- 1 - ! "#$$ "#$$% !! &!'!( ') !! * ' ) !"" # " $% & # % '' ( #% & ' ') " #% ' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *$'& + + *# %#'% & * + ' ,--# ,--%' + - # -% )' ,-* & - '""$+" . "))$ +/ +$+ $+ ' / $+ ' " " - / - 3 - "" $" " 0$ / ! " # + $) #%#%1 " +$)-/% */ $ ))1 ) ) ,- ) ) $ " " - " $ )2 ) *' ) " " ""$" " 0 $ / "" # " +$% & '' ( #% & ' - * "" - 4 - " #% ' *$ '& + + - *# %#'% & * + ' - ,--# ,--% ' + # % - )' ,-* & - '""$+" . ")) / +$+ $+ ' - $+ ' - 5 - " # + $ )#%/#%1*- $1 $) ))% ) ) ,-' ) ) $ " " ) ' "" - " $ )3 ' ) "" )) ' $ 4 4 $ - 6 - $# #"4 % 567689:;<<6;=7;>6?@=6ABCA6?6DA;D8:7;DA >67<6E8@F6=C @D : :D 856 ?@=6 :? 856 AA@8@:D;= 6D@:> @F@= GAH6 ;DA ) ;8 ;@E5G> E5;==6DH@DH 856 IGAHJ6D8 ;DA A6E>66 A;86A - BC95@E58567G@89;7A6E>66A 56 <;>8@67 ;>6 56DE6?:>85 >6?6>>6A 8: ;7 856C 96>6;>>;C6AB6?:>68568>@;=:G>8 * 56 7G@8 @D : 9;7 ?@=6A ?:> <;>8@8@:D;DA76<;>;86<:77677@:D:?856<=;@D8@??(775;>6@D 856 7G@847 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67 56 <=;@D8@?? E=;@J6A 85;8 756;DA856A6?6DA;D8:7;DA*;>6856E5@=A>6D:? 5;@K5 ;I@ ;DA ;5B::B 6HGJ 56 E=;@J6A 85;8 756 5;A ?;@85 @D 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * 85;8 856C 9:G=A J;D;H68567G@8<>:<6>8@67:96F6>8567;@AA6?6DA;D87 5;A ;=@6D;86A ;DA 6DEGJB6>6A <:>8@:D7 :? 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 @D ?;F:G> :? 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 - ;DA - 7 - 56 856>6?:>6 A6J;DA6A ; 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 95@E5956D>6?G76AE:J<6==6A56>8:7G6?:><;>8@8@:D #@%56A6?6DA;D8:7;DA*B6@DH8567@B=@DH7 :? 856 <=;@D8@?? E:D86786A 856 7G@8 56 A6?6DA;D8 : ;AJ@886A85;8 J865B::B6HGJ856J:856>A@6A:D * , BG8E=;@J6A85;87565;A:>;==CH@?86A6;786>D <:>8@:D :? C:* J6;7G>@DH * ;E>67 8: 56> ;DA 85;8 756 8::K :F6> <:77677@:D :? 856 7;J6 56 E=;@J6A 85;8 J8 65B::B 6HGJ 5;A ;=7: H@?86A 856 6D8@>6 =;DA B6;>@DH C: ;DA 856 >6J;@D@DH <:>8@:D :? C:* 8:856A6?6DA;D8:*@D856C6;>,,;DA5;AA6=@F6>6A <:77677@:D 56>6;?86> 856 >6F6DG6 >6E:>A7 96>6 ;EE:>A@DH=CJG8;86A56>6?:>6@89;7E:D86DA6A85;8856 <=;@D8@?? E;DD:8 7G6 ?:> <;>8@8@:D :? 56> 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67;7@85;AB6E:J6856;B7:=G86<>:<6>8@67:?856 A6?6DA;D8:7;DA* #@@% 56 A6?6DA;D8 :* E:D86DA6A 85;8 J8 65B::B 6HGJ A@6A :D * , ;DA AG>@DH 56> - 8 - =@?68@J6 756 5;A :>;==C B6LG6;856A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 @D 5@7?;F:G>@D856C6;>,,;DA?>:J856D569;7856?G== ;DA ;B7:=G86 :9D6> :? 