- 1 - ! " #! $$ %&' () $$ %&' ( ) !"#$ %&& '" "( "" & )#&** !& & !"#$ ) " &" &")& #$ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " "" " &" #$ && && "" "" **#$+ )$,- & !"#$ %& ' & " . && " . . )))/ " )&( " +'( " & && +)+ & " " 0$) " " & /)$) ) ( ) "" !"#$ && '" "( "" - 3 - & )#&** !& & !"#$ ) " &" &")& #$) " "" " &" #$) && && "" "" *#$+ )$,- & !"#$ & ' & " . && " . . +))# " ) &( " +'( "& && +)+ & " " +) & " " & )#* /# && " " 1 " - 4 - ! 2343 5663574 583 58949:; 0<= 0> =23 ?0@@0: A<B;@3:= 5:B 5C58B B5=3B +)+ 9: " 0$)5:B "0+)0:=23>9730>7358:3B BB9=90:57 94=89?= 5:B 34490:4 <B;3 5= 59?2<8 '23839:5>=38 83>3883B =0 54 ,89D<:57-( 5C58B9:; ?0@63:45=90:=0=23?759@5:=4 ) 08 =23 45E3 0> D83F9=G =23 658=934 9: =23 5663574 42577 D3 83>3883B =0 9: =38@4 0> =2398 4=5=<4 5:B 85:E9:;D3>083=2389D<:57 = 94 =23 ?543 0> =23 ?759@5:=4 =25= 0: /*)) ?759@5:= 04 5:B ) 5:B 2<4D5:B 0> ?759@5:= 0545F585A C383 680?33B9:; >80@ 25E=9:5;58 =0 =2398 F9775;3 20;5F5=29 9: @0=08?G?73 D3589:; 83;94=85=90: 0*#$+ 5:B 5= =25= =9@3 =23 89B38 0> =23 @0=08?G?73 H 545F585A =00E 294 @0=08?G?73 =0C58B4 =23 73>= 49B3 0> =23 805B =0 4=06 =23 - 5 - @0=08?G?73 = =25= =9@3 0:3 529:B85 07380 F329?73 D3589:; 83;94=85=90: 0)#&** D39:; B89F3: DG 83460:B3:= 0 >80@ =23 066049=3 B983?=90: B5423B =0 =23 @0=08?G?73 834<7=9:; 9: 9:A<8934 =0 =23 ?759@5:=4 3:?3 =23 ?759@5:=4 25F3 >973B " 0$) 5:B " 0+) D3>083 =23 89D<:57 433E9:; ?0@63:45=90: >=38438F9?30>:0=9?3=2383460:B3:=43:=383B 5663585:?3 5:B ?0:=34=3B =23 ?759@ 63=9=90:4 0: @389=4 : 08B38 =0 680F3 =2398 ?543 =23 ?759@5:= 9: " 0+) C54 3I5@9:3B 54 & 5:B 680B<?3B +* B0?<@3:=45:B=2345@3C383@58E3B54I4&=0&+* 2383460:B3:=425F33I5@9:3B0:3C9=:344545:B ;0=@58E3B49IB0?<@3:=45:B=2345@3C383@58E3B54 I4=0* # 23 89D<:57 5>=38 ?0:49B389:; =23 @5=38957 0: 83?08B DG 9=4 A<B;@3:= 5:B 5C58B B5=3B +)+ 5C58B3B ?0@63:45=90: 0> 4)#* 9: " - 6 - 0+) 5:B 4/)$) 9: " 0$) 3379:; 5;;893F3B DG =23 45@3 =23 5>083@3:=90:3B 5663574583>973B * 358B @="25:B85E575 7358:3B ?0<:437 5663589:; >08 =23 5663775:=4?759@5:=4 89 <D2542 57756<87358:3B?0<:4375663589:;>0883460:B3:=0H :4<85:?3 "0@65:G 5:B 89 8<:E<@58 @58;<:B5665 0C:38 7358:3B ?0<:437 5663589:; >08 83460:B3:= 0 0C:38 + 23 7358:3B ?0<:437 5663589:; >08 =23 658=934 25F3680B<?3B=23A<B;@3:=5:B5C58BB5=3B/)) 9: 0)*/)+ 9: 83463?= 0> =23 ?759@ 63=9=90: >973BDG=2373;578368343:=5=9F340>B3?3543B545F585A C23839: =294 "0<8= 254 56608=90:3B =23 795D979=G =0 5: 3I=3:= 0> +#J 0: =23 :4<85:?3 "0@65:G 5:B =0 5: 3I=3:=0>)#J5;59:4==230C:380>=23@0=08?G?7323 45@3 254 835?23B >9:579=G 5:B =2383>083 =23 K<34=90: - 7 - 8375=9:;=0795D979=G94=0D354638=23A<B;@3:=5:B5C58B B5=3B/))9:0)*/)+ $ :40>5854=23K<5:=<@0>?0@63:45=90:9: " 0+)94?0:49B383B=23?759@5:=2544<4=59:3B=23 >85?=<830>89;2=>3@<85:B=2389;2=>08358@2389D<:57 25B =5E3: =23 B945D979=G 0> =23 ?759@5:= 5= #J =20<;2 &) H =23 B0?