- 1 - !"## "$$ %&'%($)*+ %) , ! "## $ % $&' # $ #()(" *$(# ! * *(" $#+ $#, $#,- #' #() Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (" *$(# ! **(" $#+ $ # , $#,-#' % . . / #" 01232103,4+151++16207,3441383937:,2201;<69=1:2 >5 3?@<72238 63216 #()(" 43,,16 7: 48 3,1 >*$(#AB2016681,,7>:,<6913:641?738<691 32 383A<+397 5>+ A+1-72B C813+:16 41?738 <691D E01+1AB 201813+:1641?738<6913?@<722162013??<,16+1,4>:61:25>+ 201 >551:?1, 4<:7,03A81 <:61+ 1?27>:, * *(" >5 3:6 1?27>:, $#+ $#, 3:6 $#,- >5 ?2 #' 01 3A+76916 53?2, >5 201 ?3,1 7, %#+3F3,0 8>69163?>=4837:2A15>+12017=A3+393>87?1>:#(("(# 3937:,2201+1,4>:61:23??<,16388197:92032>:203263BE01: 01E3,:13+=A16F3+7+?81327=A3+93%$:3:6?3=1 3:67:5>+=1607=2032%#( 3,07:32003,4<2,232<,>:07, - 3 - %032,3443??><:2E720+193+62>#'207+2063B?181A+327>:>5 + =A16F3+ B -71E7:9 201 ,376 ,232<, 201 3441883:23??<,16?38816%#(20+><9007,=>A7813:63A<,16 07= AB =1:27>:7:9 07, ?3,21 3:6 38,> 3A<,16 + =A16F3+7:5><883:9<391,,<?0%#1:@<7+16%,$3:6 #( 3A><2 201 ,3=1 3:6 E1:2 2> 201 483?1 >5 3??<,16 01 3??<,16 3A<,16 %,# $ 3:6 #( AB =1:27>:7:9 2017+ ?3,21 1:?1%#8>6916201?>=4837:2A15>+12017=A3+393>87?1 E07?0 +197,21+16 7: +7=1 >$#(# 3, 41+ G) 5>+ 201 35>+1=1:27>:16 >551:?1, <A,1@<1:28B 201 3441883:2>87?1 ?>:6<?216 201 7:-1,279327>: 3:6 8376 ?03+91 ,0112 3937:,2 201 3??<,16 5>+ 201 35>+1=1:27>:16 >551:?1, A15>+1 201 41?738 ><+2 $ > 4+>-1 201 ?03+91, 81-1816 3937:,2 201 3??<,16 A15>+120141?738><+22014+>,1?<27>:7:2>2381G3=7:16#) E72:1,,1,3,%,#2>#)=3+F16'6>?<=1:2,3,G,#2> '3:6761:275716$321+738A;1?2,3,#2>$ " : 3,,1,,=1:2 >5>+38 3:66>?<=1:23+B1-761:?1 20141?738><+23?@<722162013??<,165>+201>551:?1,01036 - 4 - A11:?03+91,01121601,376;<69=1:27,?03881:916AB201 23217:207,344138 * 13+6813+:16 5>+2013441883:22321 ) 43+2 5+>= <+97:9 ,1-1+38 ?>:21:27>:, 813+:16 5>+2013441883:24+7=3+78B?>:21:6162032201;<69=1:2 <:61+ 207, 344138 ,<551+, 5+>= 41+-1+,72B 3:6 788193872B ,7:?1 201 41?738 <691 537816 344+1?7321 201 1-761:?1 7: 3 +7902 41+,41?27-1??>+67:92>07=%,#$3:6#(03-1,<44>+216 201 ?3,1 >5 4+>,1?<27>: 3=>:9 201= 201 3??<,16 3A<,16 %,# 3:6 #( AB=1:27>:7:9 2017+ ?3,21 01 >201+ E72:1,,1, 71%,"3:6*3+12011B1E72:1,,1,2>2017:?761:2:,<?0 ?7+?<=,23:?1 201 41?738 <691 537816 2> 344+1?7321 2017+ 1-761:?17:+790241+,41?27-13:63?@<722162013??<,16A3,16 >:,<+=7,13:6?>:;1?2<+1138,>?>:21:61620322016183B7: 5787:9207,3441387,6<12>-1+757?327>:>5+1?>+6,AB201>=1 143+2=1:23:638,>E0781>A237:7:9?1+275716?>4B,,<?001 4+3B,2>388>E201344138AB?>:6>:7:92016183B & 03-197-1:=B3:G7><,?>:,761+327>:A>20>:201 ,<A=7,,7>: =361 AB 201 813+:16 3:6 201 6>?<=1:2, =3613-3783A81A15>+1207,><+2 - 5 - ' , ?