Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54558 (KAR)
MAHEBOOBBI v. ANAND AND ANR
MFA/202489/2022 · 2026-02-03
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54558 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54558 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$$
%&' () $$
*
%&' $$
*
%&' $$
*
%&' $$
%&' $$
+ +
%&'
(
)
!"
#
$
%
"
$%
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"%
!"! !"&"
# $'(
""&"&)" %
' ' "*)$"% '
'
" &"&'
&!! &"&
*(
)
+*
!"
$
%
"
"%
$%
- 3 -
!"! !"&"
$'(
" &*&)" %
' ' "*)$"% '
'
" &"& '
&! &"&
*(
)
+*
!"
$
%
"
"
$%
!"! - 4 -
!"&"
$'(
*&!&)" %
''"*)$"%'
'
" &"& '
&!* &"&
*
(
)
,
&
!"
$
%
"
"%
$%
!"! !"&"
- 5 -
$'(
*&!&)" %
' ' "*)$"% '
'
" &"& '
&! &"&
(
)
+&
!"
$
%
"
"
$%
!"! !"&"
- 6 -
$'(
*&!&)" %
''"*)$"%'
'
" &"&'
&*" &"&
+ +(
)
+
!"
$
%
"
"
$%
!"! !"&"
$'(
"&!&)" %
- 7 -
''"*)$"%'
'
" &"&
'
&*& &"&
'
-
#
" ./012./03.145637.2/88./093:;50<=.8/0<9.7
=.7. /88./27 /0.80.;.00.1 >? <=. 0.78.4<9@. 42/9A/3<7 93 57&! &"& &!! &"& &!* &"& &! &"& &*& &"& /31 &*" &"& /77/9293: <=. B61:A.3< /31 /C/01 1/<.1 " &"& 53 <=. ;92. 5; <=. 119<953/2 .3950 9@92 61:./31D/<9B/?/860/7..E93:.3=/34.A.3<5; 45A8.37/<953 ) ./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. 3760/34. 5A8/3? 76>A9<<.1<=/<<=.09>63/2=/7/C/01.1B67<45A8.37/<95393 <=./>5@.4/7.7/313593<.0;.0.34.974/22.1;5093<=.A/<<.0
- 8 -
+ /@93: </E.3 35<. 5; <=. 76>A9779537 A/1. >? <=. 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. 8/0<9.7 /31 <=. ;93193: 0.4501.1>?<=.09>63/29<9735<9319786<./7<5<=.93B609.7 767</93.1>?<=.42/9A/3<79357&!! &"&&!* &"& &*& &"*53/44563<5;<=.05/1<0/;;94/4491.3<544600.153
"+&F&"&=.09>63/2=/7/C/01.1/:25>/245A8.37/<953 5; 7)&&&& <5 <=. 42/9A/3<7 93 <=. />5@. 4/7.7 5C.@.0</E93:93<5/44563<<=. A/<.09/2/@/92/>2.530.4501 /7<5<=.3/<60.5;93B60?767</93.1>?<=./;50.7/9142/9A/3<7 /7 8.0 <=. C5631 4.0<9;94/<.7 805164.1 >? <=.A /A 5; <=. @9.C<=/</:25>/245A8.37/<9535;7"&&&&& >./C/01.1 <5 <=.7. 42/9A/3<7 C9<= 93<.0.7< /< !G 8.0 /336A ;05A <=. 1/<.5;42/9A8.<9<953<9220./29H/<953
/@93:</E.335<.5;<=.;93193:0.4501.1>?<=.09>63/2 9<9735<9319786<.<=/<<=.42/9A/3<935&! &"&=/7 767</93.1 :09.@567 93B60? 53 /44563< 5; <=. /4491.3< 544600.1 53"+&F&"&3501.0<5805@.<=.93B609.7<=.42/9A/3<=/7 .I/A93.1 <=. <0./<93: 154<50 /7 /7 <5 <=. 93B60? 767</93.1>?<=.42/9A/3<=56:=9<971.857.1>?<=.154<50 <=/< 42/9A/3< =/7 767</93.1 8.0A/3.3< 197/>929<? />56< )& <5
- 9 -
)G 0.2/<.1 <5 09:=< 688.0 29A> =5C.@.0 /A 5; <=. @9.C <=/<9<97/8805809/<.<5</E.197/>929<?<5<=..I<.3<5;"&G<5 <=.C=52.>51? ! /E93:93<5/44563<<=.:691.293.75;<=./03/</E/</<. .:/2.0@94.76<=509<?<=.35<953/29345A.5;<=.42/9A/3<97 </E.3 /< 7&& 8.0 A53<= /31 /882?93: <=. A62<9829.0 5;
"!<=.42/9A/3<97.3<9<2.1;507"&!&& $&&I"I"!I
"&G% <5C/017 <=. 2577 5; ;6<60. 9345A. /E93: 93<5 /44563< <=.3/<60.5;93B60?767</93.1>?<=.42/9A/3</78.0I*<=.
