Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54561 (KAR)

SANGAMESH @ MAHESH S/O BABU RAO DONAGAO v. THE STATE THROUGH

CRL.A/200169/2016 · 2026-01-12

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# "#$ #!! %&'%(!)*' +%) , ! ! " #$% " " &$# ' " ()((* " ' + ' () " !" "' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ' ! ,' ' -./ ,' ' # ,' ' 012 -334-5 12 6154/ 78 -33455-.9 :;.<1:9 ; :0-554.=1.= 904 >?/=@4.9 ;6 :;.<1:91;. -./ ;A/4A ;6 24.94.:4 /-94/ ()((* 3-224/ 78 904 34:1-5 '?/=4 -./ //191;.-5 129A1:9 -./ 4221;.2 '?/=4 -9 1/-A :;.<1:91.= 01@ 6;A 904 ;664.:42 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;.#**BA4-/C1904:91;.#%;6-./4:91;.$ ;6 A;94:91;. ;6 015/A4. 6A;@ 4D?-5 664.:42 :9 ( 04A41.-694A A464AA4/ 9; -2 E904 :9 (F 6;A 7A4<198 4 0-2 -52; :0-554.=4/ 904 ;A/4A ;6 24.94.:4 9; ?./4A=; 21@354 1@3A12;.@4.9 6;A 61<4 84-A2 -./ 9; 3-8 61.4 ;6 2)((( B 1. /46-?59 21@354 1@3A12;.@4.9 6;A ;.4 @;.90 6;A 904 ;664.:4 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;. #**B ;6 -./ 21@354 1@3A12;.@4.9 6;A - 3 - 5164 -./ 9; 3-8 61.4 ;6 2(((( B 1. /46-?59 21@354 1@3A12;.@4.9 6;A 9C; @;.902 6;A 904 ;664.:4 3?.120-754 ?./4A4:91;.$;6904:9( 04 A423;./4.9 A4=1294A4/ A1@4 ;#&) (% 6;A904;664.:423?.120-754?./4A4:91;.#**A4-/C190 4:91;. #% ;6 -./ 4:91;.2 -./ * ;6 904 :9(;.9047-212;61.6;A@-91;.6?A.1204/78 904 @;904A ;6 904 <1:91@ =1A5 ;. (% 04 A423;./4.9-694A:;./?:91.=-.1.<4291=-91;.-33A404./4/ 904 -::?24/ -./ -694A A4:;A/1.= A454<-.9 @-0-G-A2 -./ 2?7>4:91.= 904 <1:91@ =1A5 -./ -::?24/ 6;A @4/1:-5 4D-@1.-91;. -./ A4:;A/1.= 904 29-94@4.9 ?./4A 4:91;. *% ;6 A 6154/ - :0-A=4 6;A 904 ;664.:42 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;.2 #% (& #% #** #$* ;6 -./ 4:91;.2 -./ * ;6 904 :9 ( 04 -::?24/ C4A4 A454-24/ ;. 7-15 04 A;54 ;6 904 -::?24/ ;C-290-9040-/-74994/904:;@@1221;.;6904:A1@4 78-::?24/; - 4 - # 04 9A1-5 ;?A9 6A-@4/ :0-A=4 -=-1.29 -::?24/ ; 6;A 904 ;664.:4 3?.120-754?./4A4:91;. #** #$* A4-/ C190 4:91;. #% ;6 -./ 4:91;.2 % -./ * ;6 904 :9 ( 04 -::?24/ /4.14/ 904 :0-A=42 -./ :5-1@4/ 9; 74 9A14/ . 