Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54653 (KAR)

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER NATIONAL v. ABDUL NAZEER SHAIKH

MFA/202127/2018 · 2026-02-03

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!" #$ %% &'( ) ! " ! # " $ ! % & ' ($ ") " ($ " ($ " Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) * ($ "+ !*! , $ " * " ! # $+- .// ! , $ $)+ % & / 0 ) ' +&' * -+ /+ * $ * ! " " 1 * $ 234 566758 34 697:7997; <= >27 ?4@95?A7 BC65?= 5445383?D >27 E@;DC7?> 5?; 5F59; ;5>7; -+ 3? B/+ B? >27 :387 B: 8759?7; ;;3>3B?58 - 3 - 34>93A>5?;7443B?4*@;D7 3;5943>>3?D5> 545G5H58=5? &27973?5:>79 97:7997; >B 54 193<@?581' 5F59;3?D ABC67?45>3B?>B>27A853C5?>4 B9 >27 45H7 B: <97G3>= >27 659>374 3? >27 566758 42588 <7 97:7997; >B 3? >79C4 B: >2739 4>5>@4 5?; 95?H3?D<7:B97>2793<@?58 >34>27A547B:>27A853C5?>4>25>>27F3:7B: A853C5?> B I @95==5 7D@C F54 >95G7883?D 3? 5 7C6B95J <7593?D 97D34>95>3B? B$+- :9BC 3;59 >B @?7 58B?D F3>2 B>279 3?C5>74 5?; 54 >B >27 ?7D83D7?A7 B? >27 659> B: >27 ;93G79 B: >27 G723A87 3? K@74>3B?>275887D7;5AA3;7?>BAA@997;5?;545974@8>B: >27 45C7 F3:7 B: A853C5?> B I @95==5 7D@C ;37; 7?A7 >27 A853C5?>4 25G7 697:7997; B/+ 477H3?DABC67?45>3B? ) ? 479G3A7 B: ?B>3A7 >27 9746B?;7?>4 25G7 7?>797; 5667595?A7 5?; AB?>74>7; >27 C5>>79 B? C793>4 ? B9;79 >B 69BG7 >2739 A547 A853C5?> B 7J5C3?7; - 4 - 23C478: 54 ! 5?; 69B;@A7; ;BA@C7?>4 5?; >27 45C7 F797 C59H7; 54 J4 >B 27 9746B?;7?>4 25G77J5C3?7;>FBF3>?7447454!5?;!5?;DB> C59H7; 47G7? ;BA@C7?>4 5?; >27 45C7 F797 C59H7; 54 J4 >B + 27 93<@?58 5:>79 AB?43;793?D C5>79358 B? 97AB9; <= 3>4 E@;DC7?> 5?; 5F59; ;5>7; -+ 5F59;7; ABC67?45>3B? B: 4-// F3>2 3?>7974> 5> >2795>7B:-L6795??@C5?;:7783?D5D977;<=>2745C7 >27?4@95?A7BC65?=254697:7997;>234566758 93 2595?5<545665 5>38 >27 8759?7; AB@?4785667593?D:B9>275667885?>?4@95?A7BC65?= 59D@7; >25> >27 ;7A7547; F54 >95G7883?D 3? >27 693G5>7 A59F23A2ABG794>27693G5>765AH5D76B83A=5?;544@A2 >27BF?79B:>27G723A873?K@74>3B?254G3B85>7;>27>79C4 5?; AB?;3>3B?4 B: >27 6B83A= <= 2393?D >27 G723A87 5> >27 >3C7B:>275AA3;7?>2797:B97274B@D2>:B93?>79:797?A7 B: >234 B@9> > 34 584B 59D@7; <= >27 8759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D:B9>275667885?>>25>5F59;B:3?>7974>5>>27 95>7B:-L6795??@C34B?>2723D27943;7 - 5 - / 5G3?D >5H7? ?B>7 B: >27 4@<C3443B? C5;7 <= >278759?7;AB@?4785667593?D:B9>275667885?>3>34?B>3? ;346@>754>B>27;75>2B:>27F3:7B:A853C5?> B3?>27 5887D7; 5AA3;7?> BAA@997; B? - 3? F23A2 >27 ;7A7547; F54 >95G7883?D 54 5 D95>@3>B@4 65447?D79 3? 7C6B95J<7593?D97D34>95>3B? B$+-?>25> G37F B: >27 C5>>79 >5H3?D 3?>B AB?43;795>3B? >25> >27 5667885?>?4@95?A7BC65?=254AB?>74>7;>27C5>>79 B?C793>4<7:B97>2793<@?585?;584B69B;@A7;9787G5?> ;BA@C7?>4;346@>3?D>27:5A>>25>>27G723A873?K@74>3B? F54 >5H7? B? 2397 2797:B97 5C B: >27 B63?3B? >25> :54>7?3?D835<383>=B?>27?4@95?A7BC65?=>B3?;7C?3:= 9746B?;7?> B 34 97K@397; >B <7 3?>79:797; F3>2 3? >234 566758 B88BF3?D >27 ;7A8595>3B? B: 85F C5;7 <= >27 B?M<87 @697C7 B@9> 3? >27 A547 B: 976B9>7;3? !"F27973?3>34278;>25>>27 ?4@95?A7BC65?=34>B45>34:=>27A853CB:>27A853C5?>4 5?;>27975:>79>B97ABG79>2745C7:9BC>27BF?79B:>27 - 6 - G723A873?F23A2>27;7A7547;F54>95G7883?D54D95>@3>B@4 65447?D79?>25>G37FB:>27C5>>79:3?;:B9A73?>27 4@<C3443B?C5;7<=>278759?7;AB@?4785667593?D:B9>27 5667885?> + 5H3?D 3?>B AB?43;795>3B? >27 93<@?58 254 5F59;7;3?>7974>5>>2795>7B:-L6795??@CF23A234B? >27 23D279 43;7 2797:B97 >27 A853C5?>4 597 7?>3>87; :B9 3?>7974>5>>2795>7B:/L6795??@CF23A234697G5383?D 3?4>75;B:-L6795??@C54D95?>7;<=>2793<@?58B? >27ABC67?45>3B?5F59;7; ?>27974@8>6544>27:B88BF3?D" 2756675834588BF7;3?659> 27 E@;DC7?> 5?; 5F59; ;5>7; -+ 3? B/+B?>27:387B:8759?7; ;;3>3B?5834>93A>5?;7443B?4*@;D7 3;59 43>>3?D5> 545G5H58=5?34CB;3:37; - 7 - 27 5667885?> ?4@95?A7 BC65?= 34 >B 45>34:= >27 A853C B: >27 A853C5?>4 5?; >27975:>7997ABG79>2745C7:9BC>27BF?79 B:>27G723A873?K@74>3B? 27 95>7 B: 3?>7974> 3? 97467A> B: >27 5F59; 5CB@?> 42588 <7 /L 679 5??@C :9BC >27 ;5>7B:A853C67>3>3B?>38897583N5>3B? CB@?>3?;76B43>3:5?=<7>95?4C3>>7;>B >2793<@?58 *+ &( $ 34> B"8 B"/ "$