- 1 - ! "# "#$ $#!! %& &!! '( % & ! " # #$ %% &' ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % # % %# ( !% " # %)$ % "$ * % % $ % % *% * +' '' * * $ , , % % % %- . & % & % # %# / %% &' + %% &' - 3 - ' %% &' ! " # $ " # #$ * % ' % / $ % - '' * +'" $ 0$ , % % % %- . % * 1- - 1- - # - 4 - " 1- -$ 23 4543 256 7893: 4286 ;<84 5==359 >25993?@8?@ 423 A<:3< :543: '' =5663: BC 423 935<?3: 8?@93 -D:@3A74286AD<48?*A+' 2375>468?B<8375<34254 23 <36=A?:3?4 >958E8?@ 4A B3 423 A;?3< A7 95?: B35<8?@ CAF E356D<8?@ + 5><36 @D?456 684D543:54624AA<G8995@3H5?: 8648:5<6AD@247A< >A?G3<68A?7<AE5@<8>D94D<594A?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 23 <3HD364 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 ;56 ?A4 >A?68:3<3: ;8428? + :5C6 56 =<36><8B3: D?:3< 3>48A? "$ A7 423 5<?545I5 5?: 3G3?D3 >4 /' "7A< 62A<4 J423 >4,$ 23 <36=A?:3?4 ;56 =D<=A<43:9C 3?48493: 4A 423 B3?3784 A7 K:33E3: >A?G3<68A?L 5?: 23?>3 7893: ;<84 =34848A? A+' 4A 866D3 ?3>3665<C 5==<AG59 BC 4<3548?@ 423 95?: 56 >A?G3<43: 7A< <368:3?4859 =D<=A63 D<8?@ 423 =3?:3?>C A7 423 ;<84 =34848A? 423 3=D4C - 5 - AEE8668A?3< <3M3>43: 423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 A? +/' ;28>2 ;56 >25993?@3: BC 5E3?:8?@ 423 ;<84=34848A? + 23 935<?3: 8?@93 -D:@3 5743< >A?68:3<8?@ 423 >A?63HD3?>36 A7 ?A4 >A?68:3<8?@ 5? 5==98>548A? 7A< >A?G3<68A? <373<<3: 4A 3>48A? "$ A7 423 >4 5?: 239: 4254 423 <36=A?:3?4 86 3?48493: 4A 423 B3?3784 A7 :33E3: >A?G3<68A? 5?: >A?63HD3?49C HD5623: 423 3?:A<63E3?4866D3:BC423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<<3M3>48?@ 423 <3HD364 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 5?: :8<3>43: 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< 4A 8?48E543 423 =34848A?3< 56 4A 423 4A459 5EAD?4 =5C5B93 4A;5<:6 >A?G3<68A? >25<@36 7336 34> 5?: 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< ;56 7D<423< :8<3>43: 4A 866D3 5==<A=<8543 A<:3<6 A7 >A?G3<68A? 8? 75GAD< A7 423 <36=A?:3?4;8428?5=3<8A:A77AD<;33I638?@5@@<83G3: BC423658:A<:3<4234543868?5==359 ' 23 35<?3: ::848A?59 AG3<?E3?4 :GA>543 >A?43?:3: 4254 :D<8?@ 423 =3?:3?>C A7 423 ;<84 =34848A? - 6 - 423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<56>3<458?3:42348493:A>DE3?46 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 5?: >5E3 4A 423 >A?>9D68A? 4254 423 G3?:A<A7423<36=A?:3?425:?A484935642395?:;56?A4 @<5?43: BC 423 4543 AG3<?E3?4 4 ;56 D?:3< 42A63 >8<>DE645?>36 423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 7A< >A?G3<68A?A742395?:7A<?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859D63 ;56 <3M3>43: 3 2A;3G3< :8: ?A4 :86=D43 423 75>4 4254 6D>2 <3M3>48A? ;56 ?A4 ;8428? 