
/ ! ! I68 49:23 4/;
32D:6;679/5 7167 C:6957944
/8 7/
/$ 6;2 712 6G8/:=72 /I52;8 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 653 4/; C2;C27=6: 95E=5D79/5 7/ ;287;695 712 3242536578 4;/F 9572;42;95>I9717129;C/882889/56534/;632D:6;679/57167 712 86:2 32238 G26;95> 3/D=F257
/% ! ! ! 653
- 4 -
%! ! ! ! ;2>9872;23 95 712 /449D2 /4 712 =G 2>987;6;2<63=;>636723 ! !6532J2D=723GH 324253657
/653324253657
/!9546</=;/4324253657 /$ 6;2 9::2>6: 5=:: 653 </93 653 5/7 G95395> /5 712 C:69579448 653 7/ 87;9K2 /44 712 56F28 /4 712 3242536578 4;/F 712 ;2D/;3 /4 ;9>178 95 ;28C2D7 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;79286539582;771256F28/4712C:6957944895/:=F5 /8%653!/4712;2D/;3/4;9>178
)99* 12 C:69579448 D:69F23 7167 712 1=8G653 /4 C:6957944
/712C:6957944
/!653C:6957944
/$6;2712 D19:3;25/4 16;636FF6653F6;2>6=3612HD:69F23 7167 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 87//3 95 712 56F2 /4 F7 16;636FF6 653 I68 12:3 GH 712 E/957 46F9:H D/FC;9823 /4 712 C:69579448 12 8693 16;36FF6 3923 957287672 472; 12; 32671 324253657
/ G295> 712 G;/712;/4 F7 16;636FF6>/719856F22572;2395712 ;2<25=2;2D/;38653712;26472;D/5<2H237128=97C;/C2;7H 9546</=;/4324253657
/$12C:69579448D:69F7167712 86:2 F632 GH 324253657
/ 653 324253657
/!
95
- 5 -
46</=; /4 324253657
/$ 98 9::2>6: 653 5/7 G95395> =C/5 7129; 9572;287 653 D/582L=257:H 8/=>17 4/; 712 ;2:9248 F2579/5236G/<2
)999* 12 324253657
/ 49:23 6 I;97725 87672F257 D/5725395> 7167 12 653 16;36FF6 6:/5> I971 82<25 /712;8 I2;2 712 D19:3;25 /4 65=F657;6H6 2 D:69F23 7167 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 C=;D16823 GH 65=F6571;6H6 95 712 56F2 /4 F7 16;636FF6 653 712;26472; F7 16;636FF6D/5825723/571286H/412;
46712; 7/ 7;65842; 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 95 712 56F2 /4 12;
2:32;G;/712;8 DD/;395>:H68 C2; 65/;6: C6;7979/5 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 42:: 7/ 712 816;2 /4 324253657
/ 2 D:69F23716719856F2I682572;2395712;2<25=2;2D/;38 4;/F 712 H26; %%-% 3=;95> 712 :94279F2 /4 F7 16;636FF6 2 6:8/ D/5725323 7167 712 C:69579448 71/=>1I2;26I6;2/47126G/<246D7816<2D/F2=CI971 646:82C:267167712:6538I2;27;65842;;237/71256F2/4 324253657
/ G21953 7129; G6DK 2 6:8/ D:69F23 7167 529712; F7 16;636FF6 5/; 712 C:69579448 I2;2 95
- 6 -
C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 653 7167 97 98 712 3242536578
/ 653
/! I1/ 6;2 95 :6I4=: C/882889/5 653 D=:79<679/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 12 I;97725 87672F257 /4 324253657
/ I68 63/C723 GH 324253657 /!24253657
/$3935/749:265H87672F257
)9<* &6823/57126G/<2D/572579/58712;96:/=;7 4;6F237124/::/I95>988=28
