- 1 - ! " #! $$ %&' ( !!"!!# $ % & '"(" ) # ! * + !& , '"("" Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ! &+ * + * !'' '"("" $ &'(!'# ! * + * ! ' & '"(" $ &'(!'# ! & - & '$ ("./ # ) + +&&& 0 0 # # + $ ' ! + ! 1 + $ * * 2 + - 3 - ! 3456.738345936:/;9<38<=/5.73>45.?3< 7?<4>>348?<>53=35536@A.734.?/948 9<;549:3 /B>49A 4<<4?8?9C .73 +;6CB39. 496 4D456 64.36 >4<<36 ?9 /! /9 .73 =?83 /= .73 66?.?/94839?/5 ?E?8+;6C3496 ?645=/5<7/5.F.73 .5?@;9481#4D456?9C:/B>39<4.?/9./.73:84?B49.< /5 .73 <4G3 /= :/9E39?39:3 .73 >45.?3< D?88 @3 53=35536./4<>35.73?5549G?9C@3=/53.73.5?@;948 .?<.73:4<3/=.73:84?B49.<@3=/53.73.5?@;948 .74./9(.73:84?B49.D4<>5/:336?9C4<4>?88?/9 5?635 /9 B/./5:A:83 @345?9C 53C?<.54.?/9 /&'(!' 48/9C D?.7 7?< =5?396 ?84< !/ ?H4AG;B45 46?C35 496 4. .74. .?B3 .73 5?635 /= 49/.735 B/./5:A:83 @345?9C 53C?<.54.?/9 /&'(!' @3?9C 65?E39 ?9 4 54<7 496 93C8?C39. B49935 64<736 ./ .73 B/./5:A:83 ?9 D7?:7 .73 :84?B49.D4<.54E388?9C<453<;8./=.73<4B3.73:84?B49. <;<.4?936 ?9H;5?3< 496 4::/56?9C8A .73 :84?B49. =?836 /! <33G?9C :/B>39<4.?/9 73 <4?6 :84?B >3.?.?/9 - 4 - D4<:/9.3<.36@A.7353<>/9639.< 9/5635./3<.4@8?<7.73?5 :4<3.73:84?B49.74<3I4B?936.D/D?.93<<3<4<$496 $ 496 C/. B45G36 " 6/:;B39.< 4< I ./ I" 7353<>/9639.<74E33I4B?936.D/D?.93<<3<4<$496 $496C/.B45G36 6/:;B39.<4<I./I 73 5?@;948 4=.35 :/9<?635?9C .73 B4.35?48 /9 53:/56 @A ?.< +;6CB39. 496 4D456 64.36 488/D36 .73 :84?B >3.?.?/9?9>45.4964D45636:/B>39<4.?/9/=< "!' 48/9C D?.7 ?9.353<. 4. .73 54.3 /= J >35 499;B =5/B .73 64.3/=>3.?.?/9.?885348?K4.?/9 .?<48</./@39/.36.74..73 5?@;948 <466836 .73 8?4@?8?.A ./ 49 3I.39. /= "J 34:7 /9 @/.7.73E37?:83<?9E/8E36?9.73:4<339:3.7?<4>>348?< >53=35536@A.734>>38849.' 9<;549:3:/B>49A " 3456 5? ;645<749 8345936 :/;9<38 4>>345?9C =/5 .73 4>>38849. 5? +4?54H &;GG4 496 5? <>488?8345936:/;9<38=/5.7353<>/9639./ 5?;645<749 8345936:/;9<384>>345?9C=/5 .73 4>>38849. :/9.39.36 .74. .73 .5?@;94874<:/BB?..36 49 355/5?9455?E?9C4.4:/9:8;<?/9.74.@/.7.73E37?:83<74E3 - 5 - :/9.5?@;.36 =/5 .73 4883C36 4::?639. 7/D3E35 .73 4883C36 4::?639. /::;5536 6;3 ./ .73 /==396?9C B/./5:A:83 496 .73 <4?64<>3:./=.73B4..35D4<9/.>5/>358A:/9<?63536@A.73 5?@;948 496 4::/56?9C8A </;C7. =/5 ?9.35=3539:3 /= .7?< /;5. .?<48</45C;36@A.738345936:/;9<384>>345?9C=/5 .734>>38849..74..735?635/=.73?9<;536B/./5:A:83@345?9C 53C?<.54.?/9/&'(!'D4<9/.7/86?9C65?E?9C8?:39:3 4. .73 .?B3 /= 65?E?9C .73 B/./5:A:83 496 .7353=/53 </;C7. =/5?9.35=3539:3/=.7?< /;5. .?<48</45C;36@A.73:/;9<38 4>>345?9C=/5.734>>38849..74..734D456/=:/B>39<4.?