Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54571 (KAR)

THE DIRECTOR v. DR. SYED SAHID IRFAN AND ANR

WA/200214/2024 · 2026-01-09

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $%!! $%! !& ## '( ! "# # $ % % " " & "' " % " ( " $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & % % " " )$$) & $*)!$$) " " & & "& " " & # # + +" !% # + ,- .//-00.12 ,.3 4,.00-15-6 .1 786-8 6.2-6 )$$) /.33-6 9: 0-.81-6 ;150- <65- ;1 & 7$*)!$$) 9: =,;4, 2,- 9-1->;2 7> -?28.786;1.8: 0-.@- =;2, 72,-8 ;14;6-12.0 9-1->;23 =.3 786-8-6 27 9- 58.12-6 27 -1.90- 8-3/716-12 7 27 /<83<- 732 "8.6<.2-7<83- $ ,- >.423 98;->0: 32.2-6 .8- 2,.2 8-3/716-12 7 =.3 .//7;12-6 .3 . <1;78 -3;6-12 74278 71 $'$*.16=.30.2-8/87A72-6.3.-1;78-3;6-12 74278 71 $ .16 /8-3-120: ,- ;3 =78B;15 .3 .1 - 3 - 33;32.1287>-3378;12,-.//-00.12132;2<2;71,-2.2- "7@-81A-12,.6.//87@-62,-8-C<-327>8-3/716-12 7 27 -1.90- ,;A 27 /<83<- /73258.6<.2;71 .2 .@76.:. -6;4.0700-5-.16-3-.84,132;2<2- .;4,<87=-@-8 2,- 3.;6 .//87@.0 =.3 =;2,7<2 -?28.786;1.8: 0-.@- =;2, /.: .16 .007=.14-3 -@-1 2,7<5, ,- =.3 -12;20-6 27 2,- 3.A- -3/716-12 7 2,-8->78- 4,.00-15-6 2,- 3.;6 786-8 9->78- 2,- 0-.81-6 ;150- <65- ;1 & 7$*)!$$) ,- 0-.81-6 ;150- <65- 7> 2,;3 7<82 /-8<3-6 2,- 7>>;4;.0 A-A78.16<A3 6.2-6 )$ .16 ''$' =,-8-;1 2,- .//-00.12 ,.6 58.12-6 2,- 9-1->;23 7> -?28.786;1.8: 0-.@- =;2, /.: .16 .007=.14-3 27 71- 8 .3.@.8.D .4,1<8 3374;.2- 87>-3378 -/.82A-127>"-1-8.0-6;4;1- -.4,;15 73/;2.0 .;4,<8<82,-8 3;A;0.89-1->;2=.3.0375;@-1 27 2,- 32.>> 7> 2,- .//-00.12 132;2<2;71 9: . -370<2;71 6.2-6 $$* ,- 0-.81-6 ;150- <65- 2,-8->78- .007=-62,-=8;2/-2;2;71.16,-062,.28-3/716-12 7;3 .037 -12;20-6 27 . 3;A;0.8 9-1->;2 .16 .44786;150:6;8-42-6 - 4 - 8-3/716-12 7$ 27 58.12 2,- 9-1->;2 7> -?28.786;1.8: 0-.@- =;2, 72,-8 ;14;6-12.0 9-1->;23 27 -1.90- 8-3/716-12 7 27 /<83<- 2,- 732 "8.6<.2;71 7<83- -;15 .558;-@-6 9: 2,- .>78-3.;6 786-8 2,- .//-00.12 ,.3 >;0-6 2,;3.//-.0 ) ,-0-.81-647<13-0>782,-.//-00.123<9A;22-6 2,.22,-9-1->;2-?2-16-6278.3.@.8.D.4,1<84.1172 9--?2-16-6278-3/716-12 7.38.3.@.8.D.4,1<8 =.3 172 /<83<;15 732 "8.6<.2;71 7<83- ;1 . 8;@.2- -6;4.0 700-5- - 2,-8->78- 3<9A;23 2,.2 2,- /.8.00-0 68.=19:2,-0-.81-6;150-<65-9-2=--12,-4.3-7>8 .3.@.8.D .4,1<8 .16 2,- 4.3- 7> 8-3/716-12 7 ;3 <1=.88.12-6.1617;16<05-14-47<06,.@-9--13,7=127 8-3/716-12 7 2,- 0-.81-6 47<13-0 >78 8-3/716-12 7 8-0;-6 71 <0- 7> 2,-%.81.2.B. ;@;0 -8@;4-3 -/<2.2;71>78873-4<2;717>;5,-82<6;-3.168.;1;15 - 5 - -.@- 27 "87</ ++ >>;4-83 <0-3 $ =,;4, 8-.63 .3 >7007=3# ! " # ! ! ! ## $ ! ! ! #$%& ' ! " ! ! ! ## $ ! ! $ # $$( $ # ### ) # $ # # ## $ ' % & $ ( $ $ $( $ # $ - 6 - * ! $ *! ! # ! ! $ +# ###$ $ ! ! ! ! $ ! , - 4712-163 2,.2 8-3/716-12 7 ,.3 .58--6 273-8@-2,-.//-00.12132;2<2;71>78./-8;767>:-.83 .3."".32,-2.2-"7@-81A-12;3A--2;152,- 47327>>--3>782,-32<6:-2,-8->78-3<9A;232,.22,- ;A/<51-6786-8/.33-69:2,-0-.81-6;150-<65-;3D<32 .16/87/-8;12,->.423.164;84<A32.14-37>2,-4.3-.16 67-3172=.88.12.1:;12-8>-8-14- ' &- ,.@- 4713;6-8-6 2,- 3<9A;33;71 7> 2,- 0-.81-6 47<13-0 >78 2,- .//-00.12 .3 =-00 .3 2,- 0-.81-6 47<13-0>788-3/716-12 7 - 7 - * ,- ;A/<51-6 .//87@.0 =.3 58.12-6 9: 2,- 2.2- "7@-81A-12 9<2 ;2 8-><3-6 27 58.12 2,- -?28.786;1.8:0-.@-.1672,-8;14;6-12.09-1->;2327-1.90- 8-3/716-12 727/<83<-,;3/73258.6<.2;71,;3=.3 4,.00-15-6 9->78- 2,-0-.81-6 ;150-<65- 7> 2,;37<82 ,-0-.81-6;150-<65-,.3.007=-62,-=8;2/-2;2;71.16 ,.3 6;8-42-6 2,- 2.2- "7@-81A-12 27 58.12 2,- -?28.786;1.8: 0-.@- .16 72,-8 ;14;6-12.0 9-1->;23 27 8-3/716-12 7 27 -1.90- ,;A 27 /<83<- ,;3 732 "8.6<.2;71 ,;3 =8;2 .//-.0 ;3 172 >;0-6 9: 2,- 2.2- "7@-81A-129<2;3>;0-69:2,-.//-00.12 =,7,.317 274,.00-15-2,-786-8-2,.2.3;2A.: .38;5,20: 4712-12-6 9: 2,- 0-.81-6 47<13-0 >78 8-3/716-12 7 =,-1 3;A;0.8 9-1->;2 ;3 58.12-6 27 71- 8 .3.@.8.D .4,1<8.1672,-832.>>7>2,-.//-00.12132;2<2;71.16;1 @;-=7><0-7>2,-<0-3$-?28.42-6.97@-.162,- <14716;2;71.0 <16-82.B;15 5;@-1 9: 8-3/716-12 7 2,.2 ,-=7<063-8@-2,-.//-00.12>78./-8;767>:-.83.>2-8 58.6<.2;15 >87A 2,- 47<83- 2,- ;A/<51-6 786-8 /.33-6 - 8 - 9: 2,- 0-.81-6 ;150- <65- ;3 D<32 .16 /87/-8 .16 67-3 172 =.88.12 .1: ;12-8>-8-14- -14- 2,- .//-.0 ;3 6;3A;33-6 1 @;-= 7> 6;3A;33.0 7> 2,- .//-.0 2,- /8.:-8 37<5,2 ;1 7)!$$ 67-3 172 3<8@;@- >78 4713;6-8.2;71 .16 .44786;150: 7)!$$ .037 32.163 6;3A;33-6 )* '!( ! )* ' !& ( ! ;32 7#0 7#)