Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54604 (KAR)
MUMTAZ BEGUM v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201032/2025 · 2026-01-27
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54604 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54604 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#
$!! $
%&' %()* '%) *+ $ '&
*
+
! "
"
#
! "
$
$! ! "
%
$" #
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! "
"! &
! "
&
' () *
#
#
! +
" #
$%
! " &
' #,
()#"*
# %!" # '*
"! #
!%
"""
# # ) # ' *
%$
"""
#
# ##
%-! $"$ % %- # -
$%
#
)
# #
- 3 -
'&*
+
"+
' () *
#
#
. ! +
" #
$
' #,
)#"*
# %!" # '*
"! # ' *
!%
"""
# )
%$
"""
#
#
##
%-!$"$ % %-# -
$ %
#
- 4 -
)
# #
#
/
/ 0
123"$"
"" 45 64278 9: ;<7 =7;4;43>715
?@@A578 35" ;3
?>8 +, B<717?5 123"!%
"" 45 64278 9: ;<7 =7;4;43>71
?@@A578 3;3CA?5<;<7=13@7784>D54>3!%
"""'14E7 3%$
"""* 17D45;7178 9: ?8D41 3E7> 324@7 631 ;<7 3667>@7 =A>45<?927 A>871 7@;43>5 %-! $"$ % ?>8 1
B7@;43>%-36?>87@;43>5$?>8%363B1:
13<494;43> @; - =7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36 7>431 4F42 A8D7(?8D41
" <7 6?@;A?2 E?;14G 36 ;<7 @?57 45 ;<?; 175=3>87>;3"@3E=2?4>?>;E?11478?@@A578398A2 ?5<778 3> %+"+ ; ;<7 ;4E7 36 E?114?D7 ;<7 175=3>87>; 3"H5 6?;<71 D4F7> ;B3 ;32?5 36 D328 ?>8 5
@?5<?>8?2533>7E3;31@:@27?=?1;613E;<7
- 5 -
A;7>5425 ?>8 3;<71 <3A57<328 E?;714?25 ;3 ?@@A578 3 6;71 ;<7 E?114?D7 175=3>87>; 3" 5;?1;78 ;3 175487 ?23>D B4;< <71 <A59?>8 ?>8 4>2?B5 4> ;<7 E?;14E3>4?2 <3E7 <7: 233I78 ?6;71 <71 B722 631 ? =71438 36 3>7 E3>;<?6;71;<7E?114?D7<717?6;71?@@A5783B7>;
;3 34E9?;317 ;3 ?;;7>8 <45 J39 <717?6;71 ;<7 4>2?B5 ?>8 3;<71 ?@@A578 =7153>5 5;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55 175=3>87>; 3"93;<=<:54@?22:?>8E7>;?22:9:87E?>84>D?884;43>?2 83B1: <3AD< ;<7 5?48 ?5=7@; B?5 4>631E78 9:
175=3>87>; 3" ;3 <71 <A59?>8?@@A578 3 <7 5A==31;78<456?E42:E7E9715473;<71?@@A578?>8?253 5;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55 175=3>87>; 3" @@3184>D ;3 <71 ;<7 ?@@A578 B717 >3; D4F7> 6338 3> ;4E7 ?>8 ?253 ?55?A2;78 <713>57F71?23@@?543>59:87E?>84>D?884;43>?283B1:
#4>?22: ?>@<?:?; B?5 @3>F7:78 B4;< ;<7 4>;71F7>;43> 36 ;<7 728715 36 53@47;: <717?6;71 631 53E7;4E7 ;<7: 233I78?6;71<71B722?>85A957CA7>;2:5;?1;78;3<?1?55 @3>;4>A3A52: 631 ?884;43>?2 83B1: 631 ?
5AE 36
- 6 -
5
?>8;32?536D328?;715<7D?F7941;< ;3?67E?27@<428 $ 3B7F713>" """?@@A5783B7>;;3 175=3>87>;3"H5=?17>;?2<3A57?>8?9A578<714>642;<: 2?>DA?D7?>8;<17?;7>78<71;3J34>;<7E?;14E3>4?2<3E7 ?>8?2534>631E78;<?;<7B3A28=71631E57@3>8E?114?D7 465<787>475;3J34><4E7>@75<7238D78;<7@3E=2?4>; 976317;<7175=3>87>;3=324@73>"!"""?D?4>5; ;<7=7;4;43>715?>8?>3;<71 % > ;<7 5;17>D;< 36 ;<7 @3E=2?4>; 175=3>87>;
3324@717D45;7178?@?574>14E73%$
"""631;<7 ?6317E7>;43>78 3667>@75 ?;71 175=3>87>; 3324@7 @3>8A@;78;<74>F75;4D?;43>?>82?48@<?1D75<77;?D?4>5;
;<7 =7;4;43>715 ?>8 ?>3;<71 9: ?11?:4>D ;<757 =7;4;43>715 ?5 ?@@A578 35" ;3 + <7 27?1>78 ?D45;1?;7 ;33I @3D>4K?>@736;<73667>@75 74>D?DD147F789:;<75?E7 ;<7=7;4;43>7154>93;<;<7=7;4;43>5?17976317;<453A1; ;3CA?5<;<7=13@7784>D5
- 7 -
7?18 27?1>78 @3A>572 631 ;<7 =7;4;43>715 27?1>78 4D< 3A1; 3F71>E7>; 27?871 631 175=3>87>;
3;?;7 ?>8 27?1>78 @3A>572 631 175=3>87>; 3" @3E=2?4>?>;4>93;<;<7=7;4;43>5
=?1; 613E A1D4>D 57F71?2 @3>;7>;43>5 27?1>78 @3A>572631;<7=7;4;43>7154>93;<;<7=7;4;43>5@3>;7>;78 ;<?;175=3>87>;3"?>8<71<A59?>8
?@@A5783B717 175484>D?;34E9?;31754>@7?@@A5783B?57E=23:78 ?>8B31I4>D4>?@7E7>;6?@;31:?;34E9?;31755A@< ;<717 45 >3 =35549424;: 36 ;<7 3;<71 ?@@A578 <?1?554>D 175=3>87>;3"76A1;<71@3>;7>;78;<?;7G@7=;53E7 3E>49A5 ?227D?;43>5 E?87 4> ;<7 5;?;7E7>; 36 B4;>75575 ;<717 ?17 >3 5=7@464@ ?227D?;43>5 ?D?4>5; ;<757 =7;4;43>715 ;3 ?;;1?@; ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D78 7 ?253 @3>;7>;78 ;<?; =7;4;43>71 35$ % ?>8 4> 14E4>?2 3"$"
"" 47?@@A5783%B?57?12471175484>D?;
AE9?4 ?>8 >3B?; A>7 @@A578 35 ?>8 B<3 ?17 ;<7<A59?>8?>8B467;<7:?17175484>D?; 7>D?2A1A<7 =7;4;43>71 47 ?@@A578 3 4> 14E4>?2 7;4;43>
- 8 -
3"!%
"" 45 >3>7 3;<71 ;<?> ;<7 B467 36 ?@@A578 3% ?>8 ;<7: 93;< ?17 175484>D ?; A>7 > 5A@< @41@AE5;?>@754E=24@?;43>36;<757=7;4;43>715453>2:3A;
36 F7>D7?>@7 ?>8 ;<7: >7F71 <?1?5578 175=3>87>; 3" =<:54@?22: 31 E7>;?22: 631 87E?>8 36 83B1: @@3184>D2: <7=1?:5;3CA?5<;<7=13@7784>D5?D?4>5;;<7=7;4;43>715 4>93;<;<7=7;4;43>5 + 27?1>78@3A>572631175=3>87>;3" @3>;7>878 ;<?; >3B ;<7 175=3>87>; 3324@7 <?F7 4>F75;4D?;78 ;<7 @?57 ?>8 2?48 @<?1D7 5<77; ?D?4>5; ;<7 =7;4;43>715 ?>8 ;<7 @<?1D7 5<77; E?;714?25 845@2357 ;<?;
;<717 45 ?> 4>F32F7E7>; 36 ?22 ;<757 =7;4;43>715 4> ;<7 @14E7 @@3184>D ;3 <4E ?@@A578 35" ?>8 $ 47 =7;4;43>71 35 ?>8 " 4> 123"$"
"" ?17 175484>D ?; ?84 3B> <4;;?=A1 ?2AI ?>8 175=3>87>; 3"B?5?253175484>D?23>DB4;<;<7E?>8;<7:<?1?5578 175=3>87>; 3" 93;< =<:54@?22: ?>8 E7>;?22: 7 ?253 @3>;7>878;<?;;<73;<71?@@A578<?F7?2534>F32F784>;<7 ?227D78 3667>@75 ?5 =71 ;<7 5;?;7E7>; 36 E?;714?2
- 9 -
B4;>75575 7G?E4>78 9: ;<7 =1357@A;43> 7>@7 <7 =1?:5 ;3845E45593;<;<7=7;4;43>5 !
7?1>78 4D< 3A1; 3F71>E7>; 27?871 3==357893;<;<7=7;4;43>5?>8=1?:5;3845E455;<75?E7 - <?F7D4F7>E:?>G43A5@3>54871?;43>93;<3> ;<7 5A9E45543>5 E?87 9: ;<7 27?1>78 @3A>572 631 ;<7 175=7@;4F7=?1;475?>8;<783@AE7>;5?F?42?9273>17@318
5 @3A2897 D?;<7178 613E 17@3185 ?5 =71 ;<7 @3E=2?4>; ?F71E7>;5 ?6;71 ;<7 E?114?D7 36 175=3>87>;
3" B4;< ?@@A578 3 5<7 5;?1;78 175484>D ?; ?84 3B> <4;;?=A1 ?2AI ?23>D B4;< ?@@A578 35 ;3 $ <717?6;71?@@A5783B7>;;334E9?;317631B31I; ;<?;;4E7?@@A57835"?>8$?23>DB4;<3;<7155;?1;78 ;3 <?1?55 <71 93;< =<:54@?22: ?>8 E7>;?22: 631 ?884;43>?2 83B1:<717@3185845@2357;<?;?@@A57835"?>8$47 6?;<714>2?B ?>8 E3;<714>2?B 36 175=3>87>; 3" 175=7@;4F72: B717 175484>D ?; ?84 3B> ?23>D B4;< 175=3>87>; 3" 4> ;<7 5<?178 <3A57 ; ;<?; ;4E7 ;<7:
- 10 -
87E?>878 ?884;43>?2 83B1: <7 5?48 ?5=7@; B?5 >7F71 5;?;789:;<7>74D<93A1547;<7E?;714?2B4;>75575
<7 ?227D?;43>5 ?D?4>5; ?@@A578 35% ;3 + 45 @3>@71>78 ;<741 =?1;4@4=?;43> 4> ;<7 4>@487>; @?>>3; 97 97247F78?;;<455;?D7631;<717?53>;<?;27?1>78@3A>572 631 ;<7 =7;4;43>715 =2?@78 ;<7 ?881755 =1336 36 ;<757 =7;4;43>715 B<4@< 5;?;7 ;<?; ?@@A578 35% ?>8 ?17 175484>D?;A>7?>8?@@A57835 ?>8+?17175484>D?; 7>D?2A1A>=71A5?236@<?1D75<77;?F71E7>;57G@7=; 53E73E>49A5?227D?;43>5?D?4>5;;<757=7;4;43>715;<717 ?17 >3 5A@< 5=7@464@ ?227D?;43>5 E?87 ?D?4>5; ;<757 =7;4;43>715 631 ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D7 5<77;78
" >5A@<@41@AE5;?>@7;<73>0927=7G3A1;4> ;<7 @?57 36
! " # $"% & ' ( ' ! )* 17=31;78 4> + ,- ?; =?1?D1?=< 3<728;<?;;<73A1;5<3A2897@?176A24>=13@7784>D ?D?4>5; ;<7 845;?>; 172?;4F75 4> @14E75 =71;?4>4>D ;3
- 11 -
E?;14E3>4?2 845=A;75 ?>8 83B1: 87?;<5 <7 172?;4F75 36 ;<7 <A59?>8 5<3A28 >3; 97 13=784> 3> ;<7 9?545 36 3E>49A5 ?227D?;43>5 A>2755 5=7@464@ 4>5;?>@7 36 ;<741 4>F32F7E7>; 4> ;<7 @14E7 ?17 E?87 3A;; 45?25357;;278 =354;43>362?B;<?;46?=7153>45E?87;36?@7?@14E4>?2 ;14?2 3> 53E7 D7>71?2 ?>8 5B77=4>D ?227D?;43>5 B4;<3A;
914>D4>D 3> 17@318 ?>: 5=7@464@ 4>5;?>@75 36 @14E4>?2 @3>8A@; 4; 45 >3;<4>D 9A; ?9A57 36 =13@755 36 ;<7 3A1; <73A1;5=357?8A;:;35A9J7@;;<7?227D?;43>27F722784> ;<7@3E=2?4>;;3?;<313AD<5@1A;4>:;364>83A;B<7;<71 ;<717 45 ?>: D?4> 36 ;1A;< 4> ;<7 ?227D?;43>5 31 B<7;<71 ;<7: ?17 E?87 3>2: B4;< ;<7 5327 39J7@; 36 4>F32F4>D @71;?4> 4>84F48A?25 4> ? @14E4>?2 @<?1D7 E317 =?1;4@A2?12: B<7>?=1357@A;43>?1457613E?E?;14E3>4?2845=A;7 $ #A1;<71;<73>H927 =7G3A1; 4> ;<7 @?5736 & .*'# "
17=31;784>/0/<7284>=?1?35" ?>8"! ?5A>871/
- 12 -
! " #
$% & $'
$' $% (
)!*+,#
! (
- 13 -
- . !*+,#
/ . "
0 ! . . ! *+, # . #- #
1
% > ;<7 4>5;?>; @?57 ?
9?17 =71A5?2 36 @<?1D7 5<77;E?;714?25@27?12:5<3B5;<?;;<7?227D?;43>5E?879:
175=3>87>; 3" ?17 F?DA7 ?>8 3E>49A5 =?1; 613E @2?4E4>D ;<?; ;<7 <A59?>8 47 ?@@A578 3 ?>8 <45 6?E42:E7E9715E7>;?22:<?1?5578<71B4;<?87E?>8631 83B1: 175=3>87>; 3" <?5 >3; =13F4878 ?>: 5=7@464@ 87;?42531875@14978?>:=?1;4@A2?14>5;?>@736<?1?55E7>; <7<?5>3;E7>;43>78;<7;4E78?;7=2?@731?E?>>71 4>B<4@<;<7?227D78<?1?55E7>;3@@A117831;<787;?42536
- 14 -
;<7 >?;A17 36 87E?>8 31 4;5 =?1;4@A2?15 <7176317 ;<7 @<?1D7 5<77; 2?@I5 @3>@17;7 ?>8 =17@457 ?227D?;43>5 <7 ;71E L@1A72;:M @?>>3; 97 75;?9245<78 B4;<3A; 5=7@464@ 4>5;?>@7 <7 5?E7 B7?I7>5 ;<7 @?57 36 ;<7 =1357@A;43> ?>8@?5;557143A583A9;3>;<7=139?9424;:36;<7F71543>36 175=3>87>; 3" <7 E717 D7>71?2 ?227D?;43>5 36 <?1?55E7>;B4;<3A;=34>;4>D3A;;<75=7@464@87;?425B3A28 >3;975A664@47>;;3 @3>;4>A7@14E4>?2=13@7784>D5?D?4>5; ?>:=7153>
;4557;;278=354;43>362?B;<?;3A1;5<?F7;3 97@?176A2?>8@?A;43A54>87?24>DB4;<@3E=2?4>;?>8EA5;
;?I7 =1?DE?;4@ 17?24;475 4>;3 @3>54871?;43> B<427 87?24>D B4;< E?;14E3>4?2 845=A;75 B<717 ;<7 ?227D?;43>5 <?F7 ;3 975@1A;4>4K78B4;<D17?;@?17?>8@41@AE5=7@;43>4>31871 ;3=17F7>;E45@?114?D736JA5;4@7?>8?9A5736=13@75536 3A1;
==2:4>D ;<7 ?93F7 =14>@4=275 ;3 ;<7 6?@;5 ?>8 @41@AE5;?>@75 36 ;<45 @?57 4> E: @3>5487178 F47B @3>;4>A?;43>36@14E4>?2=13@7784>D5?D?4>5;;<7=7;4;43>71
- 15 -
47?@@A57835%;3+45>3;<4>D9A;?9A5736=13@75536 3A1; 3B7F71 ;<717 ?17
E?;714?25 ?17 631;<@3E4>D ?D?4>5; ;<7 =7;4;43>71 35 ?>8 "
?@@A578 35" ?>8 $ 631 ;<7 3667>@75 ;<7: <?F7 977> @<?1D7 5<77;78@@3184>D2:=13@778;3=?55;<763223B4>D,
4 123"$"
"" 45 1!#
44 123"$"
"" 4> 175=7@; 36 =7;4;43>71 35 ?>8 " 47 ?@@A578 35" ?>8$45<7179:!#'#! 444 <7=13@7784>D54>3!%
"""?1454>D 3A; 36 14E7 3%$
""" 17D45;7178 9: ?8D41 3E7> 324@7 631 ;<7 3667>@7 =A>45<?927 A>871 7@;43>5 %-! $"$ % ?>8 1
B 7@;43> %- 36 ?>8 7@;43>5 $ ?>8 % 36 3B1: 13<494;43> @;
- =7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36 7>431 4F42 A8D7(?8D414>175=7@;36=7;4;43>71 35$ ;3 47 ?@@A578 35% ?>8 + 45 <7179:CA?5<78
- 16 -
4F 123"!%
"" 45 1! F <7=13@7784>D54>3!%
"""?1454>D 3A; 36 14E7 3%$
""" 17D45;7178 9: ?8D41 3E7> 324@7 631 ;<7 3667>@7 =A>45<?927 A>871 7@;43>5 %-! $"$ % ?>8 1
B 7@;43> %- 36 ?>8 7@;43>5 $ ?>8 % 36 3B1: 13<494;43> @;
- =7>84>D 3> ;<7 6427 36 7>431 4F42 A8D7(?8D414>175=7@;36=7;4;43>71 47?@@A578345<7179:CA?5<78
,* %!) ! 45;3/23/% ;,1J