Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54646 (KAR)
SHOBHA AND ORS v. NARAYAN AND ORS
MFA/203745/2023 · 2026-01-22
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54646 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54646 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" " ##$
##%& %'
" ("!& $$#$ $!$))! *+
$!$))! "
! #
" #
$ $ %& %
$
$
$ $ %' %
& $
$ $ %" %
&
#
$ $! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
()*'"
! ! # % %
$
! %& %
! $ %&' %
! $ %+ %
()
", &
", '*' ! ! ! &'"! &"' #
"-
./0 '&''" 1 "
2
"
- 3 -
"
" #
$ $ %
$
$ $ %
& $
$ $
" %
(
! #
"
! # + %
! & %
! $ &
! $ &" %
(*'"
- 4 -
*'"
,
"''+' "# 3
"! &'"! # "+'&'"*
"'"
(
# #
'**'
3
#
%
% 4
!& #
" /56789/:/56;/7<=>;?/:?0=689/@568A/? 9/?/5@@/5:?56/56A?A;B=>8=089/>7BC/;85;7 5.567758/7"+'&'"*@5??/7A; ="'=;89/0A:/ =0 89/ 77A8A=;5: /;A=6 ADA: >7B/ 5;7 A756 0=6 ?9=68 E89/ 86AF>;5:3! 5.567A;B <=C@/;?58A=; 8= 89/ <:5AC5;8? - 5 -
& =6 89/ ?5G/ <=;D/;A/;</ 89/ @568A/? .A:: F/ 6/0/66/78=5?@/689/A665;GA;BF/0=6/89/86AF>;5:
8 A? 89/ <5?/ =0 89/ <:5AC5;8? 8958 89/ <:5AC5;8? 56/89/:/B5:6/@6/?/;858AD/?=089/7/</5?/7>G565C/?G/H .9=7A/7=;'&''"7>6A;B89/<=>6?/=0/C@:=HC/;88A? ?858/789586/?@=;7/;8="A?89/=.;/6=089/865<8=6F/56A;B 6/BA?8658A=; =$&*"* 5;7 =; '&''" @>6?>5;8 8= 89/7A6/<8A=;A??>/7FH6/?@=;7/;8="89/7/</5?/7>G565C .5? 865D/::A;B A; 89/ 865<8=6 8= 8A:: 89/ :5;7? =0 =;/ $6A?9;5 #5BB/8A?89/<5?/=089/<:5AC5;8?8958.9/;89/7/</5?/7 >G565C.5?8A::A;B89/:5;789/865<8=69578>6;/78>68:/5;7 5?56/?>:8=089/?5C/89/9>?F5;7=089/<:5AC5;8="7A/7 A; 89/ 5<<A7/;8 /;</ 89/ <:5AC5;8? @6/0/66/7
="'"?//GA;B<=C@/;?58A=;
08/6 ?/6DA</ =0 ;=8A</ 89/ 6/?@=;7/;8 /;8/6/7 5@@/565;</ 5;7 0A:/7 7/85A:/7 .6A88/; ?858/C/;8 ; =67/6 8= /?85F:A?9 89/A6 <5?/ 89/ <:5AC5;8 =" 9/6?/:0 /I5CA;/7 5? #"5;7@6=7></7""7=<>C/;8?5;789/?5C/./6/C56G/7 5? I" 8= I"" = =65: =6 7=<>C/;8 /DA7/;</ .5? 577></7FH89/6/?@=;7/;8?A7/9/:/56;/7 =CCA??A=;/6FH
- 6 -
>7BC/;8 5;7 5.567 758/7 "+'&'"* 5::=./7 89/ <:5AC @/8A8A=; A;@568 FH 5.567A;B <=C@/;?58A=; =0 ?&"' 5:=;B .A89 A;8/6/?8 58 89/ 658/ =0 "- @/6 5;;>C 06=C '&''" 508/6 /I@A6H =0 =;/ C=;89 06=C 89/ 758/ =0 89/ 5<<A7/;8 8A:: A8? 6/5:AJ58A=; //:A;B 5BB6A/D/7 FH 05?8/;A;B 89/ :A5FA:A8H=;89/6/?@=;7/;8=8=A;7/C;A0H89/=.;/6=089/ D/9A<:/A;K>/?8A=;89/;?>65;</<=C@5;H95?@6/0/66/7
='"&*'"*<95::/;BA;B89/:A5FA:A8H5;7K>5;8>C;89/ =89/695;789/<:5AC5;8?95D/@6/0/66/7 ='&L'& ?//GA;B/;95;</C/;8=089/<=C@/;?58A=;
+ 9A? =>68 DA7/ =67/6 758/7 '""' 95? 0=6C>:58/789/0=::=.A;B?>F?85;8A5:K>/?8A=;?=0:5.%
,
!"# $%"& ' (
,
- 7 -
L 6A 5;M5H =?9A :/56;/7 <=>;?/: 5@@/56A;B 0=6 89/;?>65;</<=C@5;H?>FCA88/7895889/7/</5?/7>G565C /?G/H.5??A88A;B5:=;B.A8989/76AD/6A;89/865<8=65;789/6/ .5?;==<<5?A=;0=689/7/</5?/78=?A85:=;B.A8989/76AD/6A; 89/865<8=6.9/6/89/?/58A;B<5@5<A8HA?=;:H0=689/76AD/6=0 89/865<8=65;789/6/0=6/?>FCA88/7895889/6/A?DA=:58A=;=0 89/8/6C?5;7<=;7A8A=;?=089/@=:A<H8A?5:?=56B>/7FH89/ :/56;/7 <=>;?/: 0=6 89/ ;?>65;</ <=C@5;H8958 89/ 5.567 =0 <=C@/;?58A=; A? =; 89/ 9AB9/6 ?A7/ .9A<9 6/K>A6/? 8= F/ A;8/60/6/7FH89A? =>68
* /6 <=;865 :/56;/7 <=>;?/: 5@@/56A;B 0=6 89/ <:5AC5;8?M>?8A0A/789/AC@>B;/7>7BC/;85;75.5675?8=89/ :A5FA:A8H5;70>689/6<=;8/;7/7895889/5.567=0<=C@/;?58A=;
A?C/5B/65;76/K>A6/?8=F//;95;</7FH89A? =>68
;89/:AB98=089/?>FCA??A=;?C57/FH89/:/56;/7 <=>;?/:?0=689/@568A/?A8A?;=8A;7A?@>8/895889/7/</5?/7 >G565C /?G/H .5?