/C/015;45A8.37/<95397A519;9.1/7>.25C
./17 A563< $9368..7%
/93/3176;;.093: )&&&&&&
577 5; ./0393:7 16093: 2/91 68 8.0951$7&&I)%
"!&&&& 5775;;6<60.5;./0393:7
"&!&&&&
5C/017 A.194/2 /31 93491.3</2 .I8.37.7 &&&&&&
5775;/A.39<9.7
"&&&&&& 5</2
" "&&&&
- 10 -
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
/E93:93<5/44563<<=.93B60?767</93.1>?<=.42/9A/3< <=./C/015;45A8.37/<953<5C/0175<=.0=./17970./77.77.1 /7;5225C7 ./17 A563< $9368..7%
/93/3176;;.093: &&&&&
- 11 -
577 5; ./0393:7 16093: 2/91 68 8.0951$7&&I)%
"!&&&& 5775;;6<60.5;./0393:7 FF&&&&&
5C/017 A.194/2 /31 93491.3</2 .I8.37.7 &&&&&
5775;/A.39<9.7
"&&&&&& 5</2
"*"&&&&&
F /@93: </E.3 35<. 5; <=. 76>A9779537 A/1. >? <=. 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. 8/0<9.7 /31 <=. ;93193: 0.4501.1 >? <=. 09>63/2 93 5&*" &"& 9< 97 35< 93 19786<.<=/<<=.42/9A/3<767</93.1:09.@56793B60?53/44563< 5;<=./4491.3<544600.153"+&F&"&.067/25;<=..@91.34. 5; 0<=58.194 60:.53 /31 <=. 197/>929<? 4.0<9;94/<. 805164.1 /< I* 9< 97 ;50<=45A93: <=/< <=. 93B60? 5* 97 :09.@567 93 3/<60. 4450193:2? <=. 09>63/2 56:=< <5 =/@. </E.3<=.8.0A/3.3<197/>929<?<5<=..I<.3<5;"G937<./15; G 882?93: <=. 8058.0 A62<9829.05; " >? 453791.093: <=. 35<953/2 A53<=2? 9345A. 5; <=. 42/9A/3< /< 7&& <=. 42/9A/3<97.3<9<2.1;507"" && $&&I"I"I"G% <5C/01725775;;6<60.9345A./E93:93<5/44563<<=.93B60? - 12 -
767</93.1>?<=.42/9A/3<8/0<9462/02?0/6A/<94/A86</<9535;
09:=< 931.I ;93:.0 <=. /C/01 5; 45A8.37/<953 A/1. >? <=. 09>63/2970./77.77.1/7;5225C7
./17 A563< $9368..7%
/93/3176;;.093: )&&&&&&
577 5; ./0393:7 16093: 2/91 68 8.0951$7&&I)%
"!&&&& 5775;;6<60.5;./0393:7
"" &&&&&
5C/017 A.194/2 /31 93491.3</2 .I8.37.7 &&&&&&
5</2
"&)&&&&
"& 3<=.0.762<8/77<=.;5225C93:
$9% =. />5@. 974.22/3.567 '907< 88./27 /0. /225C.1 938/0<
$99% =.42/9A/3<793579357&!! &"& &!* &"& &*& &"* /0. =.21 .3<9<2.1 ;50 :25>/2 45A8.37/<953 5; 7"&&&&& ./4= $/7 /:/937< 7)&&&&
- 13 -
/C/01.1>?<=.09>63/2%C9<=93<.0.7</<!G8.0/336A;05A <=.1/<.5;42/9A8.<9<953<9220./29H/<953 3@9.C5;<=.501.05;<=97560<1/<.1""&"&)<=. 42/9A/3<935&!! &"&7=/2235<>..3<9<2.1;5093<.0.7< ;50/8.09515;*F1/?71.2/?93;9293:<=97/88./2
$999% =. 42/9A/3< 93 5&! &"& 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 <5</2 45A8.37/<953 5; 7" "&&
$/7 /:/937< <=. 45A8.37/<953 5; 7F+&&& /C/01.1 >? <=. 09>63/2% C9<= 93<.0.7< /< !G 8.0 /336A ;05A <=. 1/<. 5; 42/9A 8.<9<953 <922 0./29H/<953 $9@% =. 42/9A/3< 93 5&!
&"& 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 <5</2 45A8.37/<953 5; 7"*"&&&
$/7 /:/937< <=. 45A8.37/<953 5; 7F"&&& /C/01.1 >? <=. 09>63/2% C9<= 93<.0.7< /< !G 8.0 /336A ;05A <=. 1/<. 5; 42/9A 8.<9<953 <922 0./29H/<953 $@% =. 42/9A/3< 93 5&*" &"& 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 <5</2 45A8.37/<953 5; 7"&)&&
$/7 /:/937< <=. 45A8.37/<9535;7""&&&& /C/01.1>?<=.09>63/2%C9<=
- 14 -
93<.0.7< /< !G 8.0 /336A ;05A <=. 1/<. 5; 42/9A 8.<9<953 <922 0./29H/<953 $@9% 3 /22 5<=.0 0.78.4<7 <=. 45AA53 61:A.3< /31 C/01 8/77.1 >? <=. 09>63/2 7=/22 0.A/93 63/2<.0.1 4450193:2? <=. 45AA53 61:A.3< /31 C/01 1/<.1
" &"& 532? C9<= 0.78.4< <5
57&! &"& &!! &"& &!* &"& &! &"& &*& &"& /31 &*" &"&53<=.;92.5;<=.119<953/2.39509@9261:./31 D/<9B/?/860/7=/227</31A519;9.1
,( %' #
7/4 97<5"25)