- 1 - !"!# $" %% &'( )* %% &'( ) * ! "# $%&%' ( %( ) ( % " $ *%( )+ '!',('(% ( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) -* ) '!'&('- .& (('% ) * %' "# $%&%' %* ) $( $ % " $ *%( ( $%&%' )(+ ','('(* ) ) -* ) ) '!'&('- & (('% - 3 - ) ',& '$ ,/ %''''$ (/ ) 0 " 1232 4552463 472 478389: .;< .= <12 >;?:@29< 49? 4A47? ?4<2? '!'&('- 89 .& (('% .9 <12 =862 .= <12 ??8<8.946 298.7 8B86 ;?:2 49? 464C;74:8 466.A89: <12 D648@ 52<8<8.9 89 547< ) .('&!&('- 83 =862? CE <12 93;749D2 .@549E D146629:89: <12 684C868<E <. 54E <12 D.@52934<8.9 <. <12 D648@49< 49? ) .('**('& 83 =862? CE <12 D648@49<322F89:29149D2@29<.=D.@52934<8.9 ( ).7<1234F2.=D.9B29829D2<12547<823A.;6? C2 72=2772? 43 <12 D648@49< 49? 93;749D2 .@549E 72352D<8B26E - 4 - * < 83 <12 D432 .= <12 D648@49< <14< .9 '&',(' <12D648@49<A43<74B26689:8947;DFC24789: 2:9 .$( $ % =7.@ 434B4F46E49 49:64 <. ;92 46.9: A8<1 <12 :..?3 < 83 463. 3<4<2? <14< <12 D648@49<A43<74B26689:46.9:A8<11273.94B4938??4554 <83463.3<4<2?<14<<12B218D6289G;23<8.9@2<A8<149 4DD8?29< 47.;9? '**' 4@ 9247 .918 4<<4 .= .98 46C.72 .68D2 <4<8.9 68@8<3 49? .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 348? 4DD8?29< <12 D648@49< 143 3;3<4892? =4<46 89>;7823 49? 318=<2? <. 18B4@ .358<46 4< .918 46C.72 =.7 =873< 48? 49?<12724=<27318=<2?<.;92=.7=;7<127<724<@29<<83 <12 D432 .= <12 D648@49< <14< <12 4662:2? 4DD8?29< A43 .DD;772? .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 7431 49? 92:68:29D2 .9 <12 547<.=<12?78B27.=<12B218D6289G;23<8.949?433;D1 <12D648@49< 143 572=2772? .& ( .=('% 322F89: D.@52934<8.9 9 327B8D2 .= 9.<8D2 7235.9?29< .($ 93;749D2 .@549E29<272?45524749D249?=862??2<4862? - 5 - A78<<29 3<4<2@29< ?29E89: <12 4B27@29<3 @4?2 89 <12 D648@52<8<8.9 % 432?.9<125624?89:3.972D.7?<1278C;946 =74@2?<12833;23=.78<3D.938?274<8.9 , 9 .7?27 <. 23<4C6831 127 D432 <12 D648@49< 2H4@892?127326=4349?<12?.D<.743(49?:.< @47F2?,?.D;@29<343H3<.,..7462B8?29D2 A43 4??;D2? CE <12 7235.9?29<$93;749D2 .@549E 1.A2B27 @47F2? <12 D.5E .= <12 893;749D2 5.68DE 43 H - 12 78C;946 4=<27 D.938?2789: <12@4<27846 .9 72D.7? CE 8<3 >;?:@29< 49? 4A47? ?4<2? '!'&('- 466.A2? <12 D648@ 52<8<8.9 89 547< 49? 4A47?2? D.@52934<8.9.=3',!'''$46.9:A8<189<2723<4<,/ 54 =7.@ <12 ?4<2 .= 52<8<8.9 <866 72468I4<8.9 49? ?872D<2? 7235.9?29< .($93;749D2 .@549E <. ?25.38< <12 348? D.@52934<8.9)22689:4::782B2?CE<12348?>;?:@29<49? 4A47? <12 93;749D2 .@549E 143 572=2772? ) - 6 - .('&!&('- G;23<8.989: <12 684C868<E =43<292? .9 8< 127243 <12 D648@49< 143 572=2772? ) .('**('&322F89:29149D2@29<.=D.@52934<8.9 & 14B2 1247? 78 354668 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 93;749D2 .@549E 49? 78 ;C; 2<4:;??4624792?D.;932645524789:=.7<12D648@49< ! 78 354668 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <1293;749D2 .@549E CE 72=27789: <. <12 D.@56489< 4< H(49?<12D147:23122<4<H3*49?*4D.9<29?2? <14<<12D648@49<834:74<;8<.;3543329:2789<12B218D62 89G;23<8.949?<1272=.724A47?89:.=D.@52934<8.9<.4 :74<;8<.;3543329:27?.239.<4783249?<1272=.723.;:1< =.7 89<27=2729D2 .= <183 .;7< <. 