- 1 - ! ""# $%&! !" '(!) !! ! !! ! " ! # $ !! %# & ' $ # Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ ())) # # & $ ' ())) ! # ) ) $$ ) ( # $$ ) " $$ ) $ " - 3 - * $ %# & " $ ! + # $ $ )))( *# ' # $ ( $ $ # ' $ $ , # ## () )()! $ # # - , # # $ $ "' $ $ $ # ## () )()! # ' $ # $ # # $ *.. $ , )**( ) )** . *. $ " )!) ) ) ))) $" # $ # /"# # - 4 - 012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674=2 244>17? 504 86996@17?=491482 !"#$$%$$ &"'%#$%$( ) *+,- . - / ! . ! !"#$$%$$ & "'%#$%$( . -!0.+ 1 -! ! 23 240 ! ! ! 3 " 5 ! -! ! . 03 & $"677 8 "'""" 9 :-! 8 1 2 3 %"6'+6#- & %)%;"66' 03 & ;;7 03 & ;67 <. : 1/ 123 %($%""+"$ 23 %)$%""+"$. &$%+"%+$%""- / ! ! !! ! != 512ABA246894A=74:B6C724950A5345151674=2 A=4 17 34AB48C9 3622422167 BC951DA5167 A7: 47E6<F475 68 504 9A7: ;4A=17? C=D4< 6. F4A2C=17? ?C75A2 C=D4< 6*.. F4A2C=17? ! AB=42 A7: ( - 5 - ?C75A2 ;650 215CA54: A5 17?A7A>0A7A 6::1 199A?4 4=?4=A6;91GA7:125A1B0C=A7:A?=1BC95C=A99A7:2 ;4A=17?C=D4< 6. F4A2C=17?AB=42?C75A2 C=D4< 6* F4A2C=17? AB=42 !( ?C75A2 ;650 215CA54: A5 "AF;A9A:1771 199A?4 4=?4=A 6;91 G A7: 125A1B0C= 7504?=6C7:50A55042A1:3=634=5142A=4 A7B425=A9 3=634=5142 68 345151674=2 04=417 A7: 674 =F19A 4D1 :AC?054= 68 345151674= 6 A7: 21254= 68 345151674= 62 A7: ! @06 :14: 17 504 <4A= )) 94AD17? ;4017: 04=F6504=345151674= 6A2A94?A9041=5125048C=504= B675475167 68 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674=2 12 50A5 A854=504:4A5068674 A=A21F0A4::<26 A=A21F0A 4::<17504<4A=**@06125040C2;A7:68345151674= 6 A7: 8A504= 68 345151674= 62 A7: ! ;A24: 67 504 @199 :A54: ))!** 4H4BC54: ;< 01F 504 9A7:2 68 17?A7A>0A7A 6::1 199A?4 ?65 FC5A54: 17 504 7AF4 68 345151674=2 D1:4 6**( :A54: ) )** A7: 7AF42 68 504 345151674=2 @4=4 8C=504= B6==4B54: A7: 4754=4: 17 504 2 04=4A854= 504 7AF4 68 504 - 6 - 345151674= 6@A2FC5A54:17504=4D47C4=4B6=:2512 8C=504= B67547:4: 50A5 674 AD15=AFFA :AC?054= 68 A=A<A7A4::<=421:17?17A1B0C=@063A224:A@A<67 ))) A5 C7EA7A0A991 199A?4 A1B0C= :123C54: 504 9A7:2 68 C=D4< 6 ! A7: ( 68 4=?4=A 199A?4 G A7:125A1B0C=A7:?65504FFC5A54:A7:A9147A54:504 2AF4175047AF468674AFAB0A7:=A4::<47B4 345151674=2A33=6AB04:504 ::15167A94716=1D19"C:?4 A5 A1B0C= 17 6 )*))*A7: 6;5A174: AEC:?F475 A7::4B=44175041=8AD6C=;A24:67504@199 ! 5128C=504=B67547:4:50A567!)*504 A7: =1;C7A9 A1B0C= B67:CB54: 3=6B44:17?2 =49A517? 56 8AF19< 3=634=5142 68 345151674=/2 8A504= A7: 8A504=/2 ;=6504=2$C=504=B6754751672A=4=A124:@150=4?A=:56674 AD15=AFFA@06122A1:560AD48194:A76504=A3391BA5167 ;486=4 22125A75 6FF1221674= A1B0C= 86= FC5A5167 68 504 9A7: =4B6=:2 17 C=D4< 6* 17?A7A>0A7A 6::1 C=D4< 6 * 68 "AF;A9A:1771 199A?4 G A7: 125 A1B0C= 42367:475 6 22125A75 6FF1221674= - 7 - 3A224:A76=:4=C7:4=4B5167!