! "##$
!"##$
#%# # &
'
% ()(
- 7 -
*
!!*$! +
,
)<* 12 C:6957944
/ I68 2J6F9523 68 (" 653 812 F6;K23 J8( 7/ (!! I975288 I68 2J6F9523 68 ("! 24253657
/ I68 2J6F9523 68 " 653 12 F6;K23 J8 7/ &6823 /5 712 /;6: 653 3/D=F2576;H 2<9325D2 712 ;96: /=;7 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448163C;/<237167712H6;2712/I52;8/47128=97 C;/C2;7928 /I2<2; 97 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 393 5/7 C;/3=D2 65H 3/D=F2578 7/ 81/I 7167 712H I2;2 95 C/882889/5/47128=97C;/C2;792868/57123672/47128=97 653 D/582L=257:H 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 469:23 7/ C;/<2 7167 712H 6;2 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 7 712;24/;2 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 163 469:23 7/ C;/<2 712 6::2>23 9572;42;25D2 GH 712 3242536578 8 ;2>6;38 712
- 8 -
L=2879/5 I12712; 712 86:232238 2J2D=723 GH 712 3242536578
/ 653 324253657
/! 95 46</=; /4 324253657
/$ I68 G95395> /5712 C:69579448 9712:37167 712 86:2 32238 G295> 9::2>6: 393 5/7 G953 712 C:69579448 -68712988=2I12712;712C:695794486;225797:234/;
;2D7949D679/5 /4 712 ;2D/;3 /4 ;9>178 97 12:3 7167 68 712 C:69579448469:237/C;/<27167712H6;295C/882889/5/4712 8=97C;/C2;7928712HI2;25/725797:234/;7;65842;/47129; 56F2895712;2<25=2;2D/;3876:8/12:37167324253657 / 469:23 7/ C;/<2 7167 12 653 324253657 ! I2;2 95 :6I4=:C/882889/5653D=:79<679/5/47128=97C;/C2;79287 32D;223 712 8=97 95 C6;7 653 32D:6;23 712 86:2 32238 2J2D=723 GH 3242536578
/ 653 324253657
/!
95 46</=;/4324253657
/$685=::653</936535/7G95395> =C/5712C:69579448&295>6>>;92<23GH7128693E=3>F257 65332D;2271232425365786;2G24/;27198/=;7
198/=;7988=235/79D27/712;28C/532578653 6:8/82D=;23712;2D/;38/4712;96:/=;7
- 9 -
12 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 3242536578 D/5725323 7167 712 C:69579448 16<2 5/7 D16::25>23 712 ;2<25=2 257;928 GH I19D1 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 I2;2 7;65842;;23 4;/F 712 56F2 /4 F7 16;636FF6 7/ 712 56F2 /4 324253657
/ 2 D/572538 7167 712 ;2<25=2 257;928 I2;2 6::/I23 7/ 87653 4;/F 712 H26; %%-%% 653/5I6;38653712;24/;2712C:695794486;2G/=537/16<2 K5/I:23>2 /4 712 D:69F /4 324253657
/ 2 D/572538 71677128=979849:2395712H26;! !653712;24/;27128=97 98G6;;23GH:6I/4:9F97679/526:8/D/5725387167712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 5/F956::H C=;D16823 95 712 56F2 /4 F7 16;636FF6 653 67 6 C6;7979/5 G27I225 324253657 /653198G;/712;87128=97C;/C2;792842::7/712816;2 /4 324253657
/ 653 F7 16;636FF6 12;24/;2 F7 16;636FF6 D/5825723 7/ 7;65842; 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;387/71256F2/4324253657
