Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54618 (KAR)
THE BRANCH MANAGER v. JETTEPPA AND ORS
MFA/202293/2018 · 2026-01-22
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54618 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54618 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
# $!! $! !% ##
&%' () ## * &%'
(
)
!"
! #
! $ %
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
'
$('
)! * +,",!-! , . ' * /,",!-! #
)
./$$/-"-
. )
(!0$(' )
!0 ,/
) ) $
)
#
*
#
$-!-"
$$&!-,
*(
)
!&
! #
! - 3 -
$ %
-
'
"
$' )
! *
. . '! ( *
#
) ./$$/-"-
! )) $
) &"" # ) # ) ,$,-/
# ) !1 )
# $-!-"
$$&!-,
- 4 -
)
#
2
2
%! 2
)3!-!!&$!-"456 )3!---$!-&478 9:;86 <= >?8 :5@A787 456 >?8 B;4:C45>@ 78@D8B>:E8;= B?4;;85F:5F >?8 GA45>AC 39 B3CD85@4>:35 456 ;:4<:;:>= >3 D4= >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 4H47686 <= >?8 85:37 :E:; A6F8 456 66:>:354;
?4?4DA7 937 @?37> I7:<A54;J :5
3$$&!-, E:68 KA6FC85> 456 4H476 64>86 $-!-" ! B;4:CD8>:>:35H4@9:;86A56878B>:3539 >?8 3>37 8?:B;8@ B> &"" B;4:C:5F B3CD85@4>:35 39 @"-----/ <= >?8 ;8F4; 78D78@85>4>:E8@ 39 >?8 68B84@86 4@?4CC4 H?3 6:86 :5 4 7346>7499:B 4BB:685> 35 --'!-, H?85 @?8 H4@ >74E8;:5F :5 4 :4FF:3 D8 4A>3<847:5F78F:@>74>:353./$$/-"-
- 5 -
$ ?8B;4:CD8>:>:35H4@B35>8@>86<=>?8:5@A787 H?3 685:86 >?8 4BB:685> 456 :>@ ;:4<:;:>= >3 D4= B3CD85@4>:35 4@86 35 >?8 4<3E8 >?8 7:<A54; ?8;6 D73B886:5F@ 456 78B37686 >?8 8E:685B8 39 B;4:C45> 3 4@ #/ 456 C47L86 63BAC85>@ M@ >3 ?8 3H58739>?8399856:5FE8?:B;8H4@8M4C:5864@#456 C47L8663BAC85>@4@M@>3,
' 4@86 35 >?8 374; 456 63BAC85>47= 8E:685B8 >?8 7:<A54; ?8;6 >?4> >?8 4BB:685> H4@ 6A8 >3 >?8 74@? 45658F;:F85>67:E:5F<=>?867:E8739>?84A>3>9A7>?87 ?8;6 >?4> >?8 68B84@86 4@?4CC4 H4@ 4 B33;:8 456 >?8789378 4DD;:86 53>:354; :5B3C8 456 68>87C:586 >?8 B3CD85@4>:354@93;;3H@
+
,-./ 0123
3@@393E84564998B>:35 @-----/ ! )33645653A7:@?C85> @----/ $ 74E8;:5F8MD85@8@ @----/ ' 3@@39:5B3C86A7:5F >784>C85>D87:36 @---/ , >>85645>B?47F8@ @---/
- 6 -
86:B4;8MD85@8@ @!!,-/
)A5874;8MD85@8@ @$----/
3-+ /
"
" 4(
, ?8 7:<A54; 6:78B>86 >?8 :5@A787 >3 D4= >?8 B3CD85@4>:354;35FH:>?:5>878@>8:5F4FF7:8E86<=>?8 GA45>AC39B3CD85@4>:354H47686<3>?>?8B;4:C45>@4@ H8;;4@>?8:5@A787478:5>?8:778@D8B>:E84DD84;@
?8 ;847586 B3A5@8; 937 >?8 B;4:C45>@ B35>85686 >?4> 8E85 >?3AF? >?8= ?4E8 B;4:C86 B3CD85@4>:354@68D85685>@39>?868B84@86 4@?4CC4 >?8 7:<A54; 94:;86 >3 F745> 45= B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8 ?846I;3@@3968D85685B=J35>?8F73A56>?4>>?868B84@86 H4@ 4F86 ,- =847@ 4@ 35 >?8 64>8 39 ?87 684>?