2?33;A9 ;6 904 :-24 ;6 904 3A;24:?91;.!B9;!BC4A44D-@1.4/-./DB9; B&-./2B9;&C4A4@-AH4/042?729-.:4;6904 4<1/4.:4 ;6 904 3A;24:?91;. C19.42242 C4A4 A4-/ ;<4A 9; 904-::?24/C0;/4.14/2-@4;C4<4A904-::?24//1/ .;954-/-.84<1/4.:4-24/;.904;A-5-.//;:?@4.9-A8 4<1/4.:49049A1-5;?A9045/90-9904-::?24/;=?1598 6;A904;664.:43?.120-754?./4A4:91;.#**;6-./ 4:91;. $ ;6 :9 ( -./ 24.94.:4/ 01@ -::;A/1.=58 41.= -==A14<4/ 78 904 2-1/ >?/=@4.9 ;6 :;.<1:91;.-./904;A/4A;624.94.:4904-::?24/;12 746;A49012;?A9 % 4-A.4/ :;?.245 6;A 904 -::?24/ ; :;.94./4/ 90-9 904 9A1-5 ;?A9 /1/ .;9 :;.21/4A 904 6-:9 90-9 904 -::?24/ ; C-2 .;9 1.<;5<4/ 1. 904 ;664.:4 - 5 - -554=4/.904:;.9A-A890429-94@4.9;6904<1:91@=1A5 ?./4A4:91;.*%;6;/4;6A1@1.-5A;:4/?A420;C4/ 90-9 904 -::?24/ ; :-554/ 904 -::?24/ ; C0; A4-:04/90435-:4C04A4904-::?24/;-./904<1:91@ C-2 29-./1.= 04 <1:91@ 0-./4/ ;<4A 04A 6;?A 84-A ;5/ .14:4<1:91@9;-::?24/;-./90-9-::?24/;9;;H 904 <1:91@ ;. 904 @;9;A:8:54 4 :;.94./2 90-9 -::?24/ ; C-2 .;9 1.<;5<4/ 1. 904 ;664.:4 ;6 5?A1.= -C-8 904 <1:91@ ;A 1. 904 ;664.:4 ?./4A 4:91;. #** ;6 4 :;.94./290-904C-2?.-C-A490-9904<1:91@C-2-@1.;A -./ 90-9 204 C-2 9-H4. 78 -::?24/ ; 6;A:1758 -./ C190;?9 04A :;.24.9 4 904A46;A4 2?7@192 90-9 904 9A1-5 ;?A9 :?A2;A158 5;;H4/ 1.9; 904 4<1/4.:4 54/ 78 904 3A;24:?91;.9;0;5/90-9904-::?24/;C-2:;@351:191. 904:;@@1221;.;6904;664.:446?A904A29-94290-9904 <1:91@ C-2 .;9 4<4. H.;C. 9; 904 -::?24/ ; -./ 904A46;A4904-::?24/;:;?5/.;90-<4744.-AA-1=.4/ 6;A-.;664.:43?.120-754?./4A4:91;.$;6904 :9(46?A904A2?7@19290-9!B12904@;904A;6 - 6 - 904<1:91@4.I?1A4/C190-::?24/;C0;/12:5;24/90-9 904-::?24/;0-/9-H4.904<1:91@9;C-A/2904A-15C-8 29-91;. 4 :;.94./2 90-9 4D:439 9012 904A4 12 .; -554=-91;. -=-1.29 904 -::?24/ ; -./ 04 .41904A :;.231A4/ C190 904 -::?24/ ; .;A /1/ 04 0-<4 -.8 1.94.91;. 9; H1/.-3 904 <1:91@ =1A5 4 904A46;A4 2?7@192 90-99049A1-5;?A93A;:44/4/;.904-22?@391;.90-9904 -::?24/;-74994/904H1/.-331.=;6904<1:91@=1A54 2?7@19290-9904-::?24/;/1/.;90-<49041.94.91;. 9; -749 904 H1/.-3 -./ /1/ .; -:9 1. 6?A904A-.:4 ;6 90-9 1.94.91;.4.:49049A1-5;?A9:;?5/.;90-<4:;.