- 1 - ! "# # $%& $'() &$( * ! " ! # # $ # %&'&() " ! # &'# $! ' # ! * $ &' # ( * (& ( # ! # ## '+ # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,! # * '' ## # # $ - - . /012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ </:=:=52/17 ;07 9=8/3 0 >/>5 7//?=2@ :5 A=:;310A :;/ </:=:=52 =2 1/7</4: 59 </:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 5 ;/>/>5=7:0?/2521/4513 2B=/A59:;/0,5B/:;/</:=:=520@0=27:</:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 5=73=7>=77/307A=:;310A2 ) ! # ;=7</:=:=52=79=8/3623/1/4:=52&'59;010:=C0 0@01=?610?7;002;=:0(7//?=2@:5D607;<154//3=2@7 0@0=27:</:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 5=2 5 (& 01=7=2@ 56: 59 1=>/ 5 (! 1/@=7:/1/3 ,C :;/ ?080?/1= 58=4/ - 3 - :0:=52 =E0C0<610</23=2@52:;/9=8/59338=B=863@/023 #=23@=951:;/599/24/7<62=7;0,8/623/17/4:=527'+59 023 ,! 59 23=02 F<857=B/7 6,7:024/7 4: '' 951 7;51:G:;/4:H! & ;/0,1=3@/3904:759:;/407/01/:;0::;/59 080?/1= 58=4/ :0:=52 =/ 45><80=202: 1/4/=B/3 0 41/3=,8/ =2951>0:=52 :;0: =2 0 104:51 023 10=8/1 :;/ /F<857=B/7 8=?/ </F <5A/1 ( % :A5 /:520:51 967/! A07 =88/@088C 7:51/3 =2 513/1 :5 3=@ 0 5</2 A/88 =2 :;/ 8023 59 52/ >/7;@5630 5330>02= A=:;=2 :;/ 8=>=:7 59 02308 B=880@/ ;/1/09:/1 452364:/3 0 10=3 0852@ A=:; :;/ <024;07 ;/ 45><80=202:95623:;0:0:104:51023:10=8/1A/1/<01?/3=2:;/ 9=/8359>/7;@56305330>02=0232/01:;/:104:5104467/3 5 =/ 5,6 ;0B02 A07 7:023=2@ 023 <577/77=2@ 7/B/108 /F<857=B/7 =/ * %! & * &@ * '>>3=0F)'?@*%% /:520:51 <67/! 023 * %% /:520:51 67/! ;/1/09:/1 52 /2D6=1C04467/3 57:0:/3:;0:;/;03<614;07/3:;/70>/ 915> </:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 5 A=:;56: 02C 8=4/24/ 7 764; :;/ 45><80=202: 7/=I/3 :;/ /F<857=B/7 623/1 0 - 4 - <024;020>0 023 011/7:/3 04467/3 5 07/3 52 ;=7 B5862:01C 7:0:/>/2: </:=:=52/1 5 0875 =><8=40:/3 =2 :;/ 41=>/ 6,7/D6/2:8C 1/7<523/2: 5 % <58=4/ 452364:/3 :;/ =2B/7:=@0:=5202380=34;01@/7;//:0@0=27:04467/3 57023 951:;/0951/>/2:=52/3599/24/7;/8/012/30@=7:10:/:55? 45@2=I024/59:;/599/24/7/24/0@@1=/B/3,C:;/70>/:;/ </:=:=52/179=8/3:;=7</:=:=52:5D607;:;/<154//3=2@7 + /013 8/012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ </:=:=52/17 023 :;/ 8/012/3 =@; 561: 5B/12>/2: 8/03/1 951 :;/ 1/7<523/2:%:0:/ ) <01: 915> 61@=2@ 7/B/108 452:/2:=527 8/012/3 45627/8951</:=:=52/1 5;07452:/23/3:;0:</:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 25 =><8=40:/3 =2 :;/ 41=>/ 758/8C ,07/3 52 :;/ B5862:01C7:0:/>/2:5904467/3 5/0875452:/23/3:;0: </:=:=52/1 5 A07 0 8=4/27/3 7/88/1 59 /F<857=B/7 C <804=2@ :;/8=4/27/;/76,>=::/3:;0:3/7<=:/<577/77=2@B08=38=4/27/ 