- 1 - !!"!#$#% & $""!" ""'' ()!* ""'' ()* ""'' ()!* ! " # ! $ % &' & !!!%$ &' &! % Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ) % & & % ( # * ) +) ! ,! + -% , ! " ! !!!% , &. &/ ! % ( - 3 - % & & % ( +) ! , ! + +% , $ % &'- & !!!%$ &'. &! % ( ! % &- & % ( - 4 - * % -+) ! +) ! ! +)% % ! 0 , ! + , -% ,! & & 1 , $! 23456728234925:;<9=28>;4672?346@2= ;) % @= >@825 AB 672 9=<439:2 ;C?39B :738829D@9D 672 8@3A8@6B 395 ;.-%) @= >@825 AB 672 :83@C396= 3D3@9=6 672 ,<5DC296 395 3E345 53625 + ?3==25@9;-% ;9672>@82;>67229@;4 - 5 - @F@8 ,<5D2 395 55@6@;938 36 7;43?<4 D4396@9D :;C?29=36@;9 ) ;).% @= >@825 AB 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 3D3@9=6 672 ,<5DC296 395 3E345 53625 + ?3==25@9;+% ;9672>@82;>67229@;4@F@8,<5D2 395 558 36 7;43?<4 D4396@9D :;C?29=36@;9 6; 672 :83@C396 @9:2 672 3::@5296 @9F;8F25 @9 672=2 3??238= 342 :;CC;9 395 3::;45@9D8B 672 3??238= E242 :8<AA25 6;D26724 3955@=?;=25;>AB67@=:;CC;9,<5DC296 . 724282F396>3:6=>;435G<5@:36@;9;>672=23??238= 342 6736 ;9 -. 724282F396>3:6=>;435G<5@:36@;9;>672=23??238= 342 6736 ;9 -. + 53<D7624 ;> 672 :83@C396= 393C3EE3 E3= ?4;:225@9D @9 39 <6; 4@:H=73E A234@9D 42D@=6436@;9;))%..A2@9D54@F29AB;92343=7<43C @9343=739592D8@D296C39924395=3@53<6;6<49256<46829 3::;<96 ;> 672 =3@5 3::@5296 672 53<D7624 ;> 672 :83@C396= I 393C3EE3 5@25 ;9 672 =?;6 29:2 672 :83@C396= 73F2 ?42>24425;-% =22H@9D:;C?29=36@;9@942=?2:6;> 67252367;>672@453<D7624I393C3EE3;+% @= >@825 AB ;92 ;> 672 @9G<425 @9 672 3>;42=3@5 3::@5296 I @CC3EE3=22H@9D:;C?29=36@;9>;46723882D253::@5296 - 6 - 9 =24F@:2 ;> 9;6@:2 672 42=?;95296 9=<439:2 :;C?39B29624253??23439:2395672:83@C396=73F2355<:25 2F@529:2395C34H25:2463@95;:<C296=7242=?;95296=73F2 9;6355<:2539B2F@529:2 ' 72 4@A<938 3>624 :;9=@524@9D 672 C3624@38 ;9 42:;45 AB @6= ,<5DC296 395 3E345 53625 + @9 ;-% 73=3E34525:;C?29=36@;9;> =+)%38;9D E@67 @96242=6 36 672 4362 ;> '0 ?24:296 ?24 399<C >4;C 672 5362;>?26@6@;96@886725362;>4238@J36@;9 + 9 ;+% 672 4@A<938 73= 3E34525 :;C?29=36@;9 ;> =--% 38;9DE@67 @96242=6 36 672 4362 ;> '0 ?24 399<C >4;C 672 5362 ;> ?26@6@;9 6@88 672 5362 ;> 4238@J36@;9228@9D3DD4@2F25AB>3=629@9D;>6728@3A@8@6B;9672 9=<439:2:;C?39B672 9=<439:2:;C?39B73=?42>24425 ;) % 395 ;).% 3D3@9=6 672 ,<5DC296 395 3E345 53625 + ?3==25 @9 ;-% 395;+% 42=?2:6@F28B 2345 C6 4226@ 36@8 8234925 :;<9=28 >;4 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 395 4@ @543C4255B 29H3993 34355B >;4672:83@C396= - 7 - - 6 @= 34D<25 AB C6 4226@ 36@8 8234925 :;<9=28 3??234@9D >;4 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 6736 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 73= >@825 3??8@:36@;9 @9 ; A2>;42 672 4@A<938 =22H@9D 5@42:6@;9 6; 672 ;E924 ;> 672 F27@:82 @9 K<2=6@;9 6; ?4;5<:2?24C@62L643:654@F@9D8@:29:2395?;8@:B?346@:<834=;> 672@9=<425<6;4@:H=73E;E2F24672=3@53??8@:36@;9:3C2 6;A25@=C@==25;9-+ 395672423>624672:83@C?26@6@;9 E3= ?;=625 >;4 34D<C296= ;9 + 395 672 @C?<D925 ,<5DC296 395 3E345 :3C2 6; A2 ?3==25 ;9 + 395 67242>;42@6@=:;9629525AB6728234925:;<9=283??234@9D>;4 6723??28839667363>3@4;??;46<9@6BE3=9;62L6295256;672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 395 67242>;42 =;<D76 >;4 @9624>2429:2 ;> 67@=;<46 24 :;9643 4@ 34355B 8234925 :;<9=28 3??234@9D >;4 672 :83@C396=%3??288396= @9 ;.