2H.9274<2 <12 93;749D2 .@549E =7.@ <12 684C868<E <. 54E D.@52934<8.9 <. <12 D648@49< ' 27 D.9<74 78 4C; 2<4:;??4 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 D648@49< CE 72=27789: <. <12 D7.33$2H4@894<8.9.=3;C@8<<2?<14<43<12D648@49< - 7 - 143 318=<2? 127 1.;32 .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 C2724B2@29< 89 <12 =4@86E 312 D499.< C2 D.938?272? 43 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 14< 4547< 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 D648@49< 564D23 726849D2 .9 <12 >;?:@29< .= <12 .90C62 ;572@2 .;7< 89 <12 D432 .= ! 89 " ##" $% % ?4<2? -'-('(% 49? D.9<29<2?<14<<12D432.9149?83=4876ED.B272?CE<12 >;?:@29<.=<12.90C62 ;572@2 .;7<89<124C.B2D432 49?<1272=.723.;:1<=.7?83@83346.=<12455246572=2772? CE<1293;749D2 .@549E 93.=47 43 <12 G;49<;@ .= D.@52934<8.9 83 D.9D2792? 8< 83 47:;2? CE <12 624792?D.;9326 45524789: =.7<12D648@49<<14<<124A47?.=D.@52934<8.9@4?2.9 B478.;3124?34<5474:7451((.=<128@5;:92?>;?:@29< CE<1278C;94672G;8723<.C229149D2?89<183455246< 83 463. 47:;2? <14< <12 78C;946 =4863 <. 4A47? <12 D.@52934<8.9 <.A47?3 6.33 .= 4@298<823 49? <1272=.72 3.;:1<=.789<27=2729D2.=<183 .;7< - 8 - ( 9 <12 68:1< .= <12 3;C@8338.93 @4?2 CE <12 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 547<823 49? .9 D472=;6 D.938?274<8.9 .= <12 @4<27846 .9 72D.7? 8< A.;6? 89?8D4<2 <14<<12D648@49<A43<74B26689:8947;DFC24789:2:9 .$( $ % < 83 463. =.7<1D.@89: =7.@ <12 D7.33$ 2H4@894<8.9.=A18D1724?343;9?27 !"#$ %" "&' ()*("' +,( -."#,$ / 0 1" 2( 3* +,( -."#,$ - &4 (" -(5" %* ( , $ %+6* " 7 ( &89 :*5$ , -."# ' " -(5" - 8 ," ;8 : " - 1 !" / - %"7 -< -=!*5" &" $ / ' 8 ," 1>?@"%+6*< &" $A ;9?276892?CE@2 * 27;346 .= <12 4=.72@29<8.92? ?25.38<8.9 .= 89 <12 D7.33$2H4@894<8.9 @4F23 8< D6247 <14< <12 D648@49<46.9:A8<11273.914B2318=<2?<12871.;3249? A272D477E89:<1287:..?389<12B218D6289G;23<8.99<183 - 9 - 72:47? .9 D472=;6 D.938?274<8.9 .= <12 A78<<29 3<4<2@29< =862? CE <12 93;749D2 .@549E 8< 4552473 <14< <12 93;749D2 .@549E1439.<<4F294352D8=8D5624<14<<12 D648@49< 83 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 89 <12 B218D62 89 G;23<8.99<14<B82A.=<12@4<<274@.=<12B82A<14< <12 =4D<;46 4352D<3 .9 72D.7? A.;6? D62476E 89?8D4<2 <14< <12D648@49<839.<4:74<;8<.;3543329:27 12 .9JC62 ;572@2 .;7< 89 <12 D432 .= ;5744<5474:74513 <.,126?43=.66.A3 " ! &"' ( )*+, - ! & . / 0" ! 1 )*, 2- - 10 - " # $# % & " 3 !" ("4 5 .# '())*+ , - ./ 6 ! 74 '(0110+ 0 - 0.*/ " ! "" # 8 '(011+ * - !./ 6 ! 93" 5 '(011+ - 23 - )/ " ! ' : :" '(01,+ 0 - / ( 8' (3;'(01.+-.)&/ :## 83/)* ! +$2-4 % 9B82A.=<12D.9D6;38.946724?E4778B2?4<CE <183 .;7<<14<<12D648@49<839.<4:74<;8<.;3543329:27 4@.=<12B82A<14<<12G;23<8.9 .= 684C868<E 493A272? - 11 - CE<1278C;94683>;3<49?57.527A18D1?.239.<72G;872 89<27=2729D2CE<183 .;7< , 93.=47 43 <12 G;49<;@ .= D.@52934<8.9 4A47?2? CE <12 78C;946 83 D.9D2792? <12 2B8?29D2 .= ( @4F23 8< D6247 <14< <12 D648@49< 143 3;==272? =74D<;72 .= 314=< .= 78:1< <8C84 49? =8C;64 82 4@5;<4<8.9 143D4;32?527@4929<?834C62@29<<.<12D648@49<49?8< 83 463. =.7<1D.@89: =7.@ H 9 <14< B82A .