=08 25B 5443443B =23 B945D979=G 5= #J 0C3F38 =5E9:; 9:=0 ?0:49B385=90: =23 9:A<8934 4<4=59:3B DG=23?759@5:=5@0>=23F93C=25==23B945D979=G94=0 D35443443B5=)#J23?759@5:=945;3B5D0<=#G3584 5:B=2383>083=5E9:;9:=0?0:49B385=90:=239:?0@30>=23 ?759@5:= 5= 4*# 638 @0:=2 54 638 =23 ;<9B379:34 944<3BDG58:5=5E5=5=3 3;5738F9?34<=2089=G9:40>58 54=239:?0@30>=239:A<83B>08=23G358))5:B54638 =235;30>?759@5:==23680638@<7=96793856679?5D7394* 3:?3=2370440>><=<83358:9:;C0<7BD34) '4*#I)I*I)#J( 23 ?759@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 4#=0C58B4659:5:B4<>>389:;5:B4)94 5C58B3B =0C58B4 5==3:B5:= ?258;34 5E9:; 9:=0 - 8 - ?0:49B385=90:=23>5?==25==23?759@5:=254:0=C08E3B>08 =2833 @0:=24 5@ 0> =23 F93C =25= =23 ?759@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 4/# '4*#I( =0C58B4 7044 0> 9:?0@3 B<89:; 759B <6 63890B 4<@ 0> 4#+* 5C58B3B DG =23 89D<:57 =0C58B4 @3B9?57 3I63:434 94 83=59:3B ??08B9:;7G =23 K<5:=<@ 0> ?0@63:45=90: 83K<9834=0D3835443443B54>0770C4 *+,- ./01 &59:5:B4<>>389:; 4# 044 0> 358:9:;4 B<89:; 759B <6 63890B'4*#I( 4/# 044 0> ><=<83 0> 358:9:;4 '4*#I)I*I)#J( 4) 0C58B4B93=5:B5==3:B5:=?258;34 4) 3B9?573I63:434 4#+* 0=57 3445C58B3BDG89D<:57 :25:?3@3:= 4#))* 4)#* - " "( 2<4 =23 ?75@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 3:25:?3B ?0@63:45=90:0>- " "(C9=29:=3834=5==2385=3 0>*J6385::<@ / :40>5854=23?759@5:=9: "0$)94 ?0:?38:3B=23?759@5:=945;3B5D0<=+G35845==23=9@3 - 9 - 0> =23 5??9B3:= : =25= C5G 0> =23 @5==38 =5E9:; 9:=0 ?0:49B385=90:=23B3?7585=90:0> 75C @5B3DG=230:1D73 <683@3"0<8=9:=23?5430> ! "# " ! 83608=3B 9: $ %%& '() =23 9:?0@3 0> =23 ?759@5:= 94 =5E3: 5= 4# 638 5::<@ 23 680638 @<7=967938 56679?5D7394$5:B=5E9:;9:=0?0:49B385=90:=23B945D979=G 5= )J 5@ 0> =23 F93C =25= =23 ?0@63:45=90: =0C58B4 7044 0> 358:9:; C0<7B D3 4# '4#I$I)J( 5E9:; 9:=0 ?0:49B385=90: =23 9:A<8G 4<4=59:3B DG =23 ?759@5:= 5@ 0> =23 F93C =25= =23 K<5:=<@ 0> ?0@63:45=90: 5C58B3B DG =23 89D<:57 5= 4# <:B38 =23 235B 0> 659: 5:B 4<>>389:; 94 A<4= 5:B 680638 0C58B4B94?0@>08=5:B?0:F3G5:?35:BB93==23?759@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 4) 23 ?759@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 4) =0C58B4 7044 0> ><=<83 9:?0@3 5E9:; 9:=0 ?0:49B385=90: =23 ><=<83 @3B9?57 3I63:434 54 58;<3B DG =237358:3B?0<:4375663589:;>08=235663775:=54<@0> - 10 - 4))$) 5C58B3B DG =23 89D<:57 94 :0= 57=383B ??08B9:;7G=23K<5:=<@0>?0@63:45=90:83K<9834=0D3 835443443B54>0770C4 *+,- ./01 &59:5:B4<>>389:; 4# 0440>><=<83358:9:;4 4) 044 0> ><=<83 0> 358:9:;4 '4#I$I)J( 4# 0C58B4B93=5:B5==3:B5:=?258;34 4) 3B9?573I63:434 4))$) 0=57 3445C58B3BDG89D<:57 :25:?3@3:= 4**$) 4/)$) - 2"( 2<4 =23 ?75@5:= 94 3:=9=73B >08 3:25:?3B ?0@63:45=90:0>- 2"(C9=29:=3834=5==2385=30> *J6385::<@ :=23834<7=6544=23>0770C9:; 2356635745835770C3B9:658= 23 5663775:=?759@5:= 9: 0)*$/)+ ' " 0$)( 94 3:=9=73B >08 3:25:?3B ?0@63:45=90: 0> - 2"( C9=2 9:=3834= 5= - 11 - =23 85=3 0> *J 638 5::<@ >80@ =23 B5=3 0> 63=9=90:=977=23B5=30>83579L5=90: 23 5663775:=?759@5:= 9: 0)*$$)+ ' " 0+)( 94 3:=9=73B >08 3:25:?3B ?0@63:45=90:0>- " "(C9=29:=3834=5= =23 85=3 0> *J 638 5::<@ >80@ =23 B5=3 0> 63=9=90:=977=23B5=30>83579L5=90: 2383460:B3:=:4<85:?3"0@65:G94B983?=3B =0 B36049= =23 5>083459B ?0@63:45=90: 5@0<:= C9=29: 49I C33E4 >80@ =23 B5=3 0> 83?396= 0> ?38=9>93B?06G0>=294A<B;@3:= ,( %' ! 94=070* "&