<1:94/ 01@6;A904;664.:43?.120-754?./4A4:91;.#**;6 -./4:91;.$;6904:9( ) 904 54-A.4/ //191;.-5 9-94 ?751: A;24:?9;A 2?7@1994/ 90-9 904 -::?24/ ; C-2 -52; - A421/4.9;69042-@4<155-=4-./04127;?./9;H.;C90-9 -7;?9 904 <1:91@ =1A5 -2 C455 -2 904 -::?24/ ; 4 2?7@192 90-9 C04. 904 -::?24/ ; 0-/ 3A;<1/4/ - @;9;A:8:549;904-::?24/;9;9-H4904<1:91@=1A51912 - 7 - :54-A90-9904-::?24/;-52;0-/H.;C54/=4-7;?9904 :A1@1.-51.94.9;6904-::?24/;4904A46;A42?7@192 90-9 904 -::?24/ ; -74994/ 904 -::?24/ ; 1. :;@@1221;.;6904:A1@4-./04.:4-::?24/;1251-754 6;A ;664.:4 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;. #** ;6 -./ 4:91;.$;6904:9 * 694A 04-A1.= 904 54-A.4/ :;?.245 6;A 904 -::?24/;-2C455-290454-A.4///191;.-59-94?751: A;24:?9;A9043;1.96;A:;.21/4A-91;.90-9-A12426;A;?A :;.21/4A-91;.12B J!04904A904A4122?661:14.94<1/4.:49;:;.<1:9 904 -::?24/ ; 6;A -. ;664.:4 3?.120-754 ?./4A4:91;.#**A4-/C1904:91;.#%;6 -./4:91;.$;6904:9(KL $ :A1@1.-5 3A;24:?91;. C-2 5-?.:04/ 7-24/ ;. 904 1.6;A@-91;. 3A;<1/4/ 78 ! ;. (% 04 -::?24/;-./904<1:91@=1A5C4A49A-:4/1.8/4A-7-/ ;.#((%0429-94@4.9;6904<1:91@=1A5A4:;A/4/ ;.((%C01:012-694AM/-826A;@904/-94;6904 - 8 - -554=4/ 1.:1/4.9 9 12 4<1/4.9 6A;@ 904 29-94@4.9 <1:91@ =1A590-9904-::?24/;5?A4/04A041.:1/4.9-554=4/58 ;::?AA4/ 1. 6A;.9 ;6 - >443 29-./ C04A4 24<4A-5 34A2;.2 C;?5/ 74 =-904A4/ 9; =; 9; 9041A A4234:91<4 /4291.-91;.2 01229-94@4.9-52;1./1:-94290-919C-2904-::?24/; C0; :;@34554/ 904 <1:91@ =1A5 9; =; -5;.= C190 01@ 04 -::?24/ ; -554=4/58 :-@4 1.9; 904 31:9?A4 -694A 904 -::?24/;945430;.4/01@-./04-AA1<4/-99042:4.4 ;6 904 1.:1/4.9 ;. - @;9;A:8:54 04 -::?24/ ; 4.9A?294/904.14:4;6904<1:91@=1A59;904-::?24/; -./ 234/ -C-8 ;. 904 @;9;A:8:54 -5;.= C190 904 <1:91@ =1A5 M !B :5-1@4/ 90-9 -::?24/ ; C-2 -52; - A421/4.9 ;6 04A <155-=4 !04. 204 4.I?1A4/ C190 01@ 04 /12:5;24/ 90-9 -::?24/ ; 9;;H 904 <1:91@ =1A5 9;C-A/2 904 A-15C-8 29-91;. D:439 9012 204 /1/ .;9 @4.91;. -.8901.=-7;?99041.<;5<4@4.9;6904-::?24/;04 @;9;A:8:54 C-2 241G4/ ;. 904 2-@4 /-8 14 ;. (%-234ADB)!BC0;C-2904@;904A;6 - 9 - 904<1:91@=1A5/1/.;9@4.91;.