- 1 - ! " #$!! $ % %&'() %' (* $ + ) ( * ! " # ! ! $ !! % & ' ' ! ( ) ! ' $* '( $&# Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ & $ # & $ ! $ %&&& %&&# $ ! $ $ & &&) $ ( ' '! &)&&)#$$$ ! ))&) +$ $$(('$ ' $ ! ' $ $ ( &,%&& !- ' ! ( & ! ' ! ( & ! '( # $ ! ! $ !! .& & + $' &, - 3 - ! ' $* $&# $ & $ # & $ ! # ' ' ' ' %&& &&&)# $ $ (('$'$ $$ ! %))&)+) $( ' $ ' ' - '- /!' ( ( 01 2 &&& 34 53167 89 :;6 <6:3:32=60 2=6 30><?@4;?<<?3 6 064<2=76=:2 &3=01 2 &,%&& & 01 2 &,%&& 34 53167 89 <6:3:32=60 2 30A?1? ?=7 ?=2:;60 3 6 064<2=76=: 2 & 3= 01 2 &&& ) 01 2 &&&3453167>=760 6B:32=&25 !;?0?:39? ?C?03@ >0?@4;? ?=;3:? &&) 466@3=C :2 D>?4; :;6 <02B6673=C4 ?C?3=4: :;6 <6:3:32=60?BB>467 3= 2 &)&&) 03A62 %&&#06C34:606789:;6 30E?0 - 4 - 213B6 <6=73=C 2= :;6 5316 25 6=320 3F31 (>7C6 ?=7 ('$ '?=F3 520806F3:9G:;603?12>0:H#520:;62556=B64<>=34;?816 >=76046B:32=4))&)?=7+25 01 2 &,%&&3453167>=760 6B:32=&25 !;?0?:39? ?C?03@ >0?@4;? ?=;3:? &&) 466@3=C :2 D>?4; :;6<02B6673=C4?C?3=4::;6<6:3:32=604?BB>46724 ?=7&3= 2 &&&) 03A62 %&&#06C34:606789:;6 30E?0 213B6 <6=73=C 2= :;6 5316 25 6=320 3F31 (>7C6 ?=7 ('$ '?=F3 520806F3:9G:;603?12>0:H#520:;62556=B64<>=34;?816 >=76046B:32=4%))&)+0E 6B:32=)25 ;6 ?8037C67 5?B:4 25 :;6 B?46 ?06 :;?: 3= 01 2 &&& :;6 <6:3:32=60?BB>467 34 :;6 61760 802:;60 25 064<2=76=: 2 &H4 ;>48?=7 ;6 1?=7 86?03=C 9 2 )A6?4>03=C?B064)C>=:?443:>?:67?: 30E?0 ?1>@ ?=7 :;6 1?=7 86?03=C 9 2 ) A6?4>03=C , ?B064 C>=:?42560?A?0?4F311?C68612=C4:2:;6<?06=:425<6:3:32=60 3 6 3=1?E425064<2=76=:2 &E;3B;4:?=743=:;6=?A625 3=1?E4 25 064<2=76=: 2 & = ) && ?: ?82>: - ? A 064<2=76=:2 &E6=::2:;61?=7520;?0F64:3=C?::;?: :3A6 :;6 <6:3:32=60 E?4 3= :;6 53617 ?=7 ;?0F64:3=C :;6 1?=7 - 5 - ;6064<2=76=:2 &D>64:32=67:;64?A64:?:3=C:;?::;61?=7 8612=C4 :2 :;6A ;6=B6 ? D>?0061 :22@ <1?B6 86:E66= :;6A BB2073=C :2 064<2=76=: 2 & :;6 <6:3:32=60 ?8>467 ;60 3= 531:;91?=C>?C6?=7<>4;67;60?43767>6:2E;3B;4;656112= :;6C02>=7 ;606?5:60:;6<6:3:32=60:;06?:6=67;60E3:;7306 B2=46D>6=B64895234:3=C1356:;06?:2=;60 + 6=B6 ? B?46 ?=7 B2>=:60 B?46 ;?F6 866= 06C34:60673=03A62 %&&?C?3=4::;6<6:3:32=604?BB>467 24 ?=7 & 3= 01 2 &,%&& ?=7 03A6 2 %&& ?C?3=4::;6<6:3:32=60?BB>4673=01 2 &&&520:;6 ?5206A6=:32=67 2556=B64 ?:60 ><2= 3=F64:3C?:32= :;6 064<2=76=:213B6 1?37 B;?0C6 4;66: ?C?3=4: :;6 <6:3:32=604?BB>467 3= 82:; :;6 <6:3:32=4 520 :;6 ?52064?37 2556=B64 =06B63<:25:;6B;?0C64;66::;616?0=67'?C34:0?:6 :22@ B2C=3I?=B6 25 2556=B64 CC036F67 89 :;6 4?A6 :;6 <6:3:32=604?BB>467<06560067:;646<6:3:32=4 % 6?07 16?0=67 B2>=461 520 :;6 <6:3:32=604 16?0=67 3C;2>0:2F60=A6=:16?760520064<2=76=:2 . :?:6?