Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54518 (KAR)

THE MANAGER LEGAL v. SMT. MAHADEVI W/O SHIVAPPA KUMABAR

MFA/201980/2014 · 2026-01-21

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! ! "#"$ %#!! ! !!&& '() ( !" # $ ! % & %! #'! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (& (%)*#"! + , !- , &- # ! , . , , !" , / (0)#" , , , 1 ( "*")#"! , , 1 # 23456675834697:7997;<=>27 ?4@95?A7BC65?= 5445383?D >27 E@;DC7?> 5?; 5F59; ;5>7; "*")#"! 3? B0)#"B?>27:387B:>27 5<B@9::3A795?; BCC3443B?79:B9B9GC7?/4BC67?45>3B?@<(3H343B? B 3E5=56@95 # ,B9>2745G7B:AB?H7?37?A7>27659>374FB@8; <797:7997;54679>273995?G<7:B97>27BCC3443B?79 - 3 - ! > 34 >27 A547 B: >27 A853C5?>4 >25> >27 ;7A7547;23H5665@C<59F54FB9G3?D545;93H79F3>2 9746B?;7?> B 5?; B? "$"!#" >27 8B99= <78B?D3?D >B9746B?;7?>BF548B5;7;F3>2DBB;45?;>27975:>79 >27 DBB;4 F797 @?8B5;7; B? "0"!#"# 5?; 54 4@A2 ;@93?D>27453;>95?43>>278B99=3?I@74>3B?F54659G7;5> 5?D5C58D@;3H3885D7?7595?D5H5>35?;>27975:>79>27 ;93H79 B:>27 H723A87 3? I@74>3B? 4876> B?>B6 B: >278B99= 5?;;@93?D>27453;6793B;27;37;B?5AAB@?>B:A59;35A 59974> 7?A7 >27 A853C5?>4 25H7 :387; A853C 67>3>3B? <7:B97>278759?7;BCC3443B?79477G3?DABC67?45>3B? & 27 453; A853C 67>3>3B? F54 AB?>74>7; <= >27 9746B?;7?>4;346@>3?D>27BAA@997?A7B:>275AA3;7?>5?; 584B >27 9785>3B?4236 B: 7C68B=79 5?; 7C68B=77 <7>F77? >27;7A7547;5?;9746B?;7?>B % 27 8759?7; BCC3443B?79 5:>79 AB?43;793?D >27 C5>79358 B? 97AB9; 5?; >27 7H3;7?A7 5;;@A7; <= >27 659>374 588BF7; >27 A853C 67>3>3B? 3? 659> <= 5F59;3?D ABC67?45>3B? B: 4%"0*#% F3>2 3?>7974> 5> #J 679 - 4 - 5??@C >B >27 A853C5?>4 5?; ;397A>7; 9746B?;7?> B#( ?4@95?A7 BC65?= >B ;76B43> >27 453; 5CB@?> ,7783?D 5DD937H7; <= >27 45C7 >27 ?4@95?A7 BC65?= 254 697:7997;>234566758 * 234 B@9> H3;7 B9;79 ;5>7; 0"#"#* :B9C@85>7;>27:B88BF3?D4@<4>5?>358I@74>3B?4B:85F ! " "# $ 25H7 2759; C> 5?D77>5 25;95427>>= 8759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D :B9 >27 5667885?> 935?D5?5<545H55>388759?7;AB@?4785667593?D:B9 9746B?;7?> B4 >B ! 5?; 93 C742 5C5;56@9 8759?7;AB@?4785667593?D:B99746B?;7?>B& ) > 34 AB?>7?>7; <= >27 8759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D:B9>275667885?>( ?4@95?A7BC65?=<=3?H3>3?D >275>>7?>3B?B:>27B@9>>BK>25>>27ABC6853?>F54 - 5 - 8B;D7; 5?; >27975:>79 69BA77;3?D4 @?;79 7A>3B? $& B: 9F5497AB9;7;3? B*#"5?;>2797:B973> 34 AB?>7?>7; <= >27 8759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D :B9 >27 5667885?> >25> >27 ;75>2 B: 453; 23H5665 3>478: 34 @?;79 4@463A3B@4 A39A@C4>5?A74 5?; >2797:B97 4B@D2> :B9 3?>79:797?A7B:>234B@9> >34584B59D@7;<=>278759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D :B9 >27 5667885?> >25> >27 A853C5?>4 25H7 :5387; >B 69BH7 >27 9785>3B?4236 B: 7C68B=79 5?; 7C68B=77<7>F77?>27;7A7547;5?;9746B?;7?