456 B;4:C45>3456!<8:5F@3545664AF?>87/:5/;4H39>?8 68B84@86 H878 53> 68D85685>@ 35 >?8 :5B3C8 39 >?8 68B84@86937>?8:7;:E8;:?336?87:<A54;4H47686>3>4;
B3CD85@4>:35 39 @!!!,-/ A5687 E47:3A@ ?846@ <A> 6:6 53> 4H476 45= B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39 68D85685B=J4569A7>?87@A<C:>>86>?4>>?87:<A54;94:;86
- 7 -
>3 4H476 468GA4>8 B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8 3>?87 B35E85>:354;?846@
;847586 B3A5@8; 937 >?8 :5@A787 B35>85686>?4>>?8B3CD85@4>:354H47686<=>?87:<A54;
:@ 8MB8@@:E8 456 685:86 :>@ ;:4<:;:>= >3 D4= :> 4@ >?8 B;4:C45>@47853>68D85685>@39>?868B84@86
" 5 D87A@4; 39 >?8 :CDAF586 KA6FC85> 456 4H476 D4@@86 <= >?8 7:<A54; :> 4DD847@ >?4> >?8 68B84@86H4@4F86,-=847@4@35>?864>839?87684>? 3H8E87 4@ @A<C:>>86 <= >?8 ;847586 B3A5@8; 937 >?8 B;4:C45>@ :> :@ A56:@DA>86 94B> >?4> >?8 68B84@86 H4@ 4 33;:84F7:BA;>A74; ;4<3A787 456 ?85B8 H3A;6 ?4E8 B35>7:<A>86 937 >?8 H8;; <8:5F 39 >?8 94C:;= 5687 >?8 B:7BAC@>45B8@ 4 53>:354; :5B3C8 39 @"---/ :@ >4L85 :5>3 4BB3A5> 456-1 39 :>:@ B35@>7A864@ ;3@@399A>A78 D73@D8B>@?A@>?8>3>4;:5B3C839>?868B84@86H3A;6 <8 @""--/ D87 C35>? @ >?8 68D85685>@ 478 C378 >?45 ' '>? 39 ?87 :5B3C8 @!!--/ @?3A;6 <8
- 8 -
686AB>86 >3H476@ ?87 D87@354; 8MD85@8@ 85B8 >?8 C35>?;= :5B3C8 39 >?8 68B84@86 937 >?8 DA7D3@8 39 B4;BA;4>:5F B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39 68D85685B=J@?4;;<8@--/5E:8H39>?8D7:5B:D;8 39;4H;4:663H5:5>?8B4@839B35@:687:5F >?8 4F8 39 >?8 68B84@86 >?8 CA;>:D;:87 4DD;:B4<;8 >3 >?8 B4@8 35 ?456 :@ I$J 85B8 >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 D4=4<;8 A5687>?8?846I;3@@3968D85685B=J@?4;;<8@--/M !M$H?:B?4C3A5>@>3@-!&--/
& )A7>?87 :5 E:8H 39 ;4H ;4:6 63H5 <= >?8 D8M 3A7> :5 >?8 B4@8 39 !" #
$% & " & ' ()
* >?8 B;4:C45>@ 3 456 ! <8:5F >?8 @35 456 64AF?>87/:5/;4H 456 >?8 B;4:C45>@ 3$ 456 ' <8:5F F7456B?:;6785 39 >?8 68B84@86 478 85>:>;86 >3 B3CD85@4>:35 39 @'----/ 84B?>3H476@9:;:4;B35@37>:AC456>?8789378>?8B;4:C45>@ 47885>:>;86>3>3>4;B3CD85@4>:3539@!-----/A5687 >?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39 B35@37>:ACJ ?8 B;4:C45>@ 478 4;@3 85>:>;86 937 45 4C3A5> 39 @,---/ 84B?