865D/::A;B A; 5 865<8=6 5;7 C/8 .A89 5; 5<<A7/;8=;'&''"7>6A;B89/<=>6?/=0/C@:=HC/;8.A89 89/ 6/?@=;7/;8 =" 9/ K>/?8A=;? 8= F/ 5;?./6/7 A; 89/?/ 5@@/5:? 56/ 5? 8= .9/89/6 89/ 8/6C? 5;7 <=;7A8A=;? =0 89/
- 8 -
@=:A<H 56/ DA=:58/7 =6 ;=8 ; 89A? 6/B567 A8 A? 6/:/D5;8 8= C/;8A=; 89/ >7BC/;8 =0 89/ =;3F:/ >@6/C/ =>68 A; 89/ <5?/=0 A;
7A?@=?/7=0=;'''"*5;7A;89/ <5?/ =0 ! "#
$ % &! '( )' 6/@=68/7 A; % *+ .9/6/A; A; 89/ A7/;8A<5:
<A6<>C?85;</? .9/6/ 89/ A;M>6H7/589 .5? 95@@/;/7 =; 5<<=>;8 =0 89/ 5<<A7/;8 A; 89/ 865<8=6 5;7 A; 89/ 50=6/C/;8A=;/7 >7BC/;8? 89/ =;3F:/ >@6/C/ =>68 95? 7A6/<8/7 89/ ;?>65;</ <=C@5;H 8= ?58A?0H 89/ <:5AC =0 89/ <:5AC5;8? 5;7 89/6/508/6 6/<=D/689/ ?5C/06=C 89/=.;/6 =0 89/D/9A<:/A;K>/?8A=;
"' ; 89/ <5?/ =0 6/0/66/7 ?>@65 89/ A;M>6/7 .5? ?85;7A;B =; 89/ 9==G A; F/8.//; 89/ 865<8=6 5;7 865A:/6 5GA;B A;8= <=;?A7/658A=; 89/ >7BC/;8 =0 89/ =;3F:/ >@6/C/ =>68 6/0/66/7 8= 5F=D/ 5C =0 89/ DA/. 8958 89/ <=;8/;8A=;? 65A?/7 FH 89/ :/56;/7 <=>;?/: 5@@/56A;B 0=6 89/ ;?>65;</ <=C@5;H <5;;=8 F/ 5<</@8/7 8= 5F?=:D/ 89/ ;?>65;</ <=C@5;H 8= ?58A?0H 89/ <:5AC /;</ 5C =0 89/ DA/. 8958 A; 89/ /D/;8 =0 89/ DA=:58A=; =0 89/ 8/6C? 5;7
- 9 -
<=;7A8A=;?=089/@=:A<H89/;?>65;</<=C@5;H95?8=?58A?0H 89/ <:5AC 5;789/6/508/6 6/<=D/6 89/ ?5C/ 06=C 89/=.;/6 =0 89/D/9A<:/A;K>/?8A=;
"" 9/6/:/D5;805<8=65?@/6<9/7>:/=089/<80=6 89/ 5B/ =0 89/ 7/</5?/7 A? "L'+ 5GA;B A;8= <=;?A7/658A=; 89/C=;89:HA;<=C/=089/7/</5?/758?*'''5?@/689/ 6/:/D5;8 ;=8A0A<58A=; 5? =; 89/ 758/ =0 89/ 5<<A7/;8 89/ <:5AC5;8 A? /;8A8:/7 0=6 8=85: <=C@/;?58A=; =0 ?L**' ?*''' CA;>? '- N ?''' 1 "L'+! 5:=;B .A89 A;8/6/?8 58 89/ 658/ =0 "- @/6 5;;>C 06=C 89/ 758/ =0 5<<A7/;8 A/ '&''" 8A::
A8? 6/5:AJ58A=; <<=67A;B:H ?>F?85;8A5:K>/?8A=;A?5;?./6/7
" /;</@5??89/0=::=.A;B% #
A! @@/5:?56/5::=./7A;@568,
AA! 9/ >7BC/;8 5;7 5.567 758/7
"+'&'"* A; ="'=; 89/ 0A:/ =0 89/ 77A8A=;5:/;A=6 ADA:>7B/5;7 =>68A756 A?9/6/FHC=7A0A/7,
- 10 -
AAA! 9/;?>65;</<=C@5;HA?7A6/<8/78=@5H 89/ <=C@/;?58A=; =0 ?L**' 5:=;B .A89 A;8/6/?85889/658/=0"-@/65;;>C06=C89/758/ =0 5<<A7/;8 A/ '&''" 8A:: A8? 6/5:AJ58A=; 5;7 89/6/508/6 6/<=D/6 89/ ?5C/ 06=C 89/ =.;/6 =0 89/ D/9A<:/A;K>/?8A=;0=689.A89
$- *$#$+ & #
D9 A?8=%":=%