- 1 - ! " # # $ "" %$& ' !"#$%$ & ' ( $ ) *)"+ !"#$%$ , )) !"#$%$ & ' ), %$%#,%," $ ( Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) $+'$() $-## ) ,$%,,%," ) *",,%,$ ) , ) ) . . $ ' . ( /012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ 3;<=19 <> ?<;@/1A390<1 3B346/6 78 9:/ C/341/6 66090<13C /10<4 050C =62/ 316 30?:=4 ':/1?/><49: 4/>/44/6 9< 3A D9:/ 407=13CE(01 <*",,%,$506/F=62;/193163B346 639/6 ,$%,,%," 9:/ ?C30;319 :3A ?<;/ =@ B09: 9:/ @4/A/193@@/3C=16/4/?90<1$+'$(<>9:/<9<4/:0?C/ ?9$-## - 3 - , :/>3?9A<>9:/?3A/<>9:/?C30;31901740/>34/ 9:39<1,-%#,%,$3937<=9%+%@;:/B3A4060123 ;<9<4?8?C/ >4<; //4;3150 316 B:/1 :/ 4/3?:/6 1/34 36:3G40A:13 3;@ 0;09A <1 04B34 ! 3150 4<36 3 =A 7/34012 /2 < *)"+ 6405/1 78 09A 6405/4 01 3 43A: 316 1/2C02/19 ;311/4 >4<; <@@<A09/ 604/?90<1 63A:/6 32301A9 9:/ ;<9<4?8?C/ =/ 9< 9:/ 0;@3?9 9:/ ?C30;319 >/CC 6<B1 316 A=A9301/6 240/5<=A 01F=40/A/9<<G94/39;/193A01@390/19316A=>>/4/6C<AA <> 01?<;/ 6=/ 9< 60A370C098 /1?/ 9:/ ?C30;319 :3A A<=2:9><4?<;@/1A390<1<>A""%%%%B09:019/4/A9 >9/4 :/34012 7<9: 9:/ @3490/A 316 ?<1A06/4012 9:/ /506/1?/ ><49:?<;012 <1 4/?<46 9:/ 407=13C 3CC<B/6 9:/@/9090<1<>9:/?C30;31901@34924319012?<;@/1A390<1 <>A+-,%%%B09:019/4/A939*H@3>4<;9:/639/<> @/9090<1 90CC 4/3C0I390<1 :/ ?C30;319 ?<19/16012 9:39 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 24319 0A ;/32/4:3A ?<;/ =@ B09: @4/A/19 3@@/3C - 4 - :/ 342=;/19 <> 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 9:/ ?C30;319 0A 9:39 9:/ 407=13C :3A ?<;;099/6 /44<4 01 >3A9/10129:/C0370C098<19:/?C30;3199<9://J9/19<>%H B09:<=9318/506/1?/)=49:/49:/?<;@/1A390<124319/6 =16/49:/:/36<>C<AA<>/3410126=40129:/C306=@@/40<6 0A ;/32/4 :/ 407=13C :3A 1<9 ?<1A06/4/6 9:/ >=9=4/ @4<A@/?9A <> 9:/ ?C30;319 /5/1 9:<=2: 9:/ 6<?9<4 :3A 3AA/AA/6 9:/ C0370C098 39 %H 9< 9:/ B:<C/ 7<68 / ?<19/16A 9:39 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 3B346/6 9<B346A @301 316 A=>>/4012 0A ;/32/4 3A 9:/ ?C30;319 :36 A=>>/4/6 >43?9=4/ <> 5093C 7<1/A B:0?: B3A >0J/6 =A012 0;@C319A /A06/A :/ ?<19/16A 9:39 1< ?<;@/1A390<1 0A @306 9<B346A >=9=4/ ;/60?3C /J@/1A/A /5/1 9:<=2: 9:/ 6<?9<4 :366/@<A/69:393A=;<>A"%%%B<=C67/1//6/6 ><44/;<53C<>0;@C319A:/4/><4/9:/C/341/6?<=1A/C><4 9:/ ?C30;319 :3A A<=2:9 ><4 /1:31?/;/19 <> 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 - 5 - " 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 9:/ 4/A@<16/19 <, :3A ?<19/16/6 9:39 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 24319/6789:/407=13C0AF=A93164/3A<137C/3169:/4/0A 1< 4/3A<1 ><4 /1:31?