- 1 - ! "# # $%& $'() &$( * ! " ! #$#% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " &$ !!! " " #$' " ! ( !&$! ) %''* ! ! " " ! " ! !! %! *## !" ! + + , " " -./012.2.34./5.617847191:2.34#$35 /11;.4< 23 =8>/- 2-1 093:117.4</ 3%''* 9.?1 3#* 91<./21917 @A ">6>4><>9 36.:1 2>2.34 .B>A>089> 539 2-1 35514:1/ 084./->@61 84719 1:2.34/>47%352-1//142.>63??37.2.1/:2*## 539 /-392 C2-1 :2D ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/ 091/1426A 0147.4< 34 2-1 5.61 35 776 .E.6 "87<1 >47 " ! .B>A>089> - 3 - -1 5>:28>6 ?>29.F 35 2-1 :>/1 ./ 2->2 34 &* 2-1 35 ">6>4><>9 36.:1 2>2.34 .B>A>089> 34 91:1.02 35 :917.@61 .4539?>2.34 >@382 2-1 .661<>6 29>4/0392>2.34 >47 /239.4< 35 8@6.: ./29.@82.34 A/21? 9.:1 539 /-392 C 9.:1D .4 2-1 <337/ E1-.:61 @1>9.4< 91<./29>2.34 3 $** 98/-17 23 2-1 /032>634<G.2-2-1/2>55>470>4:->/>47.4219:102172-1 E1-.:61 >47 /1.H17 #& =8.42>6/ 35 9.:1 E>6817 >2 /%#'>4779>G40>4:->4>?>>4791<./219172-1 :3?06>.42 ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/ 4 14=8.9A .2 G>/ 91E1>6172->22-1012.2.3419/>91.661<>66A29>4/0392.4<>47 /239.4<2-19.:1G-.:-./?1>425397./29.@82.3484719 8@6.: ./29.@82.34 A/21? >47 2-1A >91 /166.4< .2 .4 2-1 3014 ?>9;12 >2 -.<-19 09.:1 -191>5219 2-1 91/0347142 036.:1 .4E1/2.<>217 2-1 :>/1 >47 6>.7 2-1 :->9<1 /-112 ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/ 539 2-1 >5391/>.7 35514:1/ 1.4< ><<9.1E17@A2-1/>?12-1091/142012.2.34./5.617 2.//2>217.42-1012.2.342->22-1093:117.4</ .4.2.>217 84719 1:2.34/ >47 % 35 2-1 :2 ./ .661<>6 >47 - 4 - >9@.29>9A .4 E.1G 35 2-1 5>:2 2->2 />.7 093E./.34 ./ >006.:>@61 346A 23 2-1 019/34/ G-3 >91 -367.4< >82-39.H>2.34847192-1 3429369719'4 2-1 .4/2>42 :>/1 2-1 012.2.3419/ >91 432 -367.4< >82-39.H>2.34 84719 /A/21? -1915391 2-1 =81/2.34 35 :3429>E142.34 35 2-1 .4<917.142/ 35 1:2.34/ >47 % 731/432>9./114:11:2.34/>47%352-1:273432 >229>:2 ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/ ::397.4<6A 09>A17 23 =8>/-2-1093:117.4</ & 61>9417 .<- 3892 3E194?142 61>719 >001>9.4< 539 91/0347142 32>21 /8@?.2217 2->2 2-1 91/0347142 036.:1 >5219 :3478:2.4< > 712>.617 .4E1/2.<>2.34 6>.7 :->9<1 /-112 ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/ 539 2-135514:1/084./->@61847191:2.34/>47%352-1:2 >472-1:->9<1/-112G.241//1/->E1:61>96A/2>217>@382 2-1 9>.7 :3478:217 @A 2-1 .4E1/2.<>2.34 355.:19 34 &* >47 >6/3 /1.H891 35 9.:1 .1 &$% @></ 232>6.4< #& =8.42>6/ .4 2-1 E1-.:61 4 /8:- - 5 - :.9:8?/2>4:1/2-1093:117.4</:>4432@1=8>/-17><>.4/2 2-1012.2.3419/ # ->E1<.E14?A>4F.38/:34/.719>2.34@32-34 2-1 /8@?.//.34 ?>71 @A 2-1 61>9417 .<- 3892 3E194?142 61>719 >47 >6/3 0198/17 2-1 73:8?142/ >E>.6>@613491:397.4:687.4<2-1:->9<1/-112 ' / :3867 @1 <>2-1917 593? 91:397/ @>/17 34 2-1 :917.@61 .4539?>2.34 2-1 35 ">6>4><>9 36.:1 2>2.34:3478:217>9>.7>634<G.2-2-1!3374/01:23935 .B>A>089> >2 >@382 0? 34 &* @A .4219:102.4<2-1E1-.:61@1>9.4<91<./29>2.343 $ ** >47 /1.H17 #& =8.42>6/ 35 9.:1 E>6817 >2 /%#'>47>6/379>G40>4:->4>?>>472-191>5219 91<./21917 2-1 :3?06>.42 -1 0>4:-> G.241//1/ ->E1 /2>217 2-1 />?1 .4 2-1.9 /2>21?142/ >47 ?>->H>9 G>/ 79>G4 23 2->2 1551:2 91/1426A 2-1 .4E1/2.<>2.34 ./ :3?061217>47:->9<1/-112->/@1146>.7 - 6 - % 2 ./ /122617 03/.2.34 35 6>G 2->2 =8>/-.4< 2-1 :9.?.4>6093:117.4</./:>6617539346A.4>:>/1G-1912-1 :3?06>.42 731/ 432 7./:63/1 >4A 35514:1 39 ./ 59.E3638/ E1F>2.38/ 3930091//.E1 5 2-1 >661<>2.34/ /12 382 .4 2-1 :3?06>.42 73 432 :34/2.2821 2-1 35514:1 35 G-.:- :3<4.H>4:1->/@1142>;14@A2-1 ><./29>21.2./3014539 2-./ 3892 23 =8>/- 2-1 />?1 2 ./ 432 41:1//>9A 2->2 > ?12.:8638/>4>6A/./352-1:>/1/-3867@17341@153912-1 29.>6235.47382G-12-192-1:>/1G3867147.4:34E.:2.34 39 >:=8.22>6 5 .2 >001>9/ 34 > 91>7.4< 35 2-1 :3?06>.42 >47:34/.719>2.34352-1>661<>2.34/2-191.4.42-16.<-235 2-1 /2>21?142 ?>71 34 3>2- 2->2 2-1 .4<917.142/ 35 2-1 35514:1 >91 7./:63/17 2-191 G3867 @1 43 B8/2.5.:>2.34 539 2-./389223.42195191.42-1093:117.4</ $ 42-1.4/2>42:>/12-1>006.:>@.6.2A351:2.34/ >47 % 35 :2 23 2-1 012.2.3419/ ->/ 23 @1 21/217 .4 > 712>.617 29.>6 /.4:1 2-1.9 .4E36E1?142 ./ 5392-:3?.4< >/ 2-1A G191 >991/217 G-.61 .661<>66A 29>4/0392.4<2-19.:14/8:-:.9:8?/2>4:1/5.4743 - 7 - <337 <93847/ 23 =8>/- 2-1 093:117.4</ ><>.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419/::397.4<6A2-1012.2.34./ +) $ ( ./23+63+