423 48E3 =<36><8B3: D?:3< 3>48A? "$A7423>4 ? 423 A423< 25?: 935<?3: >AD?639 7A< 423 <36=A?:3?46>A?43?:3:425442393@86954D<38?846;86:AE 25: <3:D>3: 423 48E3 7A< >A?68:3<8?@ 5? 5==98>548A? 7A< >A?G3<68A? A7 5@<8>D94D<59 95?: 4A ?A? 5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 7<AE :5C6 4A + :5C6 ;28>2 ;56 ;842 423 5GA;3: ABM3>48G3 A7 3?6D<8?@ 4254 423<3 86 ?A :395C 8? >A?68:3<8?@ 423 5==98>548A?6 7A< >A?G3<68A?A75@<8>D94D<5995?:7A<?A?5@<8>D94D<59D63 3 423<37A<3 >A?43?:6 4254 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< 86 BAD?: 4A 5>4 ;842 595><84C 5?: >A?68:3< 423 5==98>548A?6 - 7 - ;8428? 423 48E3 =<36><8B3: 3 >A?43?:6 4254 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< :8: ?A4 >A?68:3< 423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 ;8428? + :5C6 56 6=3>8783: D?:3< 3>48A? "$ 5?: 423<37A<3 423 <36=A?:3?4 ;56 3?48493: 4A :33E3: >A?G3<68A? 3 7D<423<>A?43?:6 4254423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3<:D<8?@423=3?:3?>CA7423;<84=34848A?25: 866D3: 423 8E=D@?3: 3?:A<63E3?4 <3M3>48?@ 423 <3HD364 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 A? 423 @<AD?: 4254 423 G3?:A< A7 423 <36=A?:3?4:8:?A425G3484934A423=<A=3<4C8?HD3648A? 3 >A?43?:6 4254 4286 62AD9: 25G3 B33? :A?3 ;8428? + :5C6 5?: ?A4 B3CA?: 423 658: =3<8A: 3 423<37A<3 >A?43?:6 4254423 8E=D@?3: A<:3<=5663:BC423935<?3: 8?@93 -D:@3 86 MD64 5?: =<A=3< 8? 423 98@24 A7 3>48A? "$A7423>4 / *3 25G3 >A?68:3<3: 423 6DBE8668A?6 A7 423 935<?3:::848A?59AG3<?E3?4:GA>5437A<4235==3995?46 56;39956423935<?3:>AD?6397A<423<36=A?:3?4 - 8 - 23 5==3995?4 ;2A 6AD@24 >A?G3<68A? A7 5@<8>D94D<59 95?: 4A ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 ;56 BAD?:4A7D<?862?A4A?9C42348493:A>DE3?46BD4596A423 <393G5?4 <3G3?D3 <3>A<:6 2363 <3>A<:6 ;3<3 4A B3 6><D48?8N3: BC 423 9A;364 <3G3?D3 A778>3< 5?: D?:3<@A 63G3<59 93G396 A7 6><D48?C B37A<3 B38?@ =95>3: B37A<3 423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<23935<?3:::848A?59AG3<?E3?4 :GA>543:8:?A4:86=D4342375>44254;23?4235==98>548A? ;567893:BC423<36=A?:3?4423<393G5?4<3G3?D33?4<836 <3793>43: 423 ?5E3 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 7 4254 B3 6A 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< AD@24 4A 25G3 >A?68:3<3: 423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 ;8428? 423 =<36><8B3: 48E3 75898?@ ;28>2 423 >A?63HD3?>36 ?5E39C :33E3: >A?G3<68A?;AD9:7A99A;23 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<>5??A4 B3 AB98G8AD6 A7 423 >A?63HD3?