Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54619 (KAR)
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. FATHRUSAB AND ANR
MFA/201978/2018 · 2026-01-19
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54619 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54619 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#! $$
%&'
(
! ! " #! ! $
%! %
&
' ! '
&
& %(
%
)*+ ! '
"
#! (
,
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*''
'
$
)#$ ! ( +'
! ( ''+ ! ! ! (
%
% - (
! ./0123.4./05.167859.49:7023.;/02<.9 ' 3<9 /;;./4 <9 /0<9<5= 782 7: 23. (81=>.52 /51 /?/011/2.1+';/99.1<5
7''+7523. :<4. 7: 23. 11<2<75/4 .5<70
<@<4 (81=. /51 114 <1/0#:7093702A23.20<B85/4C$/?/01<5=67>;.59/2<753<9 /;;./4 <9 :<4.1 BD 23. 5980/56. 67>;/5D /99/<4<5= 23. E8/528>7:67>;.59/2<75/?/01.1BD23.20<B85/4
0</5@.510/.11D4./05.167859.4/;;./0<5= :7023./;;.44/5298B><22.123/223.20<B85/43/967>><22.1 /5 .0070 <5 18;4<6/2<75 7: 23. >.1<6/4 B<449 /51 <5@<2.1 23. /22.52<757:23. 78022723.;/0/=0/;377:23./?/01 >/1. BD 23. 20<B85/4 2 <9 /497 /0=8.1 BD 23. 4./05.1
- 3 -
67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. /;;.44/52 23/2 23. /?/01 7:
67>;.59/2<75 851.0 23. 3./1 A:8280. >.1<6/4 .F;.59.9C <9 0.E8<0.1 27 B. <52.0:.0.1 ?<23 /9 ?.44 /9 23. /?/01 7: <52.0.92 /2 23. 0/2. 7: *G ;.0 /558> <9 75 23. 3<=3.0 9<1. /51 572 ?<23 0.9;.62 27 23. B/5H <52.0.92 ;0.@/<4<5= 180<5=
23. 9/<1 ;.0<71 7: /66<1.52 /51 23.0.:70. 978=32 :70 <52.0:.0.56.7:23<9
7802
.0 67520/ 0< /9/@/0/I /23 4./05.1 67859.4/;;./0<5=:7023.0.9;751.527978=3227I892<:D 23.<>;8=5.1(81=>.52/51/?/01;/99.1BD23.20<B85/4
5 23. 4<=32 7: 23. 98B><99<75 >/1. BD 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. ;/02<.9 /51 75 6/0.:84 6759<1.0/2<757:23.0.6701?7841<51<6/2.23/223.0.<957 1<9;82./92723.766800.56.7:23./66<1.5275'+*' ?3.0.<5 23. 64/<>/520.9;751.52 7 3.0.<5 98::.0.1 =0<.@789<5I80<.9/@<5=2/H.5572.7:23.98B><99<75>/1. BD23.4./05.167859.4:7023.;/02<.9:785123/223.0.<9 /18;4<6/2<757:>.1<6/4B<4427/5.F2.527:9''/51 23.0.:70. 23. >.1<6/4 .F;.59.9 /?/01.1 BD 23. 20<B85/4 <9 9'+* /H<5= <527 6759<1.0/2<75 23. .@<1.56. - 4 -
/1186.1 BD 23. ;/02<.9 23. :8280. >.1<6/4 .F;.59.9 67841 5723/@.B..5/?/01.1BD23.20<B85/4523/2@<.?7:23. >/22.0 :<51 :706. <5 23. 98B><99<75 >/1. BD 23.4./05.1 67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. /;;.44/52 27 1.1862 9'' :07>23.3./1A>.1<6/4.F;.59.9C/51:8023.023.64/<>/52<9 572.52<24.1:7067>;.59/2<75851.023.3./1A:8280.>.1<6/4 .F;.59.9C <. 9 /?/01.1 BD 23. 20<B85/4 .56. 23.64/<>/52<9.52<24.1:70272/467>;.59/2<757:/9851.0% ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412
.1<6/4.F;.59.9 9'+* ' /<5/5198::.0<5=9 9'
7997:/>.5<2<.9 9'
7997:.F;.62/2<757:4<:. 9'
2+) -5"
"6
+ 597:/0/923./?/017:<52.0.92<96756.05.123. 20<B85/4 3/9 .F.06<9.1 <29 1<960.2<75 BD /?/01<5=<52.0.92/2
23. 0/2. 7: *G ;.0 /558> 37?.@.0 2/H<5= <527 6759<1.0/2<7523.B/5H<52.0.92:7023.0.4.@/52;.0<71/> 7: 23. @<.? 23/2 23. 20<B85/4 78=32 27 3/@. 2/H.5 +G ;.0 /558> /9 <52.0.92 27 B. /?/01.1 27 23. 64/<>/52 :07> 23. 1/2. 7: 23. ;.2<2<75 2<44 0./4<J/2<75 7: 23. 67>;.59/2<75 />7852
- 5 -
) 66701<5=4D23.:7447?<5=701.0%
#<$ 3./;;./4<9/447?.1<5;/02,
#<<$
3. 67>;.59/2<75 />7852 /?/01.1 BD 23.20<B85/4<90./99.99.1/51>71<:<.1, #<<<$
3. 64/<>/52 <9 .52<24.1 :70 272/4 67>;.59/2<75 7: 9'* /475= ?<23 <52.0.92 /2 23. 0/2. 7: +G ;.0 /558> :07> 23. 1/2. 7:
;.2<2<75 2<44 23. 1/2. 7: 0./4<J/2<75 /9 /=/<592 9/?/01.1BD23.20<B85/4,
#<@$
3. />7852 1.;79<2.1 BD 23.
5980/56. 67>;/5D B.:70. 23<9
7802 93/44 B. 20/59><22.1 27 23.20<B85/4:7023?<23
,6 %' ! <927% 47%