Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54572 (KAR)
NAGAMMA AND ORS v. THE UNION OF INDIA
MFA/201733/2019 · 2026-01-28
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54572 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54572 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$" %%
&
! "#$%$&
' !(
(
"
)
#$&&&& ! "
'
!(*"
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
) )
) +%
*
&&%
&$& )& ,
! " ! "
-
# .
)
*
)
-
#
(
/ +0 )
)
&&$
&+&%
) ) *
(
,
*
"
123 455647 23 482329: ;<= ;> =16 ?<@:A69= @4=6@ &&% 29 &$& ;> & ;9 =16 >276 ;> =16 427B4C742A382D<947!49:47;8669E1"@23A23329:=16 E742A56=2=2;9
);8=1634F6;>E;9G69269E6=16548=263B;<7@ D686>6886@=;43568=1628849FD6>;86=1682D<947
= 23 =16 E436 ;> =16 45572E49=3 =14= =16 1<3D49@ ;> 45572E49= ;#149A<F14554 B69= =;
- 3 -
42@45<8 427B4C =4=2;9 =; 5<8E1436 =2EF6= D64829: ;#)+=;=84G67>8;A42@45<8=;474D<84:2 <829:=16E;<836;>=16?;<896C=16342@149A<F14554 >677 @;B9 >8;A =16 A;G29: =8429 49@ 43 3<E1 3<3=4296@ :826G;<3 29?<8263 49@ =16864>=68 3<EE<AD6@ =; 29?<8263 69E6 =16 E742A49=3 14G6 4558;4E16@ =16 82D<947 366F29:E;A56934=2;9
16 E742A 45572E4=2;9 B43 E;9=63=6@ DC =16 8635;9@69=3 @69C29: =16 4G68A69=3 A4@6 29 =16 45572E4=2;9 $ 6>;86 =16 82D<947 =16 45572E49=3 14G6 6H4A296@ =B; B2=963363 43 49@ 49@ :;= A48F6@ @;E<A69=3 43
H3 =; 9 =16 ;=168 149@9;;8476G2@69E6B434@@<E6@DC=168635;9@69=3 1;B6G68 865;8= ;> =16 2G232;947 427B4C 494:68 B43 A48F6@43
H
16 82D<947 4>=68 E;932@6829: =16A4=68247 ;9 86E;8@ DC ?<@:A69= @4=6@ &&% @23A2336@ =16
- 4 -
E742A 56=2=2;9 49@ D629: 4::826G6@ DC =16 34A6 =16 45572E49=314G6586>6886@=123455647
14G6 1648@ A= 12G476674 764896@ E;<9367 45564829: >;8 =16 45572E49=3 49@ 82 <@128329:1 (2?45<8 764896@ 65<=C ;72E2=;8 696847 ;> 9@24 45564829:>;8=168635;9@69= % = 23 48:<6@ DC =16 764896@ E;<9367 45564829: >;8=1645572E49=3=14==1686239;@235<=643=;=16@64=1 ;>=16@6E6436@!1<3D49@;>45572E49=;";94EE;<9=;> =16 4EE2@69= 49@ @6352=6 =16 34A6 =16 82D<947 143 E;AA2==6@ 49 688;8 29 4882G29: 4= 4 E;9E7<32;9 =14= =16 29E2@69=E499;=D6E;93=8<6@43<9=;B48@29E2@69=49@=16 @6E6436@ B43 9;= 4 D;94>2@6 543369:68 49@ 4EE;8@29:7C =16 E742A 56=2=2;9 B43 688;96;<37C @23A2336@ B12E1 86I<2863 =; D6 29=68>686@ B2=1 29 =123 455647 = 23 473; 48:<6@DC=16764896@E;<936745564829:>;8=1645572E49=3 B2=1 86:48@ =; E;A56934=2;9 >;8 =16 @64=1 ;> 82 149A<F1455429=164776:6@4EE2@69=
- 5 -
+ 68 E;9=84 82 <@128329:1 (2?45<8 764896@ 65<=C ;72E2=;8 696847 ;> 9@24 45564829: >;8 =16 8635;9@69= 3;<:1= =; ?<3=2>C =16 2A5<:96@ ?<@:A69= 54336@DC=1682D<947 & 4G29:=4F699;=6;>=163<DA2332;93A4@6DC =16 764896@ E;<9367 45564829: >;8 =16 548=263 14G6 E486><77C 6H4A296@ =16 86E;8@3 568<347 ;> =16 86E;8@3 B;<7@ 29@2E4=6 =14= ;9 &&$ =16 @6E6436@ 149A<F14554 >677 @;B9 >8;A =16 A;G29: =8429 D6=B669 149:<@2 49@ 14A5<814772 427B4C =4=2;9 49@ 143 5;336336@=16=2EF6=D64829:;#)+16342@ E;A5<=68236@=2EF6=B43A48F6@43
H=23473;=;D6 9;=6@ =14= 43 568 =16 549E1494A4 @6E6436@ 149A<F14554J3D;@CB437C29:;9=16=84EF9=14=G26B ;> =16 A4==68 =16 >29@29: 86E;8@6@ DC =16 82D<947 23 E;9=848C =; =16 86E;8@3 DC @23A23329: =16 E742A 56=2=2;9 @6352=6=16E436;>=1645572E49=3E;A6B2=129=165<8G26B ;>6E=2;9!";>=16427B4C3E=+%+
- 6 -
16;9JD76<586A6;<8=29=16E436;>
865;8=6@ 29 &$ & 29 5484:84513 $ 49@ 167@ 43<9@68
!
" #$ ! % #$
! ! &
! ' &
! (
) * + ! ! %
! - 7 -
! ! &
,
! ! -!& . /*
! . &
. *
0
/112
. &
3
3 . 4 " **5637869/619
"
)1)1
. :
7
0
: 42) 12
; 11 1116 # <
- 8 -
8
%$
; #$ %
"
. /=
" . 7
>
);77;B29: =16 74B @6E7486@ DC =16 ;9JD76 <586A6;<8=29=164D;G6E436 =168635;9@69=29=123 E436 23 473; @286E=6@ =; 54C 4 E;A56934=2;9 ;> 3%&&&&& #=;=1645572E49=3B2=129>;<8B66F3>8;A=16 @4=6;>86E625=;>4E68=2>26@E;5C;>=123?<@:A69=>42729: B12E1=16E;A56934=2;931477E488C29=6863=4==1684=6;> 054>8;A=16@4=6;>=123?<@:A69==2778647234=2;9 69E65433=16>;77;B29:
2" 5564723477;B6@29548= 22" 16?<@:A69=@4=6@&&%29 &$& ;> & ;9 =16 >276 ;> =16 427B4C 742A3 82D<947!49:47;8669E1"231686DC36=432@6
- 9 -
222" 168635;9@69=23@286E=6@=;54C4E;A5492;9 ;> 3%&&&&& # =; =16 45572E49=3 B2=129 >;<8 B66F3 >8;A =16 @4=6 ;> 86E625= ;> 4 E68=2>26@ E;5C ;> =123 ?<@:A69= >42729: B12E1 =16 E;A56934=2;931477E488C29=6863=4==1684=6;> 0568499<A>8;A=16@4=6;>=123?<@:A69= =2778647234=2;9
'( ) *
"
23=;7;