>B5?; >27 453; 5467A> B: >27 C5>>79 F54 ?B> AB?43;797; <= >27 8759?7; BCC3443B?79 5?; 5AAB9;3?D8= 4B@D2> :B9 3?>79:797?A7B:>234B@9> 0 79AB?>95935?D5?5<545H55>388759?7; AB@?4785667593?D:B9>27A853C5?>4H727C7?>8=AB?>7?>7; >25> >27 8759?7; BCC3443B?79 5:>79 AB?43;793?D >27 C5>79358 B? 97AB9; 93D2>8= 5F59;7; ABC67?45>3B? F23A2 97I@3974 ?B 3?>79:797?A7 759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D :B9 >27A853C5?>497:794>B>274>5>7C7?>C5;7<=9746B?;7?> B54679K&F27973?9746B?;7?>B2544>5>7; - 6 - >25> >27 ;7A7547; 23H5665 F54 FB9G3?D 54 5 ;93H79 3? 8B99= <7593?D B(#%(!%"* 5?; 3? >27 453; 5467A> B: >27C5>>79?B3?>79:797?A734A5887;:B93?>2345667585?; 5AAB9;3?D8=4B@D2>:B9;34C34458B:>27566758 " ? >27 83D2> B: >27 4@<C3443B?4 C5;7 <= >27 8759?7; AB@?478 5667593?D :B9 >27 659>374 3> 34 ?B> 3? ;346@>7 54 >B >27 ;75>2 B: 23H5665 2@4<5?; B: 9746B?;7?> B 27973? 79@458 B: >27 4>5>7C7?> 5> K& <= 9746B?;7?> B FB@8; 3?;3A5>7 >25> >27 ;7A7547; F54 FB9G3?D 54 5 ;93H79 3? >27 8B99= 5?; F54 487763?D5>>27>B6B:>278B99=5?;584B3>34:B9>2ABC3?D >25>?B<B;=F5469747?>3?>27A5<3?5?;>27<B;=B:>27 8B99=3?I@74>3B?5?;>27453;5467A>B:>27C5>>79FB@8; 3?;3A5>7 >25> >27 A853C5?>4 25H7 :5387; >B 69BH7 >25>>27 ;7A7547;254;37;3?>27AB@947B:>277C68B=C7?> >34 584B>B<7?B>7;>25>?B;BA@C7?>425H7<77?69B;@A7; <= >27 A853C5?>4 >B 4@<4>5?>35>7 >27 9785>3B?4236 B: 7C68B=79 5?; 7C68B=77 <7>F77? >27 ;7A7547; 5?; 9746B?;7?>B25>5659>B?679@458B:K#F27973? - 7 - A259D7 4277> 34 :387; <547; B? >27 976B9> 3? B*#"@?;797A>3B?$&B:93>FB@8;A87598= 3?;3A5>7 >25> >27 <B;= B:>27 ;7A7547; F54 ;7ABC6B47; 5?;3:4@A2<73?D>27A547>27;75>2B:>27;7A7547;3>478: 34 @?;79 4@463A3B@4 A39A@C4>5?A74 5?; ?B> F3>2B@> >27 G?BF87;D7 B: >27 9746B?;7?>(7C68B=79 B:3?>795835 ?B> 3? >27AB@947B:7C68B=C7?> :5>5889746B?;7?>B<73?D >27BF?79B:>27H723A87B@D2>>B25H73?>795A>7;F3>2>27 ;7A7547;<73?D5;93H79B:>27H723A873?I@74>3B?54679 >27AB?>7?>3B?4B:>27A853C5?>4>279734?BC5>7935854>B >27453;5467A>B:>27C5>>79 ? >25> H37F B: >27 C5>>79 5C B: >27 H37F >25>>278759?7;BCC3443B?79254ABCC3>>7;5?799B93? 7?>79>53?3?D>27A853C67>3>3B?<=5F59;3?DABC67?45>3B? 54 >27 A853C5?>4 25H7 :5387; >B 69BH7 >27 9785>3B?4236 B: >27 7C68B=79 5?; 7C68B=77 <7>F77? >27 ;7A7547; 5?; 9746B?;7?>B25> 5659> ?B 5AA76>5<877H3;7?A7 254 <77? 69B;@A7; <= >27 A853C5?>4 ?B99746B?;7?> B54 - 8 - >B >27 :5A> >25> >27 ;7A7547; ;37; 3? >27 AB@947 B: >27 7C68B=C7?> # ? >25> H37F B: >27 C5>>79 :3?; :B9A7 3? >27 4@<C3443B?C5;7<=>278759?7;AB@?4785667593?D:B9>27 5667885?>( ?4@95?A7BC65?= ! ?>27974@8> 6544>27:B88BF3?DB9;79 3 2756675834588BF7; 33 27 E@;DC7?> 5?; B9;79 ;5>7; "*")#"! 3? B0)#" >27 :387 B: >27 5<B@9 ::3A79 5?; BCC3443B?79:B9B9GC7?/4BC67?45>3B?@<(3H343B? B 3E5=56@95342797<=47>543;7 333 B?47I@7?>8= >27 A853C 67>3>3B? :387; <= >27 A853C5?>43? B0)#"342797<=;34C3447; !*+ '! !) # 34>B 8B %"