/;/19 <> 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 :/4/><4/ 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 9:/ 4/A@<16/19 <, A<=2:9><460A;0AA3C<>9:/3@@/3C * /346 9:/ 342=;/19A <> C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 7<9:9:/@3490/A/4=A/69:/4/C/5319;39/403CA<14/?<46 + A @/4 9:/ 0;@=21/6 F=62;/19 9:/ 407=13C 6/9/4;01/6 9<93C ?<;@/1A390<1 <> A$$--"% 316 ?3;/ 9< 9:/ ?<1?C=A0<1 9:39 9:/4/ B3A ?<19407=9<48 1/2C02/1?/<19:/@349<>9:/?C30;3199<31/J9/19<>%H 01 ?3=A012 9:/ 3??06/19 9 9:/4/><4/ @4<@<490<139/C8 3B346/6 ?<;@/1A390<1 <> A+-,%%% B09: 019/4/A9 39 *H@3 # 19:/@4/A/193@@/3C9:/4/A@<16/19 <,:3A 1<960A@=9/6 9:/ >3?9 9:39 9:/ ?C30;319 A=A9301/6 01F=40/A 01 9:/ 3??06/19 015<C5012 9:/ ;<9<4?8?C/ <> 9:/ ?C30;319 - 6 - 316 9:/ 37<5/ A306 =A :/ A=7;0AA0<1 <> 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 9:/ 4/A@<16/19A 0A 9:39 9:/ 407=13C :3A402:9C8?<1A06/4/69:/1<90<13C01?<;/<>9:/?C30;319 316 9:/60A370C098 3A 6/@<A/678 9:/ 6<?9<4 316 3B346/6 F=A93164/3A<137C/?<;@/1A390<1=16/49:/:/36<>C<AA <>>=9=4//341012A - <B/5/4 3A A=7;099/6 78 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><49:/?C30;3193163CA<3A><49:?<;012>4<;9:/@3@/4A <1 4/?<46 09 0A ?C/34 9:39 9:/ ?C30;319 A=>>/4/6 240/5<=A 01F=40/AA=?:3A ! $% :/ 5093C @349A <> 9:/ 402:9 C<B/4 C0;7 B3A A/5/4/C8 3>>/?9/6 4/A=C9012 01 9/;@<4348 60A37C/;/19 :/4/><4/ 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 9<B346A @301 316 A=>>/4012 ?317/4/3A<137C86/9/4;01/639A,"%%%@/4>43?9=4/ <> 5093C 7<1/A /1?/ 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 <> A,$,%% - 7 - 3B346/6 78 9:/ 407=13C =16/4 9:/ :/36 <> @301 316 A=>>/4012 6/A/45/A /1:31?/;/19 :/4/><4/ 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<13;<=19=16/49:/:/36 0A/1:31?/69< $$ <4/<5/4?<1A06/40129:/139=4/<>9:/01F=40/A A=>>/4/6 316 9:/ @/40<6 <> 94/39;/19 93G/1 78 9:/ ?C30;319 :/ ;=A9 :35/ A=>>/4/6 C<AA <> 01?<;/ ><4 3 @/40<6 <> 9:4// ;<19:A 6=4012 9:/ 94/39;/19 /1?/ 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1=16/49:/:/36<> 0A /1:31?/6 9< $, )=49:/4 3A 342=/6 78 9:/ C/341/6 ?<=1A/C ><4 9:/ ?C30;319 /5/1 9:<=2: 9:/ 6<?9<4 :3A 6/@<A/6 01 :0A /506/1?/ 9:39 9:/ ?C30;319 B<=C6 4/K=04/ /J@/1A/A 9<B346A >=9=4/ ;/60?3C 94/39;/19 A=?: 3A A=42/48 ><4 4/;<53C <> 0;@C319A 9:/ 407=13C :3A>30C/69< 24319 318 ?<;@/1A390<1=16/49:/:/36<>>=9=4/;/60?3C/J@/1A/A 5/1 9:<=2: 09 0A ;/190<1/6 01 9:/ 0;@=21/6 F=62;/19 - 8 - 9:399:/?<;@/1A390<1<>A$""%0A3B346/6=16/4 9:/ :/36;/60?3C /J@/1A/A316 >=9=4/ ;/60?3C /J@/1A/A 9:/ A306 3;<=19 0A 9:/ 3;<=19 3C4/368 A@/19 78 9:/ ?C30;3199<B346A:0A94/39;/193A@/49:/;/60?3C70CCA39 J$% :/4/><4/ 9:/ 37<5/ A306 3;<=19 6</A 1<9 01?C=6/ 9:/ /J@/1A/A 9<B346A >=9=4/ ;/60?3C /J@/1A/A /1?/ =16/4 9:/ ?04?=;A931?/A ?<1A06/4012 9:/ ;/60?3C /506/1?/ <1 4/?<46 31 3;<=19 <> 0A 3B346/6 3A ?