- 1 - ! " # # $% $&'( %$' ) !!" # $%&%' ( $%&%' %' $%&%""' ( ) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & % & * '% ' " +, -&& % ' ' # #* . . /## 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 % & 68 0,<,51>, ,?,<1@ ;<,@20, ,7015, ' " 244@17? 56 A;,20 504 3<6=44:17?2 ,?,1725 504 345151674< ,==;24: 17 39,24 6'% ' " <1B4 6% ' ' <4?1254<4: C> 6@,>;@5, 691=4 1:,< 347:17? 67 504 8194 68 <9 125<1=5 ,7: 4221672 #;:?41:,<86<50468847=43;7120,C94;7:4<24=5167+,68 <4D475167 68 6<<;35167 =5 -&& B47:B475 '& 86< 206<5E504=5F 04 ,C<1:?4: 8,=52 68 504 =,24 ,<4 50,5 504 =6B39,17,75G2 H184!BC1@, 12 ,7 7?,7,H,:1 H6<@4< ,5 4450,9,?4<4199,?4 ;B7,C,:,9;@8<6B9,25'>4,<204 - 3 - <4A;4254: 504 019: 4D4963B475 <6I4=5 881=4< 86< 206<5 E F ;B7,C,: 56 5<,7284< 04< 56 504 D,=,75 3625 68 7?,7,H,:1 475<4 6'' 04 2,1: <4A;425 94554< H,2 2;CB1554: 56 674 ,551 06C0, 14 345151674< ,==;24: H06 H,2 H6<@17? ,2 C486<4 504 6B47 ,7: 019: 498,<4 43,<5B475 ,5 ;B7,C,: 1:,< 125<1=5 ,54< 504 H184 68 =6B39,17,75 34<267,99> ,33<6,=04: 504 345151674< ,7: ,5 50,5 51B4 204 :4B,7:4: , 2;B 68 2%'''' ! 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 56?4504<H6<@:67422;=0504=6B39,17,75,33<6,=04:504 691=4 ,7: 1786<B4: 504 2,B4 04<4,854< <42367:475 6! 691=4,:D124:504=6B39,17,75G2H18456<4=6<:504=67D4<2,5167 C45H44704<,7:504345151674<==6<:17?9>504>0,7:4:6D4< , D61=4 <4=6<:4< ,54< 504 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 B45 504 345151674< !" 51B42 17 04< 6881=4 06H4D4< 504 345151674< =6725,759>:4B,7:4:2%'''' !,2,C<1C404=6B39,17,75G2 H184 17!5;<7 1786<B4: 504 2,B4 56 504 691=4 ,2 2;=0) <42367:475 6!691=4 <4=41D4: 504 =6B39,175 68 504 =6B39,17,75,7:<4?1254<4:504=,2417<1B46% ' '86<504 68847=4 3;7120,C94 ;7:4< 4=5167 +, 68 =5 04<4,854< 67'% ' '<42367:4756!691=4=67:;=54:475<;25B475 3,7=0,7,B,,7:504<4,854<=67:;=54:504<,1:565046881=468 - 4 - 504 345151674< H0194 204 <4=41D17? 2"'''' ! ,2 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 8<6B 504 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 ;C24A;4759> <42367:475 6!691=4 =67:;=54: , 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, ,7: =,;?05 069: 504 ,==;24: ,7: 241J4: 504 5,1754: B674> 8<6B 04< ;<2;,759> 6@,>;@5, 6881=1,92 H,204: 504 0,7:2 68 504 ,==;24: H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696< H01=0 D4<> B;=0 47D12,?4250,5,==;24:0,:,==4354:504C<1C4,B6;75,234< 04< :4B,7: 04<4,854< 504 691=4 ,926 241J4: 504 <4=6<:2 34<5,1717?565045<,7284<68=6B39,17,75G2H184H01=0H,2@435 C> 504 345151674< 17 , H,<:<6C4 17 504 6881=4 ,5 1:,< ,7: 3<6:;=4: 