- 1 - ! "#$ %#& !" #$ "$ % &" "" &" $ ' ( " " " ' ! " #$ % ) " & * + & & " ) & Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " +* ) *+*" " " , " & " -. " ) / 0 " " 123 45626278 23 92:5; <= 615 456262785> 355?28@ 67 ABC31 615 7>;5> ;C65; +* <5C>28@ 73 7D;=31556 * 4C335; <= >53478;586 7E2;5885FB>5 6 23 615 GC35 79 615 456262785> 61C6 15 23 615 <B328533HC8 >532;28@ C6 C:C<B>C@2 53478;586 7( D>26658 C :5665> 67 >53478;586 7 58BH5>C628@ 615 ;56C2:3 79 615 GC35 >5@2365>5; C@C2836 615 456262785> "B>3BC866761C6>53478;5867>5265>C628@615G7865863 79615:5665>36C628@61C6615456262785>D2611233B447>65>3 23 2862H2;C628@ 61>5C65828@ C8; 358;28@ D>78@ H533C@53 - 3 - 676154B<:2GC8;CG628@28@>7B43C8;;236B><28@:CDC8; 7>;5> 28 615 E2::C@53 58G5 C GC35 23 >5@2365>5; C@C2836 615 456262785> 28 6C6278 CIC> "7:2G5 6C6278 28 >2H5 7* * 97> 615 79958G53 4B8231C<:5 B8;5> 5G62783 ( + (( ( ( * C8; ( >5C; D261 5G627879" ( C35;78615>5@236>C627879615G>2H5C8;92:28@ 79 615 G1C>@5 31556 >53478;586 7( 8345G67> 79 "7:2G5 >5G7HH58;5; 67 7458 C >7D;= 31556 C@C2836 615 456262785> 15>528 C35; 78 D12G1 >53478;586 7 1C3 4C335;6157>;5>28G:B;28@6158CH579615456262785><= 745828@ >7D;= 31556 C@C2836 12H 28 615 >5@2365> ;C65; +* C3 615 456262785> DC3 28E7:E5; 28 >2H5 7* * 623G78658;5;<=615G7B835:97>615456262785> 61C6 615 456262785> 1C3 <558 CGAB2665; 28 5332783 C35 7'' + C>2328@ 7B6 79 >2H5 7* * DC= <CG? 78 +' 534265 D12G1 615 456262785>.3 8CH5 23 28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556 C8; 15 23 3BHH785; 67 615 - 4 - 47:2G5 36C6278 62H5 C8; C@C28 D2617B6 C8= >5C378 D1C6375E5> 2::5@C::= C8; G786>C>= 67 615 4>7E232783 79 >;5>73'C8;79615 C>8C6C?C"7:2G5C8BC: 6 23 C:37 G78658;5; 61C6 87 317D GCB35 8762G5 23 233B5; C8; H5>5:= 78 615 <C323 79 C8 5C>:25> G>2H5 8BH<5> 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> 23 28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556 15>597>5 615 456262785> HC;5 >54>53586C6278 67 >53478;586 7 78 ( 97> >5E25D28@ 615 2H4B@85; 7>;5> C8; 67 ;5:565 123 8CH5 9>7H 615 >7D;= 31556 C3 15 1C3 <558 CGAB2665; 28 615 GC35 <C35; 78 D12G1 123 8CH5 DC3 28G:B;5; 28 615 >7D;= 31556 15 3CH51C3876<558G7832;5>5;<=>53478;5867 6 23 G78658;5; 61C6 D158 615 456262785> HC;5 C44:2GC6278 7> >54>53586C6278 615 >53478;586 CB617>26253 7B@16 67 1CE5 CGG5465; 615 >54>53586C6278 C8; 4>7E2;5; C8 7447>6B826= 67 615 456262785> 67 4B6 97>61 123 GC35 79 615>5<528@87C::5@C627879G>2H28C:GC353458;28@C@C2836 12H C8; 61C6 28G:B3278 79 123 8CH5 C8; G78628B28@ 123 - 5 - 8CH5 28 615 7D;= 1556 5@2365> 23 E27:C62E5 79 615 4>28G24:53798C6B>C:JB362G528G:B;28@12345>378C::2<5>6= * 6 23 C:37 G78658;5; 61C6 28 34265 79 615 456262785> <528@ CGAB2665; 28 615 GC35 61C6 DC3 92:5; C@C2836 12H C8; ;534265 615 >54>53586C6278 <528@ HC;5 615456262785>.38CH52387636>BG?7999>7H615>5@2365>79 >7D;253615>5<=GCB328@B867:;1C>;3124C8;E27:C627879 1239B8;CH586C:>2@16799>55H7E5H586C8;123:2<5>6= + 623C:37G78658;5;<=615:5C>85;G7B835:61C6 >53478;5863 1CE5 876 97::7D5; 615 85G533C>= @B2;5:2853 :C2;;7D8<=61237B>628615GC3579 >547>65; 28 15>597>5 15 G78658;3 61C6 2H4:2GC628@ 615 456262785> C8;>5@2365>28@123 8CH528 615>7D;=3155623 2::5@C:C8;E27:C62E5794>28G24:53798C6B>C:JB362G558G5 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> >5AB2>53 67 <5 >5H7E5; C8; G7835AB586:= 615 3C2; 7>;5> <5 ABC315; 58G5 615 456262785>2345>97>G5;67C44>7CG161237B>628E7?28@615 D>26JB>23;2G6278 - 6 - ' :5C>85; ;;26278C: 7E5>8H586 ;E7GC65 >54>5358628@ >53478;5866C65 C;H263 615 CGAB266C: 79 615 456262785> 28 615 C97>53C2; G>2H28C: GC35 C8; 78 E5>292GC6278 C8; C965> 6C?28@ 2836>BG62783 3B<H263 61C6615 456262785>.38CH5 23 362:: G78628B28@ 28 615>7D;= 31556<B66158CH579615456262785>DC328G:B;5;28615 7D;=15565@2365>4>27>67CGAB266C:C8;C:37AB536278 79 97::7D28@ 615 @B2;5:2853 :C2; ;7D8 <= 615 77>;28C65 58G1 79 6123 7B>6 28 615 GC35 79 #3B4>C%D7B:;876C>23597>615>5C37861C628G:B327879615 8CH579615456262785>286157D;=15565@2365>234>27> 67 615 3C2; JB;@H586 58G5 615 3CH5 D2:: 876 58B>5 67 6152><585926GG7>;28@:=15355?367;23H23361545626278 1CE515C>;:5C>85;G7B835:97>615456262785> C8;:5C>85;;;26278C:7E5>8H586;E7GC6597>6156C65 6 23 C 9B8;CH586C: >B:5 79 :CD 61C6 D158 C 45>378 23 2H4:2GC65; C3 C >7D;= 315565> <= 28G:B;28@ 123 8CH528615:23679>7D;=3155661578B323B4786156C65 67 97::7D 615 ;B5 4>7G5;B>5 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 615 - 7 - >5:5EC86 >B:53 C8; >5@B:C62783 8 615 4>53586 GC35 615 C>8C6C?C"7:2G5C8BC:H7>5345G292GC::=6155@2365>79 7D;253 HC286C285; 28 7>;5> 7 D12G1 ;5C:3 D261 12367>= 315563 C8; >7D;= 315563 C8; 58>7::H586 7> >5@236>C6278 79 45>3783 28 615 3C2; 31556 97> >5@2365> 97> G78628B7B3 H78267>28@ <= 615 47:2G5 CB617>26253 23 876 97::7D5; 6C8;28@ >;5> 7 ;5C:3 D261 >5@236>C6278 79>7D;25315;5928262784>7E2;5;2361C6C>7D;=HC=<5 ;59285; C3 C @B8;C C8; 28G:B;53 C 177:2@C8 67B@1 EC@C<78;7>C8=45>378D1723;C8@5>7B3674B<:2G45CG5 C8;6>C8AB2:26=15>5C>5HC8=97>H379>7D;23H D12G1 C>5 ;53G>2<5; 615>528 C8; 615 4>7G533 C8; 4>7G5;B>5 G7865H4:C65; 67<5 HC286C285; 28;2995>5864C>63 8CH5:= "C>6"C>6C8;"C>6D12G1@7E5>8615HC28658C8G5 79 C >5@2365> C8; 615 8CH53 79 615 >7D;253 28 6152> >5345G62E5 4C>63 6 23 615 ;B6= C8; 7<:2@C6278 GC36 B478 615 >53478;5863 D12G1 23 876 746278C: 67 97::7D 615 ;B5 4>7G5;B>5G7865H4:C65;B8;5>61536C8;28@7>;5>379615 C>8C6C?C "7:2G5 C8BC: D12:5 5865>28@ 615 8CH5 79 C - 8 - 45>378 28 615 >7D;= 31556 C8; 615>5 C>5 G5>6C28 4>7G5;B>5367<5HC8;C67>2:=97::7D5;<597>55865>28@615 8CH533G78658;5;<=:5C>85;G7B835:97>615456262785> 615 4>7G533 C8; 4>7G5;B>5 C3 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 615 36C8;28@ >;5> 7 79 615 C>8C6C?C "7:2G5 C8BC: 1C3876<55897::7D5;C8;877447>6B826=DC3@2E5867615 456262785>6792:5123>54:=7>5F4:C8C627897>>5H7E28@123 8CH5286157D;=15565@2365>C8;H5>5:=<5GCB3515 DC328E7:E5;28G>2H28C:GC3528D12G1C:37615456262785> 1C3<558CGAB2665;28615=5C>'623C:37G78658;5; 61C6617B@1615456262785>1C3HC;5>54>53586C627867615 >53478;586 CB617>26253 C965> 615 CGAB266C: 78 ( 615>54>53586C62781C3876<558G7832;5>5;C8;5E58C965> 615CGAB266C:151C3<5583BHH785;67615JB>23;2G6278C: 47:2G536C627897>B885G533C>=2865>>7@C6278D158615>523 87GC35458;28@C@C283612H 6D7B:;<5>5:5EC86675F6>CG64C>C@>C417+ 79615JB;@H586792E2327858G17961237B>628615GC35 79 !" " - 9 - >547>65; 28 #$ %&& ' ( D15>528 615 2E23278 58G1 ;5C:6 D261 32H2:C> 3B<J5G6 HC665> D12G1 >5C;3 C3 B8;5> ! "# # $ % &'( ) # $ $ % &'( # ) *) # + ) ) ) ) # )) ) ) ) ) , )# ) - K 6C8;28@ >;5> 7 79 C>8C6C?C "7:2G5 C8BC:'235F6>CG65;<5:7D &'( ./0 # ) ) 1 - 10 - .2/ 3+ / ! 45, / 6 )) # # 3 /), / !)1 + + ))))) , /*, /, / .7/ 6 # 8 8 % &&) #9 0 : 4 ) ; 0# .</. /% ) 848 0 ) ) ./% ) 848 ) = 8"48 : ) # ) ./ % ) >%#> 4 + - 11 - .'/ $ ) +*# $ # .?/% ) ) 0 : !6) ./ @ ) # ) 848 # ) 1 $ .A/ 4 # ) ) ) ) ) ) 0 " * ) ) ) .(/$ " * ) # # # 8 8 : ) ) " * 4 6) *$ # # .&/)#) # #)) - 12 - ./ @ # + $ ! 8:8 )) $ ! 808 .2/@ 8481 + 8488:8 @ 848 ) ! $ 46) .7/ % ! 808 8:8 ) 6 6) ) +*# $ .</6) + ) ) 6) 1 ! ) .'/ B C 3 ./ ) ! # - 13 - ./ ))) 2(< 4 . 9 /, ./ # ! (2./.)/.1/ ./D ! 0(?7 )# #C3 .#/0&A./ 4 , .#/0&4 4 .#/0&4 4 .#/ 0 )## , #/EC)'' '?D ! 0(?7, .C/ 0 '&( 6 4 #+ 3 .?/E# ) E " : ) + # )) # ++ )) !) + ./ @ # $ ) ) " # # .A/)&? ) - 14 - 3+ / % 2/% ) 7/5) ) </ % ) '/ ?/$F /% A/ ! .(/ 6 ) ) # ) 1 ) # ! ) - ( 1577>;28C6558G17961237B>628615GC35 79 #3B4>C% 1C3 :C2; ;7D8 @B2;5:2853 D12G1 C>5 67 <5 97::7D5;D12:5 >5@2365>28@ 615 8CH579 C 45>378 28 615 7D;= 1556 5@2365> D12G1 5E58 4>27> 67 6153C2;JB;@H586DC3CHC8;C6597>615>53478;586367 1CE597::7D5;36>2G6:=28CGG7>;C8G56761536C8;28@7>;5> 7 79 615 C>8C6C?C "7:2G5 C8BC: D12G1 28 H= - 15 - 7428278 G7832;5>28@ 615 9CG63 C8; G2>GBH36C8G5 79 615 4>53586 GC35 1C3 876 <558 97::7D5; C8; 5E58 C965> 615 CGAB266C: 79 615 456262785> C8; 5E58 C965> 615 >54>53586C6278 @2E58 <= 615 456262785> 97> >5H7E28@ 123 8CH5 9>7H 615 7D;= 1556 5@2365> 615>5 23 87 >5347835 7> >54:= 7> CG6278 <= 615 >53478;5863 28 >5H7E28@1238CH5 8 E25D 79 878G7H4:2C8G5 79 615 4>7G5;B>5 G7865H4:C65; B8;5> 36C8;28@ 7>;5> 7 79 615 C>8C6C?C "7:2G5 C8BC: C8; 878G7832;5>C6278 79 615 >54>53586C6278 @2E58 <= 615 456262785> 4B>3BC86 67 123 CGAB266C: 6123 7B>6 23 79 615 7428278 61C6 615 456262785> 1C3HC;57B6CEC:2;GC3567G7832;5>9CE7B>C<:= GG7>;28@:=4C3361597::7D28@ 2 15)>26"562627823)) 22 15 2H4B@85; 7>;5> ;C65; +* >5@C>;28@745828@7D;=15565@2365>28 - 16 - 615 8CH5 79 615 456262785> <5C>28@ 7 7D;=31556 * 4C335; <= >53478;58672315>5<=ABC315; 222 15 >53478;5863 C>5 15>5<= ;2>5G65; 67 >5H7E56158CH579615456262785>9>7H615 7D;=15565@2365>HC286C285;<=615H D26128C45>27;7997B>D55?39>7H615;C65 79>5G524679G5>62925;G74=796157>;5> 2E 2<5>6= 17D5E5> 23 >535>E5; 67 615 >53478;586 6C65674>7G55; 28 CGG7>;C8G5 D261:CDC@C2836615456262785>29C6C::C8= GC3523HC;57B6C8;D12:5;728@37615= 31C::36>2G6:=97::7D615@B2;5:2853:C2;;7D8 <= 6123 7B>6 28 615 GC35 79 >547>65;28 '( % & $ " +