(&'68A=7A5A>AA7: 4D47C4 B5 *( &04=417A854= =484==4: 56 A2 I504 B5J' @1506C5 122C17? 7651B4 56 504 345151674= 62 56 ! A==A<17? 345151674= 6! @150 :4B4158C9 7AF4 17 6=:4= 56 :43=1D4 01F 56 24=D4 7651B4 68 504 3=6B44:17?2 42367:475 6 A854= 504 :4A50 68 AD15=AFFA 3A224: 504 4==6746C2 6=:4= :A54: *) 67 504 8194 6 # ) A7: =42367:475 6 0A2 1F394F4754:5042AF450=6C?0FC5A5167475=142042A1: 1F3C?74: 6=:4= A7: 2C;24GC475 6=:4=2 @4=4 GCA204: ;< 66=:17A54 47B0 68 5012 6C=5 D1:4 6=:4= :A54: ))() A7: )() A7: =4FA7:4: 504 FA554= ;AB>56504=42367:475 6 56;=17?94?A9=43=42475A51D42 689A54AD15=AFA67=4B6=:A7:3A22A33=63=1A546=:4=25 128C=504=B67547:4:50A5A854=504=4FA7:504345151674=2 0AD424=D4:504B63<685046=:4=56=42367:475 6!56 1F394F4755042AF450=6C?0I6C=56:C94J 5 12 B67547:4: 50A5 =42367:475 6 17 :481A7B4 A7: 767B6F391A7B4 68 504 6=:4= 68 5012 6C=5 - 8 - @1506C5 ;=17?17? 504 94?A9 =43=42475A51D42 68 :4B4A24: 345151674=67=4B6=:3C=2CA7556504A3391BA5167FA:4;< A 501=: 3A=5< + 25A=54: 8=420 3=6B44:17?2 17 =4234B5685042C;E4B53=634=5142685046=:4=3A224:17# 6)() 04 345151674=2 04=417 A=4 GC42516717? 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 504 =42367:475 6 22125A75 6FF1221674=D1:4 =:4=:A54:)()!A5 774HC=4 A7: ;< FA>17? 24D4=A9 6504= 2C;F1221672 A7: B6754751672 A2 3C5 86=50 17 504 34515167 244>17? 56 245 A21:45046=:4=A7:86=AFA7:AFC256=4256=45044A=914= 475=142FA:4175047AF468504345151674=2 > ! 94A=74: ::15167A9 6D4=7F475 :D6BA54 =43=4247517? 504 =42367:47525A54 D404F4759< B67547:2 50A5 504 3=42475 34515167 12 765 FA175A17A;94 741504= @6C9: 15 ;4 2C25A17A;94 17 D14@ 68 504=4;417? A7 A954=7A51D4 4881BAB16C2 =4F4:< A2 34= 4B5167 !( &!' 68 504 B5 ( 4A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 3=1DA54 =42367:4752 A926 FA>42 A 21F19A= 2C;F122167 B67547:17? 50A5 5012 - 9 - 34515167@6C9:7652C=D1D486=B6721:4=A5167;65067F4=152 A7: 67 9A@ 17 D14@ 68 504 8AB5 50A5 504 6=:4= 50A5 12 GC4251674: 68 504 22125A75 6FF1221674==42367:475 6 A=1242 6C5 68 4B5167 !( &' 68 504 B5 04=486=4 504 345151674=2 @6C9: 0AD4 56 A33=6AB0 504 A33=63=1A54 86=CF 56 B0A9947?4 504 6=:4= 68 504 22125A75 6FF1221674=@01B012GC4251674:04=417A5 774HC=4 0AD4 04A=: 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674=2 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 3=1DA54 =42367:4752 A7: 504 94A=74: ::15167A9 6D4=7F475 :D6BA54 86= 504 5A54 33A=4759< 15 12 765 17 :123C54 50A5 504 B0A9947?4 17 504 3=42475 @=15 34515167 12 56 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 504 22125A75 6FF1221674==42367:475 6 3A224:C7:4=4B5167!