504 345151674< C486<4 504 94,<74: 34=1,9 #;:?4 ,7: 504<4C>247556I;:1=1,9=;256:>854<=6B394517?17D4251?,5167 <42367:4756!691=49,1:=0,<?420445,?,1725504345151674< 86<504,86<4B4751674:68847=4,7:50494,<74:,?125<,54566@ =6?71J,7=46850468847=4 47=4501234515167 " 4,<: 504 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< ,7: 94,<74:34=1,9=6;724986<<42367:475606;?07651=412 24<D4:56<42367:4756 04<4B,174:,C2475 3,<5 8<6B ;<?17? 24D4<,9 =6754751672 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< =67547:4: 50,5 67 34<;2,9 68 504 - 5 - =0,<?420445B,54<1,927668847=40,2C447B,:46;5,?,1725 504 345151674< ;7:4< 4=5167 +, 68 504 =5 217=4 504 3<624=;5167 8,194: 56 39,=4 B,54<1,92 56 3<6D4 504 17?<4:147526850468847=414,:4B,7:C,==435,7=4,7: =H6<@475<;25B4756<H6<@347:17?==6<:17?5601B,576 36175 68 51B4 504 345151674< 0,2 :4B,7:4: 504 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 ,7: 504 =67D4<2,5167 ,994?4:9> <4=6<:4: C> 504 =6B39,17,75 :642 765 :12=9624 2;=0 =67D4<2,5167 ,2 25,54: 17 504 5<,3 B,0,J,< C> 504 7D4251?,5167 881=4< ,7: 504 3,7=0 H157422 4 8;<504< =67547:4: 50,5 504 5,1754: B674> H,2 ,994?4:9><4=6D4<4:8<6B5045,C9468504345151674<06;?0504 0,7:268504345151674<H4<4H,204:H1506:1;BC1=,<C67,54 269;5167 504 2,B4 :1: 765 5;<7 1756 317@ =696< ,2 <4A;1<4: ;<504<504<4H,276H6<@68=6B39,17,75G2H184475<;254:56 504 ,==;24: :;<17? 5<,3 ,7: 504 <4=6<:2 H4<4 241J4: 8<6B , :1884<475 6881=4 7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4 504 3<624=;5167 ;554<9> 8,194: 56 39,=4 B,54<1,92 56 3<6D4 504 :4B,7: ,==435,7=4,7:H6<@347:47=>C>504,==;24: % 4,926=67547:4:50,5504<412,7176<:17,54:49,> 68-:,>21796:?17?504=6B39,175C>504=6B39,17,75234< 504 245594: 36215167 68 9,H 504 =6B39,175 0,2 56 C4 96:?4: - 6 - H15017 + :,>2 8<6B 504 :,54 68 :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 ,7:504=6B39,1750,256C4A;,204:,9674H1505012?<6;7: 4 ,926=67547:4:50,54D4718504,994?,51672B,:417504,7 =0,<?420445,<45,@47,55041<8,=4D,9;4,7:,==4354:175041< 4751<45> 504 2,B4 :6 765 =672515;54 ,7> 68847=4 ,?,1725 504 ,==;24: 6 C;55<422 012 ,<?;B4752 04 <4914: 67 504I;:?B475268504 67GC9434K6;<5,7:5046!6<:17,54 47=06850126;<5,2;7:4<. 1 <96%' ' " :,54: ' ' <1 ,7I;7,50, D2 5,54 C> 6@,>;@5, 691=4 ,7:76504< 11 <96 '"+ ' :,54: ' ' <1 ,I; D2 5,54 68 ,<7,5,@, ,7: 76504< 111 <96'' ' :,54: &' ' % 6B,<,I;D25,54687:0<,<,:420 1D ,913 17?0 D2 5,54 68 ,7: 504<2 <436<54:17 '' ==6<:17?9>043<,>256,996H50434515167 94,<74: 34=1,9 =6;7249 ,334,<17? 