- 1 - ! " #$!! $ % %&'() %' * ! " # $# % & $# ' & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $#!( " $# % & ) & "# & ' * +"! & & & && ""("#""#"!(!" !,'"+ & ' & +! & & & & & & ' - - . /01 23404056 01 70839 :693; 3<4056 # 57 133=06> 45 ?:@1/ 4/3 2;5<33906>1 @>@0614 4/3 234040563;1 03 @<<:139 51+ ! @69 06 5+"! @;0106> 5:4 57 ;0A3 5+! ;3>0143;39 BC /044@2:; - 3 - 580<3 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/@B83 :693; 3<40561 " "( "# ""# " !( !" @69 !, ;D 3<4056 "+57 236906>564/3708357 ;8014;0<4@693110561 :9>3@8@B:;@>0 /3 7@<4:@8 A@4;0E 57 4/3 <@13 01 4/@4 56 !,!"! @4 @B5:4 !+-! 2A 4/3 <5A28@06@64$' 0;:2@=1/0>5:9@$'" /@69;@=@64@$' @69 /@69;@=@4/@ /@69;:$', @;3 14@6906> 63@; 0;3 @1@F@6@ 43A283 @44@ 4 4/@4 40A3 @<<:139 5 45 @B:139 4/3 <5A28@06@64 /3;3@743; 4/3C 8374 4/3 1254 @43;@<<:13954506<8:906>4/313234040563;1D364 45 4/3 /5:13 57 <5A28@06@64 @4 @B5:4 !+!! 2A @69 20<=39 :2 @ ?:@;;38 D04/ 4/3 <5A28@06@64 @69 @11@:8439 /0A /5:>/ ', '( @69 '+ A@93 @6 @443A24 45 ;31<:3'7;5A4/3@<<:1394/3C@8806<8:906>';@6 @D@C454/3/5:1357'"$0;:2@=1/@5D9@4/3@<<:139 75885D39 4/3A @69 @A56> 4/3A @<<:139 5 @69 @<<:1395,@11@:84394/3<5A28@06@6456/01/3@9D04/ 4/3 </5223; @69 @E3 ;3123<40F38C :3 45 4/3 1@A3 4/3 - 4 - <5A28@06@64 1:14@0639 B833906> 06G:;031 56 /01 /3@9 /3;3@743; @<<:139 5, @815 @11@:8439 4/3 <5A28@06@64 D04/ @ <8:B 31:84@648C 4/3 <5A28@06@64 B3<@A3 :6<561<05:1 @69 7388 95D6 56 4/3 >;5:69 4 4/@4 40A3 D/36 '" @69 ' 4;039 45 ;31<:3 4/3 <5A28@06@64 @<<:139 5$@64/51/ 18@2239 ' 56 /01 </33= @69 @<<:139 5 @815 @11@:8439 /0A BC /@69 @69 4/3;3@743; 7839@D@C7;5A4/312544017:;4/3;@883>394/@46304/3; 4/313234040563;1D3;32;31364@44/31<363575<<:;;36<3 65; 06140>@439 @<<:139 51 45 , 45 <5AA04 4/3 <;0A3 36<3@<5A28@064<@A345B3;3>0143;3956!(!"! BC4/3<5A28@06@64B375;3;312569364$ 580<3 6 4/3 14;36>4/ 57 4/3 <5A28@064 4/3 ;312569364$ 580<3 ;3>0143;39 4/3 <@13 @>@0614 23;1561 06<8:906> 4/313 234040563;1 06 ;0A3 5+! 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/@B83 :693; 3<40561 " "( ""# "!"@69!,;D3<4056"+57 :B13?:3648C 4/3;312569364$ 580<3<5A2834394/306F3140>@4056@698@09 </@;>3 1/334 @>@0614 @88 @<<:139 BC @;;@C06> 4/313 - 5 - 234040563;1@1@<<:13951+45@6975;4/357736<31 2:601/@B83:693;3<40561"("#""#"!( !" @69 !, ;D 3<4056 "+ 57 <<5;906>8C 4/3 83@;639 @>014;@43 455= <5>60H@6<3 57 4/3 57736<31 /3;3@743; 4/3 <@13 D@1 <5AA04439 45 3110561 5:;4 06 5+"! 36<3 @>>;03F39 BC 4/3 1@A3 4/3 234040563;12;373;;394/012340405645?:@1/4/32;5<33906>1 @>@06144/3A " 3@;9 83@;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 @69 83@;639 0>/ 5:;4 5F3;6A364 83@93; 75; ;312569364 5 /5:>/ 6540<3 01 13;F39 45 ;312569364 5 /3 ;3A@0639@B1364 2@;4 7;5A :;>06> 13F3;@8 <5643640561 83@;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 <56436439 4/@4 56 23;:1@8 57 4/3<5A28@064@69</@;>31/334A@43;0@813E<3245A60B:1 @883>@40561 @>@0614 4/313 234040563;1 4/@4 4/3C D3;3 2;31364@44/3@883>391<363575<<:;;36<3@B158:438C65 54/3; @883>@40561 @;3 A@93 @>@0614 4/3A 06 ;3123<4 57 4/30; 2@;40<02@4056 06 4/3 <;0A3 3 @815 - 6 - <56436939 4/@4 06 4/3 06040@8 <5A28@064 859>39 BC 4/3 234040563;4/36@A31574/313234040563;545"95654 75;4/<5A06> :B13?:3648C 06 4/3 7:;4/3; 14@43A364 57 ;312569364 5 4/3 6@A31 57 4/3 234040563; 51 45 " @;3A36405639 , 3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/@4 56 23;:1@8 57 4/3 14@43A36457D0463114/31@A39320<414/@4@<<:1395 45 , 3643;39 4/3 /5:13 57 <5A28@06@64 @69 '" @69 4/3;3BC @11@:8439 4/3 <5A28@06@64 @69 ' E<324 4/3 @883>@40564/@44/313234040561@;32;31364064/31<36357 5<<:;;36<34/3;30165123<070<5F3;4@<4@44;0B:439@>@0614 4/313234040563;1 <<5;906>8C2;@C145@885D4/323404056 ( 83@;639 0>/ 5:;4 5F3;6A364 83@93; 5225139 45 4/3 23404056 @69 2;@C1 45 901A011 4/3 1@A3 # /@F3 >0F36 AC @6E05:1 <561093;@4056 45 4/3 1:BA011056 A@93 BC 4/3 83@;639 <5:6138 75; ;3123<40F3 - 7 - 2@;403115@81523;:1394/3<5A28@064@6954/3;A@43;0@81 @F@08@B8356;3<5;9 + 1 <5:89B3 >@4/3;39 7;5A ;3<5;9156 23;:1@8 574/3<5A28@064@69</@;>31/334A@43;0@814/3<5A28@064 01 70839 BC 563 ;0 :;:>31/ @883>06> 4/@4 56 4/3 9@43 57 06<093640356!,!"!D/36/3@856>D04/'"' @69 ', 14@6906> 63@; 0;3 @1@F@6@ 3A283 @44@ @<<:139 5 45 <@A3 4/3;3 @69 @B:139 4/3 <5A28@06@64 /3;3@743; 4/3C 8374 4/3 1254 6 4/3 1@A3 9@C@4@B5:4+!!2A@<<:139545,4;312@11314/3 /5:1357'@6920<=39:2@?:@;;38@69@11@:8439/0A /5:>/','(@69'+A@93@6@443A2445;31<:3 '7;5A4/3@<<:1394/3C@8806<8:906>';@6@D@C 45 4/3 /5:13 57 '"$0;:2@=1/@ 5D9@ 4/3 @<<:139 75885D39 4/3A @69 @11@:8439 45 ' @69 ' 4 01 65D/3;3 14@4394/@4 4/313 234040563;1 @;306F58F3906 4/3 06<09364 @883>398C 4@=36 28@<3 06 4/3 /5:13 57 ' @69 '" 6 23;:1@8 57 4/3 <5A28@064 </@;>3 1/334 @69 14@43A364 57 54/3; D04631131 5A60B:1 14@43A3641 D3;3 - 8 - A@934/@44/313234040563;1D3;32;31364064/31<36357 5<<:;;36<3/31@A39531654041387<561404:43@657736<3 @>@06144/313234040563;1D04/5:4@6C06140>@40565;123<070< 5F3;4@<4@>@06144/3A ! 65F3;@8823;:1@8574/3A@43;0@8156;3<5;9 @A 57 4/3 <561093;39 F03D 4/@4 <56406:@4056 57 <;0A06@8 2;5<33906>1@>@06144/3234040563;1@<<:13951+! @69 01 @B:13 57 2;5<311 57 5:;4 106<3 4/3 1@A3 01 A@6073148C 7;0F585:1 F3E@405:1 @69 061404:439 D04/ @6 :843;05; A540F3 /3 3640;3 @883>@40561 06 4/3 & @69 </@;>3 1/334 @<<32439 56 041 7@<3 F@8:3 3F36 4/36 4/3 1@A3 95 654 <561404:43 @6 57736<31 </@;>3 1/33439@>@06144/3234040563;1@<<:13951+!@69 <<5;906>8C2;5<339452@114/375885D06>- 0 /32340405601 00 /3 2;5<33906>1 @>@0614 4/3 234040563;1 03 @<<:139 51+ ! @69 06 5+"! @;0106> 5:4 57 ;0A3 - 9 - 5+! ;3>0143;39 BC /044@2:; 580<3 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/@B83 :693; 3<40561 ""("#""#"!(!"@69 !,;D3<4056"+57 236906>564/3 7083 57 ;8 014;0<4 @69 3110561 :9>3 @8@B:;@>001/3;3BC?:@1/39 +( %!' ! 0145-85-