856 <>:<6>8C 7: B6LG6;856A ;DA 85;85@7D;J6 9;7 6D86>6A @D856>6F6DG6>6E:>A7 @D 856 C6;>,,6E=;@J6A85;8567:=A8567G@8<>:<6>8C8:856 A6?6DA;D8 :- :D , @K69@76 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7;DA;=7:7:=A856@>75;>678:856A6?6DA;D8:- 56 A6?6DA;D8 : ;=7: ?@=6A ; 9>@886D 78;86J6D8:D7@J@=;>=@D67;78569>@886D78;86J6D8?@=6ABC 856A6?6DA;D8:*;DAE=;@J6A85;8565;A<G>E5;76A- ;E>67 *- HGD8;7 :? =;DA @D C:* ?>:J 856 A6?6DA;D8 :* :D - 56 A6?6DA;D8 : A6D@6A 856 ;F6>J6D87 :? 856 <=;@D8 ;DA E:D86DA6A 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DAA6?6DA;D87:7;DA96>6D6F6>@DI:@D8<:77677@:D :?8567G@8=;DAB6;>@DH C:6E=;@J6A85;8<=;@D8@?? 5;AKD:9=6AH6:?856?;E885;856>J:856>5;AH@?86A856 7G@8=;DA@D C:8:856A6?6DA;D8:*;DA856>6?:>6 56 9;7 856 ?G== ;DA ;B7:=G86 :9D6> :? 856 7;@A <>:<6>8C 5G7@8@7E:D86DA6A85;8856<=;@D8@??;DA856A6?6DA;D87 - 9 - :7 ;DA 5;F6 D: >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 @D =;DA B6;>@DH C:;DA56DE68567G@8?:><;>8@8@:D9;7D:8 J;@D8;@D;B=6 - 56 A6?6DA;D87 :7- ;DA B6@DH <G>E5;76>7 ;=7:?@=6A8569>@886D78;86J6D8E:D86DA@DH85;88567G@8@7 ?@=6A9@85;@D86D8@:D8:6M<=:@88567@8G;8@:D;DA 6M8>;E8?>:J856A6?6DA;D8:7-;DA56CE=;@J6A85;8 856C5;A<G>E5;76A856<>:<6>8@67?:>F;=@A E:D7@A6>;8@:D ;DA 856>6?:>6 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 D:8 6D8@8=6A 8: ;DC 75;>6 @D 856<>:<6>8C ;76A:D 85676 E:D86D8@:D7 8>@;= :G>8?>;J6A 856?:==:9@DH@77G67 N'56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? <>:F67 85;8 856 7G@8 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@67 ;>6 856 <>:<6>8@67 :? J865B::B6HGJO '56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? ?G>856> <>:F67 85;8 756@7@DI:@D8<:77677@:D;DA6DI:CJ6D8:? 7G@8 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8C ;=:DH 9@85 A6?6DA;D87:8:*O * '56856> 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A ?:> -85 75;>6@D8567G@87E56AG=6<>:<6>8@67O - 10 - '56856> 856 A6?6DA;D8 :* <>:F67 856 :>;=H@?87;@A8:5;F6B66D6M6EG86ABC=;86 ;56B::B 6HGJ @D 5@7 ?;F:G> B6LG6;85@DH <>:<6>8C B6;>@DH C:* J6;7G>@DH , ;E>67 HGD8;7 ;DA C:J6;7G>@DH;E>6,HGD8;7O '56856>856A6?6DA;D87:7;DA-<>:F6 85;8 856C ;>6 856 B:D;?@A6 <G>E5;76>7 :? 856<>:<6>8@67?>:J856*>AA6?6DA;D8?:>; F;=G;B=6E:D7@A6>;8@:DO - '56856>8567G@8@7D:8<>:<6>=CF;=G6A?:> 856 <G><:76 :? :G>8 ?66 ;DA IG>@7A@E8@:D ;DA:G>8?66<;@A@7@D7G??@E@6D8O '5;8A6E>66:>:>A6>O AA=77G6 '56856> 856 A6?6DA;D8 : <>:F67 85;8 56 @7 856 B:D;?@A6 <G>E5;76> :? 7G@8 <>:<6>8C?>:JA6?6DA;D8:*?:>F;=G;B=6 E:D7@A6>;8@:DOP 56 <=;@D8@?? 