-7;?99041.<;5<4@4.9;6 904 -::?24/ ; 04 @;904A ;6 904 <1:91@ =1A5 /1/ .;9 -554=4 -.8 @;91<4 ;A 1.<;5<4@4.9 ;6 904 -::?24/ ; 1. -74991.= 904 ;664.:4 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;. #** ;6 . 904 :;.9A-A8 904 -::?24/ ; C-2 3A424.9 90A;?=0;?9C190904!B & !B 904 <1:91@ =1A5 ;.58 @4.91;.4/ -7;?9 904 -::?24/9-H1.=04A9;/A;304A-99040;2319-5C04A4!B 0-/ =;.4 6;A 9A4-9@4.9 7?9 9;;H 04A 9; A-15C-8 29-91;. 012 12 0;C4<4A :;.9A-A8 9; 04A 29-94@4.9 ?./4A 4:91;.*%;6A-220429-94/90-92040-./4/;<4A 04A%84-A;5/.14:49;904-::?24/;!B-52;29-94/ 90-9 -::?24/ ; C-2 -9 904 7?2 29-./ 04A46;A4 19 12 4<1/4.96A;@9044<1/4.:4;6!B90-91912-::?24/; C0;C-2A423;.217546;A-7/?:91.=04AD:4399012904A4 12.;;904A4<1/4.:4;.A4:;A/9;:;..4:9904-::?24/C190 904:A1@4?./4A4:91;.#**(&A4-/C1904:91;.#%;6 -./4:91;.$;6:9 - 10 - ( 04 9A1-5 ;?A9 C0154 0;5/1.= 90-9 904 -::?24/ ;C-2=?1598;6904;664.:4045/90-9904-::?24/; 0-/-74994/904-::?24/;9;H1/.-3904<1:91@=1A59; 0-5H1 -15C-8 9-91;. ; @-94A1-5 12 35-:4/ 78 904 3A;24:?91;. 9; 51.H 904 -::?24/ ; 9; 904 @;9;A:8:54 241G4/ -2 B D:439 904 2C4431.= 29-94@4.9 @-/4 1. 904 >?/=@4.9 ;6 904 9A1-5 ;?A9 904A4 12 .; 61./1.= A4:;A/4/789049A1-5;?A9A4=-A/1.=904-749@4.978904 -::?24/;1.-.;664.:43?.120-754?./4A4:91;.#** A4-/C1904:91;.$;6904:9 .<14C;6904-7;<4C40-<4.;04219-91;.9; 0;5/90-99043A;24:?91;.6-154/9;3A;<4904;664.:4?./4A 4:91;. #** (& A4-/ C190 4:91;. #% ;6 -./ 4:91;.$;6904:9(-2-=-1.29904-::?24/ ;.90-9<14C;6904@-994AC43A;:44/9;3-22904 6;55;C1.= 1 334-512 - 11 - 11 04 1@3?=.4/ >?/=@4.9 ;6 :;.<1:91;. -./ ;A/4A;624.94.:4/-94/()((*3-224/ 1.34:1-5-24; ()78904:;?A9;6 904 34:1-5 '?/=4 -./ //191;.-5 129A1:9 -./ 4221;.2 '?/=4 1/-A :;.<1:91.= 904 -33455-.9 -::?24/ ; 6;A 904 ;664.:42 3?.120-754 ?./4A 4:91;.2 #** (& A4-/ C190 4:91;. #% ;6 -./ 4:91;. $ ;6 904:9(12249-21/4 111 04-33455-.9 -::?24/ ;12 -:I?1994/;6 9042-1/;664.:42 1< 04 ;661:4 12 /1A4:94/ 9; :;@@?.1:-94 - :;38 ;6 9012 ;A/4A 9; 904 A1-5 ;?A9 6;A 6?A904A.44/6?5-:91;. < .8 7-15 7;./2 24:?A198 6?A.1204/ 78 904 -::?24/; -33455-.929-./2/12:0-A=4/ -* %) -* %$) 129;5;%&