=7 16?0=67B2>=461520064<2=76=:2 &3=82:;:;6<6:3:32=4 - 6 - <?0: 502A >0C3=C 46F60?1 B2=:6=:32=4 16?0=67 B2>=461520:;6<6:3:32=6043=82:;:;6<6:3:32=4B2=:6=767:;?: 3=F36E25:;6B3F31734<>:63=064<6B::2:;61?=767<02<60:364 5?146B2A<1?3=:4;?F6866=5234:67?C?3=4:6?B;2:;60?=7?:=2 <23=:25:3A6:;693=F21F673=:;6?116C672556=B64 JB6<::;6 2A=38>44:?:6A6=:4A?763=:;6B;?0C64;66:=22:;60 A?:603?14?06520:;B2A3=C3=:;6B;?0C64;66:3=064<6B: 25:;630?116C673=F21F6A6=: , 16?0=67B2>=461520064<2=76=:2 &3= 82:;:;6<6:3:32=4;?F6F6;6A6=:192<<2467:;6<6:3:32=4 ;6 16?0=67 520 064<2=76=: :?:6 2<<2467 ?=7<0?94:2734A344:;6<6:3:32=4 ;?F6C3F6=A9?=J32>4B2=43760?:32=82:;2=:;6 4>8A34432=4 A?76 89 :;6 16?0=67 B2>=461 520 :;6 064<6B:3F6 <?0:364 ?=7 ?142 <60>467 :;6 72B>A6=:4 <1?B67 865206 :;34 2>0:3=82:;:;6<6:3:32=4 & 4 B2>17 86 C?:;6067 502A :;6 B;?0C6 4;66: A?:603?14 :;2>C; :;606 34 ? B3F31 734<>:6 3= 064<6B: 25 1?=767 <02<60:9 86?03=C 9 2 ) A6?4>03=C ?B064 ) C>=:?4 - 7 - 43:>?:67 ?: 30E?0 ?1>@ ?=7 :;6 1?=7 86?03=C 9 2 ) A6?4>03=C,?B064C>=:?42560?A?0?4F311?C686:E66=:;6 <6:3:32=6043=82:;:;6<6:3:32=4?7A3::6719:;606E?4?D>?0061 86:E66=:;6<6:3:32=604 6=B6?B?46?=7B2>=:60B?46;?F6 866= 06C34:6067 3= 03A6 2 %&& ?=7 03A6 2 %&& ?C?3=4::;6<6:3:32=604?BB>467?=7<0646=:19:;6213B6;?F6 3=F64:3C?:67 :;6 A?::604 ?=7 1?37 B;?0C6 4;66: 3= 82:; :;6 B?464 <2= 06?73=C :;6 B;?0C6 4;66: ?F60A6=:4 :;2>C; :;6 734<>:6 ?<<6?04 :2 86 B3F31 3= =?:>06 3= :;6 5304: 81>4; 2= 6J?A3=3=C :;6 06B2074 :;606 ?06 A?:603?14<1?B67 89 :;6 064<2=76=:213B6 3= 064<6B: 25 :;6 B2AA34432= 25 :;6 2556=B6 ) >?4;3=C:;6B03A3=?1<02B6673=C434B?11675202=19 3=?B?46E;606:;6B2A<1?3=:7264=2:734B1246?=92556=B620 34503F212>4F6J?:32>4202<<06443F6 5:;6?116C?:32=446:2>: 3=:;6B2A<1?3=:72=2:B2=4:3:>:62556=B625E;3B;B2C=3I?=B6 ;?4 866= :?@6= 89 :;6 A?C34:0?:6 3: 34 2<6= 520 :;34 2>0: :2 D>?4;:;64?A6 :34=2:=6B644?09:;?:?A6:3B>12>4?=?19434 25B?464;2>178672=6865206:03?1:253=72>:E;6:;60:;6B?46 E2>176=73=B2=F3B:32=20?BD>3::?1 53:?<<6?042=?06?73=C - 8 - 25:;6B2A<1?3=:?=7B2=43760?:32=25:;6?116C?:32=:;6063=3= :;613C;:25:;64:?:6A6=:A?762=2?:;:;?::;63=C06736=:425 :;62556=B6?06734B12467:;606E2>1786=2K>4:353B?:32=520:;34 2>0::23=:605606?4;6173=:;6B?4625 06<20:673= !"# = :;6 3=4:?=: B?464 :;6 B;?0C6 4;66: A?:603?14 734B12464? B?46?C?3=4::;6<6:3:32=6043=82:;:;6 B03A3=?1<6:3:32=4520:;62556=B64:;69;?F6B;?0C64;66:67 = 4>B; B30B>A4:?=B6 :;6 4?A6 ;?4 :2 86 :64:67 3= ? 76:?3167 :03?1 6=B6 E3:;2>: 6J<06443=C ?=9 2<3=32= 2= :;6 A603:4 25 :;6B?4644>553B6:2;217:;?::;6<02B6673=C43=:;6<6:3:32=4 B?==2:86D>?4;67?::;344:?C6 BB2073=C19:;6<6:3:32=41?B@4A603:?=7:;64?A6 ?06$%&'%&&($ ,( %!' ! ' 34:2 - 12 -&