-%) =<AC@6625 6736 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 73= 9;6 355<:25 39B 2F@529:2 @9 672 C36624 395 67242>;42 672 4@A<938 73= 4@D768B 5@=C@==25 672 3??8@:36@;9 >@825 =22H@9D 6; ?4;5<:25 :2463@9 5;:<C296= 6 @= 38=; 34D<25 AB 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3??234@9D >;4 672 :83@C396 6736 672 3E345 ;> - 8 - :;C?29=36@;9 42K<@42= 6; A2 29739:25 @9 67@= 3??238 395 3::;45@9D8B=;<D76>;4@9624>2429:2;>67@=;<46 96728@D76;>672=<AC@==@;9C352AB6728234925 :;<9=283??234@9D>;4672?346@2=@6@=9;6@95@=?<626736672 ;::<4429:2 ;> 672 3::@5296 ;9 -. + E7242@9 672 53<D7624 ;> 672 :83@C396= I 393C3EE3 5@25 @9 672 3882D25 3::@529624<=38;>672;4@D@93842:;45E;<85@95@:3626736672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 73= >@825 39 3??8@:36@;9 @9 ;) <9524 4524 <82 .;>=22H@9D5@42:6@;96;67242=?;95296 ; ;E924;>672<6;4@:H=73E6;?4;5<:2672:;?B;>672 54@F@9D8@:29:2395?346@:<834=;>672F27@:823956723??8@:36@;9 :3C2 6; A2 5@=C@==25 ;9 + 72423>624 672 C36624 E3=72345395?;=625>;4,<5DC2963H@9D@96;:;9=@52436@;9 672 423=;9= 3==@D925 AB 672 4@A<938 E7242 672 3>;42C296@;925 5;:<C296= 342 672 ?<A8@: 5;:<C296= 395 67242>;42 672 4@A<938 @= G<=6@>@25 @9 5@=C@==@9D 672 =3@5 3??8@:36@;9 395 6736 3?346 9; 2F@529:2 73= A229 355<:25 AB 672 9=<439:2 :;C?39B 3= 6; 5@=?<62 672 3>;42C296@;925 5;:<C296= 96736F@2E;>672C36624672>@95@9D42:;4525AB 672 4@A<938 @9=;>34 3= 672 8@3A@8@6B @= :;9:24925 @= G<=6 395 - 9 - ?4;?24 9=;>343=672K<396<C;>:;C?29=36@;9@=:;9:24925 672 52:23=25 393C3EE3 E3= 3D25 3A;<6 B234= 395 67242>;42 672 3??4;?4@362 C<86@?8@24 E;<85 A2 M N ;88;E@9D 67252:83436@;9;>83EC352AB;9NA82<?42C2;<46@9672 :3=2 ;> 42?;4625 @9 ! !" .0 ;> 672@9:;C2@=6;A2355256;E345=><6<42?4;=?2:6=@9:2672 3::@5296 @= ;> 672 B234 + 395 >;88;E@9D 672 D<@528@92= 83@5 5;E9AB672349363H32D3824F@:2=<67;4@6B672@9:;C2;> 67252:23=25@=6;A263H2936 = %?24C;96729:2 6728;==;>52?29529:B@=:38:<836253=<9524& = %O.0 =. %P = .)% = .)%Q Q P =)--'% @9:267252:23=25@=3=?@9=6240;>672@9:;C2@=6; A2525<:6256;E345=724?24=;9382L?29=2= 29:26728;==;>52?29529:BE;<85A2 = .-% 72 :83@C396= 342 ?34296= ;> 672 52:23=25 395 3::;45@9D8B 672 :83@C396 ;= 395 342 296@6825 6; - 10 - =.%23:76;E345=8;==;>:;9=;46@<C::;45@9D8B672 :83@C396=342296@6825>;46;638:;C?29=36@;93=>;88;E=& 8; 235=;>:;C?29=36@;9 C;<96 ;==;>52?29529:B = .-% ;==;>:;9=;46@<C Q =.% =% ;638 = '-% ) ::;45@9D8B672>;88;E@9D& ! @ ;) % 395 ;).% >@825AB672 9=<439:2:;C?39B342 5@=C@==25* @@ ;.-%) >@825 AB 672 :83@C396=@=388;E25@9?346* @@@ 72 :83@C396= @9 ;.-%) 342296@6825>;46;638:;C?29=36@;9;> = '-% 38;9DE@67@96242=6366724362;>'0?24399<C>4;C 672 5362 ;> ?26@6@;9 6@88 672 5362 ;> 4238@J36@;9 3= 3D3@9=6 =+)%3E34525AB6724@A<93872 42=?;95296 9=<439:2:;C?39B@=5@42:6256;52?;=@6 672:;C?29=36@;93C;<9638;9DE@67@96242=6E@67@9 3?24@;5;>=@LE22H=>4;C6725362;>67@=;4524 - 11 - @F 9 F@2E ;> 672 ;4524 53625 -+) 672:83@C396=3429;6296@6825>;4@96242=6>;43?24@;5 ;> +. 53B= @9 >@8@9D 672 3??238 @9 ;.-%) "+ ("!"* $! @=6;& 8;& - &