86< <42367:4756633624:50434515167C>=67547:17?50,5504<4 12 , =94,< :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167C> 504 345151674< ,7: 5042,B412<4=6<:4:17,D61=4<4=6<:4<,7:504=67D4<2,5167 - 7 - C45H447504345151674<,7:=6B39,17,75G2H18486;7:175043<4! 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, 04 2,B4 :431=52 50,5 504 345151674< :4B,7:4:5041994?,9?<,5181=,516786<5<,7284<68=6B39,17,75G2 H184 4 ,926 =67547:4: 50,5 504 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, 8;<504< :431=5250,5C486<4504<,1:,7475<;25B4753,7=0,7,B,H,2 =67:;=54: ,7: 3047693050,9417 36H:4< H,2 ,33914: 56 504 =;<<47=>76542,7:0,7:4:6D4<56504H18468504=6B39,17,75 ,7: 50624 =;<<47=> 76542 H4<4 <4=41D4: C> 504 ,==;24: 504 2,B4 H,2 241J4: C> 504 6@,>;@5,!691=4 ,7: 0,7:2 68 504 ,==;24: H4<4 H,204: H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696< 7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4,==435,7=468504C<1C412,9263<6D4:;<504< 5045<,7284<,3391=,516768504H18468=6B39,17,75H,2@435C> 504345151674<175046881=46850443;5>1<4=56<6B47,7: 019: 498,<4 43,<5B475 1:,< 7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4 15 =,7765C42,1:50,5504345151674<0,2B,:46;5, =,2456A;,205043<6=44:17?2==6<:17?9>043<,>256:12B122 50434515167 + 0,D4?1D47B>,7K16;2=6721:4<,5167C65067504 2;CB1221672 B,:4 C> 504 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51D4 3,<5142,7:34<;24:504:6=;B4752B,:4,D,19,C94C486<45012 6;<5 - 8 - & 7 34<;2,9 68 504 =6B39,175 ,7: 504 =0,<?4 20445 B,54<1,9215=6;9:C4?,504<4:50,5504=6B39,17596:?4:C>504 =6B39,17,75 86< :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 68 2%'''' ! C>504345151674<H06H,2504 ,5 ;B7,C,:86<5<,7284< 68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 8<6B 7?,7,H,:1 475<4 6+& 56 7?,7,H,:1 475<4 6'' ,5 ;B7,C,: 04 =0,<?4 20445 3,34<<4D4,9250,5504:4B,7:B,:4C>504,==;24: 345151674< 0,D17? C447 <4=6<:4: 17 , D61=4 <4=6<:4< ,7: 50624 =67D4<2,51672 86;7: 17 504 3<4!5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, 7 =,<48;9 34<;2,9685042,B4504<412,=94,<:4B,7:682"'''' !C> 504345151674<,2,:D,7=4C486<45045<,7284<68=6B39,17,75G2 H184;<504<175045<,33,7=0,7,B,1512=94,<9>25,54:50,5 17 504 3<4247=4 68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 =6B39,17,75 3,7=0,2 ,7:504691=46881=1,92504345151674<=,;?05069:<4:0,7:4: ,7:,2;B682"'''' !H,2<4=6D4<4:,504<1725,7=4,967? H150 504 =04B1=,9 ,33914: =;<<47=> 76542 0,7:4: 6D4< 56 504 =6B39,17,75G2H184:;<17?3<4!5<,33,7=0,7,B,;C24A;4759> 5040,7:268345151674<H4<4H,204:H1506:1;BC1=,<C67,54 91A;1: H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696< 2 2;=0 15 <4D4,9250,5504345151674<,==4354:504C<1C4,B6;758<6B504 =6B39,17,75G2H184 - 9 - - 6 :6;C5 504 <4=6<:2 34<5,1717? 56 5<,7284< 68 =6B39,17,75G2H184H4<4765175046881=468345151674<06H4D4< 5045<,33,7=0,7,B,:12=9624250,550624<4=6<:2H4<4@435C> 504345151674<175046881=46843;5>1<4=56<6B47,7:019: 4D4963B475 43,<5B475 1:,< 17 , H,<:<6C4 ,7: 504 2,B4 H,2241J4:,55041725,7=468345151674<72;=0=1<=;B25,7=4 ,2 <1?059> =67547:4: C> 504 94,<74: 34=1,9 =6;7249 86< 504 <42367:475!5,54504<4,<42;881=1475 B,54<1,92,<4 39,=4: ,?,1725 504 345151674< ,C6;5 04< 17D69D4B475 17 504 =<1B4 ' 06;?0 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< D404B4759> =67547:4: 50,5 504<4 12 , :49,> 17 81917? 504 =6B39,175,234<4=5167+,68504=5504<4127651B4 91B15 86< 81917? 504 =6B39,175 04 :49,> 17 81917? 504 17 ,==6<:,7=4H1504=5167& 68504=512765<494D,75 56 5012 =,24 ,2 4=5167 & 12 86< 3;C91= 24<D,75 56 96:?4 , =6B39,175,?,172550434<267H0617:;=425043;C91=24<D,7556 ,==4351994?,9?<,5181=,5167=6BB679>@76H7,2E<4D4<245<,3F 04 67GC94 34K 17 504 =,24 68 !"##$ # %"##$ - 10 - 049:50,517,=,24<4?1254<4:504234=1,925,5;5414=5 , A;,2017? 68 504 68847=42 ;7:4< 504 2,1: ,=5 H6;9: 0,D4 , ?<,D4,7:2;C25,751,91B3,=5765I;25675043,<514217D69D4: C;5,9266750426=145>,59,<?4 ;<504< 504 67/C94 ;3<4B4 6;<5 17 =,24 68 & ' ()* <436<54:17#+$+,049:173,<,?<,3062&,7: -,286996H2. ! " # $ " #! % $ &' !# &' # $ &' % " $ $ $ !# % ( ! # ! # $ # - 11 - # ! $ !) # ! * # $ # ! ! % +, , # , + & !# ! !# ' - ! #" % ! $ ! % $ " $ $ % $ % * # % $ % # $ " $ $ - 12 - % # % " $ % , ! . $ ,! ! # % - $ , - ! $ , $ / ! # ! 00 * $# $ ! # # , ! $ $ $ ! ! $ ! ! !#! - 13 - ) # $ $ ## ! ! $ # 1 $ ! ! % ,! ! ! & 23 4# 50667 89: ;!$&4'# < *"; &06=' 0' " $ ! ! $$ # $ $ # ! $ , " $ $ $ - ! ! $ - 14 - " ! # ! # ! ! , $ # $ $ ,! ! & 2 4/ # ; > 506697== <# *"; &066=' 896 ; 4 <%% # > ! ?5066:7=06 > # 1 > *"; &0666' 09 @ #1 5066=7A A9: ; > # B > < 5066A7 86A # > # &?# ( 4 *"; &066=' 68 ;% <%% # ( 4 5066678:6' 0 " $ # ! ! $ ! / $ - ! - 15 - % $ # ! ! $ $ ! ! ! C # $ # , # # ! " 4& '#3D1 50667880A $ # $ , $ # $ $ $ $ $ # $ ! # +& ' - 16 - 6 $# E$ / $ $ ! ! $ $ # F 75041725,75=,24,2:12=;224:2;3<,5043<1B,<> 17?<4:147526850468847=4;7:4<4=5167+,68504=512 B,:46;5C>5043<624=;5167,7:5042,B40,256C454254:17 , :45,194: 5<1,9 012 6;<5 =,7765 =67:;=5 , B171 5<1,9 ,5 5012 25,?4 56 069: 50,5 H04504< 504 ,==;2,5167 B,:4 ,?,1725 345151674< H199 3<6D4 6< 765 7 ,7 4751<4 34<;2,9 68 =0,<?4 20445B,54<1,92,B68504D14H50,5=67517;,516768=<1B17,9 3<6=44:17?2 ,?,1725 504 345151674< ,==;24: H199 765 ,B6;75 56 ,C;24683<6=422686;<5 47=4345151679,=@2B4<15,7:504 2,B412* *( $ ' 1256.96."'