023 A=:;56: =776=2@ 02C 7;5A 4067/ 25:=4/ 07 452:/><80:/3 623/1:;/4:</:=:=52/1 5A07=><8=40:/3=2:;/41=>// 0875 452:/23/3 :;0: 4;01@/ 7;//: A;=4; A07 9=8/3 0@0=27: </:=:=52/1 5 =7 A=:;56: 02C 764; 7024:=52 07 452:/><80:/3 - 5 - 623/1 :;/ <15B=7=52 59 /4:=52 ) 951 :;/ 599/24/7 <62=7;0,8/ 623/1/4:=527&023+59:;/4:''44513=2@8C;/ <10C7:50885A:;/</:=:=52 ' 8/012/3=@;561:5B/12>/2:8/03/1 0<</01=2@9511/7<523/2: 5%:0:/5<<57/3:;/</:=:=52 ;0B/@=B/2>C02F=5674527=3/10:=52,5:;52:;/ 76,>=77=527 >03/ ,C :;/ 8/012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ 1/7</4:=B/ <01:=/7023</167/3:;/3546>/2:7>03/0B0=80,8/521/4513 ( 7 45683 ,/ @0:;/1/3 915> 1/45137 ,07/3 52 :;/ 41/3=,8/ =2951>0:=52 :;/ 452364:/3 0 10=3 52 :;/ 9=/83 59 >/7;@56305330>02=A;/1/7;/9562304467/3 50852@ A=:;:;//F<857=B/77:0:/3 2/2D6=1C;/1/B/08/3:;0: :;/ 70>/ A07 <614;07/3 915> </:=:=52/1 5 ;/ 8/012/3 45627/8 951 </:=:=52/1 5 <804/3 :;/ 8=4/27/ 5,:0=2/3 ,C </:=:=52/1 5 951 76<<8C 59 :;/ /F<857=B/7 023 :;/ 70>/ 3/<=4:7 :;0: :;/ 70=3 8=4/24/ =7 B08=3 915> '((+ :5 ((' B/2 5:;/1A=7/ 07 1=@;:8C 452:/2:/3 ,C :;/ 8/012/3 45627/8 951 </:=:=52/1 5 /F4/<: :;/ B5862:01C 7:0:/>/2: 59 04467/3 5 0,7586:/8C 25 5:;/1 >0:/1=087 01/ <804/3 0@0=27: </:=:=52/1 5 :5 76,7:02:=0:/ :;0: 04467/3 - 6 - 5<614;07/3:;/70>/915></:=:=52/1 551/5B/1:;/ 45%513=20:/ ,/24; 59 :;=7 561: =2 1=>=208 /:=:=52 5((( (& ;/83 :;0: A=:;56: 5,:0=2=2@ 0 B08=3 7024:=52 915>:;/=7:1=4:0@=7:10:/ /<6:C5>>=77=52/1:;/4;01@/ 7;//:40225:,/1/@=7:/1/30@0=27:02C</1752951:;/599/24/7 623/1:;/<15B=7=52759&023+59:;/4:''2:;/ 407/52;02325764;7024:=52513/1;07,//25,:0=2/3,/951/ 9=8=2@:;/4;01@/7;//:0@0=27:</:=:=52/1 5 25B/1088</1670859:;/>0:/1=087521/45130> 59 :;/ 4527=3/1/3 B=/A :;0: 452:=260:=52 59 :;/ 41=>=208 <154//3=2@70@0=27:</:=:=52/1 5=748/010,67/59<154/7759 561: 7=24/ :;/ 70>/ =7 >02=9/7:8C 91=B58567 B/F0:=567 023 =27:=:6:/3A=:;:;/68:/1=51>5:=B/951A1/4?=2@B/2@/024/;/ /2:=1/ 088/@0:=52 =2 :;/ # 023 4;01@/ 7;//: 044/<:/3 52 =:7 904/B086//B/2:;/2:;/70>/3525: 4527:=:6:/ 02 599/24/7 4;01@/ 7;//:/3 0@0=27: </:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 544513=2@8C<154//3:5<077:;/95885A=2@J = ;/ </:=:=52 0@0=27: </:=:=52/1 5 =7 - 7 - == ;/</:=:=520@0=27:</:=:=52/1 5=7 === ;/ <154//3=2@7 0@0=27: </:=:=52/1 5 04467/3 5 =2 5 (& 01=7=2@ 56:591=>/ 5 (!1/@=7:/1/3,C080?/1= 58=4/ :0:=52 =E0C<610 951 :;/ 599/24/7 <62=7;0,8/ 623/1 7/4:=527 '+ 59 023 ,! 59 23=02 F<857=B/7 6,7:024/7 4: '' <1/7/2:8C</23=2@52:;/9=8/591=24=<08=7:1=4: 023 /77=527 63@/ 0: 080,610@= =7 ;/1/,C D607;/3 +) $ ( =7: 5-8 5-)