/2D/5725387167 324253657
/ G295> 712 :6I4=: /I52; /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 163 D/5<2H23 712F 7/ 324253657
/$ 653 712;24/;2 712 86F2 98 G95395> =C/5 712 C:69579448 2
- 10 -
4=;712; D/5725323 7167 712 ;96: /=;7 168 398F98823 712 8=97 68 97 ;2:6728 7/ 712 ;2:924 /4 C2;C27=6:
95E=5D79/5 2 712;24/;2 D/572538 7167 712 ;96: /=;7 D/=:3 5/7 16<2 >;65723 6 G6;2 32D:6;679/5 7167 712 86:2 322382J2D=7239546</=;/4324253657
/$985/7G95395> =C/5712C:695794482D/5725387167GH<9;7=2/4 2D79/5 $/4712 C2D949D2:924D7%-$97I6895D=FG257=C/5 712C:695794487/C;/<27167712HI2;295:6I4=:C/882889/5 /4 712 C;/C2;7928 653 895D2 712H 16<2 5/7 D16::25>23 712 E=3>F25765332D;22/4712;96:/=;7/;16<249:23D;/88 /GE2D79/58 97 98 322F23 7167 712 C:69579448 6;2 5/7 95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 653 712;24/;2 5/ 32D:6;67/;H ;2:9248 D/=:3 G2 >;65723 7/ 712 C:69579448 &289328719812D/5725387167712C:6957944816<263F97723 716771232425365786;295C/882889/5/47128=97C;/C2;7928 653 712;24/;2 712 C:69579448 D655/7 F6957695 6 8=97 4/;
32D:6;679/5 I971/=7 822K95> 712 ;2:924 /4 ;2D/<2;H /4 C/882889/5
- 11 -
- 12:26;523D/=582:4/;712C:695794488=GF97723 716771246D771677128=97C;/C2;792887//39571256F2/4 F7 16;36FF698 5/7 398C=723 GH 712 3242536578 2 D/572538 7167 324253657
/ 98 D:69F95> 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 GH <9;7=2 /4 ;2<25=2 257;928 2 95<9723 712 6772579/5 /4 712 /=;7 7/ 2D79/5 !
/4 712 6;5676K6 653 2<25=2 D7 %- 653 D/5725323 7167 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38D65G27;65842;;23/5:HI125712;298656:925679/5 9572;<9</8 653 712;24/;2 ;2<25=2 257;928 D:69F23 GH 324253657
/ 3/28 5/7 D/542; 65H 797:2 /5 19F 653 125D2712;96:/=;7I68E=87949239532D;2295>7128=9795 C6;7 2 D/572538 7167 95 ;28C2D7 /4 <6D657 6>;9D=:7=;6:
:6538 712 49;87 C;95D9C:2 /4 :6I 98 7167 C/882889/5 4/::/I8 797:2 2 D/572538 I125 712 797:2 /4 F7 16;36FF6 98 5/795398C=7271259781/=:3/;3956;9:HG2D/587;=237167 F7 16;36FF6I6895C/882889/5/47128=97C;/C2;7928 2 712;24/;2 C;6H23 7167 7198 /=;7 F6H 2J2;D982 978 C/I2; =532; ;32; =:2 $$ /4 712 /32 /4 9<9:
- 12 -
(;/D23=;27/;2<2;82712495395>8/4712;96:/=;7958/46;
6888=2
/8!6536;2D/5D2;523
"2 16<2 D/58932;23 712 8=GF9889/58 /4 712 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 3242536578 653 712 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 C:69579448 "2 16<2 6:8/ C2;=823 712 ;2D/;38 /4 712 ;96: /=;7 68 I2:: 68 978 E=3>F257 653 32D;22 12 /5:H C/957 7167 6;9828 4/; D/58932;679/5 98 M"12712;324253657