A5687 >?8
- 9 -
?846@ I;3@@ 39 8@>4>8J 456 I9A5874; 8MD85@8@J 4@ D87 >?8 68B:@:35:5>?8B4@839$%&
- )A7>?87:>:@937>?B3C:5F973C>?878B376@>?4> >?8 68B84@86 @A998786 :5KA7:8@ :5 >?8 4BB:685> 35 --'!-, 456 @?8 H4@ @?:9>86 >3 ?4?4DA74 3E875C85>3@D:>4; 9379:7@>4:6456>?87849>87@?8>33L 9A7>?87 >784>C85> 4> 5:>86 3@D:>4; .4;4<A74F: 973C --'!-,>3'-'!-,A<@8GA85>;=@?8H4@@?:9>86 >3 4>@4;=4 :98 3@D:>4; .4;4<A74F: H?878:5 @?8 >33L >784>C85>973C,-'!-,>3!$-'!-,456@?86:8635 !'-'!-, 6A8 >3 >?8 :5KA7:8@ @A@>4:586 :5 >?8 4BB:685> ?8B;4:C45>@?4E8D736AB86:@B?47F8 4764<8D37>@ , 86:B4; :;;@ 456 &' 78@B7:D>:35@ 78F476:5F >?8 >784>C85>>4L85<=>?868B84@86:5>?8?3@D:>4;@847;:87>3 ?87 684>? ?8789378 >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 F745>86 <= >?8 7:<A54; A5687 >?8 ?846@ I9336 456 53A7:@?C85>J I>74E8;:5F 8MD85@8@J I4>>85645> B?47F8@J IC86:B4;
8MD85@8@J 456 I9A5874; 8MD85@8@J 638@ 53> 78GA:78 45= C36:9:B4>:35
- 10 -
BB376:5F;=>?8B3CD85@4>:35:@78/68>87C:586 4@93;;3H@ +
,-./ 0123
3@@398D85685B= @-!&--/ ! 3@@399:;:4;B35@37>:AC @!-----/ $ )33645653A7:@?C85> @----/ ' 74E8;:5F8MD85@8@ @----/ , >>85645>B?47F8@ @---/
86:B4;8MD85@8@ @!!,-/
3@@398@>4>8 @,---/
" )A5874;MD85@8@ @,---/
3-+ /
"5"4(
! > :@ 46C:>>86 94B> >?4> >?8 4DD8;;45> :5 ) 3!-!!&$!-":@45:5@A78739>?8399856:5FE8?:B;8456 5@A745B83;:B=H4@E4;:64@35>?864>839>?84BB:685> 3H8E87 :> ?4@ B;4:C86 >?4> >?8 D3;:B= B3E8786 35;= $ D4@@85F87@<A>>?878H878,D4@@85F87@>74E8;:5F:5>?8 399856:5F E8?:B;8 4> >?8 >:C8 39 4BB:685> 456 >?8789378 >?878H4@E:3;4>:3539B356:>:35@39>?8D3;:B=39:5@A745B8 456?85B8:>H4@53>;:4<;8>3D4=45=B3CD85@4>:35
- 11 -
$ 3H8E87:>:@H8;;@8>>;86>?4>:9>?8B;4:C45>@ 478 >?:76 D47>:8@ >3 >?8 :5@A745B8 D3;:B= 8E85 :9 >?878 :@ E:3;4>:353945=B356:>:35@39D3;:B=>?8:5@A787:@;:4<;8>3 D4= B3CD85@4>:35 H:>? ;:<87>= >3 78B3E87 >?8 @4C8 973C >?8 :5@A7863H587 39 >?8 E8?:B;8 ?8789378 >?8 :5@A787 ?4@ 94:;86 >3 C4L8 3A> 45= F73A56 >3 @8> 4@:68 >?8 :CDAF586 KA6FC85> 456 4H476 39 >?8 7:<A54; :5 :>@ 85>:78>=4@@3AF?>937:5>?8:74DD84;
' 5>?878@A;>H847839>?8B35@:68786E:8H>?4> >?84DD84;@9:;86<=>?8B;4:C45>@456:5@A78768@87E8>3 <84;;3H86:5D47>456>?8789378H8D73B886>3D4@@>?8 93;;3H:5F
:
3>?>?84DD84;@478 +", :: ?8:CDAF586KA6FC85>4564H47664>86 $-!-" D4@@86 <= >?8 85:37 :E:; A6F845666:>:354; 4>?4?4DA7:5
3$$&!-,:@C36:9:86
- 12 -
::: ?8 B3CD85@4>:35 4H47686 <= >?8 7:<A54; :@ 85?45B86 973C @!!!,-/ >34@AC39@$'"",-/ :E ?8@4:64C3A5>:@D4=4<;8<=>?8:5@A787 4;35F H:>? :5>878@>4> >?874>8 39 1 D87 455AC973C>?864>839B;4:CD8>:>:35>:;; >?864>83968D3@:> E ?8 :5@A787 :@ 6:78B>86 >3 68D3@:> >?8 85?45B86 B3CD85@4>:35 <89378 >?8 7:<A54; H:>?:5 4 D87:36 39 $- 64=@ 973C >?8 64>8 39 78B8:D> 39 B3D= 39 >?:@ KA6FC85> 94:;:5F H?:B? >?8 :5@A787 @?4;; D4=:5>878@>4>>?874>839&1D87455AC 456 78B3E87 >?8 8MB8@@ :5>878@> 973C >?8 D87@35 78@D35@:<;8 937 >?8 68;4= :5 68D3@:>:5F>?84C3A5> E:
?8 :5@A787 :@ 85>:>;86 >3 78B3E87 >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 4C3A5> 973C >?8
- 13 -
:5@A7863H587 39 >?8 E8?:B;8 :5 >?8 @4C8 D73B886:5F@ E:: ?878@?4;;53376874@>3B3@>@ E::: ?84H476@?4;;<8674H54BB376:5F;=
.( &!' ! .( & !% ' ! :@>3;3