= <12 @4<<27<4F89:89<.D.938?274<8.9<12:;8?268923648??.A9 CE<124794<4F4 <4<22:46 27B8D23 ;<1.78<E43<.<12 89D.@2.=<1289>;72?=.7<127262B49<5278.?82(' 8< 83<.C23-%''527@.9<1 3<12D648@49<A434:2? - E2473<12@;6<856827.=K*J4?.5<2?CE<1278C;94683>;3< 49? 57.527 4F89: 89<. D.938?274<8.9 <12 2B8?29D2 .= ( A1. ?25.32? <14< <12 D648@49< 143 3;==272? <12 ?834C868<E <. 49 2H<29< .= &'/ <12 ?834C868<E 83 <. C2 D.938?272?4<&'/);7<12789<27@3.=<1264A648??.A9 CE <12 .9JC62 ;572@2 .;7< 89 <12 D432 .= " 3#4 !3 9 :4 1 - 12 - 725.7<2? 89 * <, 2 2 D.938?2789: <12 4:2 .= <12 D648@49< (%/ 83 <. C2 4??2? <.A47?3 =;<;72 57.352D<3 1;3 <12 6.33 .= =;<;72 89D.@2 A.;6? C2 3-''''$3-%''L(%/H(H*H&'/ - E 6..F89: 89<. <12 89>;7E 3;3<4892? CE <12 D648@49<312@8:1<9.<C24C62<.?.49EA.7F4<6243<=.7 45278.?.=<1722@.9<1349?4DD.7?89:6E<12D648@49<83 29<8<62? =.7 4 3;@ .= 3((%''$ 3-%'' H* <.A47?3 6.33.=89D.@2?;789:648?;55278.? & 12 78C;946 143 4557.5784<26E 4A47?2? 4 3;@ .=3* %''$<.A47?3@2?8D462H529323A18D1922?39. 89<27=2729D2 ! 93.=47 43 <12 4<<29?49< 49? D.9B2E49D2 D147:23 83 D.9D2792? CE 6..F89: 89<. <12 89>;7823 3;3<4892? CE <12 D648@49< <12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 4 3;@.=3(%'''$;9?27<12348?124? (' 4B89:4778B2?4<4D.9D6;38.9<14<<12D648@49< 143 3;==272? &'/ .= ?834C868<E .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 - 13 - 4@5;<4<8.9<12D.@52934<8.9<.A47?3548949?3;==2789: A.;6?C23%''''$ ( );7<127 <12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 4 3;@ .= 3'''''$<.A47?36.33.=4@298<823 (( 29D2<12D648@49<8329<8<62?=.7<12@.?8=82? D.@52934<8.9;9?27?8==2729<124?343C26.A 48949?3;==2789: 3%''''$ 2?8D462H529323 3* %''$ .33.==;<;7289D.@2 3-''''$ <<29?49<49?D.9B2E49D2D147:23 3(%'''$ .33.=4@298<823 3'''''$ .33.=89D.@2?;789:648?;55278.? 3((%''$ .<46 + ,# #) 1;3 <12 D64@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 <.<46 D.@52934<8.9 .=3%'('''$A8<189<2723<4<,/527499;@ (* 4B89: 4778B2? 4< 4 D.9D6;38.9 <14< <12 93;749D2 .@549E143=4862?<.57.B2<124352D<343<. <12 D648@49< 83 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 89 <12 B218D62 89 G;23<8.9 ) .('&!&('- =862? CE <12 93;749D2 .@549E 83 684C62 <. C2 ?83@8332? 49? 4DD.7?89:6E ) - 14 - .('**('& =862? CE <12 D648@49< ?2327B23 <. C2 466.A2?89547< ( 9<12723;6<<12=.66.A89:.7?278354332? 8 ) .('**('& =862? CE <12 D648@49< 83 466.A2?89547< 88 12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 <.<46 D.@52934<8.9 .=3%'('''$A8<189<2723<4<,/527499;@=7.@<12 ?4<2 .= 52<8<8.9 <866 72468I4<8.9 43 4:4893< 3',!'''$ 4A47?2?CE<1278C;946.A2B2743527<12.7?27.=<183 .;7< ?4<2? (('!('(% <12 D648@49<45526649< 89 ) .('**('&839.<29<8<62?=.789<2723<=.7<12?264E2? 5278.?.=(%?4E389=8689:<12455246 888 235.9?29< .($93;749D2 .@549E 83 ?872D<2? <. ?25.38< <12 29<872 D.@52934<8.9 A8<189 38H A22F3=7.@<12?4<2.=72D285<.=4D27<8=82?D.5E.=<183 >;?:@29< 8B .932G;29<6E ) .('&!&('- =862? CE <1293;749D2 .@549E83?83@8332? - 15 - B 12 4@.;9< 89 ?25.38< @4?2 CE <12 93;749D2 .@549EC2=.72<183 .;7< 8=49E C2 <7493@8<<2?<. <12 78C;946=.7?83C;732@29< -) &( " 83<. 6.(