/I68E=879492395D:69F95>716712 163 G2D/F2 712 /I52; /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 G6823 /5 F=7679/5 257;928 G;/=>17 6G/=7 3=;95> 712 :94279F2/4 F7 16;36FF6653I12712;12D/=:3;28987 712 8=97 49:23 GH 712 C:69579448 4/; 6 32D:6;679/5 7167 712H 6;2 712 /I52;8 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 653 7/ 32D:6;2716771286:2322382J2D=723GH324253657
/8 653 ! 95 46</=; /4 324253657
/$ 3/28 5/7 G953 712 C:69579448NO
12 ;2D/;38 F6;K23 G24/;2 712 ;96: /=;7 GH 712 C:69579448 2876G:981 G2H/53 3/=G7 7167 712 8=97
- 13 -
8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 I2;2 /I523 653 C/8828823 GH F7 16;36FF665371286F2982<932574;/FJ(I19D198 712 F=7679/5 2J7;6D7 95
/$ 24253657
/ 6:8/ 3/28 5/7 398C=72 712 8693 46D7 G=7 168 D672>/;9D6::H 63F9772371286F295712I;9772587672F25712;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 /4 712 :6538 G26;95> =;<2H
/8! 653 !% 87//3 95 71256F2 /4 F7 16;36FF6 653 712 86F298 2<93257 4;/F J( 7/ J( 12 56F2 /4 324253657 /I682572;2395712;2<25=2;2D/;38/4 =;<2H
/!% 4;/F712H26;%%%%-653/5I6;3865395;28C2D7/4 =;<2H
/! 4;/F 712 H26; %%%! 653 /5I6;38 J8(7/J(! 6;2712;2<25=2;2D/;38/4712:6538/4 7128=97C;/C2;792879::712H26;! ! ! ! % 24253657
/3935/7C;/3=D265H3/D=F2578 7/ 81/I 712G6898 /5 I19D1 19856F2 I68 2572;23 95712 ;2<25=2;2D/;38653I12712; F7 16;36FF6163;26::H D/5825723 7/ 8=D1 7;65842; /4 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 7/ 198 56F226:8/3935/7C;/3=D265H3/D=F2576;H2<9325D2
- 14 -
7/ E=8794H 198 D:69F 7167 67 6 C6;7979/5 G27I225 19F 198 G;/712;8653 F7 16;36FF67128=97C;/C2;792842::7/ 198816;26537167 F7 16;36FF6163D/58257237/712 7;65842; /4 712 ;2<25=2 ;2D/;38 95 198 56F2 24253657 / 7;923 7/ ;2:H =C/5 D2;7695 C;/D22395>8 95 9<9:
98D2::652/=8
/$ ! 95;28C2D7/4 =;<2H
/
/4 6F3=;>6 <9::6>2 653 =;<2H
/!
I19D1 I68 6DL=9;234/;712C=;C/82/4712
6;6H656C=;69>17656:
/I2<2; 712 46D7 ;2F6958 7167 712 :6538 95 L=2879/5I2;2/I523653C/8828823GH F7 16;36FF6 653957126G825D2/465HF672;96:7/81/I7167324253657 / 6DL=9;23 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 712 C:69579448 G295> 712 129;8 /4 F7 16;36FF6 6;2 25797:23 7/ G2 32D:6;2368712/I52;8/47128=97C;/C2;792868712H16<2 8=DD223237/7128=97C;/C2;7928=C/512;32671
5 7167 <92I /4 712 F6772; 712 86:2 3223 2J2D=723GH324253657
/8653!9546</=;/4324253657 /$ 393 D2;7695:H 5/7 G953 712 C:69579448 12 ;96: /=;7
- 15 -
I68 E=8794923 95 32D;2295> 712 8=97 653 32D:6;95> 7167 712 86:232232J2D=723GH324253657
/8653!9546</=;/4 324253657
/$3935/7G953712;9>178797:26539572;287/4 712C:69579448957128=978D123=:2C;/C2;7928
! 8 ;2>6;38 712 D/572579/5 /4 712 C:69579448 7167 712 ;96: /=;7 D/FF97723 65 2;;/; 95 658I2;95> 88=2 /8!