<;@/1A390<1 =16/4 9:/ :/36 <> A342=/6789:/C/341/6?<=1A/C><4 9:/ 4/A@<16/19A 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 3B346/6 78 9:/ 407=13C=16/4<9:/4:/36A34/F=A93164/3A<137C/ $ :/ 6<?=;/19348 /506/1?/ 01 9:/ ><4; <> ?:342/A://9 @4<6=?/6 78 9:/ ?C30;319 39 J B<=C6 A:<B 9:39 3>9/4 015/A902390<1 9:/ @<C0?/ >0C/6 9:/ ?:342/ A://9 32301A9 9:/ ?C30;319 316 3CA< 32301A9 9:/ 4/A@<16/19 <$ B:< B/4/ 406/4 <> 9:/ ;<9<4?8?C/ 316 9:/6405/4<>9:/=A4/A@/?905/C83CC/20129:399:/ 3??06/199<<G@C3?/6=/9<43A:3161/2C02/19406012<>9:/ - 9 - ;<9<4?8?C/3166405012<>9:/7=A789:/?C30;319 3169:/4/A@<16/19 <$4/A@/?905/C8:/4/><4/9:/4/0A 1< /44<4 ?<;;099/6 78 9:/ 407=13C 01 ?<;012 9< 9:/ ?<1?C=A0<1 9:39 9:/4/ B3A 1/2C02/1?/ <1 9:/ @349 <> 9:/ ?C30;319 9< 9:/ /J9/19 <> %H 316 9:/4/78 6/9/4;01012 9:/?<;@/1A390<139*%H $ 150/B<>9:/60A?=AA0<1;36/37<5/B/34/<> 9:/ ?<1A06/4/6 50/B 9:39 9:/ 9<93C ?<;@/1A390<1 0A /1:31?/63A9:/><CC<B012 ( ")*+,-.()*/ 0.1+ %,1/& $ 301316A=>>/4012 +"%%% , )<<6 316 <=40A:;/19 ?<15/831?/ 316 399/16319?:342/A ,%%%% /60?3C/J@/1A/A $""% <AA <> 01?<;/ 6=4012 9:/@/40<6<>94/39;/19 "%%% " <AA<>>=9=4//341012 $%-%% * <AA<>3;/1090/A $%%%% + J@/1A/A9<B346A>=9=4/ ;/60?3C94/39;/19 "%%% +)( 2!23!4 - 10 - $" A A939/6 /34C0/4 9:/4/ B3A 1/2C02/1?/ <1 9:/ @349 <> 9:/ ?C30;319 9< 31 /J9/19 <> %H 316 9:/4/><4/ %H <> 9:/ 37<5/ 6/9/4;01/6 ?<;@/1A390<1 3;<=19 A:<=C67/4/6=?/69<B346A?<19407=9<481/2C02/1?/<19:/ @349<>?C30;319/1?/9:/?C30;3190A/1909C/69<*%H<> 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 4/6/9/4;01/6 78 9:0A <=49 3A 37<5/ 316 9:/4/><4/ :/ 0A /1909C/6 9< ?<;@/1A390<1 <> A#**,"% B09: 019/4/A9 39 *H @/4 311=; :/ ?<;@/1A390<13B346/60AF=A93164/3A<137C/ $* 01?/9:/C0370C098<>9:/4/A@<16/19 <,7/012 <B1/4316A/C>01A=4/40A=160A@=9/69:/4/A@<16/19 <, A:3CC@389:/3><4/A306?<;@/1A390<13C<12B09:019/4/A939 *H@/4311=;>4<;9:/639/<>@/9090<190CC4/3C0I390<1 $+ 19:/4/A=C99:/3@@/3C6/A/45/A9<7/3CC<B/6 01@3493169:/4/><4/B/@4<?//69<@3AA9:/><CC<B012 0 :/3@@/3C0A! - 11 - 00 :/ ?C30;3193@@/CC319 0A /1909C/6 9< 9<93C ?<;@/1A390<1 <> A#**,"% 3A 32301A9 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 24319/6 78 9:/ 407=13C 39A+-,%%% 000 :/ 4/A@<16/19 <, A:3CC @38 9:/ ?<;@/1A390<1 3;<=19 B09: 019/4/A9 39 *H @/4 311=; >4<; 9:/ 639/ <> @/9090<1 90CC 4/3C0I390<1 05 :/ ?<;@/1A390<1 3;<=19 B09: 019/4/A9 A:3CC 7/6/@<A09/6 789:/4/A@<16/19 <, 7/><4/ 9:/ 407=13C B09:01 3 @/40<6 <> <1/ ;<19: >4<; 9:/ 639/ <> 4/?/0@9 <> 3 ?/490>0/6?<@8<>9:0AF=62;/19 5 ://1:31?/6 ?<;@/1A390<1 3;<=19 7/012 ;/32/4 =@<1 6/@<A09 <> 9:/ 3;<=19 9:/ /1904/ /1:31?/6 ?<;@/1A390<1 3;<=19 A:3CC7/@3069<9:/?C30;319 50 13B346A:3CC7/643B13??<46012C8 0A9 <$C <" 56 % & 56 % $&