>36 A7 3>48A? "$ A7 423 >4 7 23 256 693=4 AG3< 423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?47A<5?D?:D9C9A?@=3<8A:2386BAD?:4A75>3 423>A?63HD3?>36=5<47<AE428684;5664543:544235< BC423935<?3:>AD?6397A<423<36=A?:3?4425442395?:8? - 9 - HD3648A?9836;8428?5NA?37<335<35E35?8?@423<3BC4254 423<386?A<364<8>48A?A?>A?G3<68A?A75@<8>D94D<5995?:4A ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859D63 & ?G83;A742357A<3658:6DBE8668A?6;3:A?A4 78?: 5?C 3<<A< 8? 423 935<?3: 8?@93 -D:@3 HD5628?@ 423 3?:A<63E3?4866D3:BC423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<<3M3>48?@ 423 <3HD364 A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 7A< >A?G3<68A? A7 5@<8>D94D<59 95?: 4A ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 *3 596A :A ?A4 78?: 5?C 8<<3@D95<84C A< 3<<A< 8? 423 935<?3: 8?@93-D:@3:8<3>48?@423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<4A<3>38G3 423>A?G3<68A?>25<@365?:866D35==<A=<8543>3<4878>5436 >3<487C8?@ 423 >A?G3<68A? A7 423 95?: 8? HD3648A? 7<AE 5@<8>D94D<59 4A ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 3?>3 423<3 86 ?A E3<84 8? 4286 5==359 5?: 423 5==359 86 37A<3 =5<48?@ 84 86 <393G5?4 4A ?A43 4254 423 =D<=A63A73>48A? "$A7423>4864A3?6D<34254 423<386?A25<566E3?4A7>848N3?6;2A633I>A?G3<68A?A7 - 10 - 4238< 95?: 7<AE 5@<8>D94D<59 4A ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D6323<37A<3423 3=D4CAEE8668A?3<62599>A?:D>45? 3?HD8<C<3@5<:8?@423<356A?67A<:395C8?>A?68:3<8?@423 5==98>548A? A7 423 <36=A?:3?4 5?: 45I3 6D845B93 :3=5<4E3?4595>48A?5@58?64423=3<6A?<36=A?68B937A<423 :395C 23 >A?43E=4 =34848A? 86 7893: >AE=958?8?@ 423 ?A?>AE=985?>3A7423A<:3<:543:''=5663:BC 423935<?3:8?@93-D:@38?;<84=34848A?A+' C42357A<3658:A<:3<423935<?3:8?@93-D:@3 25: :8<3>43: 423 3=D4C AEE8668A?3< 4A <3>38G3 423 >A?G3<68A? >25<@36 5?: 866D3 5==<A=<8543 >3<4878>5436 >A?G3<48?@ 423 95?: B35<8?@ CAF E356D<8?@ + 5><36 @D?456 684D543: 54 624AA< G8995@3 H 5?: 8648:5< 7A< ?A?5@<8>D94D<59<368:3?4859 D63 23 658: :8<3>48A?6 ;3<3 4A B3 >AE=983: ;8428? 5 =3<8A: A7 7AD< ;33I67<AE423:543A7=5CE3?4BC423>AE=958?5?4286 A<:3< 86 ?A; D=239: BC 4286 AD<4 8? ;<84 5==359 - 11 - A/23<37A<34235==3995?4:363<G364AB3 @<5?43:5?A==A<4D?84C4A>AE=9C;842423A<:3<=5663:BC 423935<?3:8?@93-D:@3 >>A<:8?@9C 4286 >A?43E=4 =34848A? 645?:6 BC@<5?48?@7AD<;33I648E37<AE423:543A7 <3>38=4 A7 >A=C A7 4286 A<:3< 4A >AE=9C ;842 423 A<:3< =5663: BC 423 935<?3: 8?@93 -D:@3 8? ;<84 =34848A? A+' + 4 86 E5:3 >935< 4254 87 423 5==3995?46 7589 4A >AE=9C423658:A<:3<423>AE=958?5?4865498B3<4C4A633I <3G8G59A74286>A?43E=4=34848A? )% '( )% '$( 864A9A