- 1 - ! " #$! % &' ( ! " # $ ! % " #&' $ & (& & ( & ) )& & & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & *) +,-./+,-0+.12304+/52-67+8+696920+-,0./+,-0+. 12304+/52-67+-+4820.+06 7948+6969209459/+.:;67+<95+4++=90>6-,045+- 25 67+ ?,6-9?209,/ 8-21++.90>4 90 2 25 ( 8+0.90> :+52-+ 67+ +092- 9@9/ )3.>+ ,0. )& 23-6 7966,83-6267+-90198,/)3.>+&,?9/;23-6,/,:3-,>9 69467+1206+069202567+/+,-0+.12304+/67,6 67+8+696920+-9467+/+>,//;<+..+.<95+2567+-+4820.+06 ,0. 67+9- ?,--9,>+ 7,@90> 6,=+0 8/,1+ 20 ,6 ,-@,69 ,/;,0 ,06,8 ,A?9 30B 7,7,:,. ,/3= 7,7,:,. 946-916 ,/,:3-,>9 ,4 8+- 67+ 90.3 13462?4 -96+4 ,0. 1+-+?209+4 3+ 62 1+-6,90 .955+-+01+4 ,44,3/6 ,0. 7,-,44?+06 :; 67+ -+4820.+06 734:,0. 67+ 8+696920+- -+63-0+. 62 7+- 8,-+06,/ 72?+ ,0. 59/+. , - 3 - 1-9?90,/ 12?8/,906 ,>,9046 67+ -+4820.+06 ,0. 794 5,?9/; ?+?:+-4 :+52-+ 67+ ,/,:3-,>9 2?+0 2/91+ 6,6920 90 -9?+ 2(C 52- 67+ 255+01+4 830947,:/+ 30.+- +169204 (D ! !(D 25 67+ 0.9,0 +0,/ 2.+ -+,.<967+169204,0.(25 2<-;-279:9692016794 :+90>67+46,6+25,55,9-467+8+696920+-,/4259/+.,8+696920 30.+- +16920 ! 25 - 90 -9?90,/ 941+//,0+234 2 ! 25:+52-+67+-90198,/)3.>+&,?9/;23-6,6 ,/,:3-,>9 <7917 94 8+0.90> ,.B3.91,6920 ,0. 67+ -+4820.+06 7,4 ,11+86+. 02691+ ,0. 94 ,88+,-90> 90 67+ ?,66+- 6 94 53-67+- 1206+0.+. 67,6 67+ -+4820.+06 734:,0. 7,4 90969,6+. , 8+696920 52- .9@2-1+ 30.+-+16920!#$#9,$2567+90.3,--9,>+1690 2 ( ,>,9046 67+ 8+696920+- :+52-+ 67+ +092- 9@9/ )3.>+,0.)&23-67966,83- ( 6 94 67+ 1206+06920 25 67+ /+,-0+. 12304+/ 52- 67+8+696920+-67,667+23-6,67966,83-94,6,.946,01+ 25 =9/2?+6+-4 5-2? ,/,:3-,>9 6 <9// 6,=+ ?2-+ 67,0 6<2723-452-67+8+696920+-62-+,1767+-+7+4,?+<9// - 4 - :+ 6+.9234 ,0. 3012?52-6,:/+ ,0. 7,-.4798 123/. :+ 1,34+. 62 67+ 8+696920+- 62 6-,@+/ 42 ,/42 47+ 1206+0.4 67,6 7+- 8,-+064 ,-+ 4355+-90> 5-2? 2/. ,>+ ,9/?+064 901/3.90> ,0. .9,:+6+4 ,0. 47+ 94 5,190> 590,019,/ .955913/69+4 7+ 53-67+- 1206+0.4 67,6 95 67+ 8+696920 5-2? 67+ +092- 9@9/ )3.>+ ,0. )& 23-6 7966,83- 94 6-,045+--+. 62 67+ -90198,/ )3.>+ &,?9/; 23-6 ,6 ,/,:3-,>9 96 <23/. 026 1,34+ 7,-.4798 2- 90120@+09+01+ 6267+-+4820.+06 734:,0.,47+94,/-+,.;,66+0.90>67+ 23-6 1,4+ 90969,6+. :; 67+ 8+696920+- <95+ :+52-+ 67+ &,?9/; 23-6 ,/,:3-,>9 90 67+ 8+696920 59/+. 30.+- +16920! 25- /+,-0+. 12304+/ ,88+,-90> 52- 67+ -+4820.+06 1206+0.4 67,6 67+ .946,01+ 94 026 ?317 5-2? ,/,:3-,>9627966,83-7+,/426,=+438,8/+,67,667+ :345,-+945-++02<:;67+2@+-0?+0625,-0,6,=,,0. 47+<23/.0267,@+6248+0.?31720590,01+4626-,@+/ 7+-+52-+67+8+696920+-1,0@+-;<+//6-,@+/627966,83- - 5 - 62 ,66+0. 67+ 23-6 +01+ 47+ 4++=4 .94?944,/ 25 6794 8+696920 C ,@90> 7+,-. /+,-0+. 12304+/ 52- :267 67+ 8,-69+4 67+ 20*:/+ 8+A 23-6 90 1,6+0, 25 B3.>?+064 7,4 7+/. 67,6 <7+0 67+ ?,6-9?209,/ 8-21++.90>4 ,-+ 423>7662:+6-,045+--+.5-2?20+8/,1+62,0267+-,667+ 9046,01+2567+<95+>+0+-,//;964723/.:+,//2<+.,667+ :+7+462567+<95+6,=90>906212049.+-,692025123-4+67+ .946,01+ 67+ 7,-.4798 ,0. 67+ .955913/6; 67,6 <23/. :+ 5,1+. :;67+ <95+ ,0. 95 ,0;267+- 122-.90,6+ 8+69692094 8+0.90><7+-+67+734:,0.7,4626-,@+/6267+8/,1+25 67+<95+67+096<23/.:+8-3.+06626-,045+-67+8+696920 62 67+ 8/,1+ <7+-+ 67+ <95+ 94 -+49.90> <7+-+ ,0267+- 8+6969209490969,6+.:;67+<95+,>,904667+734:,0.067+ 8-+4+061,4+67+8+69692030.+-+16920! 25-94 90969,6+. :; 67+ <95+ <7917 94 8+0.90> :+52-+ 67+ &,?9/; 23-6 ,6 ,/,:3-,>9 0.+- 67+ 19-13?46,01+4 67+ -+4820.+06 734:,0. 7,@90> ,/-+,.; ,11+86+. 02691+ 96 <23/. 026 :+ .955913/6 52- 79? 62 ,66+0. -,67+- ?2-+ - 6 - 7,-.4798 ,0. .955913/6; <23/. :+ 1,34+. 62 67+ 8+696920+- <95+67,067+-+4820.+06 734:,0.112-.90>/; 8-21++.628,4467+52//2<90> #,$ 7+9@9/+69692094,//2<+. #:$ 7+ ?,6-9?209,/ 8-21++.90>4 90 2 ( 8+0.90> 20 67+ 59/+ 25 67+ +092-9@9/)3.>+,0.)&23-67966,83-94 6-,045+--+.6267+-90198,/)3.>+&,?9/;23-6 ,/,:3-,>9 62 :+ 6-9+. ,/20> <967 -9?90,/ 941+//,0+2342 ! -.+-+.,112-.90> )* & ' ! !( E