9;7 6M;J@D6A ;7 "' ;DA 756 J;>K6A M7" 8: "* 56 A6?6DA;D8 :7* ;DA 96>6 6M;J@D6A ;7 '7 8: ;DA 856C J;>K6A A:EGJ6D87 ;7 M7 8: ;76A :D 856 :>;= ;DA A:EGJ6D8;>C 6F@A6DE6 856 8>@;= :G>8 56=A 85;8 856 <=;@D8@??5;A<>:F6A85;87569;76D8@8=6A8:;75;>6@D856 7G@8<>:<6>8@67;DA@8;=7:56=A85;8856A6?6DA;D8:78: - 11 - *96>6D:8;B=68:678;B=@75856:>;=H@?8768G<BC856J ;==6H6A=C6M6EG86ABC856@>J:856>@D>67<6E8:? C:7* ;DA8856>6?:>6A6E>66A8567G@8;DAA6E=;>6A85;8856 <=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A8: -85 75;>6:G8 @D 856 7G@8 7E56AG=6 <>:<6>8@678;=7:56=A85;88567;=6A66A6M6EG86ABC856 A6?6DA;D8:78:@D?;F:G>:?A6?6DA;D8:78:;>6 D:8 B@DA@DH :D 856 <=;@D8@??47 -85 75;>6 @D 856 7G@8 7E56AG=6<>:<6>8@676@DH;HH>@6F6ABC8567;@AIGAHJ6D8 ;DA A6E>66 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 ;DA ;>6 B6?:>6 85@7 :G>8@D8567689:;<<6;=7 , 56 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 ;DA 7GBJ@886A 85;8 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 96>6 =;9?G==C <G>E5;76A BC 856J BC <;C@DH F;=@A E:D7@A6>;8@:D 8: 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * 6 856>6?:>6 E:D86DA6A 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? E;DD:8 D:9 ;776>8 56> >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 8: 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 6 ;=7: E:D86DA 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8 :78:*5;A7<6E@?@E;==CE=;@J6A85;88567G@8<>:<6>8@67 96>6 :>;==C B6LG6;856A BC 856@> J:856> @D ?;F:G> :? 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * ;DA 856>6?:>6 856 8>@;= :G>8 E:G=A - 12 - D:8 5;F6 =@H58=C E:D7@A6>6A 856 6F@A6DE6 :? 856 A6?6DA;D87 6 E:D86DA7 85;8 856>6 @7 D: >6LG@>6J6D8 :? =;98:H68;D:>;=H@?8>6H@786>6A;DA5;F@DH>6H;>A8:856 >6F6DG6>6E:>A7@875:G=AB6<>67GJ6A85;8856A6?6DA;D8 :78:*5;AB6E:J6856?G==;DA;B7:=G86:9D6>7:?856 7G@8<>:<6>8C 56=6;>D6A E:GD76= ?G>856> 7GBJ@886A85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 ;DA 5;F6 <G>E5;76A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 @D 856 C6;> - 95@=6 856 A6?6DA;D8 : <G>E5;76A @D 856 C6;> 6 856>6?:>6 E:D86DA7 85;8 8567G@8?@=6A@D856C6;> @75@H5=CB6=;86A 856 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 =6H;= >6<>676D8;8@F67 :? <=;@D8@?? E:D86DA7 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? @7 6D8@8=6A8:;DGDA@F@A6A75;>6@D8567G@8<>:<6>8@67;?86> 856A6;85:?56>?;856>;DAJ:856>6;=7:E:D86DA785;8 856>6 @7 D: <;>8@8@:D B68966D 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * ;>6 E=;@J@DH>@H588@8=6;DA@D86>678@D8567G@8<>:<6>8CB;76A :D ;D ;==6H6A :>;= H@?8 6M6EG86A BC 856@> J:856> 6 E:D86DA7 85;8 ;?86> 856 A6;85 :? 