(&'68504 B5047A7<6=:4= 12 3A224: C7:4= 4B5167 !( &' 68 504 B5 504=4 12 A7 3=6D1216768=4D12167A?A17255042A1:6=:4=C7:4=4B5167 !( &!' 68 504 B5 5 @6C9: ;4 =494DA75 56 4H5=AB5 504 3=6D121672684B5167!(68504 B5@01B0=4A:2A2C7:4= - 10 - "(# +?"@ 1 : ! ?$@ ! . .+! ?)@ ! .+ ! ?#@ 0! "$6 - * ! ! ! - ! ! . !. . 0 A 1 . ! . ?(@ - ! - ! * ! 0! "$5 0! "$6! & > 1 . *! . 1 ! .! = * 04 345151674=0AD17?765 B0A9947?4:5046=:4= 68 504 22125A75 6FF1221674= ;486=4 504 43C5< 6FF1221674= A7: 0AD17? 8194: 504 3=42475 34515167 17D6>17?504@=15EC=12:1B5167C7:4= =51B942(A7:68 504 672515C5167 68 7:1A 504 2AF4 @6C9: 765 ;4 FA175A17A;94 A2 04 @6C9: 0AD4 56 A33=6AB0 504 43C5< 6FF1221674= C7:4= 4B5167 !(&!' 68 504 B5 ;486=4 - 11 - A33=6AB017?50126C=504:4B12167685048C99;=A7B068 50126C=517504BA2468 =436=54:17 :4A92 @15050436@4=2685044D12167A96C=5C7:4=4B5167!( &!' 68 504 B5 04 2AF4 @6C9: ;4 A3391BA;94 17 504 3=42475BA24670A7: ) 04=486=4 :6 765 817: A7< ?66: ?=6C7: 6= B6?475 =4A267 56 1754=84=4 17 504 3=42475 BA24 A2 504 345151674=2@6C9:0AD456;4=494?A54:56504A33=63=1A54 86=CF56B0A9947?45046=:4=68504=42367:475 6 4A=74:B6C724986=504345151674=2C;F15250A5 17D14@685046=:4=3A224:;<50126C=5171D196754F35 #4515167 6)))!A:1=4B5167@A2?1D4750A518A7 A3391BA5167@A2FA:4@150504 22125A756FF1221674=86= 122CA7B468B4=51814:B63<5042AF4A=456;4122C4:512 2447 50A5 5012 12 765 504 2C;E4B5 FA554= 17 504 3=42475 34515167 5 A334A=2 50A5 504 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674=212FA>17?A554F35256F1294A:50126C=5;<765 FA>17?3=634=2C;F12216727:4=504B1=BCF25A7B425012 - 12 - 6C=5 12 765 1754=D4717? 17 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 504 22125A75 6FF1221674==42367:475 6 6= 56 FA>4 A7< 8C=504=6=:4=2@150=4?A=:56122CA7B468B4=51814:B63<A2 A9=4A:<5046754F356C=50A23A224:2CB06=:4=2@01B0 @1995A>415296?1BA9B67B9C2167 4A=74: B6C7249 86= 345151674=2 0A2 A926 3=6:CB4: 774HC=4B9A1F17?50A5504B4=51814:B6314268 504 =4B6=:2 A=4 ;486=4 504 22125A75 6FF1221674= A7: 7654;496@5042A1::6BCF475=4A:2A2C7:4= >9"#$$%$$ .” ! 5 12 25A54: 50A5 A2 504 345151674=2 A=4 765 3A=5142 56 504 2A1: 3=6B44:17?2 B4=51814: B63142 A=4 765 ?1D47 BB6=:17?9<3A2250486996@17? 1 012 34515167 12 @150 B625 68 2))) 3A<A;94 56 504 :D6BA54J2 - 13 - 226B1A5167 1;=A=< $C7: 1?0 6C=5 68 A=7A5A>A A9A;C=A?1 @15017 A 34=16: 68 5@6@44>28=6F504:A5468=4B413568B63< 6850126=:4= 11 1;4=5< 12 =424=D4: 56 504 345151674=2 56 A33=6AB0 504 43C5< 6FF1221674= C7:4= 4B5167!(&!'68504 B556B0A9947?4504 6=:4=68=42367:475 6 1826A:D124: 111 012 6C=5 0A2 765 4H3=4224: A7< 6317167 67504F4=15268504FA554= 1D 99B6754751672685043A=5142A=4>4356347 !*( ' !") & " 125 69 6