><86 A1 93201+16 5+>= 1-761:?1 3:6 +1?>+6, 20><90 201 4+>,1?<27>: 1G3=7:16 %,# $ 3:6 #(=321+738 E72:1,,1,7:207,?3,1727,201,41?757??3,1>5%#2032%$ 7:5>+=16 07= 2032 %#( 036 4<2 201 ,232<, 7: 07, =>A781 40>:1 7: +1,41?2 >5 #'20 7+2063B ?181A+327>: >5 + =A16F3+ 3:6 -71E7:9 201 ,3=1 3??<,16 3A<,16 07= 20+><9007,40>:1AB=1:27>:7:907,?3,213:638,>3A<,16+ =A16F3+ >E1-1+ 6<+7:9 201 ?><+,1 >5 7:-1,279327>: 201 3441883:2>87?1 03-1 :>2 ,17H16 201 =>A781 40>:1 >5 3??<,1627,2016151:?1>52013??<,162032018>,207,=>A781 40>:1>:1=>:204+7>+2>2016321>538819167:?761:23:601 3448716 5>+ 6<487?321 3, 41+ G# 3:6 201 ,3=1 E3, 7,,<16 >: #((*(# 01 3881916 7:?761:2 E3, ?3<,16 >: #(("(# 3, ,<?0 72 7, ?813+ 2032 3??<,16 E3, :>2 03-7:9 3:B =>A781 40>:1 3, >: 201 6321 >5 7:?761:2 ?>:237:7:9 >)##'##''3,,23216AB%#>+%#( <+201+201?>=4837:27,:>28>69167:3:7:67-76<38 ?343?72B 3:6 201 ,3=1 03, 8>6916 >: A10385 >5 201 38720 3:93+,03 3=7227 83:6 01 1-761:?1 >5 201 E72:1,,1, 3:6 ?03+91 ,0112 =321+738, 6> :>2 67,?8>,1 2032 %# 03, -71E16 - 6 - 201,232<,>5%#(0><90%#(I,=>A78140>:1E3,,1:22> 3, 41+ # 14>+2G& +1-138, 2032 201 7+218 ?3+6 >?>=> ?3+6 3:6 7?+> 3+6 E07?0 E1+17:,1+2167:20140>:16>:>2?>:237:3:B%032,3446323 >+%032,344->7?1:>21,014+>6<?16A15>+1201><+2AB %#( 3:6 201 ?1+2757?321 <:61+ 1?27>: )* >5 201 -761:?1 ?26>:>267,?8>,1201=>A78140>:1:<=A1+>5%#( #( 2 7, 201 ,41?757? 6151:?1 >5 201 3??<,16 2032 01 A17:93A3+A1+%#3521+07,037+?<27:3??<,16I,,38>>:676 :>243B201=>:1BE01:3??<,167:,7,2162>43B201=>:1B %# 3A<,16 3:6 8>6916 3 538,1 ?>=4837:2 3937:,2 07= 01 E72:1,,1,,<44>+2167:201?3,13+107908B7:21+1,216E72:1,,1, 3:6 201B 3+1F:>E: 2> %,#$ 3:6#( 88 201,1 3,41?2, >5 201=3221+7,613827:612378AB201813+:1641?738<6913:6 >47:162032201+17,3?813+6><A23+7,1,7:20191:1,7,>5201 ?3,1 ## 07,A17:92013441383937:,23?@<72238201>:IA81 41G><+27:201?3,1>5 +14>+216 7: ,<==3+7H16 2014+7:?7481,2>1G1+?7,12014>E1+AB20144188321><+22> - 7 - 7:21+51+17:201>+61+>52011,,7>:,><+27:43+39+340> 3,<:61+. ! " #$ " $ $ $ $ % $ $ $ !$ $$ ! $ & !$ $ $!' # <+201+ 201 >:IA81 41G ><+2 7: 201 ?3,1 >5 !!"" # +14>+216 7: $ $$ E0781,<==3+7H7:92014+7:?7481,7:61387:9 - 8 - E720 201 344138 3937:,2 3?@<72238 7: 43+39+340 >" 0186 3, <:61+. $% $ $ (&)*(+* ,-*. $ /0 12 $ 3 4 12 5 4 12 & $ $ 4 12& $ $ 4 12 & " $ 4 12& ' - 9 - #$ 1:?1?>88>?327:92014+7:?7481,,<==3+7H167:201 3A>-1;<69=1:2,2>20153?2,3:6?7+?<=,23:?1,>5207,?3,1 3= >5 201 -71E 2032 201 813+:16 41?738 <691 03, +79028B 344+1?73216 201 1-761:?1 3:6 3?@<72216 201 3??<,16 E07?0 6>1, :>2 ?388 5>+ 3:B 7:21+51+1:?1 32 201 03:6, >5 207, ><+2 ??>+67:98B4+>?1162>43,,2015>88>E7:9. 01+7=7:38441387,%&% -* %#) # 7,2>.#8>.#) .+