/9 ?</9.737?C735<?63496.73.5?@;94874<35536?94D456?9C J>35499;B4<.73?9.353<.?9</=454<.73:/B>39<4.?/9 4D45636D7?:753L;?53<./@3?9.35=3536D?.7?9.7?<4>>348 35 :/9.54 5? <>488? 8345936 :/;9<38 4>>345?9C =/5 .73 53<>/9639. / </;C7. ./ H;<.?=A .73 ?B>;C936 +;6CB39. 496 4D456 >4<<36 @A .73 5?@;948 84?B49. /< 496 <35E36 D?.7 .73 9/.?:3 496 53B4?936 4@<39. - 6 - ( 9 .73 8?C7. /= .73 <;@B?<<?/9< B463 @A .73 8345936:/;9<38<4>>345?9C=/5.73>45.?3<?.?<9/.?96?<>;.3 4<./.73/::;5539:3/=.734::?639./9(?9D7?:7 .73 :84?B49. <;<.4?936 C5?3E/;< ?9H;5?3< 4< >35 I 496 I .?<.73:/9.39.?/9/=.738345936:/;9<384>>345?9C =/5 .73 4>>38849. .74. .7353 ?< 6?<>;.3 D?.7 53C456 ./ .73 65?E?9C8?:39:3/=.73E37?:83?9L;3<.?/9 9.7?<53C456/9 :453=;8:/9<?6354.?/9/=.73=?96?9C53:/5636@A.735?@;948 /9 <<;3/D7353?9.735?@;94874<5?C7.8A93C4.36.73 :/9.39.?/9< 54?<36 .7353?9 496 .7353=/53 4B /= .73 E?3D .74.<4B3:499/.@3?9.35=3536D?.7?9.7?<4>>348 /D3E35?9</=454<.734D456/=:/B>39<4.?/9?< :/9:35936.735?@;9484=.35:/9<?635?9C.7339.?53B4.35?48 53:/56 74< 5?C7.8A 4D45636 :/B>39<4.?/9 ./ .73 :84?B49. D7?:753L;?53<./@3:/9=?5B36?9.7?<4>>348 .?<48</./@3 9/.36.74..73>35;<48/=.73=?96?9C53:/5636@A.735?@;948 4.>454C54>7/B4G3<?.:8345.74.@/.7.73B/./5:A:83< 74E3 :/9.5?@;.36 =/5 .73 4883C36 4::?639. ?9 D7?:7 .73 :84?B49. 74< <;<.4?936 ?9H;5?3< 496 ?9 .74. E?3D /= .73 B4..35 .73 :/9.5?@;./5A 93C8?C39:3 =4<.3936 /9 @/.7 .73 - 7 - E37?:83<@A.735?@;94853L;?53<./@3:/9=?5B36/D3E35 ?9</=45 4< .73 :/9.39.?/9 /= .73 8345936 :/;9<38 4>>345?9C =/5 .73 4>>38849. 4< ./ .73 4D456 /= ?9.353<. 4. .73 54.3 /= J?<:/9:35936 =?96=/5:3?9.73<;@B?<<?/9B463@A.73 8345936:/;9<384>>345?9C=/5.734>>38849..74..735?@;948 74< :/BB?..36 49 355/5 ?9 9/. :/9<?635?9C .73 >53E4?8?9C @49G?9.353<.6;5?9C.735383E49.>35?/6 9.74.E?3D/=.73 B4..35 4B /= .73 E?3D .74. .73 5?@;948 /;C7. ./ 74E3 4D45636 ?9.353<. 4. .73 54.3 /= J >4 ?9 53<>3:. /= .73 :/B>39<4.?/94B/;9.4D45636=5/B.7364.3/=>3.?.?/9.?88 5348?K4.?/9 / .74. 3I.39. .73 4>>348 ?< 7353@A ?9.35=3536 D?.7.73?B>;C936+;6CB39.4964D456 39:3 >4<<.73=/88/D?9C* ?# 734>>348?<488/D36?9'>45.0 ??# 73 +;6CB39. 496 4D456 64.36 ?9 /! /9 .73 =?83 /= 66?.?/948 39?/5 ?E?8 +;6C3 496 ?645 ?< 7353@A<3.4<?63?953<>3:./=4D456?9C/=?9.353<. - 8 - 4. .73 54.3 /= J >4 ?9<.346 /= J >4 /9 .73 :/B>39<4.?/94D45636@A.735?@;9480 ???# / ?9.35=3539:3 ?< :48836 =/5 ?9</=45 4< .73 4>>/5.?/9B39. /= 8?4@?8?.A 496 4D456?9C :/B>39<4.?/9./.73:84?B49.<?<:/9:359360 ?E# 73 4B/;9. ?9 63>/<?. @3 .549<B?..36 ./.73.5?@;948=/5.7D?.7 )* %' ! ?<./*8/*( *&