856 ?;856> 856 J:856> - 13 - 9;76D8@8=6A8:;DGDA@F@A6A75;>6;DA756856>6?:>6E:G=A D:8 5;F6 B6LG6;856A :> H@?86A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 6 856>6?:>6 E:D86DA7 85;8 856 @J<GHD6A IGAHJ6D8 ;DA A6E>66<;776ABC8568>@;=:G>8@7IG78;DA<>:<6>;7856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * 96>6 D:8 ;B=6 8: 678;B=@75 856 ;==6H6AH@?8;DA;77GJ@DH@?856C678;B=@756A8566M6EG8@:D :?856:>;=H@?8856>@H588@8=6;DA@D86>678:?856<=;@D8@?? 9;7D:8;??6E86A '6 5;F6 E:D7@A6>6A 7GBJ@77@:D7 J;A6 BC =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 <=;@D8@?? ;7 96== ;7 856 =6;>D6A E:GD76=?:>856A6?6DA;D8:7;DA 56 :D=C <:@D8 85;8 ;>@767 ?:> E:D7@A6>;8@:D @D 85@7;<<6;=@7 '56856>8568>@;=:G>89;7>@H58@DA6E>66@DH856 7G@8:?856<=;@D8@???:><;>8@8@:DO * 56 ?;E8 85;8 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67 96>6 :9D6A ;DA <:776776A BC 856 <;>6D87 :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * @7 D:8 @D A@7<G86 8 @7 ;=7: D:8 @D - 14 - A@7<G86 85;8 856 ?;856> :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * A@6A @D8678;86 56 E=;@J :? 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * @7 85;8 856@> J:856> 5;A B6LG6;856A 856 7G@8 <>:<6>8@67@D86>J7:?;:>;=7>@H58=CE:D86DA6ABC 856 =6;>D6A E:GD76= ?:> 856 <=;@D8@?? 856 J:856> :? 856 <=;@D8@?? ;DA 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * 5;A :D=C ;D GDA@F@A6A 75;>6 ;DA 856>6?:>6 756 E:G=A D:8 5;F6 B6LG6;856A 856 6D8@>6 <>:<6>8C 56 8>@;= :G>8 9;7 856>6?:>6 >@H58 @D 5:=A@DH 85;8 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * 96>6 GD;B=6 8: 678;B=@75 856 =;9?G= 6M6EG8@:D :? 856 :>;= ;7E:D86DA6ABC856J@D856@>9>@886D78;86J6D8 ;F@DH>6H;>A8:856;B:F6?;E878568>@;=:G>8 5;A D: :856> ;=86>D;8@F6 85;D 8: A6E>66 856 7G@8 ?@=6A BC 856<=;@D8@??56A6?6DA;D8:7;DA;>6;==<G>E5;76>7 :?856<:>8@:D7:?856<>:<6>8C?>:J856A6?6DA;D8:7 8: * 56@> @D86>678 E;DD:8 B6 B6C:DA 856 @D86>678:? 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * ;F@DH >6H;>A 8: 856 ?;E8 85;8 856 <=;@D8@?? 5;A ;D GDA@F@A6A >@H58 8@8=6 ;DA @D86>678 @D 856 7G@8<>:<6>8C856A6?6DA;D8:7;DAE;DD:8E=;@J85;8 - 15 - 8567;@A7;=6A66A6M6EG86ABC856A6?6DA;D8:78:*@D 856@> ?;F:G> B@DA7 856 <=;@D8@?? ;=7: 56 8>@;= :G>8 5;7 E:D7@A6>6A 85676 ?;E87 J68@EG=:G7=C ;DA 5;7 >@H58=C >68G>D6A856?@DA@DH5:=A@DH856<=;@D8@??@76D8@8=6A8:-85 75;>6@D8567G@8<>:<6>8@67 '6 A: D:8 766 ;DC 6>>:> @D 856 @J<GHD6A IGAHJ6D8;DAA6E>66<;776ABC8568>@;=:G>86DE6856 ;<<6;=@7 - '6J;K6@8E=6;>85;8856A6?6DA;D8:7;DA 5;F@DH<G>E5;76A856<:>8@:D7:?8567G@8<>:<6>8C?>:J 856 A6?6DA;D8 :7 8: * ;>6 6D8@8=6A 8: 9:>K :G8 856@> >6J6ACB6?:>6856?@D;=A6E>66:G>8;756=ABC856<6M :G>8 @D 856 E;76 :? !" "#$!%&!>6<:>86A @D' () +' &$( $ +' &$%( $ @78: =: