Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54519 (KAR)
JAISHRI v. GENERAL MANAGER AND ANR
MFA/202053/2019 · 2026-01-12
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54519 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54519 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#! $$
%&'
(
! "
#$!!$!%&$!%
'
$#(! &
''#$)$&* %!%!'
+
$#(! ' &, ! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'' %(! '
' !(*&(!)
'
! &(!-
'
. ! /01234556470164556774/0234334272/80169:;8<6/0 4/; 4=4>; ;406; !(*&(!) 2/ ?! &(!- ?/ 016 @276 ?@ ;;202?/47 6/2?> 2A27 :;86 4/; ' 2;4> 16>62/4@06>>6@6>>6;0?43B?<<2332?/6>C & 16 @4D03 2/ /:031677 @?> 016 5:>5?36 ?@ 4;9:;2D402?/?@01234556474>60140016;6D6436;$?E631 23 30406; 0? 14A6 F66/ =?>E2/8 43 4/ 76D0>2D24/ =201 4 >635?/;6/0 ?!$@4D0?>G 4/; 016 342; ?E631 =1276 0>4A672/8 2/ 123 <?0?>DGD76 F64>2/8 >68230>402?/ ?$%) $))#5>?D66;2/80?=4>;3016>635?/;6/0?! D?<54/G4/;40014002<6/;2D4D4>;>2A6/FG203;>2A6>
- 3 -
D4<6@>?<016?55?3206;2>6D02?/120016<?0?>DGD76?@016 ;6D6436;?E6314/;433:D1016342;?E6313:DD:<F6; 0?2/9:>2636/D6016<?016>?@016;6D6436;?E631143 5>6@6>>6; 45572D402?/ :/;6> 6D02?/ !( ?@ <57?G663 ?<56/3402?/ D0 366E2/8 D?<56/3402?/ 16 342; D742< 560202?/=43D?/06306;FG016>635?/;6/03 % 16 >2F:/47 4@06> D?/32;6>2/8 016 <406>247 ?/ >6D?>; FG 203 9:;8<6/0 4/; 4=4>; ;406; !(*&(!) ;23<2336; 016 D742< 560202?/ 6/D6 0123 455647 23 5>6@6>>6;FG016<?016>?@016;6D6436;
64>;>214>4/4F434554431600G764>/6;
D?:/367 @?> 016 4556774/0 4/; <0
>6602
4027 67E:/;2 764>/6;D?:/367@?>016>635?/;6/0?&
0 23 D?/06/06; FG 016 764>/6; D?:/367 45564>2/8 @?> 016 4556774/0 0140 20 23 016 D436 ?@ 016 D742<4/0 0140 016 ;6D6436; =43 5>?D66;2/8 0?=4>;3 016 @4D0?>G?@016>635?/;6/0?!1?=6A6>016>2F:/47?/ 6>>?/6?:3 @2/;2/8 143 4>>2A6; 40 4 D?/D7:32?/ 0140 016
- 4 -
;6D6436;=43?/<6;2D47764A64/;016342;4356D0?@016 <4006>23>6H:2>6;0?F62/06>@6>6;=2012/0123455647 * 6> D?/0>4 <0
>6602
4027 67E:/;2 764>/6; D?:/36745564>2/8@?>016>635?/;6/0?&3:F<2006;0140 016D742<4/0 143 /?0 5>?;:D6;4/G>676A4/0 ;?D:<6/0 0? 5>?A6 016 >67402?/3125 =201 016 >635?/;6/0 ?! 4/; 43 3:D13?:810@?>;23<23347?@016455647 - / 016 72810 ?@ 016 3:F<2332?/ <4;6 FG 016 764>/6; D?:/367 45564>2/8 @?> 016 4556774/0 14A6 D4>6@:77G6I4<2/6;016@2/;2/8>6D?>;6;FG016>2F:/4740 54>48>451 !& ?@ 016 2<5:8/6; 9:;8<6/0 =16>62/ 016 >2F:/47 143 4>>2A6; 40 4 D?/D7:32?/ 4@06> D?/32;6>2/8 016 ?<5742/0'4/;?016>5?72D6>65?>030140?/016;406?@ 4DD2;6/0 ;6D6436; ?E631 =43 ?/ 016 =4G 0?=4>;3 016 @4D0?>G?@016>635?/;6/0?!?=6A6>016>2F:/47143 ;23<2336; 016 D742< 560202?/ ?/ 016 8>?:/; 0140 016 342;
;6D6436; ?E631 =43 ?/ <6;2D47 764A6 ?/ (#(*&(!* F436;?/0162/06>2<?>;6>54336;FG016?:>0430?016 D?5G ?@ 016 4006/;4/D6 >682306> @:>/2316; FG 016
- 5 -
>635?/;6/0?!/0123>684>;01656>:347?@016@2/;2/8 >6D?>;6; FG 016 >2F:/47 40 54>48>451 !& =?:7; 2/;2D406 D?/0>4 >643?/3 43 0? 016 477686; 4DD2;6/0 0140 016 ;6D6436; ?E631 =43 5>?D66;2/83 0? 016 @4D0?>G ?@ 016 >635?/;6/0 ?! 4/; 473? 20 23 30406; 0140 016 ;6D6436; =43?/<6;2D47764A6?/(#(*&(!*=12D1>:/3D?/0>4>G 0? 016 >6D?>;3 6/D6 20 23 4 @20 D436 0? >6<4/; 016 <4006> 0? 016 >2F:/47 @?>>6$455>6D2402?/ ?@ 016 <406>247 ?/>6D?>; # / 016 72810 ?@ 016 ?F36>A402?/ <4;6 16>62/ 4F?A65>?D66;0?5433016@?77?=2/8
i) 5564723477?=6; ii) 16 9:;8<6/0 4/; 4=4>; ;406; !(*&(!) 2/ ?!
&(!- ?/ 016 @276 ?@ ;;202?/47 6/2?>2A27:;864/;'2;4>2316>6FG360 432;64/;<4006>23>6<2006;0?016>2F:/47@?> @>631D?/32;6>402?/
- 6 -
iii) /?>;6>0?4A?2;@:>016>;674G2/016<4006>43 54>0263 4>6 >65>636/06; 01>?:81 0162> 764>/6; D?:/367354>02634>6;2>6D06;0?45564>F6@?>6 016>2F:/47?/!((&&(&*40!!(( iv) 0 23 473? ?56/ @?> 016 >2F:/47 0? D?/32;6> ?! &(& @276; FG 016 4556774/0 16>62/ =1276 D?/32;6>2/8 016 D742< 560202?/ @276; FG 016 560202?/6> 4/; 5433 455>?5>2406 ?>;6> 2/ 4DD?>;4/D6=20174= 77D?/06/02?/3?@01654>02634>6E650?56/
)* %' ! 230?!7?-