Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54635 (KAR)
SHERU SAHEB @ SYED SALAUDDIN v. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
MFA/203108/2024 · 2026-01-14
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54635 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54635 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#! $$
%&' (
!" #$%$&'&
(
! ! #&)#'%&
! #$*+&+,
(
! &*&! ! ! +*$,',, '#'%#,',
! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
-
! & ./0 122314 /0 5/637835 191/:08 8.3 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>16551835''%,',210035/:!?+*$?@,',, AB 8.3 6/:7/214 3:/?6 /C/4 <593 1:5 ?8?6 77/53:8 41/=0 6/A<:14 141A<619/ @?6 0.?68
>.363AB7?=23:018/?:?@0%*)''#>/8./:83630818 D2361::<=1>16535/:@1C?<6?@8.3741/=1:8 , .3A6/3@@1780?@8.371031638.18?:')',,'& 8.3741/=1:8=38>/8.16?15861@@/7177/53:85<38?8.3 610.1:5:394/93:856/C/:9?@8.3?@@3:5/:9A<0A316/:9 639/08618/?:?#&)#'%&
8/014439358.188.301/5 A<0 510.35 191/:08 8.3 741/=1:8 1:5 10 1 630<48 ?@ >./7..30<081/:3596/3C?<0/:;<6/30
==35/1834B1@836 8.3 177/53:8 8.3 741/=1:8 >10 0./@835 8? 3:4?7E ?02/814 1:914?63 @?6 86318=3:8 1:5 8.3631@836 741/=1:80./@8358?/9.3668.?235/71:5 .B0/?8.3612B 3:83618?412<6@?6@<68.3686318=3:8?:83:5/:98.18
- 3 -
8.3 177/53:8 ?77<6635 0?434B 5<3 8? 8.3 610. 1:5 :394/93:8 56/C/:9 ?@ 8.3 ?@@3:5/:9 C3./743 8.3 741/=1:8 @/435741/=238/8/?:033E/:97?=23:018/?:
: /00<1:73 ?@ :?8/73 8.3 6302?:53:8F
:0<61:73 ?=21:B 3:83635 1223161:73 1:5 @/435 /80 >6/883:
08183=3:8 53:B/:9 8.3 1C36=3:80 =153 /: 8.3 741/= 238/8/?: + : ?6536 8? 0<A081:8/183 ./0 741/= 8.3 741/=1:8 3G1=/:35 ./=034@ 10 #& 1:5 3G1=/:35 8.3 86318/:9 ?78?610 #,1:5=16E35,&5?7<=3:8010G0 &8? ,&.36302?:53:803G1=/:3556/C36?@8.3A<0 10 #& 1:5 5/5 :?8 26?5<73 1:B 5?7<=3:816B 3C/53:73 $ .3 6/A<:14 @61=35 1226?26/183 /00<30 @?6 /80 7?:0/53618/?: 1:5 <2?: 122637/18/?: ?@ 8.3 ?614 1:5 5?7<=3:816B 3C/53:73 ?: 637?65 AB /80 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 51835 ''%,', 1>16535 7?=23:018/?: ?@
- 4 -
0%*)''#>/8./:83630818D2361::<=@6?=8.3 5183?@238/8/?:8/446314/H18/?:
3/:9 5/0018/0@/35 >/8. 8.3 I<1:8<= ?@ 7?=23:018/?:1>16535AB8.36/A<:148.3741/=1:8.10 263@366358.326303:8122314033E/:93:.1:73=3:8 * .1C3.31656/6<211916 18/44316:357?<:034 122316/:9@?68.31223441:8F741/=1:81:56/1.1:830. 18/4 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 @?6 8.3 6302?:53:8F :0<61:73?=21:B1:5236<0358.3637?650 % 6/ 6<21 1916 18/4 4316:35 7?<:034 @?6 8.3 1223441:8/:C/8358.31883:8/?:?@8./0?<688?21619612. , ?@ 8.3 /=2<9:35 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 1:5 8? 8.3 532?0/8/?:?@ #,8.386318/:9?78?61:57?:83:535 8.188.3741/=1:8.100<@@36351=2<818/?:?@8.343@8439 A34?> 8.3 E:33 1:5 8.18 8.3 6/A<:14 .10 @1/435 8? 26?2364B 100300 8.3 @<:78/?:14 5/01A/4/8B 1:5 4?00 ?@ @<8<63 316:/:9 71217/8B .3 4316:35 7?<:034 241730
- 5 -
634/1:73?:8.3;<59=3:8?@8.3?:JA43<263=3?<68 /:/C/422314?,,&?@,',$537/535?:&&',,',$ 1:5 /:/C/42214?)''?@ ,', 537/535 ?: '+'*,', 1:5 7?:83:535 8.18 8.3 741/=1:8>.?>10>?6E/:91014?66B7431:36/03:8/8435 @?63:.1:73=3:8?@7?=23:018/?: ) 36 7?:861 6/ 1.1:830. 18/4 4316:35 7?<:034 @?68.36302?:53:8F
:0<61:73?=21:B0?<9.88?;<08/@B 8.3;<59=3:81:51>165210035AB8.36/A<:14 &'
:8.34/9.8?@8.30<A=/00/?:0=153AB8.34316:35 7?<:034 @?6 8.3 2168/30 /8 /0 :?8 /: 5/02<83 8.18 8.3 177/53:8 ?77<6635 ?: ')',,'&
8 /0 140? :?8 /:
5/02<83 A1035 ?: 8.3 3C/53:73 ?@ #, 8.18 8.3 741/=1:8 .10 0<@@3635 1=2<818/?: ?@ 8.3 43@8 439 A34?> 8.3 E:33 <68.36 8.3 6/A<:14 .10 637?6535 1 74316 @/:5/:98.188.3741/=1:8>10>?6E/:91014?66B7431:36 188.38/=3?@8.3177/53:8
- 6 -
&& 1C/:9 639165 8?
8.3 :18<63 ?@ /:;<6B 0<@@3635 AB 8.3 741/=1:8 1:5 8.3 41> 53741635 AB 8.3 ?:JA43 <263=3 ?<68 /: 8.3 1@?63=3:8/?:35 537/0/?:0 >.363/: /: 8.3 71030 ?@ 1=2<818/?: ?@ 1 4/=A 8.3 @<:78/?:14 5/01A/4/8B .10 A33: 10030035 18 1 ./9.36 23673:8193 1:5 8.363@?63 8./0 ?<68 /0 ?@ 8.3 7?:0/53635 ?2/:/?: 8.18 8.3 236=1:3:8 5/01A/4/8B >?<45 A31003003518)'D8?8.3>.?43A?5B &, 1E/:9 8.3 =?:8.4B /:7?=3 ?@ 8.3 741/=1:8 18 0*'''# 1224B/:9 8.3 1226?26/183 =<48/24/36 ?@ & 155/:9 +'D 8?>1650 @<8<63 26?023780 1:5 7?:0/536/:9 )'D 5/01A/4/8B 8.3 4?00 ?@ @<8<63 316:/:9 71217/8B /0 7147<4183510@?44?>0 0*''' K &, K & K )'D L 0&,')''# 55 +'D 8?>1650 @<8<63 26?023780 L 0+%%+'# )*+,-". "/
- 7 -
& 1E/:9 /:8? 7?:0/53618/?: 8.3 /01A/4/8B 368/@/7183 G #&,8.3236/?5?@.?02/814/H18/?:1:58.3:18<63 ?@ 86318=3:8 <:5369?:3 AB 8.3 741/=1:8 10 A?8. /:218/3:8 1:5 ?<8218/3:8 8.3 741/=1:8 /0 3:8/8435 8? 7?=23:018/?:<:5368.3@?44?>/:9.3150 • 1/:1:50<@@36/:9-""/ • ?00?@1=3:/8/30-""/ • ?00 ?@ /:7?=3 5<6/:9 86318=3:8 236/?5
=?:8.0-
"/0*'''K &+ .37?=23:018/?:1>16535AB8.36/A<:148?>1650 01234*+15617-1-/0;<081:526?2361:55?30:?87144 @?6/:836@363:73 &$ .<0 8.3 741/=1:8 /0 3:8/8435 8? 1: 3:.1:735 7?=23:018/?: ?@ 0&$)'%,# 0&)*%$%, F 0%*)''>/8./:836308 18 D 2361::<=@6?=8.3 5183?@238/8/?:8/446314/H18/?:
- 8 -
& 77?65/:94B 8.3 122314 /0 .3 ;<59=3:81:51>165210035AB8.36/A<:14/0=?5/@/35 8? 8.3 3G83:8 /:5/71835 1A?C3 .3 6302?:53:8# :0<61:73 ?=21:B /0 5/637835 8? 532?0/8 8.3 3:8/63 7?=23:018/?:1=?<:8>/8./:1236/?5?@0/G>33E0@6?= 8.35183?@8./0;<59=3:8
2/ %' ! /08?&4?$