653 6>69587 712 C:69579448 653 7129; C;6H2; 7/ F/394H 712 E=3>F257 653 32D;22 GH 2J2;D9895> C/I2; =532;;32;=:2$$/4712(I26;2/4712/C959/5 7167 712 ;96: /=;7 16<95> 12:3 7167 712 C:69579448 163 C;/<23 7129; 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 81/=:3 5/7 16<2 I97112:3 9782:4 95 1/:395> 7167 712 C:69579448 393 5/7 C;/<2 7129; C/882889/5 95 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 8 ;9>17:H D/5725323 GH 712 :26;523 D/=582: 4/; 712 C:69579448 95 ;28C2D7/4<6D6576>;9D=:7=;6::65371249;87C;95D9C:2/4:6I 98 7167 C/882889/5 4/::/I8 797:2 "125 712 C:69579448 16<2 C;/<23 :6I4=: 797:2 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 712H I2;2 5/7
- 16 -
2JC2D723 7/ C;/3=D2 65H /712; F672;96: 7/ 2876G:981 7167 7129;C;232D288/; F7 16;36FF6I6895C/882889/5
$ ;32; P =:2 $$ /4 ( 98 712 ;2C/897/;H /4 C/I2;8 /4 65 6CC2::672 /=;7 7/ 3/ E=879D2 G27I225 712 C6;7928 GH C68895> 6 E=3>F257 7167 98 6C7 G6823 /5 712 46D78653D9;D=F8765D28/4712D6826537122<9325D2:23 95GH712C6;7928E=3>F257I19D1982;;/52/=8/546D78 653:6ID655/7G26::/I237/;2F695/5:H/5712>;/=53 7167 712 C6;7H 6442D723 GH 8=D1 E=3>F257 168 5/7 6CC26:2375/I522385/;2972;679/57167656CC26:986 D/5795=679/5/47128=976537126CC2::672/=;71686::712 C/I2;8/46;96:/=;7954;6F95>65988=263395>C6;7928 76K95> 2<9325D2 988=95> D/FF9889/58 27D 5D2 712 6CC26: 98 63F97723 712 D682 32D9323 GH 712;96:/=;7 98 /C254/;8D;=795H8/687/C6886E=87E=3>F2579571246D78 653D9;D=F8765D28/4712D68212;24/;2712;96:/=;7 16<95>/5D2 12:37167 712C:69579448 163 C;/<23 7129;797:2 D/=:35/716<2658I2;23988=2
/!6>69587712C:69579448
- 17 -
86F6772;/446D7712;2<25=2;2D/;3895712 4/;F/4J(68I2::68712;2<25=2257;92868C2;J( 7/J( 2876G:9817167 F7 16;36FF6I68712/I52;
95 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 79:: 712 H26;8 %% %%- 653 %%%%% /5I6;38 95 ;28C2D7 /4 =;<2H /8!%653!57126G825D2/465HF672;96:7/81/I 7167 F7 16;36FF6 163 D/5<2H23 /; 7;65842;;23 712 8=97 C;/C2;7928 7/ 324253657
/ 95 6 F6552; K5/I5 7/ :6I6F2;2D165>295712;2<25=2257;928D655/732C;9<2 12; /4 C/882889/5 /4 712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 7 6:8/ 3935/7D/542;797:2/5712324253657
/ 5 7167 <92I /4 712 F6772; 712 E=3>F257 653 32D;22 /4 712 ;96: /=;7 ;24=895> 712 ;2:924 /4 C2;C27=6:
95E=5D79/5 I6;;6578 9572;42;25D2 DD/;395>:H 712 6CC26:
49:23 GH 712 3242536578 98 /I2<2; 712 E=3>F25765332D;22/4712;96:/=;798F/39492365395 633979/5 7/ 712 32D:6;679/5 /4 797:2 /4 C:69579448 7/ 712 8=97 C;/C2;7H 6 32D;22 /4 C2;C27=6: 95E=5D79/5 98 >;65723 653 3242536578 6;2 ;287;69523 4;/F 9572;42;95> I971 712
- 18 -
C26D24=:C/882889/565325E/HF257/4712C:6957944895712 8=97 8D123=:2 C;/C2;7928 7 98 /C25 4/; 712 C:69579448 7/ I/;K /=7 712 ;2F23H 7/ >27 7129; 56F28 ;287/;23 95 712 ;2<25=2;2D/;38G6823/571232D;22C68823GH712;96: /=;76537198/=;7
- 449D2 98 39;2D723 7/ 3;6I 6 32D;22 95 72;F8 /4 7198E=3>F257 )& %'
)& %$'
& 987
/ :
/!